Bad News about walnut
bill tindall
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Whitney Cranshaw <bugbooksdirect@yahoo.com>
Date: Wed, Aug 11, 2010 at 7:34 AM
Subject: Impressions of the TCD infestation in Knoxville
I had the opportunity this week to visit the thousand cankers infestation in the Knoxville with my plant pathology cohort Ned Tisserat.
The infestation occurs over a very wide area within Knox County. Most heavily infested in the NW quadrant but preliminary surveys suggest that it may be found in almost every corner of the county. Very possibly further - they are just beginning to systematically survey.
This suggests that the walnut twig beetle was introduced and established a very long time ago � possibly 20 years ago.
There are many trees showing advanced stage decline of thousand cankers - and many trees appear to already have been cut in recent years based on all the stumps.
There is high probability that TCD-infested walnut has been leaking out of the Knoxville area for many years. Where? No one knows. However, the two main routes where I understand walnut lumber and logs from this part of the state head to are Atlanta and points in Indiana. I think it is worth some intensive surveys be done ASAP of sites handling walnut wood in these areas.
The mortality among the walnuts clearly shows that thousand cankers is a disease of major consequence that will work its way well through eastern forests - urban or natural forest areas alike. I think that several people had expected/hoped that this was a western problem due to climate differences. It is not.
There due seem to be some differences in the progress of thousand cankers and the symptoms expression from the Rocky Mountain states. In Knoxville the strongest roadside symptom is that the top dies out first and there may be quite a bit of bushy growth, perhaps some epicormic, in the lower canopy during end stages of TCD. In Colorado we do not see this and branches at all levels may die pretty much at the same time. Also, there is a modest amount of sprouting from stumps - something that we rarely see. I think that this may be due to differences in growing
conditions, primarily moisture, that allow eastern walnuts to be more vigorous and to have more stored root reserves. Since TCD is ultimately a disease that kills by depletion of the tree's energy, one would expect some differences in the disease among trees in various states of original health.
I expect other eastern infestations to become recognized in the near future. The earlier these are detected I think the better we will be so we can make the most reasonable plans to try and contain and slow the spread of thousand cankers disease.
If you are involved in detection work here are some ideas on how you might go about it.
First of all do it ASAP. You probably have about 3-4 weeks maximum to do any extensive survey in 2010. Soon there will be so many other crown symptoms developing that they will mask TCD symptoms making detection much more difficult.
Also, there are other crown symptoms that will be distracting even at this point. We saw many walnuts dropping leaves and showing a general thinning of the crown due to infestation of spider mites and/or rust mites. Aphids and lacebugs may also produce some yellowing symptoms.
And, towards the end of the season small limbs compromised by all manner of injuries will start to flag.
What I would look for first in a survey are trees with existing crown dieback. Then I would look for individucal branches that show flagging - either of yellowing leaves remaining attached or leaves that have collapsed and wilted. The latter is a somewhat stronger possible symptom. Then I would try to collect a dead or dying limb and look for the minute exit hotes. (When peeled carefully the exit holes will have associated larval galleries.) This can be considered confirmation as walnut twig beetle = Geosmithia morbida = thousand cankers disease. Remember that, despite the name of the beetle, this insect does not colonize walnut twigs, despite being a "twig beetle" of the genus Pityophthorus. I would say branches of 1-2 inch diameter are most likely to have evidence of colonization.
We are in the process of rewriting the Pest Alert and "Questions and Answers about Thousand Cankers Disease/Walnut Twig Beetle" at our web site:
http://www.colostate.edu/Depts/bspm/extension%20and%20outreach/thousand%20cankers.html
. If you want these, check back early next week for the updated version.
Again I would like to stress the importance of an effort to contain thousand cankers and slow its spread from where ever it is found. Clearly the idea of eradication is off the table and should not
even be given a moment's further consideration. We are well past the point when that was even a remote possibility. However, if we can slow the spread there can be tremendous value to this country.
For example, let's use an estimate that this insect will move an average of 2 miles a year, unassisted by humans. Personally I think this is a generous estimate overall, particularly when it moves through forested land and not along open highway corridors. However, if this is correct
the it will take about 115 years to reach Columbia, MO from Knoxville. In the interim we can expect some progress in management - including the identification and development of resistant Juglans nigra. Furthermore, this will greatly retard the necessity to prematurely cut black walnut
which will destroy the market value (particularly once the Japanese and Europeans start to turn back US exports).
Or TCD could get from Knoxville to Columbia this afternoon, in the back of a pick-up by someone who is unaware of the consequences of the casual movement of a small piece of walnut wood. (Also the beetles are flying now so that rest stops en route could also be sprinkled.)
Education about thousand cankers is key to any program that will have any possible impact on slowing the spread. Quarantines and regulations that give some enforcement strength will also be helpful. And this needs to begin in earnest yesterday.
Whitney Cranshaw
Colorado State University



