Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

bandsaw thumping

Posts

bandsaw thumping

#1

bandsaw thumping

paul in AZ

I just changed the blade on my Jet 18", putting on a 3/4" 0.025ga. 3tpi. I've used 1/2" mostly 6tpi blades in the past with no problems.

When running, there is a thumping noise that I think comes from the weld. Is this common or 'normal'?

As far as I can see the welded area looks perfectly normal.

I can put up with the sound but my other question is if this is a weld noise whether there is some risk of the weld coming apart and doing some real damage?

Re: bandsaw thumping

#2

Re: bandsaw thumping

Larry in NW OHIO

Paul Yes it more than likely it is coming from the weld. It must be offset just a smig, bandsaw technical term for offset a tiny bit. Or the weld wasn`t ground off good enough. I use to weld them together in another life. If it breaks, not likely will if it`s a brand name, it`s not going to going anywhere also it shouldn`t break anything eighter. I`ve had a couple break on me, except for haveing to clean out my pants, i just put on a new blade and kept on cutting. You also may want to run your fingers over the weld, off the machine, and see if it is level. If not, put the blade onsomething like a pipe in a vise and the weld on the pipe and file it a little smoother. Larry

Re: bandsaw thumping

#3

Re: bandsaw thumping

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Paul,

I agree witgh Larry. I think the problem stems from the weld. I have a 3/4" Timberwolf blade which also thumps, an annoyance which I don't have with other resdaw blades from either Suffolk Machinery or Highland Hardware. I'm sure its perfactly okay, but it causes me not to use the blade in favor of other stable-mates.

George

Re: bandsaw thumping

#4

A more pernicious possibility

Henry Higginbotham

Have you switched back to the 1/2" blade to see if the noise goes away? It's possible that the sheave on the lower wheel shaft has come slightly loose. I've had this to happen, and it makes a noise that I originally suspected was coming from the blade, or from something stuck on a tire. If not fixed quickly, it can really mangle the shaft, and that's a lot more expensive than a blade.

Re: bandsaw thumping

#5

Re: bandsaw thumping

bob davis

if it is a timberwolf. send it back. they will replace it

Re: bandsaw thumping

#6

Re: bandsaw thumping

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Or, if you're like me and don't run the bandsaw for weeks at a time, the drive belt has taken a set from the small pulley. The thump goes away after a 10-minute warm-up.

Re: bandsaw thumping

#7

Ah Ha!!  I am so busted....

Barry Irby

I have been wondering why my saw thumps and I think you just told me, because it goes away after a few minutes.

Re: bandsaw thumping

#8

Re: bandsaw thumping

Marv

Paul,

Check the back edge of the blade at the weld. Check to see if it was ground off even above and below the weld.

Also check the spacing of the teeth at the weld. If the weld was properly done, the spacing of the teeth should be close to the same as all the other teeth. When you have a blade with so few teeth per inch, sometimes there can be a missing tooth right at the weld. This might cause a thump when you are sawing but not when the saw is just running free.

Another thing to check is if the weld is warped and not even with the sides of the blade above and below the weld. Raise the guide bar up and lay a straight edge against the side of the blade at the weld. A wrinkled weld will thump.

I have a butt welder on my Jet bandsaw. When I weld a blade, I cut and match the ends of the blade so I have an even number of teeth after I'm done grinding the weld. Sometimes I even file a tooth right in the weld itself. Marv likes a smooth saw cut and no snicks or thumps.

Marv

Re: bandsaw thumping

#9

Re: bandsaw thumping -solved??

paul in AZ

I may or may not have solved at least part of it.

I carefully checked out the weld which looks OK to me [like I REALLY know]; the back edge is plumb; and tooth gap is good. So, I spun the top wheel manually under minimal tension and watched the blade. There seemed to be an intermittent wobble unrelated to the weld. When gently touching the blade while spinning by hand I could feel a single area that felt 'lumpy' for lack of a better word. This area looks like it had been deformed or bent. I could easily have twisted the blade in some abnormal way when uncoiling it, putting a bend into the metal. I'm guessing here.

Next i put a little extra tension on it and started to open an olive crotch I've had for several years to put tension and some heat on the blade. After a bunch of slices the thump lessened and has almost gone away. Back to spinning by hand and it feels like that ?twisted lumpy area has pulled out nearly flat.

Was that really the entire answer? Who knows?

The blade seems to cut well and I'll not worry about a breaking weld.

The real disappointment is now that this olive crotch had all kinds of twisting internal splitting and is mostly unusable. Win some, lose some. The crotch was free anyway so all I lost was the years of storage.

Thanks for the responses guys.

Re: bandsaw thumping

#10

Re: bandsaw thumping -solved??

Marv

Paul,

More than likely, you are right about the blade being twisted. I doubt though that you did it while unrolling it. It was probably done when it was rolled up. Some people when rolling up a blade will do too much twisting of the blade, especially on a 3/4" width. A little twisting makes it easier to make the blade go into a smaller circle when crossing the blade over itself from one side to the other.

You might try taking it off the machine and twist it by hand in the opposite direction that will tend to bend it straighter, that is if the lesser amount of thumping is still bugging you. I think I'd send it back and get another one.

Marv

Re: bandsaw thumping

#11

Re: bandsaw thumping -solved??

paul in AZ

Thanks Marv:

My thinking now is to sit on it a while. By the time I pay for shipping back east both ways I'll have paid for half a new blade. My guess is that with some use the blade will stretch itself out pretty flat. As it stands as long as I am reasonably sure what the problem is the diminished thumping is tolerable for my episodic use. If not and the thumping annoys me I'll ship it back.