Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Dust Deputy

Posts

Dust Deputy

#1

Dust Deputy

Larry in NW OHIO

I guess in the Jan,2010 Shopnotes magazine there is an article on making a cart for a shop vac with the dust deputy on it. If anyone has this, could you copy and send it to me or send it by email. I`ll be happy to reemburse you for any cost. Thank you. Larry

Re: Dust Deputy

#2

Re: Dust Deputy

Bob in NE Ohio

Larry

I have all of the Shop Notes so I am sure it is there. If you still need it I can scan it next weekend and send it to you.

Let me know

Bob

Re: Dust Deputy

#3

Re: Dust Deputy

Larry in NW OHIO

Bob that would be great, let me know how much I Owe you. Larry

Re: Dust Deputy

#4

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Chuck Lenz

Re: Dust Deputy

#5

Re: I really hate to go here

Larry in NW OHIO

Chuck I`m sorry that this rubbed you the wrong way. I would never "steal" anyones idea such as yours. But as I understand it,I read it sometime back in an article, that if it`s an article in a magazine it`s fair game. If I`m wrong I do want to know. Larry

Re: Dust Deputy

#6

Re: I really hate to go here

Chris Friesen

"I would never "steal" anyones idea such as yours. But as I understand it,I read it sometime back in an article, that if it`s an article in a magazine it`s fair game. If I`m wrong I do want to know."

I'm pretty sure you're wrong. The plan (and the magazine article itself) is covered under copyright law, which prohibits unauthorized copying. Generally if a plan is created by an employee of a magazine then the magazine can decide whether to waive copyright, but if it is contributed by someone else they retain copyright on the plan and the magazine has no say.

There are exceptions to copyright law for various things (educational study, "fair use", etc.) so the question is whether or not your situation falls into those exceptions.

Re: Dust Deputy

#7

Ellis Walentine

Legalities vs tacit understandings

Ellis Walentine

I grappled with this question when I sat in the editor's seat at American Woodworker. Basically, there is little incentive for publishers to pursue readers who share articles and published plans with each other. If anything, magazines like having people talk about articles and plans, as it is good advertising for them. Further, magazines realize how utterly fruitless it would be to attempt to police project plans, even when, as has often happened, a reader seizes the idea and turns it into a production item for sale. That is simply the risk a magazine or author takes when it/he publishes plans that will be distributed to half a million people.

In general, if the intellectual property value is worth protecting, you don't publish it, any more than the Defense Department publishes blueprints for H-bombs, and you protect it assiduously when someone infringes on your property rights.

Anyhow, this is the way I've always understood and handled the situation.

Ellis

Re: Dust Deputy

#8

Re: Legalities vs tacit understandings

Phil Joines

I've heard the early H bomb plans were declassified and are available in the libraries of places like MIT.

What would be fair use for them ;)

Re: Dust Deputy

#9

Re: I really hate to go here

Joe Pack

Not arguing, just asking...If a plan is published in a magazine, and if that magazine is in a public library for anyone to see, is copying the plan for personal use illegal or unethical? Isn't the purpose of publishing a dimensioned plan in a magazine so that readers can use it to build that project? If so, is making a copy of a published plan and sharing it with a buddy any different than that buddy going to the library to get the plan? Is this any different than copying a homemade chili recipe from a food magazine and sharing it with a friend?

Of course, if someone copied the plan and sold it, I do believe that to be completely unethical and probably illegal. I believe sharing a published idea is not unethical, but profiting off the sharing is out of line.