Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Switch/relay Question for DC

Posts

Switch/relay Question for DC

#1

Switch/relay Question for DC

Barry Irby

I have the Long Ranger remote switch for my DC. Its a relay that connects to low voltage switches on the blast gates. When you open the gates the low voltage closes the relay and turns on the DC. Bought it from WoodCroft. First one crapped out at about a year and a half and they replaced it under the two year warranty. The replacement lasted about two and a half years and crapped out. The local WoodCraft has stopped handling them but gave me the number for Penn State Industries. Penn State gave me the number for PSI Woodworking Industries. They said that since it was more than two years old I was on my own. Wanted the full $49.95 (retail) for a replacement. I was reluctant, so they said they might have a reconditioned one they would let me have for $29.95.

The label on the box said that if I open it, I voided the warranty. Since it was crapped out and out of warranty, I opened it anyway, hoping I could free up the contacts or advance the spark, or put the smoke back in or something. (It failed in the "on" position, so figured the contacts were welded.) No joy, the relay is sealed.

What I thought was interesting was that the relay says right on it "1 hp @ 110V" and "2 hp @ 220V". On the exterior of the box it says not to exceed 1 1/2hp. I'm running it on a 1 1/2 hp Delta unit which I also bought at Wood Craft. Could this be why they don't want you to open the box? The contractor is under rated, but they figure it will last two years in a hobby shop?

I know we live in a disposable age, but I expect products to last longer than the warranty period, a lot longer, not just barely make it.

Anybody got a better suggestion? I like the blast gate switches. Open the gate, turn on the machine, make the cuts, turn off the machine, close the gate. The DC is not in the shop, its outside in a little annex, so a Clicker would not work well and it would be something else to keep up with.

Does anybody make a 120 volt relay that will handle the DC for a long time? I could plug that into this and the DC into that, taking the high voltage strain off this.

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#2

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

Bill Howatt

I don't know how suitable it is for getting into the on/off switches themselves and controlling them with your smaller relay but a magnetic switch would have the ratings you need. Here is an inexpnesive one:

http://www.grizzly.com/products/Magnetic-Switch-Single-Phase-110V-Only-2-HP/G8291

There are things like air-conditioner contactors but often they have a good current rating but only are 1HP at 120V. Here is one that is rated at 2HP at 120V. There obviously are others but I found this site first.

http://americanhvacparts.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Product_Code=CTR30242PSD&Category_Code=C1

I'm always on the scrounge for old relays/contactors to have on hand. My DC is running off an old one from a neighbours junked central AC but it runs off 240V which seems to make relay ratings easier to deal with.

Bill

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#3

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC *LINK*

Phil Joines

What kind of base does the relay have? You can get 120v relays with all kind of power ratings. For that matter you can use two sets of contacts to double the capacity. They are usually less than $10. Here's one from the Surplus Center. One thing to look at is the base style, there are square mounts like in the link and round 8 pin mounts and lots of variations.


https://www.surpluscenter.com/item.asp?item=11-1503B&catname=electric

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#4

OK, I am flummoxed.....

Barry Irby

I seems obvious to me that the gadget I have is under rated for the job.

What is the difference between a relay and a motor starter?

A magnetic switch or starter has a electromagnet that pulls the switch closed when you press the button.

A relay ahsan electromagnet that closes the contacts when you apply current. Am I right so far?

So, If I sue the lightly rated gadget I have now to apply current to either a heavy duty relay or to a magnetic switches coil, would that not take the heavy load off the gadget and let the switch or Relay do the job?

Assuming it the heavy current draw that ruined the one I have, it seems that would make it last much longer? IS there a way to wire into the coil on the magnetic switch to allow it to be automated?

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#5

Re: OK, I am flummoxed.....

BradinMD

Barry,

A motor starter is made to handle the inrush current turning on the motor and has an overload relay - either a heater element or solid state device. This overload allows the current limit to better match the motor, the breaker in your electrical panel does not have any adjustment to it's current limit trip level. Also, the motor starter should be wired so if the power drops out, the motor does not restart. A manaul restart is required to create safe conditions.

With respect to your situation, www.newark.com will have any type of relay you would ever need. What is the voltage rating and horsepower rating of the DC motor? This will size the relay needed. Newark should have a replacement for the relay soldered into the control unit (I'm assuming it soldered in place). You may even be able to find a direct replacement for the damage relay, but with a higher rating - thus ony one relay is needed. Post pictures of your relay/control unit and any further questions.

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#6

Disagree

Bill Howatt

Using 2 sets of contacts is not a guaranteed way of doubling the capacity. Normally one contact makes or breaks slightly earlier than the other and it will be taking all the current until the second one gets into the picture. Relays are not spec'd for "matched" contact and the situation will likely further degrade as the relay gets used and pitted.

It may extend the contact life somewhat but it is not a recommended way of upgrading contact ratings. For this reason I will parallel not-needed contacts but I don't consider it doubling the rating.

Bill

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#7

Re: Disagree

Larry in NW OHIO

Barry I have some relays and sockets and a few other things. I wired my DC to the switchs of the dust maker and that activated an air solenoid which then feed an air cylinder on the blast gate. This works very well for me and that is why I have a few elec. devices around. If you think I may have something you could use just ask, and if I have it you are more than welcome to it. Larry

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#8

X10

Tony - Memphis

I've been using X10 components to start/stop my Delta 850 DC for around 12 years. The only issue I have had is accidently sucking up the remote. There are lots of great deals on X10 components on eBay. I use an X10 controlled receptacle and one of their remotes/receivers. The last remotes I bought were 3 for $9.99. I also have one of the Sears controllers that turns on a red light when it senses current so I can see the DC is on at a glance.

Tony

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#9

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Barry, whatever relay or contactor you use with your wireless remote will need contacts that can handle the voltage and current needed for the device- not just any device or current- you need a contactor that is designed for "inductive loads" (motor) not "resistive loads" (XMAS lights, coffee maker, etc.). Inductive loads are much tougher on contacts. Also, the contact rating should exceed that of your motor- an 8 amp motor will much more than that on start up and there will also be a surge during shut down, so the contacts can arc when the make and open.

Most of those cheap remotes are just not rated to work with 1.5hp and larger induction motors on DC's (in your case it was not even rated correctly). They may work for awhile, but the contacts will eventually get pitted, carboned up, then fail.

Unless your DC is really far away or you really need a wireless remote, you can likely use your existing gate switches with a 24V transformer to run a heavy duty contactor relay (contactors come with either low voltage (24V) or line voltage (120V/240V) coils). You can use inexpensive bell wire to hook the gate switch circuit to transformer and contactor coil.

I use a "three wire" low voltage control to manually operate my autogates. All parts were from the Surplus center or Ebay.

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

Jesper, Denmark

Barry, get a motor starter from and industrial electrical supply house.

The starter is a magnetic relay, where the start and stop contacts only handle the coil current, so you can wire as many contacts from the dampers you like in the start/stop circuit.

The main contacts handle the motor current and are designed to handle it. You should be able to find the circuit diagrams in the various catalogs on the net, or Google it. If you get stuck, let me know, and i can probably sketch you something you will understand.

Forget all the Mickey Mouse sealed relays, use a real industrial component, and your troubles will be over.

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#11

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

Barry Irby

I am trying to get this clear in my head. A magnetic motor starter is a relay that has a coil that closes the main contacts. One advantage is that if the coil loses power the switch opens and the machine won't run until the switch/starter is reset. Another advantage is the contacts are designed for this application and are heavy enough to withstands thousands or tens of thousands of starts and stops.

What I want is such a device that can be operated remotely with 12volts DC.

So, to hook up my present blast gate switches I need a source for 12 volts DC. (Assuming the switches are rated for 12 volts and not more)

So, Do magnetic starters come with an internal power supply? If there a built in power supply that I could just hook onto so that when one of my best gate switches closes, the magnetic starter would start the Dust Collector?

The reason I was tempted to use what I have is that it has a 12 volt power supply. It has 120 volts output. If I bought a contactor that had a 120 VAC coil, it could operate it.

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#12

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

Jesper, Denmark

If I undrstand you correctly, the "remote" does not mean wireless.

The starter can be wired up to any number of switches in paralell, which energize the starter as you open a blastgate with a switch and drops it out again as you close the blast gate. I assume your blast gate switches will handle the 120Volt - and there is very little current, so wire size is not important.

The only problem with multiple start-stop switches is that they need to momentary contacts, or the motor will start again after a power failure.

As you open a blast gate, the switch needs to close (starting the DC) and then open again, allowing the auxiliary contact on the starter to provide the holding current to the coil.

Similarly, when you close the gates, another switch needs to open, breaking the holding current to the coil, so the DC stops.

The wireless gismo can do this, as it operates a relay, so one push will close the relay and another open it. The relay contacts can be used top control the coil on the motor starter.

.............if you see what I mean?

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#13

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

BradinMD

Barry,

try www.newark.com, search for part number 17m1537. Its S30.50 and contacts are rated for 1.5 hp at 120 vac, 12VDC coil. It happens to be a douple pole douple throw (DPDT), you only need a single pole single throw (SPST) version - not shown as available from newark. The DPDT would work on 220 VAC single phase later in life if needed. The SPST would only work for 120 VAC. Suggest looking at the metal box to mount it in, part number 35D013 for $20.18. The relay above is an open frame device and would need to be mounted in a metal box of some type.

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

#14

Re: Switch/relay Question for DC

BradinMD

Barry, you can get a better price and selection at www.mcmaster.com on what should be the same relay and cover. Search p/n 7384k13 for the SPST at $18.20 or p/n 7384k32 for DPST at $19.96. Use first for 120 vac and second for 240 vac at 1.5 hp. The cover is p/n 7384k45 at $16.12. Mcmaster also has a lower shipping cost than newark typically.