Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carc
Brint in Richmond, VA
Thank you all so very much for your suggestions and input. I knew that I had been hanging out in the right forum!
A few follow-up comments:
- The clients are me and my wife. ;-) This is for a third-floor "bonus room" also used as a playroom, exercise room, etc., and covered with very cheap paneling which will also be painted (as we've already done in three other rooms in the house). In other words, while aesthetics are a consideration, they are not as important as they might be for units in the living room. These units won't be junk (I'm too OCD for that), but they'll be fine for my first foray into cabinet building. Having said that, I like Barry's suggestion about matching the visible stile widths top and bottom.
- All my plywood is cabinet-grade ("economy birch") from Siewer's Lumber and Millwork. (Thanks, Barry).
- Thanks especially for the multiple endorsements (JL, David) of spacing/furring strips for mounting the drawer hardware. I was unsure of that approach at first, but clearly it's standard practice.
- Ellis, thanks for the note about using an interior rail as an anchor for the rails in the face frame.
- While I WAS kind of looking forward to using the locking drawer joint as an excuse to buy the new bit (!), the number of comments describing the ease, quickness and sufficiency of butt joints is making me reconsider that path (the sensible part of me thanks you for that) (Sorry, Hal - !). Having said that, I have already bought the PC557 biscuit cutter to use to put these together. ;-) And David, thanks for pointing me to 1/2" ply for the drawers.
- Although I have known from the beginning that I would be scribing the face frames on both the cabinet and the bookshelves to meet the walls (they both lean outward as they rise), your comments correctly pointed out that I had, um, failed to account for that in my drawing plans. Whoops - and thanks. I had planned to use cove moulding on the vertical joints between the unit and the walls. I had also planned to put a step moulding on the edge of the countertop and return that all the way to the wall (cf. Ellis' comment).
- My plan to use red oak is, as I said, based on the fact that I have several hundred board feet on hand that won't cost me any (more) money. I'm "in between jobs" right now, so I have lots of time and not a lot of money. (So Bill, I'll have to defer on the dovetail jig for the meantime - !) I'll be sure to check the moisture content with my meter. But I also appreciate the comments about the roughness of the wood under a paint finish. I had wondered the same thing myself. Before I set out to mill a bunch, I reckon I'll try painting a sample to see how it looks (good idea, Bill). Is using grain filler here overkill? As Bill observes, there's not much lumber here, so buying poplar wouldn't break the bank. However, if I do that, then I lose the opportunity to justify to my wife the money I spent having our red oak trees sawn and stacked in our backyard. ;-)
- Ellis' comments on full depth cabinet/half-depth bookcase got me wondering. While I had read that 12" was a standard bookcase depth, I pretty much picked 20" as an outside cabinet depth out of the air. I'm not really expecting the cabinet top to function as a workspace, but simply to break up the profile a bit, act as a place to put some picture frames, and allow for some deeper drawers. Is that okay, or is there another factor I should take into consideration?
- Fred and Bill, I appreciate the design suggestions. It's particularly helpful to have comments not only on the details of the proposal, but also on the basic idea of the proposal.
+ + + The counter height is already 32" and co-planar with the bottom of the window frame. It's another 2-3/4" to the bottom of the stool - would 34-3/4" be too high for a countertop?
+ + + The bottom rank of drawers in the cabinet will house hanging files, so we need to stay with drawers. Also, while I like the idea of a continuous top across the assembly, other space considerations in the room (such as accommodating existing furniture) nix that approach.
+ + + I don't think the top shelf will be too high. I'm 5'9" with short arms, but I can stand in front of the cabinet footprint and almost touch where the wall meets the ceiling, so I figure reaching a shelf that's 12" closer and maybe 9" lower shouldn't be a problem (especially if it's a shelf that's rarely used).
One last question (for this post, at least): How do you anchor the unit to the walls/floor?
Thanks again to everyone for your thoughtful and insightful comments, and for the time you took to post them. WC is really a treasure for folks like me who have more desire than expertise, and I'm grateful to Ellis for his work in keeping this thing going. I really appreciate everyone's support, and promise to post pics when I'm finished.