Re: A question for John....
FredD
I am not John , Barry , the term Box joint is a older term for finger joint and if you cut it on the table saw , you will spend a longer time cutting it then dovetails with a router. Done both many times , Dovetails are faster and stronger and have the advantage of a mechanical lock that all of those other practical joints do not.
Then on the other hand , I guess it could just be any joint on a box. ;-))
About the original posters skill level and budget , , it was exactly those concerns that led me to suggest a different way to go about the project.
If you have not tried fitting Cabinets in a awkward space at best , this in my view wouldn't be the design to start with.
Personally I don't care what type of joint you use in a drawer or the material it is made from.
Just refrain from saying it is just as strong and attractive , even though the butt joint is the weakest of all.
Tossing around terms like "practicality" is where the sayings like "it's close enough for Government work" or "it suits the Girls I go with " spring from.
In Cabinet work , the general areas are Paint Grade and Stain grade, the former the less expensive and the latter as much as you care to spend.
But.......either form or choice of materials would not dictate lesser attention to detail, or allowing sloppy work to intrude, the client regardless of their budget expect and deserve your best effort.
Aside from that , Bill has a good approach to using lesser hardwood shorts for drawer sides, the philosophy cuts down on material waste , it is one I use all of the time and it certainly wouldn't break the bank and in the process uses material to short for any thing but firewood.
The idea that the drawer is only open for a short time and not looked on as
part of the over all design and material selection is flawed, you would be surprised at the interest in drawer construction when the client is evaluating the skill set of the proposed shop.
That particular detail to attention has got me jobs where the competition were using lesser forms of drawer construction and charging less then me .
Lastly I know many part time and weekend woodworkers who strive to advance their design and skill set, just as though it was a primary career rather then a hobby and those are the people who inquire and learn and get my best effort to help them .
FredD






