Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

What has happened to us?

Posts

Re: What has happened to us?

#26

Re: Where be ya, laddie?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Lee,

We are here in the Philadelphia area's SouthWestern suburbs, where there is plenty of cold beer and warm conviviality. I keep a frozen mug on hand awaiting your visit. Come see us too.

George

Re: What has happened to us?

#27

Lee Grindinger

Great observations, Dave!

Lee Grindinger

It's interesting how access to all this information has changed us.

This is great stuff, a quote from your post that deserves repeating...,

"I have noticed over the last 25 years that people, to a certain degree, have become more selfish (for lack of a better term...). This has ineveitably affected society as a whole. The advent of the internet, cell phones, and nearly instantaneous satellite communication has allowed the world to become smaller while somehow increasing the percieved importance of those living on it. People have come to believe that their opinions & beliefs are more important than strength of character and respect of others... By making the world smaller "we" have made our lives a little smaller. We draw "our" world in close around us, limiting our exposure to the growth opportunities that can only be experienced through life "outside"..."

Re: What has happened to us?

#28

Re: What has happened to us?

Jesse Cloud

Well, Lee, I'm crossing my fingers and hoping you might be wrong, or at least that our forum is an exception. After that first response, the conversation has been admirably civil. Makes me proud to be here.

I wish we could turn down the volume on all the media figures trying so hard to scare us or make us mad and listen to each other.

I saw a great bumper sticker - "Don't believe everything you think." Words to live by.

Let us know if you're headed thru central NM and I'll put the beer on to chill!

Jess

Re: What has happened to us?

#29

Lee Grindinger

"Don't believe everything you think."

Lee Grindinger

Okay..., that's my new slogan!

I agree, this thread has been incredibly civil.

Re: What has happened to us?

#30

getting along

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It's very hard to learn how to argue the idea without personal attachment to your perception of the right answer. Friends (Quaker) meetings make decisions by consensus, which requires that each member be prepared to argue (in the philosophical sense) his/her opinion about the right answer to a problem, while at the same time being prepared to admit s/he may be wrong and that the Meeting's larger goals may require agreement to the consensus answer - and, all the while, being prepared to listen to all other ideas with an open mind, even those coming from junior members (I still recall the first time I saw a Meeting brought to a halt in an action it was preparing to take because a 14-year-old member thought it was the wrong decision; the final outcome incorporated some of his ideas into a much better overall solution). Even though this method is central to Quaker life, not all meetings succeed at all times in maintaining it, and I can tell you it is a darned hard skill to learn as an adult.

The struggle to get along and to listen to and/or disagree with each other respectfully is well worth it; but it's a hard one. I think most people want to live with each other that way.

Re: What has happened to us?

#31

Re: What has happened to us?

iew

It finally had to happen. In the 50's through 80's we could discuss Politics, Religion and even our choice of beer freely. The masses have been dhimmied down. We are no longer a melting pot. Recent Immigrants refuse to be assimilated into main stream body. The hippies of the 60's are now in charge. The left has moved more left and the right has moved more left. There are no more main stream Democrats or Republicans. Socialism has creeped into our daily life and consumes us. The "what have you done for me today" crowd is larger and louder. Some still clammer for reparations they don't deserve. What I have in my wallet doesn't belong to me anymore. Woodworking is what brings us together. Shame on the woodworking site that became a social experiment (not here). We must again become aware that we all are different and have different opinions and be respectful of that. The current situation in Washington will continue to be abrasive and divisive.

Re: What has happened to us?

#32

Re: What has happened to us?

John Veerkamp

Lee,

I hear you loud & clear. However I came from a large family and sometimes silence is the only way to avoid hurt feelings.

I never made it to Montanafest, but I had it on my future agenda. Life has a way of changing plans, doesn't it? If you get thru the mid-west in your travels, the cold beer will be ready here also. I'm about 50 miles south oh KC, MO right off of US 71 hiway.

John

Re: What has happened to us?

#33

Re:  I don't know if is there's any relationship

North of the Border

but in some of the talk shows, views are expressed in combative, acidic or demeaning manner, whether by the hosts or by the guests invited to speak on the programs. Like kids learning from watching children's shows on TV, adults may imitate the 'arms uptight' attitude promoted among those talk shows, whenever a political topic comes up. Just a suspicion only, no proof.

Re: What has happened to us?

#34

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Europe and other foreign places...,

Jesper, Denmark

Lee, most EU countries - including Denmark - have many political parties. Not really associated with the various -isms you refer to, but different flavors across the spectrum from the socialistic left to the conservative right.

Anarkists do not, as the definition implies, form political parties, and Marxism/Communism as a form of government is universally recognized by thinking people as impossible utopias.

Political discussions tend to be centered around local interests and what to say to get elected rather than expressing any philosophical direction. I think that is universally the nature of politicians - whatever flavor they pretend to be.

I will refrain from any more explicit commentary to keep this in the intended spirit of the forum. I do not personally profess to any specific direction in politics or religion, but do tend to have strong opinions on many subjects.

Re: What has happened to us?

#35

Re:  I don't know if is there's any relationship

Bill Howatt

It may not be the primary factor but I'd say it ranges from "doesn't help the situation" to contributing a little to the problem.

Of course, the media people love it when they can fan the flames and get a heated exchange going.

Even though we live in the information age where one would think exposure to all sides of the argument is good and would sway opinions, studies have shown that the vast majority of people tend to go to outlets where they know their opinion will be supported. In other words you aren't going to find strong conservatives listening to a liberal current affairs program.

Bill

Re: What has happened to us?

#36

Re: What has happened to us?

Bill White

Personally, I think we should bring back dueling.

Bill

Re: What has happened to us?

#37

Re: What has happened to us?

Big Dave

Probably not a bad idea...

I remember as a kid that it wasn't that uncommon to see or hear about someone getting punched in the face for saying something that, maybe, could (or should) have been worded a bit differently. It's funny how people were more polite back then...

Re: What has happened to us?

#38

I Concur Lee

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

You know you are right,

There was a time when I think the format of the internet in its infancy was more conducive to some common honour and manners. Things have changed I think though over the last 5+ years or so, the net is now taken for granted as has they way we speak to others and decide on how important our thoughts are over others thoughts, balance has been lost in many places. I am not sure if this is because of the new generations of people now using the net from an earlier age, but conduct has definitely become something I have learnt to pay attention too and others have not, defending yourself on line at times comes akin to being Thugged in the street.

I have experienced some of that myself here on this forum and I have chosen to not be a member for awhile. I too shared my experience here with Ellis and there is little you can do with what happens on the forum or in the background off the screen on email. For example, I have been told to "Go F Myself" on email by a respected person on this site regarding a post I made, What was my recourse to that? I have total respect for that person and his clique of email friends. I was also "Thugged" by another person on this forum who is very well known, all distasteful and if we were face to face friends I suspect that I would not have been treated that way.

I think the comment made earlier about speaking face to face vs via the net is true, we speak face to face with all our senses, on line we write from our mind, not from our all our senses, and a sense of being able to click a screen off and walk away absolves some from their thoughts and words, no consequences.

I know I have some times written out responses in the past on line here and elsewhere that most of the time I deleted before hitting "Post", but a few times I have gone ahead and made a poor choice. Dignity is posting with consequence, standing behind your thoughts expressed in person if you had the chance. I find that dignity has become a lost social value on line and I have chosen carefully where I make friends and who I share with. As Ellis knows, I have soured on the WC because of personal experiences with some who have also forgotten what honour, sincerity and dignity truly mean, they can be who ever they choose to be ad famous as they like, but at the core of their foundations the pillar of dignity is rotted and not something I can ignore.

Lee, you are right, things have changed on line, not only WC but also on other forums, hoping for old fashioned norms to be valued is an ever increasing struggle. During my time as a mod here I saw this daily as I read nearly everything on line for nearly 2 years.

Since I stepped away from this forum and many others in the last year I have discovered my time is better spent off line doing the things that make me happiest rather than being on line.

It's time to take my dog for a walk with my daughter.

Take care

Jim

Re: What has happened to us?

#39

Correction

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

I mistyped,

Should be

I have LOST total respect for that person and his clique of email friends.

Re: What has happened to us?

#40

A few more thoughts on the subject...

Marv

Jim & Lee,

I'm not sure it has actually changed much at all. When the internet was first getting started back in the mid 90,s with chatrooms and such, I found myself frequenting them on a regular basis. Sort of an addiction for awhile. I can remember lots of arguing and fighting going on all the time. There was always a clique who seemed to decide who was in and who wasn't. It didn't take long to learn when first going into a particular chatroom who was in charge and who their cohorts were that made up the clique.

What we have here on WC are several chat rooms. What occurs here in WC is reminiscent to a degree of what those early chat rooms were like. Anytime you have a forum that attracts everyone and anyone, there will be conflicts and disagreements and back biting and everything else that people in general are capable of. It was the same way in grade school and then highschool. Always the cliques and bullies.

I have experienced a few confrontations here on WC, but nothing like I used to see in other chatrooms. Sitting here staring at a computer screen, as you guys have said, just isn't the same as face to face conversations. It seems that, that is where the problem lies. No facial expression, no body language. We try to keep our messages brief in most cases. So much more has to be writen in order to compensate for the lack of those other aspects of good communication.

The emoticons help a little at times. They can be used to convey how we are feeling when we are expressing ourselves. :)

Marv

Re: What has happened to us?

#41

Re: I Concur Lee

FredD

Jim,

your contributions far out weigh a disgruntled email sender.

Perhaps you will find the time and the inclination to return to WC and I have every confidence Ellis will take care of emails like the one you mentioned.

FredD

Re: What has happened to us?

#42

Re: A few more thoughts on the subject...

wilbur

I also don't think things have changed much at all. There were flamewars every bit as heated, if not more so, back in the days when the only forums around were the Usenet newsgroups, and that dates back to when I was in med school in the late 80's/early 90's.

Re: What has happened to us?

#43

The Thing That Bothers Me, Fred.....

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Fred, and Jim

I wondered where Jim had gone and why. I missed seeing his name and reading what he had to say. Most of all I missed his frequent and public expressions of friendship to me personally, and to so many others here.

Now that I understand the situation a little better I can empathize, since I left another forum a few years ago for the same reasons. I am bothered when a friend feels compelled to absent himself because of uncharitable actions of others. It also deprives me and other forum members of his presence. We become collectively diminished as a result.

George

Re: What has happened to us?

#44

Re: What has happened to us?

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

I shall not do a History lesson or a treatise. However, please remember that, at the moment, we are living through a manifestation of fear of change, anti-intellectualism, disdain for elites of any kind, and distrust of any experts. America was, after all, founded in large part by the Non-Possessed. The Mathers, et al, of New England obviously were intellectual but their kind did not Go West. We have had several periods such as today including the Supreme Order of the Star Spangled Banner, 1850, frankly the various religious Awakenings, the Palmer Raids of the '20s, the entire McCarthy period (and Stephenson was at fault here also by declaring that Eisenhower typified a change from the New Dealers to the Car Dealers) when little could be discussed rationally.

Also we must remember that many people still resent the cultural and economic change from rural/small town, isolationism, glacial change (so they thought) to the trauma of WWI and then the sudden global position of the US in 1945. Events creep up until they suddenly burst upon us like lightening, or so it seems.

Do not get discouraged but keep your guard up also.

Re: What has happened to us?

#45

Well analyzed and well said. But

North of the Border

there may be an exception: the Lumberjocks forum is full of woodworkers who are supportive, encouraging and interesting. Even when a different view is presented, it is worded in a civil manner. I can't say the same about some of the posts containing a different opinion seen in this forum.

Re: What has happened to us?

#46

Re: I Concur Lee

Jim Dillon

Hi Jim,

Like George, I have wondered about your absence over the past several months. Thanks for explaining what has been going on at your end. Yes, one has to have a fairly thick skin sometimes and, frankly, I don't know how politicians do it, but maybe to them it is more of a game than anything else - which is perhaps unfortunate for us ordinary citizens. Whenever I feel my blood start to boil over some, in my view, inane comment by a "20 year old" on the talk shows or blogs, I come to my senses, sort of, by reminding myself that MY generation raised these "kids". What went wrong? I think Wilber and "Big Dave" summarized some of my thoughts nicely. Compared to many, albeit nonwoodworking sites, I find WC to be pretty darn civil. While I may disagree with the opinions and philosophies expoused by some on both OT and woodworking related topics (SawStop comes to mind) here at WC, I try to understand where the other person is coming from. Doesn't always work, but it helps. HOWEVER, some of the stuff you describe, and had to put up with as a WC moderator, would also make me reconsider my commitment. Hang in there, Jim. And don't leave us!!

Time to walk our dogs as well :) .

Jim

Re: What has happened to us?

#47

It's a shame......

Brent Smith in Montreal

that these things happen on forums. For the most part people realize that their actions on the net truly are representative of their personalities. Unfortunately, there are a few people, (and there is the odd time for the majority of people) where hurtful, degrading or otherwise insulting comments are the norm. As mentioned before, the internet provides an anonymity not found in 'real' life and leads some to behave in a less than Honorable fashion.

Ellis, and all Mods, please don't take this as criticism of you or WC, it is in no way intended to be. Given the varying personalities that post on this and other message boards, conflict is going to happen. It quickly becomes apparent to everyone when it reaches that point. I hesitate to mention a number of threads lately on WC as an example, but find it fits the bill perfectly. There have been numerous calls for calm, from both management and members, in those threads, but to no avail. IMO, after the first warning these threads should have been shut down and further discussion of the topic discouraged. I know Ellis wants this to be a meeting place where ideas and opinions can be freely exchanged, but there are times, and topics, that push the boundaries of courtesy to the point where they become nothing more than pollution on the boards. WC has always been one of the most friendly and courteous of the woodworking boards I frequent, but I believe that at this time it is necessary for the Mods to step up their game a bit and put the kibosh on any thread that even remotely looks to be going south. Once people realize that only courteous disagreement will be allowed, they will not want to waste their time formulating messages that would only be deleted anyway.

Re: What has happened to us?

#48

Jesper, Denmark

Re:Please come back.......

Jesper, Denmark

Jim, we miss your gentle soul and interesting projects.

Re: What has happened to us?

#49

Re: The Thing That Bothers Me, Fred.....

FredD

A very insightful answer George and one I subscribe to in every respect.

I must say I was amazed that you got though two paragraphs without succmbing to a compulsion to Pun , I can only imagine the stress...... ;-))

FredD

Re: What has happened to us?

#50

Yeah Fred.

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

And its Sunday, besides. I was on the receiving end of some Puntification at Church this morning.

George