Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Dust Deputy

Posts

Dust Deputy

#1

Dust Deputy

Ed Freestone

Does anyone have experience with these?

I'm thinking about getting one to use with my shop vac when connected to my machines - ts, cms, router, etc.

The Dust Deputy has 2" fittings but my Fein Mini-Turbo vac has 1.25" fittings and hose. Will they work together, with the proper adapters?

Will my vac pull enough air through 1.25" hose, adapted to the Deputy's 2" connection, to work with the device? Or, will my vac pull properly through a 2" hose, stepped down to 1.25' at the vac connection?

Re: Dust Deputy

#2

Re: Dust Deputy

Larry in NW OHIO

I`m sorry I can`t answer your questions, but call Oneida and ask them. I have 3 of them hooked to my Craftsman vacs and they work very well and I really like them, they keep the filter inside clean. Larry

Re: Dust Deputy

#3

Re: Dust Deputy

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Depending on your vac* it will draw fine through a 1.25 to 2.5" hose. It is designed to do that. It will also work with the Dust Deputy, when connected to a ROS, router, biscuit jointer. That is how the Dust Deputy is designed to be used, also. That setup will NOT be sufficient to collect dust from full size tools. The Dust Deputy will still do a decent job separating out the dust that is collected, but CFM suction and the amount of dust collected with a shopvac from a machine like a tablesaw will be almost non-existent when compared to what is needed and what is accomplished by a full-size DC.

*shopvacs work on static pressure (SP) so will work with small hoses and pipes where there is extremely high static pressure resistance. There is a big difference in shopvacs, however. A standard Shopvac brand machine will suck around 60" of static pressure while the better (and much more expensive) Fein and Festool vacs can pull almost 100". Dust collectors work mainly by moving large volumes of air but at a relatively low static pressure of only around 10". That is why DCs don't work well with small hoses.

Re: Dust Deputy

#4

Re: Dust Deputy

Nat Robison

I have one and I like it although I probably don't utilize it to the fullest. I do find that it does not pull dust from my tablesaw and jointer very well but does a decent job on the router table. Haven't gotten the proper connector to use with the miter saw but I'd like to.

I find I use it mostly to vacuum piles of shavings, sawdust, etc. It beats having to clean the vac filter. One of these days, I'll try to get it hooked up properly to most of my machines but again, I find it doesn't do a great job on bigger machines.

Re: Dust Deputy

#5

Re: Dust Deputy

Ed Freestone

Thanks, Alan. Your explanation is very helpful. I don't get much collection from the table saw, although I thought that was mainly due to the lack of enclosure on the contractor-style saw. The vac works well on the others, though, so if the Dust Deputy will work with it, it should be a good addition.

Ed Freestone.

Re: Dust Deputy

#6

Re: Dust Deputy

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

You also need to know what people mean by dust collection- it is not just "chip collection." Chips are fairly easily collected, but the fine dust, the dangerous stuff that escapes from above the blade on a tablesaw and from just about every machine, is much harder to collect. This dust is generally very small and invisible, less than 10 microns. To collect that you need to move a large volume of air- a lot of CFM. OSHA and other health agencies have developed minimum CFM requirements for most machines. According to their figures at the table below, "chip collection" CFM requirements start at about 300 CFM while "dust collection" CFM starts at about 350 CFM and goes up to 900 CFM depending on machine.


Compare that with the CFM provided by the top-of-the-line vacs from these manufacturers (numbers taken from manuf. websites):

Shopvac (Contractor)= 210 CFM

Fein Turbo III= 126 CFM

Festool CT 36E= 137 CFM

As you can see, a shopvac is not designed to collect dust from woodworking machines- not chips and certainly not fine dust.