Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

What has happened to us?

Posts

What has happened to us?

#1

Lee Grindinger

What has happened to us?

Lee Grindinger

I don't understand.

Reasonable people used to be able to discuss REASONABLY politics and religion. It seems those days are gone, you are either a friend or a foe.

When did this change?

I used to discuss theology with Mormons, Jehovah's Witness and other Christians, Jews and Muslims.

I used to discuss social philosophy with Democrats, Republicans, Anarchists, Communists and Socialists.

All these conversations included respect for the others point of view. I KNEW they were LEGITIMATE views!

Now, it's either "you're with me or against me."

What happened to discourse?

I have learned from Anarchists, Communists, Christians and Atheists and I continue to.

Why has religion and politics been banned from this site? Has the age of civility passed?

If anyone turns this into a sour thread so be it, you'll reinforce my sense that we as a people have become intolerant and I'll just wait for a new Renaissance or time when we open our minds and wish to learn and respect each other.

Lee

Re: What has happened to us?

#2

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Dave (PacNW)

Re: What has happened to us?

#3

Lee Grindinger

And so it begins

Lee Grindinger

Clearly there is no room in your world for another point of view.

Please think about this. Is it possible that these people you indict love this country as much as you? Is it possible that their viewpoint may have legitimacy?

Or are they just completely wrong and that you should be the arbiter of social structure?

Lee

p.s. this thread hasn't a chance, does it.

Re: What has happened to us?

#4

Re: And so it begins

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

Lee, you are correct this thread doesn't have a chance.

Re: What has happened to us?

#5

Re: What has happened to us?

John Pappas

Lee, I would love to meet you, to have a beer with you, and I am sure we could discuss woodworking, politics and religion in the way you yearn for.

Everyone should think deeply about what you have expressed.

John

Re: What has happened to us?

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: What has happened to us?

Jesper, Denmark

Lee, I do understand - as far as this WW site is concerned. Discussions about politics and religion are very difficult to control and keep civil, as feelings in these areas tend to get overly passionate. Hence, the management have wisely decided that these discussions have no place in the�s community, where the topics relate to woodworking and the woodworkers.

We can usually be passionate about WW subjects without getting personal about it, which keeps the WoodCentral such a nice place to visit.

Your more global lament over the deteriation of civil exchanges of widely different views could have been an entry to an interesting discussion, but I doubt that it belongs in this forum. Just look at how close the AAW discussions on the Turning forum and the OT gun ownership discussions got to being out of line, and I think you can see why the topic restrictions are necessary.

My strictly personal opinion, of course.

Re: What has happened to us?

#7

It's the medium, maybe

wilbur

I think it's not so much the end of civility as it is the limitations of communicating over the internet. The internet has been very useful in bringing people of like minds and similar interests together. I know that I would not know as much about woodworking as I do today if it were not for the internet, not that I know that much about woodworking. ;)

But the internet has historically had one very major limitation: the combination of instant anonymous communication and the inability to transmit nuance. In the past, written letters were able to transmit nuanced thoughts. But I think that was partly because letters required time to write and send, and the receiver of the letter had time to think about and compose a response. This cycle was a minimum of a week for most practical circumstances, and often longer.

Compare that to what happens now. Lee posts a question, instantly people from around the world can see it, and fire off an answer instantaneously. Even if we all were trying to have a civil conversation, we just don't think about our answers as much as we used to. This leads to an imperfect expression of our thoughts.

The other thing is that there is a layer of anonymity on the internet that doesn't happen in face to face communication. This adds to the problems with nuance, and it lends to some people saying things in these sorts of conversations that they otherwise wouldn't in person.

I've had the pleasure meeting other woodworkers in person who I've had major disagreements with over internet forums. Once I met them in person, they turned out to be really wonderful people, and we were able to discuss the things that we were violently arguing over in a very civil manner.

Re: What has happened to us?

#8

Hey Lee, anytime you are in the area,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

around LR, I always have cold beer, and can make time for conversation. I hope that in your travels that sometime you and Ruthie will swing through here, and give me a call.

Re: What has happened to us?

#9

Re: What has happened to us?

Nelson

Maybe not on this site but on a daily base its the two topics that should be talked about first and the most,but it seems people are more intersted in music,movies,sports etc.

Re: What has happened to us?

#10

Lee, a comment and Wilbur too

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

Lee, I wonder if you might be a bit unique. In my opinion, Civil conversations about religon and politics would ideally be the norm, are now and always have a rarity, at least as far as groups of people have been concerned. Were civility between oppossing points of view the norm I doubt we would have had the Crusades, the inquisition and a host of other unpleasant occurances over the past centurys. Again just my opinion.

Wilbur, regrading face to face conversations. I notice where I work it is very easy for many of the various departments to not respect of see things from anothers point of view. Then a summer project, say building a chairlift, comes up. You might have people from ski school, ski patrol, food and beverage and the various miantenance departments working the side by side towards a common goal. "they" become us and one can come to understand what goes on in other departments during the winter. Each person takes an understanding of the others needs and priorities back to the home deptarments and share that with thier co-works. Remoteness be it physical or digital breeds lack of understanding, having face time does just the opposite.

glc

Re: What has happened to us?

#11

Clint Searl

Re: What has happened to us?

Clint Searl

As an earlier poster suggested, the root causes of all human conflict have been the differences between competing political/religious ideologies and the quest for dominance of one over the other. The civility of discourse to which you refer is a veneer that's easily stripped away when incongruent ideological absolutes make contact. The more diverse the society, the greater the potential for conflict. We deserve what we tolerate.

Clint

Re: What has happened to us?

#12

Working side by side

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I read some years back of some interesting management research in which departments in a company that were always in conflict were relocated next to each other. Their work assignments weren't changed - they were just neighbors. The upshot was that the interdepartmental conflicts were reduced simply by the more frequent human contact.

We're a pack animal. More tolerant people are, in my opinion, defining their pack to be much larger than less tolerant people.

Re: What has happened to us?

#13

Re: What has happened to us?

Bill Howatt

I'm going to say nothing really has happened other than the very large number of people we communicate our ideas to via the internet which means we are likely to offend somebody with strong opinions just by probability. Then there are the ease of communicating and anonymity factors.

The old saying, "Never discuss religion or politics", was in place long before the internet.

However, the pressures of everyday life and the inflamed opinion presented by the media doesn't help either.

Bill

Re: What has happened to us?

#14

Has the age of civility passed?

Dave's Not Here

Unfortunately, for the most part, yes it has. The lack of respect people have for one another seems to be growing on a daily basis. The only way to turn that around would be to eliminate the words "I" and "me" from the English language. Anybody see that happening?

Re: What has happened to us?

#15

Lee Grindinger

Wilbur, that's a really good point

Lee Grindinger

This form of communication distorts our feedback mechanisms. In essence we no longer see how our words are affecting those around us. We feel like we can say things we wouldn't normally say in face to face conversation.

In some ways our worlds have gotten smaller albeit flooded with information. For me, I work at home, isolated in large part from the world around me except for what streams through my computer. I'd say most of us get more and more of our social contact through this medium. This community, among many others, has brought people of similar interests together across the miles and I know that in person everyone I've met through forums like this have been warm, fun and kind people..., warmer and kinder than they often come across in a forum.

I'll coin the term..., Electronic Aspergers Syndrome..., EAS

There, we have a diagnosis! :D

Re: What has happened to us?

#16

Re: What has happened to us?

Marv

Lee,

You wrote:

Why has religion and politics been banned from this site? Has the age of civility passed?

I think it's more a matter of time and place. I'm sure there are forums on the internet that welcome the type of conversation and discussion that you say is banned from this site. Here we have an opportunity to discuss woodworking related topics. We can share ideas, thoughts and skills. Above all, it's an opportunity to learn from each other.

When we wander too far off the subject of woodworking such as religion and politics, we really aren't learning much of anything. That stuff is more theory, beliefs and conjecture and subjective opinions.

Here in this particulalr forum, (Messages) we have a little more leway and go can off topic where we can ask questions and discuss subjects such as what's going on with our computer or our washing machine or how to fix a plumbing problem. These kind of subjects allow us to learn something and share experiences. That is more the intent of the site in general, at least as far as I understand it.

Having said that, I understand where you are coming from. The so-called "politically correct" syndrome going on across the country is getting way out of line in my opinion. Our freedom of speech is becoming regulated to the extent that the definition is no longer as it was originally intended. However, that's a subject that can get us going in the wrong direction.

I like that Ellis has laid down some ground rules for discussion here. And I appreciate the monitors who spend their time bouncing around from forum to forum reading all the content and occasionally deleting certain unwelcome posts. That effort has to be quite time consuming. Even though I've had a few posts deleted, I think they all do a fine job.

Marv

Re: What has happened to us?

#17

Lee Grindinger

I think you're right

Lee Grindinger

I think you're right about why these topics are banned. In fact, it's an interesting experiment with predictable results.

Put 50 people together. Tell them they can only discuss a list of 10 topics.

Soon they would exhaust the topics and either get bored and leave or start to make things "more interesting" by seeking confrontation.

To me it's a natural progression to have ever deepening conversations with people I grow fond of. Of course I find people who don't share my viewpoints and the depth of these relationships becomes self limiting. However, limiting topics assures no growth beyond a certain point.

Hmmmm..., "Soon they would exhaust the topics and either get bored and leave or start to make things "more interesting" by seeking confrontation."



Perhaps I'm guilty!

Re: What has happened to us?

#18

Lee Grindinger

Keith, to be sure...

Lee Grindinger

If we ever venture near LR I'll help you scare those beers outa the fridge... :D

Re: What has happened to us?

#19

Lee Grindinger

Europe and other foreign places...,

Lee Grindinger

Jesper, tell me something. I don't know about the politics in Denmark but I know that in many European countries there are many more active political parties than the two we currently have in the States. Socialists, Communists, Anarchists, etc., all have what are considered legitimate opinions and they participate in the system.

Has this changed in Europe? Or are there still tables filled with earnest folks discussing the pitfalls and advantages of Marxism, Anarchism, etc in a spirited but not hostile way.

Re: What has happened to us?

#20

Lee Grindinger

Where be ya, laddie?

Lee Grindinger

John, where do you live? Ruthie and I move around a lot and it's possible we could land nearby.

Re: What has happened to us?

#21

Re: What has happened to us?

Bill Howatt

"The Oak" WW forum had a board for political and other topics that tend to get heated. Not everyone agrees with me on this but I feel it did impact on relationships in the general forum. So I think it is better to leave those topics out of the forum period and as was said, there are other places to pontificate on one's views on politics, etc.

Bill

Re: What has happened to us?

#22

I Fully Agree, Bill

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Re: What has happened to us?

#23

Re: What has happened to us?

Big Dave

There was a time when these topics were only discouraged in bars & pubs. With good reason, I'm sure, as the inclusion of alcohol tends to elevate the intensity of such conversations...

I have often wondered the same thing, Lee. And, it seems, I've been wondering it for a very long time. I have noticed over the last 25 years that people, to a certain degree, have become more selfish (for lack of a better term...). This has ineveitably affected society as a whole. The advent of the internet, cell phones, and nearly instantaneous satellite communication has allowed the world to become smaller while somehow increasing the percieved importance of those living on it. People have come to believe that their opinions & beliefs are more important than strength of character and respect of others... By making the world smaller "we" have made our lives a little smaller. We draw "our" world in close around us, limiting our exposure to the growth opportunities that can only be experienced through life "outside"...

I had a shop teacher in high school (shop teacher, no less...) who used to say "What you learn after you think you know it all is a damn good education." It took me a few years to fully appreciate that. But it really does make a lot of sense...

Big Dave

Re: What has happened to us?

#24

In the 19th century

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

political arguments, even on the floor of the House or Senate, led to people getting injured. I haven't had much sense that fisticuffs are common in political argument today.

Yes, people from the extremes of the political (and sociopolitical) spectrum deliberately destroy property and take lives, and are rightly arrested, tried, and if found guilty, sentenced. But you don't often hear of discussions with neighbors, on the street, at city council meetings, etc., turning into brawls.

Re: What has happened to us?

#25

Re: Where be ya, laddie?

John Pappas

Lee, thanks for the note. We're in Denver, and you would always be welcomed here. Hope that someday that chance occurs.

John