Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

Posts

Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#1

Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

doug f, san clemente, ca

After working with band saws for almost 40 years, I coming to the conclusion that setting tension is a very arbitrary thing. I have used strumming, flutter, built in gauges (useless), the side push test and just plain "cut the wood and see if it works." I can still not be sure that the tension is optimal.

The price of tension meters is slowly coming down; Iturra Design has one now for $150 and I'm thinking seriously about biting the bullet. Has anyone here used a tension meter, any tension meter, and, in your experience, is it worthwhile to buy a tool that you use perhaps twice a year?

I'm not looking for a review of any particular meter, just an overall opinion as to whether they are useful.

Thanks for the help.

Doug

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#2

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I use my own meter. I grab the blade with my thumb and index finger (that's my meter) and give it a twang. Seems to work for me. ;-)

T.

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#3

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

I have used the same meter as Tommy for nearly 60 years. Works great.

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#4

My Blade Tension Monitor

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Doug,

My most beloved wood working buddy, Kurt Augustin, once demonstrated how he learned about tensioning and detensioning a band saw blade when he was an apprentice in Germany. As Kurt told it, the Master would check the blade tension using the Tommy Skaggs method. If the blade tension was incorrect, the apprentice would be immediately and forcefully cuffed in the back of the head by The Master's Hand. And, God Help the poor apprentice if the blade was not detensioned after the work day ended!

Kurt told me he wouldn't use the Master's discipline on me, but every time he came into the shop, the first thing he'd do would be to check the tension on the blade of my bandsaw. And, he'd let me know about it.

We spent many a fine hour together, and had many a cold beer.

George

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#5

Clint Searl

Re: My Blade Tension Monitor

Clint Searl

Conventional woodworking wisdom has it that the blade must be de-tensioned after use.

Why?

Will it stretch and fall off the wheels?

Will it make the wheels egg shaped?

Will the bandsaw police ban you from the shop?

Inquiring minds want to know!

Clint

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#6

Two Answers

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Not sure on those, Clint, but

it will impair your vision and

it will make hair grow on your palms

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Two Answers

Clint Searl

Best then to live with the tension, huh, Mark?

Clint

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#8

Well worth the money.

Virgil Johnson

If you sell these for a living.

For the average home shop I think they are overkill. My PM 141 has been set using the built in gage for the 23 years I've owned it and it works just fine. The blade only gets de tensioned when it is being changed and the casting has not broke or the wheels been forced into an egg shape.

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#9

OK, I'll bite...

doug f, san clemente, ca

When you listen for the twang, what are you listening for? Keep in mind that my guitar teacher advised that perhaps I should take up drums if I wanted to play an instrument.

I'll use any method I can if i just know when it's right.

Doug

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#10

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

John Lucas

I tried the built in gauge, once in a while it works.

I tried making one the homemade quages the was demonstrated in Finewoodworking where you tension the blade X number of thousandths per width of blade. I started off using a feeler gauge like they said then tried using a dial indicator. It seemed to help get me a little more consistent.

I tried plucking the blade the same way I do my scroll saw. Again worked sometimes and other not. I have played guitar for 40 years so I think I have somewhat of an ear but honestly can't pluck a note out of the air without a reference. Not perfect pitch.

The final method that seems to work for me. I have a 14" delta with riser block. You can see the blade on the left side of the saw. I adjust the tension until it doesn't flutter. That's been about as good or better than any of the above methods.

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#11

All right, let's back up a little...

doug f, san clemente, ca

and ask a more basic question. Does anyone here even USE a tension meter? There's a ton of them for sale on various websites, but are there any buyers? Or is this just an infomercial away from a yellow, left-handed widget?

Doug

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#12

I Dunno, Doug

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Evening Doug,

I imagine if I had a shop and ran bandsaws for hours at a time, I would probably have one on each saw. It stanbds to reason that the blade lasts longer and cuts better if it is tensioned properly. And, its got to be better for the saw.

However, since Kurt left this earth, my tensioning hasn't occupied the forefront of my mind. The Skaggs method works for me.

George

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#13

What the Lenox technical rep said.....

bill tindall

He thought our club might buy one and loan it to calibrate everyone's on-board saw gauge. Once calibrated, there is no further need for it.

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#14

Ellis Walentine

Squishy subject

Ellis Walentine

Since there is disagreement among experts as to what the "correct" tension reading should be, I've never bothered with meter readings. A long time ago, someone told me to tension a blade such that when the top blade guide is in its highest position, the blade should deflect no more than 1/4" with moderate finger pressure. Even that is a squishy recommendation, since the deflection will vary with the space between the guides and since there's no quantitative definition of finger pressure. I don't always trust empirical measures, either, such as wandering and cupping during resawing operations, because I know those vary with the gauge and width of the blade, the number, style and set of the teeth, the thickness and species of the wood and the feed pressure.

Ellis

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#15

Clint Searl

Re: I Dunno, Doug *LINK*

Clint Searl

"It stanbds to reason that the blade lasts longer and cuts better if it is tensioned properly. And, its got to be better for the saw. "

George, what you say certainly supports the conventional wisdom, but I don't think there's any actual data that validates it. My guess is that a blade needs to be replaced because the teeth "wear out." If so, how does tension impact tooth wear? Also, what does "cuts better" mean, and how has that been demonstrated? Finally, How is it "better for the saw?"

I suppose (without empiricalproof) that once the blade stops flapping in the breeze, tension has little if any effect on overall performance. Check out what Suffolk has to say, below.

Clint


Six Rules of Sawing

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#16

Re: Squishy subject

Bill White

Methinks that all the tech stuff available has a tendancy to keep us from understanding the fundamentals of our chosen craft. The pyramids were built without a laser.

Bill

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#17

Yahbut...

Brad Chenoweth

The ancient Egyptians had the help of aliens from outer space, at least that's what they said on the History Channel!

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#18

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

paul in AZ

I have no thoughts of getting a tension meter. Perhaps I might give it some casual thought if there was solid data on what the exact and "correct" tension should be and the benefits thereof.

This thread does raise some interesting points going beyond the specifics of a meter. Clint and others have raised the broader issue of tradition-based vs. evidence-based practices. Many traditional practices are valid and have empirically evolved in response to failures in the past but just as many are perpetrated just because that is what we were taught. This is true in any area I can think of. Lets not forget that for lack of evidence based thinking the world was flat for a very long time and night air caused disease.

I detension my blades when I remember to but do so because 'they' said to. Does that really prevent blade stretch, or oval wheels or add to a blade's life? I don't know. Makes me wonder why I bother.

It would be nice to have some hard data.

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#19

Falling off the wheel

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I don't think stretch was ever considered, on older saws they used rubber for the tires and the rubber could take a set if the blade was tensioned and sat in one position for several days. I saw this with my Dad's band saw before the tires were replaced. This set resulted in some nasty vibrations when one operated the saw. I don't think urethane tires have the same problem, but I still try to remember to de-tension my blade after use.

Lee

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#20

Re: No to hijack your thread, but...

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

Is there sucha thing as too much tension and what does it hurt? I have an admittedly cheap 12" Craftsman saw that I just tighten up and call it good.

glc

Re: Band Saw tension meter-worth the money?

#21

Re: No to hijack your thread, but...

Larry in NW OHIO

I have a cheap about 35 year old 12" craftsman bandsaw, and I only replaced a couple of bearings in all that time and it still cuts like it`s new, and that is good. It does everything I ask of it. Of course it was made in the USA at the time. I can`t believe it but it still has the original tires on it yet. But I bet when I start it up tomorrow it`ll fall apart on the floor in a pile of metal. Larry