We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
After fiddling with this in a lamp for a few minutes this afternoon (it kept going out - I thought it might have been a wiring issue), I unscrewed it and saw this at the base (!). Is this a "simple" CFL failure? Or is there perhaps something faulty in the lamp wiring that is causing this?
Here's what's printed on the other side of the base:
Looks like an internal component failure and, unless the "lamp wiring" involved connecting the CFL to 240V, it is just one of those things that happens with electronic circuits. CFL makers do everything they can to keep their manufacturing costs down and one of those things is to use components which are able to do the job but have little room for error. I've had probably three or for CFLs over the years do similar things. One in particular was the "nightlight" in my workshop and when it failed it made the most horrendous stink which left me puzzled until I found the hole burned/blown in the side of the circuit housing.
We have a Leviton motion activated light in our front hallway. We decided to replace the incandescent lamps with CFL's. At first I replaced both lamps with CFLs. However, the fixture never went totally dark. It would go bright and then after a time would go dim when the timer ran out, but it wouldn't go completely off. I thought it would work if I had just one CFL and one incandescent so I change out one lamp. The light appeared to function normally, coming on when you walked into the hallway and going completely dark when the timer expired. HOWEVER, about 2-3 weeks later I noted that the hallway seemed dim one night when I let the dog out. Upon closer examination the CFL was not coming on. It had failed even though the bulb still looked new.
It seems the motion switch uses the lamp as part of the circuit for the electronics in the motion sensor. This low level current powers the CFl ballast, but does not provide sufficient current for the lamp to fire so it is constantly trying to start. The lower current is not a problem for conventional incandescent lamps but appears to be fatal for CFL's. Perhaps some of the newer motion sensor switches don't have this problem.
Lee, you are correct about the low levels of power "tickling " the igniter and this problem also occurs when the small electronic timers are used to turn on coach lights, porch lights, etc. CFL lasts about a day flickering and trying to come on but never quite lighting. Bulb manufacturers have decided it's not their problem. Old style timers that use mechanical contacts work fine, electronic ones, not so much!
There was a piece on the news today about GE closing down the last American incandescent bulb plant. COST 220 JOBS! Keep fellow Americans employed. Stock up on regular bulbs while you can before the 2014 ban. I hate CFLs. When I walk into a dark area, I want light NOW, not after I have stumbled through. I have my ten year supply already. Keep China out of my pocketbook, please.
The only safe application I have found for the CFL bulbs is in table or floor lamps with large shades that allow good air flow. These are also all base down.
The only base up installation is in basement porcelain fixtures that are totally open for air circulation.
Some manaufacture do note not to use base UP at all! Most all say no totally enclose fixture or recess.
Took one just like yours out of a vanity light fixture that had hanging globes so all hot air gets trapped around the base. Did last about a year!
Not able to return it as I get them FREE from our city owned power company!
I haven't heard that about cfl use in "upside down" use. I have one in a recessed light above my shower with a lens covering it and it seems to have lasted well over a year, no issues at all. I'll keep it in mind for the future.
What does that mean for the cfls that are made to look like incandescent bulbs where they put a thin, glass globe over the spiral part of the light?
I agree with others that it's a failure of the light "bulb" itself, unless you're seeing evidence of excess voltage in other parts of your house - early failures of other electronic components, for instance (like computers...no, let's not go there). It's pretty hard to have high voltage in ONE circuit, unless, as someone else commented, you've somehow got 240 volts on a circuit where you should have 120.
I'd replace it, and see what happens. If you get dramatically early failure of the next light, you might check out the circuit, or ask an electrically savvy friend to check it out (a simple multimeter will tell you whether the circuit is showing 120 volts or something higher).
This is the first I have ever heard that these bulbs are not to be installed base up. I just got out the two packages of them I have, both whatever Brand they have at Lowe's. One package is candelabra based bulbs and makes no mention of position. the other is regular base bulbs and the only mention is that the lumen rating is for a base down application and may be 5% different if installed base up. (Does not indicate more or less, just different)
Neither package mentions anything about enclosing the bulbs or operating them in fully ventilated fixtures. I have the flood light versions in some track light cans I have over a kitchen island. Seems to me the manufacturer would know that flood lights are installed in shield and are often base up.
I don't have any dimmers or timers, so I have not run into that problem, but I was thinking of putting one of those auto switches in my bathroom.
I have three CRL installed in my garage, all of them base up. They have been there several years now with no replacement issues. I don't like the fact that there is a delay on them turning on but other than that they work OK. I tried a CRL in an enclosed fixture outside by the front door and that was a disaster. Never could get one to work in that fixture.
I guess I need to stock up on incandescent bulbs before too long.
Leviton lists several motion sensors that are compatible with "Rapid Start Magnetic ballast ONLY" what ever those are. I have no idea what is consumer grade CFL's.
I guess it is another case of just depends! Just depends on the bulb, what's controlling the power to it, the temperature, the...
I have a CFL outside and it works and we get down to -20F or lower here. It is controlled by a remote control but the power is applied via a relay contact not a solid-state triac which many timer/remotes use. A lot of these control circuits are designed for incandescent bulbs and are not happy with inductive loads and other CFL lamp characteristics.
As far as the failure goes it may just be a fact of life. There are various electronic components in the base and thus they have a higher probabilty of failing than a lamp with only wire connections in the base.
the only issue for me seems to be not to buy the cheap ones, otherwise they make too much noise for my taste, and sometimes interfere with radios & amplifiers. Mine really seem to hate getting smacked with boards out in the shop. My longest "burning" one ran for about 12hrs a day for 5yrs, sideways in an old bankers lamp.
I know this post had nothing to do with wood working but I starting replacing a lot of my incandescant bulbs with CFLs and now I'm thinking about going back.
My wife HATES them. I had one that started to fail but the fixture it was in was prone to getting bumped anyway. It's the basement light that gets turned on first thing when you open the basement door.
After reading this post, I'm thinking they're really not worth it.
It appears the LED bulbs are coming on strong. They have a lot of advantages. I think they strike or come on instantly, produce almost no heat, have better light rendition than fluorescent, and don't contain mercury. They are as efficient or more efficient that CFL's. The drawback is that they have been outrageously expensive. Some if them were a hundred bucks or more. OTOH, they are supposed to be nearly permanent with a life expectancy of as much as 20 years. The last ones I saw were half the price they used to be, so maybe with mass production the price will approach something reasonable that you won't have to bump your mortgage to invest in.
I have two desk lights about three feet apart. The CFL is much brighter. I'd investigate the 'wattage' but I really don't care. I am at the age when brighter is better, and waiting for the CFL to get to full strength is not an issue. I move slower than that! LOL!
I`m getting rid of my CFL`s, I cann`t stand them and the biggest reason is the tree huggers are forcing them on us and we have nothing to say about it. The only bad thing about the LED`s, besides price, is that they don`t put out to much light as of yet, but like everything else that to shall come. Larry
They are dim, I mean really, really dim.... we bought some at work for a specific application, and they were just plain awful. We only had to put up with it about a year though before they started burning out. Great performance from a $30 bulb. Green or not, its hard to beat the plain old light bulb in my view. I'll spend extra on skylights and such rather than buy green bulbs that don't work well and burn out as quickly as regular ones but cost 10x more.
Over the last ten years or so I have noticed a big difference in the life of various incandescent lamps. The longest life have been Phillips lamps. I have never looked at the package to see where the are made but, for me at least, they outlast any other brand. The worst were Sylvania brand purchased at Costco. I was lucky to get a month out of those.