Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Jig saw differences.

Posts

Jig saw differences.

#1

Jig saw differences.

John Lucas

My jigsaw is an old Craftsman that I've had for about 25 to 27 years. It still works OK but you can't cut really close to the line. I've been wondering about a new one. Here's the question. You can buy them from about $20 to $300 or more. What's the difference? Will a $300 saw cut that much cleaner of be easier to control. I can't justify that much money but sure don't want to buy something that doesn't cut any cleaner than the one I have.

Re: Jig saw differences.

#2

Re: Jig saw differences.

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon John,

I've had a slew of jigsaws over the years, but now own and love the Bosch. I have the overhand model. It is very accurate and won't drift. Further, the Bosch blades are very good and last a long time. They don't require and extra tool like a screwdriver/allen wrench to change. The saws last a long time. My #3 son is a contractor and uses two of them on the job site. I bought mine on his recommendation.

I did retain my 25+ year old Sears Craftsman Auto Scroller for those very rare instances where that feature is required.

George

Re: Jig saw differences.

#3

Re: Jig saw differences.

Thomas S Stockton

I've had friends who have had both the Bosch and Festool and they think the bosch has the best bang for the buck.I have an older Bosch and love it. To save a little more money look at refurbished units.

Tom

Re: Jig saw differences.

#4

Re: Jig saw differences.

Grant in Iowa

Hi John,

I have a DeWalt that I am very happy with the performance of. It has two features that I'd be looking for if I were you:

1. Orbital action. This user selected feature allows the user to set the blade to sort of operate in an orbital action for better cutting speed or curve following depending on the setting.

2. Blade guide bearing. This is a slotted bearing that rides just above the work surface and keeps the blade straight(er) and more perpendicular than on a saw without that feature.

If I were in the hunt for a new jig saw, I'd look for those features. I have used both DeWalt and Bosch machines and think they are both good products. they are both miles ahead of the old school black and decker machines in terms of features and the resulting cut quality. I have no experience with others to share.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Jig saw differences.

#5

In short, yes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Some tools do comparable work at different price levels. For instance, for the most part, electric drills will drill similar holes up to their capacity, regardless of price. What you get for spending more money is greater grunt, capacity, and durability.

Not so with jigsaws*. In my experience, a consumer-grade jigsaw will cut soft 1/4" plywood accurately, but struggles if the wood gets any thicker or harder. A professional-grade saw will cut up to 2x stock, and the good ones will fool you into thinking you used a bandsaw on 1x stock, even hardwood.

I owned a number of consumer-grade jigsaws - new, used, Black and Decker, Craftsman, Skil - before I picked up my first Bosch used at a garage sale. I passed that one on to my son when he started doing remodeling, and picked up a Porter-Cable saw, one of the older models without a tilting foot. The first time I used it, I was cutting 3/4" plywood resting on 2x4s, and discovered after one cut that I'd cut through the 2x4 without even realizing it.

This is a tool where spending the green pays you back. You can read a number of reviews in various magazines; saws come and go in popularity in the magazines. The Bosch line seems to be the most reliable over time, and enough of them sell that you can find sales or reconditioned saws without much trouble. And the saw I gave my son, as well as another like it that I paid $3 for, are both older than he is (he's 34) and still running strong.

*I use "jigsaw" here because that's what everyone calls them nowadays. I'm old school (turning 62 this month), and to me a jigsaw is a big stationary tool with a blade that goes up and down, different from scroll saws in how the movement occurs; while what you're talking about is a saber saw. But words change meaning over time, and I should let go of my old-school stubbornness on this one.

Re: Jig saw differences.

#6

Re: Jig saw differences.

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Would not go against the tide here, John. Bosch all the way. I have had several brands over the years, including Porter Cable. When I moved and had my tool sale 6 years ago, I only kept the Bosch.

Re: Jig saw differences.

#7

Re: Jig saw differences.

Ron Jones

I currently have 2--Bosch and Craftsman. The Bosch is about 5 years old and has performed like the quality tool I expected. The Craftsman is about 30 years old and has never performed well. You ask why I keep the Craftsman? Which one do you think is the one that gets loaned out?

Re: Jig saw differences.

#8

Another vote for Bosch

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

I've had mine for years. Love it. I will even use it to cut boards to approx. length instead of a circular saw (even though it is slower to use for that).

Re: Jig saw differences.

#9

Thanks guys and gals- I'll go looking

john lucas

Re: Jig saw differences.

#10

Re: Jig saw differences.

FredD

Right you are George, I give the model you have to the Abilene High School shop Teacher every year and he gives it to the most deserving student in his opinion .

My own Bosch is the Barrel grip model and I am on my third one in thirty plus years.

FredD

Re: Jig saw differences.

#11

Another Bosch fan.

Jim Dillon

John,

I've had my Bosch (with handle) for probably 15 years now and it is still going strong. I use it much like Joanne does to break down long thick boards, and plywood too. The newer generation of blades are supposed to be very nice, but I stocked up on blades a few years ago and will use them till gone. I've also read good things about the Festool jigsaw. Have fun shopping.

Jim

Re: Jig saw differences.

#12

Re: Jig saw differences.

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Hello Fred,

My #3 son worked for a high end contractor for a couple years before starting up his own business. The first Bosch belonged to the firm, was used constantly, and began to wear. Ken rebuilt their Bosch on his kitchen table and it worked as new. While that one was waiting repair, he bought a new one to use himself. The firm needed another jig saw for another job, and the owners bought two more Bosch saws. They didn't need the one Ken rebuilt, and so gave it to him after initially funding the replacement parts. So now he uses two.

George

Re: Jig saw differences.

#13

So he's a two-fisted sawyer?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Jig saw differences.

#14

Re: Jig saw differences.

FredD

Hadn't thought of using two George, would be nice to be ambidextrous , and just think,do twice the work in half the time ;-))

FredD

Re: Jig saw differences.

#15

Anyone who can play pipe organ

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

can probably use two jigsaws at the same time.

Lesser mortals, like me, should stick to one at a time.

Bill, owns three, all used; no longer sure why I own one of them, but hate to let tools go

Re: Jig saw differences.

#16

5 bosch jig saws  Which one ???

del schisler

i did a google search and found 5 of them Which is the most poplur One ?? I gave all my good old Black and Decker away yrs ago and never look back Just wondering which one most people use I know it depends Which project's ?

Re: Jig saw differences.

#17

Re: 5 bosch jig saws  Which one ???

Thomas S Stockton

Del

I think most people are talking about the 15xx series jig saws either barrel grip or handle style. Don't really know the difference between the models but it looks like the biggest is the way the blades are changed. It would be worth looking at one close up to see the differences since their does seem to be a pretty good difference in price.

Tom

Re: Jig saw differences.

#18

I've used two I liked...

John in NM

A Bosch barrel grip in a furniture shop I worked for, and an older Festool I got when they were closing out the model and introducing a new one. After the Festool got stolen, I got a moderately priced Makita that imitates the Bosch features, but comes up short. Still better than $30-$50 hardware store saws, but not in a class with the other two.

Re: Jig saw differences.

#19

Re: 5 bosch jig saws  Which one ???

FredD

They are all good models, buy the one that fits your hand best.

I use the barrel grip model , because I have larger hands then most.

FredD