Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

dust collector recommendation (long)

Posts

dust collector recommendation (long)

#1

dust collector recommendation (long)

Paul Blackwell

I currently have a Jet 3hp. twin canister dust collector. I purchased it when they first came out with them, maybe about 2003. When it was delivered, the motor wouldn't run at all. After lots of interaction with customer service, they sent a replacement motor, but didn't want the original back. It's run for about six years, and worked well. Several weeks ago, it began making a loud squeeling sound when starting up, but ran okay at speed. It eventually shorted out, and I was faced with buying a new motor for $600, or having the old one rewound for $390. I choose the latter, and got it back last night. It runs fine without the fan on the shaft, but as soon as I put the fan on, it squeels horribly again. I've checked the clearance and fit of the fan carefully, and am absolutely positive it's not rubbing anywhere. The key is a good fit, and the nut is tight. I talked to the man who rewound it (30 years in the business), and he is adamant that the bearings are good. I called Jet technical service, and he feels it must be bearings since there isn't much of anything else to go wrong. I still have the original motor that never worked, so presumably the bearings in it are good. Shall I take them both back to the shop and insist that he change bearings to eliminate that as a source of the noise? I've been out of business for more than a month, and am about ready to buy a new dust collector. Is there one out there that handles the fine dust generated by the drum sander better than the canister models? What do the experts recommend? I'm desperate.

Thanks.

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

#2

JL

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

JL

Sorry to hear about your problem.

I personally prefer cyclones. I have an Oneida Super Dust Gorilla. I like it.

I know others who have Clear-Vues, Grizzly cyclones and others. They like theirs.

I have had good performance from my SDG. It has worked quite nicely for several years.

I don't know enough about motors to say anything about your particular difficulties.

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

#3

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Chuck Lenz

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

#4

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

North of the Border

If all fails including after following Chuck's suggestion or any others, consider bringing the motor and the fan over to the shop that rewound the motor for you. If they are as good as you pointed out as being in business for 30 years or so, they should be willing at least to try to figure out what the problem may lie. Power on the motor with the unit and let them hear and see for themselves. I don't know if this is practical, if so, you may want to talk the shop before you truck everything over.

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

#5

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

Paul Blackwell

I'm sure about the keystock. I've taken the unit apart again after the noise, and the key was in place. The nut is tight, and no sign of any play. Taking the unit to the repair shop is not practical. I don't have a pick-up truck anymore, and the unit is quite large to try to load and transport. The repairman is trying to contact a friend of his who is a motor expert to come to my shop and diagnose the problem.

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

#6

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

del schisler

The key is a good fit, and the nut is tight I would call the repair shop and take the old motor Should had the old motor check out befor having the other rewound ?? Mite have been cheeper ? If all of sudden it started to squell Has to be the pto beiring

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

#7

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

Larry in NW OHIO

Paul Since you said that it ran without the fan on, and when you put it back on and it started to squeel then, then I would think it has to be something in the fan somehow. Take it off again and see what happens. If it doesn`t squeel, then of course put the fan back on and try it again, if it squeels then it has to be something in the fan. At least that is my opinon. Of course I could never charge very much for my opinion. Larry

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

#8

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

Phil Joines

If the blower is rubbing there should be ware marks on both the blower blade and the housing. Does the motor squeal with the blower blade mounted but not installed in the housing?

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

#9

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

Paul Blackwelll

Thanks to all who replied. I did take the old (original) motor to the repair shop to be checked out before having the other rewound. The repairman said the old motor was shorted out and would also have to be rewound. Don't know how this could happen since it never ran, but maybe that's the reason it never ran. There is definitely no indication that the fan is rubbing anywhere. No paint damage and everything spins freely. As to trying the fan mounted outside the housing, it would involve making a mount of some sort which holds the motor securely. I'm going to wait to hear from the repairman to see if his friend is able to visit my shop and see the problem first hand.

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

#10

Re: dust collector recommendation (long)

Big Dave

I hope you can get the problem figured out, Paul. But if you can't, and are seriously considering a new DC, I'd recommend the Delta 50-760. I used mine for every tool in the shop with great results. I sold it when I upgraded to an Onieda (which I would also recommend...).

Good Luck!

Dave