Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

Posts

Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#1

Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase  *LINK*

Brint in Richmond, VA

I'm building my first set of built-ins, and drawing both on advice from a friend who's built quite a few for his own house, and from a Taunton book with some helpful illustrations and explanations (sorry, can't lay my hands on it at the moment to tell you the title). However, I still have some questions:

Is there a standard width and thickness for face frames? If not, is there a "recommended" width and thickness? Please don't say, "whatever you prefer," because I have no baseline or experience from which to draw a preference. (I'm milling my own from some red oak I've had air-drying out back for three years).


Note: Each unit is 88" tall and 55" wide (and I've changed the design to use two fixed vertical dividers in the bookcase so as to provide for adjustable shelves). Also, I've widened the top and bottom rails of the drawer cabinet face frame, and added a toe kick underneath. Lastly, contrary to the rendering above, it will be painted.

My friend told me to rout a 3/8 rabbet in the back of the units for a (plywood?) back - but I've also read several articles that suggest simply using 1/4" luaun. What factors should I consider when deciding whether to inset a plywood back or just tack on a luaun back?

My friend also suggested making the bottom case just one carcase, with a single divider sitting in a dado in the middle. But I've read other articles that seem to suggest I construct two separate carcases and attach them together. My plan is to use full-extension drawer slides for all six drawers in each unit, which project 1/2" from the interior panels. Should I build two carcases for each unit, or is one (with a divider) sufficient? (I'm using 3/4" cabinet-grade plywood). And how does my use of drawer slides affect the face frame dimension? I'm planning to use false-front drawers, and was looking at Whiteside's Locking Drawer Glue Joint (#3347). Can I use this kind of joint if I make my drawers of plywood, or can I only use this with solid wood drawers?

Sorry for all the questions, but this was the only place I felt confident of getting a range of expert opinions. Thanks so very much for any guidance you can offer.

Brint


Locking Drawer Glue Joint Bit (#3347)

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#2

Ellis Walentine

Built-ins

Ellis Walentine

There are a lot of issues here, Brint, and no hard-and-fast answers. Here are some thoughts for you to consider:

I like the idea of vertical dividers in the bookcases, but consider whether you want one or two in each case. A single center divider would net you shelves about 27" long, while two would net shelves about 18" long. A single divider would want to line up with the vertical center face frame piece in the cabinet below. If you use two dividers, you might make the center space several inches wider for effect. No big deal either way, but it might be worth thinking about.

Make the bookcases as separate units from the cases below. Put face frames on the bookcases, too, to make everything look like it goes together. If everything will be painted, I'd even consider making separate natural-wood tops for the lower cases for utility and appearance, and to overhang the lower case in the space under the window and break up that vertical surface.

Consider locating the top of the bookcase several inches lower, so you don't have to fit the unit to the ceiling so accurately, and use a taller face frame piece on it that can be scribed to the ceiling contours. Similarly, hold the short vertical bookcase pieces and the long slanted top pieces away from the side walls by 3/4" or so and make the face frames slightly over-wide there so you can scribe them to the walls.

Full-depth cases with half-depth bookcases above can be problematic, depending on what you plan to put there, because of access issues. By that I mean that if you put books there, you can't really use the full-depth work surface for anything else without restricting access to the books. Consider that.

I'd make the lower units as single cases with a single center divider in each. At the wall side of each unit, hold the cabinet side 3/4" from the wall and let the face frame extend outward for scribing. When it comes to your drawer slides, make shims to whatever thickness needed to bring them out flush with the face-frame openings.

Face frames are commonly 3/4" thick and 1 1/2" wide. Some people like to make internal face frame parts narrower, say 1" wide, for aesthetic reasons. That's up to you and your client. If you are going to have horizontal face frame pieces between the drawers, I'd provide rails inside the cabinet to attach them to.

For your kick space, consider a separate plinth for each case, so you can install the plinths first and get them dead level before installing the cases on top of them. The side plinth faces might want to be inset just 3/4" or so -- just enough to give a reveal there and break up the vertical surface. Hold the outside and back of the plinths in about 1/2" or more so you don't have to deal with any weirdness in the corners of the room when you go to fit them.

You can use those drawer-lock cutters with plywood, but consider using Baltic birch plywood for appearance. You can glue and tack the corners together and glue plywood bottoms into grooves in the sides for stability and strength.

By all means use something thicker than 1/4" lauan ply for the bookcase backs at least. Thin plywood has such a cheap feel and sound to it that it will haunt the owners every time they slide a book up against it. I'd suggest 1/2" shop birch. The base units will never be seen and no great amount of strength is necessary, so you can get away with the thinner ply.

RE cabinet construction, you might want to consider biscuit joinery instead of dados and screws. Biscuits were invented for this purpose.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#3

JL

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carc

JL

Is there a standard width and thickness for face frames? If not, is there a "recommended" width and thickness? Use whatever is comfortable. Whenever I've built face frame cabinets, I typically try for at least 1" and often go for 1.25". As you will have a "lip" around your carcass, you may consider going for the lesser width. As far as thickness - I usually mill my stock to 7/8" - so I use that.

What factors should I consider when deciding whether to inset a plywood back or just tack on a luaun back? IMO, I would go for the plywood. Yes, you will get some rack stability with 1/4" Luaun - but you would get a bit more with the plywood. What are you making your drawer bottoms from? If you use 3/8" plywood (which is a reasonable thickness) - you could also use it for the backs.



Should I build two carcases for each unit, or is one (with a divider) sufficient?
You are going to install the carcasses, that is something to consider. You have to "muscle" them around, level them, etc. On the other hand, the unit will look "cleaner" with a single divider. I would probably go for a single carcass.

And how does my use of drawer slides affect the face frame dimension? I usually put spacer blocks along the drawer slides - especially if I'm attaching the front of the slides to the face frame. So you figure if you are making your frame 1" - you would have a 1/4" spacer.

Can I use this kind of joint if I make my drawers of plywood, or can I only use this with solid wood drawers? I usually make my drawers out of poplar (I bought a few hundred board feet a while back). My friend Mike usually uses an interlocking joint that is similar with his plywood drawers and hasn't had a complaint yet.

My $0.02.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#4

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carc

David Yoho

Brint, lots of questions - let's take them in order. I'll try to keep it brief but there's more to these answers than will fit here. All I can do is go on personal experience but there are any number of ways to skin a cat!

Is there a standard width and thickness for face frames?

I don't know. There can be factors of design that would dictate specific dimensions for face frames. In your case, it looks to me like what I've done before can work. A face frame of 3/4-inch stock, 1 1/2-inch wide stock would do.

There are a couple of things to keep in mind, however. Your drawing shows the unit fitting into the space like a glove. The reality is it won't without there being some kind of gap between the wall and the unit. Do you want the face frame to fit the wall or did you plan to add trim to hide it? If no trim, then your face frame needs to be wider and overlap the carcase on the wall side so it can be scribed and cut to fit exact.

What factors should I consider when deciding whether to inset a plywood back or just tack on a luaun back?

Since this is a built-in and nobody will see the back from behind, it's not necessary to cut a rabbet for the plywood back. Tacking it on will work just fine and be just as strong.

Should I build two carcases for each unit, or is one (with a divider) sufficient?

One with a center divider is what I've done. This is less expensive because you use one less piece of plywood and is just as strong.

And how does my use of drawer slides affect the face frame dimension?

No problem using a face frame. What I've done is to use standard flush-mount slides and attach 3/4" filler strips to the inside of the case where each slide will mount. This brings the mounting surface out flush with the face frame width I mentioned earlier - - 1 1/2" face frame minus 3/4" case side panel = 3/4" filler. However, remember you'll need a vertical face frame member for the center divider of the drawer unit of 2 1/4" since drawer slides will be mounted on both sides of the divider.

Can I use this kind of joint if I make my drawers of plywood, or can I only use this with solid wood drawers?

It could work in plywood but I would hope you plan to use 1/2" Baltic birch and not your 3/4" cabinet grade plywood for the drawer boxes. Heck, I've cut dovetails in plywood drawer boxes before. However, unless you just want to purchase a new bit, I'd go with a simple rabbet joint for the front of the box and a dadoe about 1/2" short of the rear, glue, and tack with brads. Also, since you're using plywood for the boxes, there's no reason you can't glue in the plywood bottoms. This would make the box construction even more rigid.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#5

Agree with everything but frame width

Bill Tindall

The advice clearly came from someone that has built oodlins of these things so follow it closely.

On a large unit like this I think a 1 3/4 or 2" frame width will look better. The frame width will change the appearance of the unit. 1 1/2" will have a light airy feel ( not bad if that is the look you are going after) while a wider frame will have a more robust appearance. Do follow the instructions on fitting to the walls and ceiling.

If you intend to continue woodworking seize this opportunity to buy a dovetail jig and make the drawer right.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#6

Warning on plywood

Bill Tindall

I have experience some plywood problems of late. I got what seemed to be quality multiply birch from Home Depot. It was more than 18% moisture content and warped into potato chips as it dried. Inside were other issues- huge voids. overlapping plies mashed more of less back into a plane. The face ply was tissue paper thin.

I suggest you find a local cabinet shop and get plywood from where ever they get it and hope for the best.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#7

more on lumber

Bill Tindall

Just because your oak stash has been drying out back for 3 years, or 23 years, doesn't mean it is dry enough to use. If you can get it somewhere hot, like a loft or attic, it will be dry in a few days if it is not already.

You glossed past the finish issue. The frames are to be painted oak. What about the rest-also painted oak? Painted oak is going to have a unique look to it and it could be attractive, or not. I would suggest experimenting with the finish before you start. There isn't much lumber in this project, so buying poplar to be painted wouldn't break the bank.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#8

Excellent advice...

John in NM

I'll just echo Bill on the frame width. You can easily get away with 1 1/2 to 1 3/4 frames in a modern, sort of minimalist design - with slab doors for example. I'd go about 2" for a more traditional look, with inset doors and drawers, and even wider if you want a more arts and crafts look. If you go with the narrower frames, consider ripping the frames and door stiles out of 8/4 lumber - that way you tend to get rift or QS material and it compliments the look as well as being a little more stable.

I usually make the frames a bit wider where they'll meet the wall so that I can scribe them to match and still have about 1/2" between the box and the wall.

I like dados, glue, and staples for construction, screws are kind of over kill, but I'd be doing it that way if I didn't have the stapler.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#9

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carc

Barry Irby

You have gotten good advice. I won't reiterate it, but will add a few stray thoughts.

Plywood. Buy quality plywood. Hard to sort out these days, but the stuff at the borgs is suspect. Some of the face play now are so thin you can not sand the stuff. Some are so thin they are installing a second layer below because you can see through the top layer. I am local to you (Chester, VA). You might try Plywood and Plastics over near the Diamond off Rhoadmiller. they have changed their name but I think you can still find them as P and P. There Si also Diamond Hill on the southside. (If nothing else, Check with them on drawer runners, I have found them there for $4 or 5 where Loews wanted $13.

Are you going to make the drawer fronts overlap the face frames? If so, you might consider making the upper face frames the width of the "exposed" part of the lower frame. Lets say the lower unit has two inch frames and the drawers over lap 1/4". You might make the upper frames 1 1/2".

My friend and I built cabinets to work our way through college, many years ago. He is still in the business. (need a good Cabinet maker?) He has made thousands of drawers and the vast majority of them have been 1/2" thick wood with simple butt joints glued and stapled. I know the is heresy on a woodworking site, but it has worked for him and he is not aware of any call back ever for a drawer failure. Baltic birch plywood would be as good or better.

One base cabinet or two? Is this room upstairs? Can you get full width cabinets upstairs? If not, two. If you can manage it, one will be cheaper and easier.

I would allow room between the units and the wall and sloping ceiling as mentioned by others. You need to set these units so that the margin between the window facings and the cabinets are consistent. Then the spacing to the wall and slope needs to be consistent. You need to measure carefully. The carpenter that framed this would have thought that 1/4" +/- could have been fine and if the walls are within an 1/8" of plumb would have been OK. But, this much "error" might drive you nuts. You have no reason to believe this set up will be perfectly symmetrical. Measure two or three times and only cut twice.

About the backs, You need to let in the side next to the windows unless you are having a molding there. The edge of the back will show without being let in or covered with a molding.

I don't know what will be on the shelves, but the top needs to be VERY sturdy because the vertical dividers will be resting on it. Another reason to put the upper one in the center and then be sure the top is supported by the center wall in the cabinets below. Books are heavy and can cause a top to sag.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#10

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carc

Hal Smith

I have made quite a number of drawers with plywood using a Katana bit (from MLCS) that appears identical to the Whiteside you show. Generally good results, but experience with plywood - and sometimes with solid wood such as poplar - shows you need to make a climb cut to avoid some tearout, at least where the bit exits the wood at the "show" end. Not difficult - just keep a firm grip on your workpiece. Also a tall fence on you router table is almost a necessity. Good luck. Hal

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#11

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carc

FredD

That design while nicely drawn also is extremely difficult to make attractive and useful.

Just for a moment consider a different approach which will give your lack of experience a better chance of success.

If your drawing accurately reflects the actual dimensions and window placement, I would suggest raising the height of the drawer units to the bottom of the window stool and instead of drawers , make them with adjustable shelves to replace the upper units which are not a good design for a book case because ot the ceiling line and being a entirely different look in construction from the bottom cases and using up half of the top of the bottom units. Also this would change the case depth to about thirteen inches.

Then I would connect the two book units with another case that would be the drawer unit, this could vary from a standard depth of 24 inches which will accomodate 22" long drawer slides , down to a depth of about 18 inches which will accommodate a sixteen inch drawer slide.

Ideally a continuous one piece top would tie all three cases together for a better looking installation. Scribing the cases to the wall and in this approach to each other, is a good way to go and hard for a first timer to do .

In your case a separate scribe stick will do just fine if your scribing attempt doesn't please you.

About drawer construction regardless of which way you go with the case design, don't fret over the construction .

You may want to learn dovetailing with a router jig , but in any case , make the drawer box as a separate unit from the drawer face.

Just butt joints and glue and stapling will work short of Dovetails , which really are the only joint that survives time and use .

A quarter inch back tacked and glued on will allow squaring of the bottom cases, since you no longer have a clumsy top to deal with .

That solves your back question and Luan is a plywood , from the Philippines , formerly called Philippine Mahogany , but that term has been outlawed for years.

Air dried wood is to wet , it probably is about 15 % M.C. and it needs to go down to around 6 or 7 % which it will do , if you have it in a climate controlled environment , like your shop or any warm , dry room for a couple of weeks or so.

I would use two inch stiles , dictating the stile width with the use of side mounted drawer sides is backwards and rarely accurate enough for that type slide.

Regardless of the stile width, make the drawer opening one inch wider then the drawer box size , this allows for the required 1/2" clearance for that type of slide. Furr out the side panels until you have a separate rail for each slide to run on, exactly flush with the inside of the opening and the opening exactly one inch wider then the drawer box.

I make the rails three inches wide by at least the length of the drawer slide.

For the stated paint finish , in my opinion ,Red Oak is to coarse of a wood to look good painted , with the exception of a Limed Oak finish , which is a thinned white paint brushed and wiped off and then clear coated.

McCloskey's makes the best of this type finish and they call it Lime Oak Finish , which it really isn't , it needs a clear coat on top.

One last thing, you will need a center divider for the shelves and if you use solid wood , that should be stiff enough up to 32 inches for book shelves, if you use 3/4" plywood , put a hardwood rail on the front and back edge of each shelf.

if you run into a problem , there's always a answer here and after you get all of your materials together, think the process through until you are comfortable with cutting and fitting.

I would advise making the two end cases first , before cutting and fitting the center one if that is the way you choose to go.

Lots of luck,

FredD

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#12

I like this design change

Bill Tindall

The stratospheric height of the originally designed shelves will make them less useful. Fred's design will provide counter space which could be useful and I think a more attractive look. Sketch it up and report back.

The rest of the suggestions are spot on too. Apparently I am not the only one that thinks painted oak will look strange.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#13

I like this approach too...

John in NM

Or at least most aspects of it. Tying the cabinets visually to the window height wise will really help the aesthetics, and I'm a big fan of the continuous top idea. I'd probably stick with drawers or cabinet doors below, using a three box approach, or alternatively have a desk like knee hole below the window and between the two drawer boxes. I don't have a serious problem with the bookcase/ceiling angle thing, but then that will depend a lot on how it's used. I might look for a way to stop the bookcase and leave a triangular cubby or something if I thought it would be a problem. I'd also probably bring the bookcases over to the window and try to tie them in with matching molding or something similar, but that may be too fussy to attempt this time.

I'd also suggest box joints for the drawers if dovetails are not an option. I do guided drawers this way with an applied front. The wouldn't hold up for 100 years without the drawer guides, but I think dovetails on a ball bearing guided drawer box is little more than silly industry marketing. The guide removes all the stresses that made dovetailing a necessity. Glued and fastened (staples, nails or screws) butt joints or half laps will work just as well on a guided drawer, I just find the box joints quick and easy, as no fasteners are needed.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#14

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carc

Brint in Richmond, VA

Thank you all so very much for your suggestions and input. I knew that I had been hanging out in the right forum!

A few follow-up comments:

- The clients are me and my wife. ;-) This is for a third-floor "bonus room" also used as a playroom, exercise room, etc., and covered with very cheap paneling which will also be painted (as we've already done in three other rooms in the house). In other words, while aesthetics are a consideration, they are not as important as they might be for units in the living room. These units won't be junk (I'm too OCD for that), but they'll be fine for my first foray into cabinet building. Having said that, I like Barry's suggestion about matching the visible stile widths top and bottom.

- All my plywood is cabinet-grade ("economy birch") from Siewer's Lumber and Millwork. (Thanks, Barry).

- Thanks especially for the multiple endorsements (JL, David) of spacing/furring strips for mounting the drawer hardware. I was unsure of that approach at first, but clearly it's standard practice.

- Ellis, thanks for the note about using an interior rail as an anchor for the rails in the face frame.

- While I WAS kind of looking forward to using the locking drawer joint as an excuse to buy the new bit (!), the number of comments describing the ease, quickness and sufficiency of butt joints is making me reconsider that path (the sensible part of me thanks you for that) (Sorry, Hal - !). Having said that, I have already bought the PC557 biscuit cutter to use to put these together. ;-) And David, thanks for pointing me to 1/2" ply for the drawers.

- Although I have known from the beginning that I would be scribing the face frames on both the cabinet and the bookshelves to meet the walls (they both lean outward as they rise), your comments correctly pointed out that I had, um, failed to account for that in my drawing plans. Whoops - and thanks. I had planned to use cove moulding on the vertical joints between the unit and the walls. I had also planned to put a step moulding on the edge of the countertop and return that all the way to the wall (cf. Ellis' comment).

- My plan to use red oak is, as I said, based on the fact that I have several hundred board feet on hand that won't cost me any (more) money. I'm "in between jobs" right now, so I have lots of time and not a lot of money. (So Bill, I'll have to defer on the dovetail jig for the meantime - !) I'll be sure to check the moisture content with my meter. But I also appreciate the comments about the roughness of the wood under a paint finish. I had wondered the same thing myself. Before I set out to mill a bunch, I reckon I'll try painting a sample to see how it looks (good idea, Bill). Is using grain filler here overkill? As Bill observes, there's not much lumber here, so buying poplar wouldn't break the bank. However, if I do that, then I lose the opportunity to justify to my wife the money I spent having our red oak trees sawn and stacked in our backyard. ;-)

- Ellis' comments on full depth cabinet/half-depth bookcase got me wondering. While I had read that 12" was a standard bookcase depth, I pretty much picked 20" as an outside cabinet depth out of the air. I'm not really expecting the cabinet top to function as a workspace, but simply to break up the profile a bit, act as a place to put some picture frames, and allow for some deeper drawers. Is that okay, or is there another factor I should take into consideration?

- Fred and Bill, I appreciate the design suggestions. It's particularly helpful to have comments not only on the details of the proposal, but also on the basic idea of the proposal.

+ + + The counter height is already 32" and co-planar with the bottom of the window frame. It's another 2-3/4" to the bottom of the stool - would 34-3/4" be too high for a countertop?

+ + + The bottom rank of drawers in the cabinet will house hanging files, so we need to stay with drawers. Also, while I like the idea of a continuous top across the assembly, other space considerations in the room (such as accommodating existing furniture) nix that approach.

+ + + I don't think the top shelf will be too high. I'm 5'9" with short arms, but I can stand in front of the cabinet footprint and almost touch where the wall meets the ceiling, so I figure reaching a shelf that's 12" closer and maybe 9" lower shouldn't be a problem (especially if it's a shelf that's rarely used).

One last question (for this post, at least): How do you anchor the unit to the walls/floor?

Thanks again to everyone for your thoughtful and insightful comments, and for the time you took to post them. WC is really a treasure for folks like me who have more desire than expertise, and I'm grateful to Ellis for his work in keeping this thing going. I really appreciate everyone's support, and promise to post pics when I'm finished.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#15

Couple Things

David Yoho

While I've had an account at Siewer's for years and used to buy from them more often, the last 3 - 5 years I've been purchasing more elsewhere. They're a good local source around the Richmond area but I think their prices are a little bit steep for me.

As far as plywood goes, if I only need a sheet or two or don't really need a high quality grade, then Siewer's gets the nod. However, when I need the "good stuff" for cabinetry, I go to what used to be Plywood and Plastics but is now Wurth Wood Group over behind the Diamond at 1701 Rhoadmiller St. That will be your best source for the 1/2" Baltic birch.

While I'm thinking about your drawer boxes, you mentioned housing hanging files. Given that you will probably be using full extension ball bearing slides for the file drawers, they will take a lot of the stress but your drawer boxes still need to be stout enough to handle the weight and be rigid. The half-inch ply will work fine but this is not the time for butt joints. It sounds like you plan to use biscuits but, again, why make things harder when you'll get more strength from simple rabbet and dado joints and they're easier to do.

As far as your choice of wood goes, I remembered in my previous response you said it was to be painted but I ignored your choice was oak. Yikes!!! I'd never paint red oak without filling all those open pores first. I also remember wondering while reading your original post if that oak was actually dry enough yet. If you're really stuck on using it, make sure it's dry enough. I certainly understand your reason for wanting to use it and to control costs, but danged if this isn't a job that's perfect for poplar - and Siewer's price isn't all that bad.

David

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#16

sell some oak, buy some poplar

Bill Tindall

In an equivalent grade the oak is worth half again to twice more than the poplar. You will have no trouble selling part of your oak stash and using the proceeds to buy some poplar.......and a dovetail jig with the profits of the oak sale and savings of not buying the router bit. Something like the Keller inexpensive version that makes through dovetails for boxes makes drawer box construction quick and secure. I think there are even less expensive versions of this template.

Not clear how furniture considerations preclude extending counter top across the end of the room under the window. What will fit in the 20" deep space under the window? Something needs to go there or that hole is going to look strange.

Fastening to wall: I run a 3/8 x 3/8 dado up the back of my cabinet sides, inset 1/2". A board about 3" wide with a 3/8 x 3/8 tongue on each end fits into this dado and spans horizontal across the top and bottom the the cabinet unit. (It is rabbited out to accommodate the back, which I make 1/4" thick. With this arrangement the back is not needed to provide strength or squareness). The units are screwed through these horizontal pieces into studs with robust screws #10 x 2 1/2" (for hanging upper cabinet units). Note that the side dado is inset 1/2" which leaves this horizontal piece off set from the wall an 1/8". This offset accommodates wall irregularities that otherwise would keep the cabinet ends from butting the wall. This construction was used by all our customers so it will/does work well.

BTW, I dado the sides into the face frames inset about1/8", which leaves 1/8" of face frame overhanging the cabinet side. On the ends that are to be scribed the dado is inset more. This construction solves a lot of problems, it is hugely strong and it looks good.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#17

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carc

David Hay Denver

Here's what I did for my set of built-in bookcases, which aren't much different in design from yours, with respect to attaching things to the wall/floor.

First, I built a plywood frame as a base, shimmed it level and installed "feet" to hold it that way. It also got screwed to the wall, using shims where needed to bridge the gap between the wall and the frame. Then I installed the base cabinets on top of that. Each base cabinet had a cleat across the top that I screwed through and into the wall. Again, shims were used to bridge any gaps in a non-flat wall. (And the wall will not be flat ;)

Each of my upper bookshelf units have two groups of adjustable shelves, divided by a fixed shelf. Underneath the back of the fixed shelf and the top of the cabinet is a cleat that is attached to the shelf and sides. I used this cleat to screw the upper cabinets to the walls. I used trim head screws, but since you're painting your cabinets, you could use regular screws and then plug and paint over the screw heads. I think I also drove a couple of screws up through the countertop into the bottom of the upper cabinets as well.

There are a couple of articles on building built-in cabinets in the current issues of WOOD magazine and Fine Woodworking that describe this approach. Might be worth checking them out at the library (assuming you don't subscribe ;)

David

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#18

Re: Couple Things

Barry Irby

I knew somebody would know the current name of Plywood and Plastics. (Wurth Wood Group). I'm turning into an old fuddy duddy. I can drive there, I just can't remember their new fangled name.

You might also want to check out Diamond Hill and Central Wholesale, both on Coffer Rd., I think.

And try Baer Supply and/or CH Briggs on line for the runners and hardware.

We always used a 1/4 by half inch rabbet up the edge of the end panels for the 1/4" plywood back. There was a piece about 1X6 at the top set just inside the rabbit. So the plywood lapped onto it, but did not come all the way to the top. You can shim behind that piece and anchor the cabinet to the wall. It doesn't have to be that wide, but sometimes we use rear mount runners and that provided a thick enough piece to screw them to.

For the file hanger drawers, I might want heavier joint that just the butt joints I recommended earlier. I might use a false front and back out of 3/4 plywood and half inch Baltic birch of the sides. Then you could use a couple of biscuits from the end of the 3/4 into the side of the birch. The rest of the drawers could be Baltic birch all the way around with simple butt joints.

If you can sell your oak for enough to pay for poplar, I would do that, but I doubt it. I am afraid you will be selling wholesale and buying retail. Selling "Home Made" air dried yard tree oak and buying kiln dried poplar. I understand that your wood might be the finest red oak on the east coast, I am just saying that is the argument you will run into when you try to sell it.

If I had some poplar or other suitable white wood I might trade you for it, but I don't.

One way to smooth out the grain in red oak if you don't like the painted appearance is to trowel on a coat o drywall mud and then sand it. Then prime it with BIN or Kilz.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#19

Re: I like this approach too...

FredD

I disagree with your assessment of Dovetailed drawers John.

The superiority of that joint has never been in question amongst Cabinet Makers and Furniture Makers, only those who have difficulty making them sneer at the appropriateness of that joint.

In addition , Metal side mounted drawer slides have nothing to do with the joints being the joint of choice in Shops that deal in high end Cabinets and stores that do high end Stock Cabinets like Smallbone.

Any shop that wants in this market will fail with drawer boxes that look like a first attempt by a high school shop student.

That being said if your not particular about details and appearance , butt joints work for a time.

Production oriented shops who turn out Particle board boxes with Genuine Wood Grain Vinyl Veneer for low cost apartment type housing invariably staple the drawer boxes and if you ever install any from these guys in a housing complex, you would find yourself repairing the cabinets before you could install them.

FredD

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#20

Wow... raw nerve I guess...

John in NM

Sorry about that, must be tough having to spend your life defending industry marketing practices. However, having never seen my work, I find you offensive - I suppose that's fair enough, apparently I was offensive as well. I hope you at least feel a little better for the venting. Your arguments have not convinced me that a drawer with bearing guides needs a dovetail joint specifically, though I will agree that a more traditional furniture drawer on wood runners does benefit from its use (of course that was never in question). I doubt, however, that convincing me personally had much to do with your post.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#21

I agree with Fred, and a different perspective

Bill Tindall

Why not use the best joinery when building under the conditions described in the original question- namely you are building for yourself and you are learning? I hand cut the dovetails for my daughters kitchen. I was learning the process and needed the practice. The drawers were an opportunity to learn and become proficient, and it worked. Of course it didn't make economic sense, but that wasn't a factor in my case or maybe this case either. I just completed 8 frame and panel doors for a built in. I used traditional furniture techniques for these too. Same objective, to hone my skills for furniture making. I wouldn't have learned anything useful for my future furniture projects had I bought a router bit set and machine cut all the joints and panels.

What I am advocating is to establish what you woodworking objectives are and use all your projects to hone skills to meet these objectives. Most of us don't get the practice to become proficient at anything and the situation is made worse if we nail drawers together and then try dovetailing drawers for a fine desk, or whatever.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#22

Being Practical  (LONG)

David Yoho

I've refrained until now to add my two cents to this part of the discussion but I feel I must say something. There are many knowledgeable and talented craftsmen and women that contribute here on this board. Some have been fortunate enough to have honed their skills under the guidance of someone else and some, like myself, have learned by doing.

Several issues have been brought up that have lead to differing opinions and there's nothing wrong with that. However, I think sometimes we over-engineer things when it's not necessary. The question came up about the proper size of face frame parts. I don't know that there is a hard and fast rule for this. What I do know is I've always looked at it as what would look the best, provide the best function for the intended use, and be the best use of the material on hand. There have been times when I've used wider parts than 1 1/2" and times when narrower parts were in order. I might be wrong but I think you have to let the design dictate this decision.

Then there was the issue of which joinery to use on the drawer boxes. To me, it's simple. If any of you have ever cut dovetails in plywood using a router and jig, which is the material the original poster plans to use, you would know what a disaster that is. No matter what you do, the cuts will be splintered and the joint does not fit together very easy and requires further trimming.

I agree with Bill about using projects to build skills but there's a point where we must be practical. To this point I don't believe I would waste my time hand cutting dovetails in plywood. In my mind plywood is not the place for such a joint that is better used in solid stock. And butt joints to me are just plain lazy in this situation. Since plywood is the material of choice other traditional joints like rabbets and dadoes would provide better strength and are something a beginning woodworker can do.

I think some lost sight of what the original poster told us. He's a beginner, which probably means his shop is not as well equipped as it could be, and his skill level is that of a beginner. Nothing wrong with that - we've all been there. He's also not currently employed and on a tight budget for this project. It seems to me we could have been more helpful by providing answers that were practical to his situation.

I don't mean to step on anyone's toes in this thread. I just think some of the conversation headed in a direction that provided no help to the original post. On the joinery question - there are books full of typical joints - some I'll never use in my lifetime. What we have to keep in mind is what would be practical for the situation at hand.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#23

I missed that part...and more on lumber choice

Bill Tindall

Plywood drawers. I have never attempted to route a dovetail in plywood but I can anticipate the problems.(could always hand cut them...just kidding) But why? I wouldn't be paying $2/bdft for quality plywood if I had a stash of any kind of lumber I wanted to use up, what ever the joinery. Drawer parts are short....an opportunity to use up the #2 common stuff that is hard to use up otherwise. Drawer parts is where my lower grade lumber winds up either from cutting between knots or stuff with worm holes, sap wood, mineral stain, etc. And, it's an opportunity to practice getting efficient cuttings from lumber at hand.

In the beginning I made drawer boxes with rabbits and dadoes. Indeed these drawers are still sound after 40 years. But, then I found that it was easier and just as fast to get a good box (square and secure) with a dovetail jig. What ever gets decided, the idea of dovetailed drawers should not be discarded because the joint is more difficult to execute successfully by a beginner. It isn't, unless you are practicing hand cutting them, something I am not advocating Brint try at this point.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#24

Agree on both counts

David Yoho

You won't get any argument from me on both points. I've made utility drawers for my shop and other things where I've used materials I'd never think to use for finer work. I still have a stash of quarter -sawn sycamore I bought from our own, Barbara Gill, years ago that I purchased with the plan of using it solely for high end drawer boxes. I've used it several times for that purpose and the results were over the top. Sure, it won't be seen hardly, but it's certainly not wasted when the aim is to take a piece to the next level.

I built a two-drawer built-in file cabinet many years ago using plywood for the boxes. The rabbet and dado joints are still sound today. Due to the use of ball bearing slides, all the boxes have to do is stay square and strong enough to handle the weight from many stored files. I used those joints then, before I was yet equipped to cut machined dovetails, because it seemed more practical given the choice of material.

Finally, I am also guilty at times for missing part of what was said in a post that might have influenced the reply. That actually happened to me when I first replied to Brint's original post.

Re: Need Help with Face Frames, Cabinet back, Carcase *LINK*

#25

A question for John....

Barry Irby

What do you mean by a "box Joint"?