Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Hot water line trouble

Posts

Hot water line trouble

#1

Hot water line trouble

Larry in NW OHIO

My hot water line to the water heater runs very slow. The cloths washer hot water only runs vvveeerrryyyyy slowly. I know the first thing to do would be take that hose and clean out the filters, done that. The next thing is then take the shut off valve off, didn`t do that yet, that`ll be the next thing. My question is the future. I do have somthing in that line but back farther. When I put my in line water heater in that line and took a sink valve off there were something like little beads of clear jello in the line. I don`t have trouble with the cold line. Is there something with the big water heater we have creating these little glabuals somehow. This heater is around12 years old and still runs great. Larry Thanks everyone

Re: Hot water line trouble

#2

Is it a Rheem?

Dustmaker Mike

I had a Rheem taken out yesterday and replaced with a Whirlpool. When I first moved into my house I noticed the facuet aireators would get pluged up with a little white stuff. I started looking around at the cause and found out Rheem had a recall on their water heaters because the drip tube would fall apart and cause the problem I was having. I replaced what was left of the dip tube and the problem started to get a lot less. But the damage was done the bottom of the tank must have been covered with them.

Other then that I have no clue

later

Re: Hot water line trouble

#3

Re: Hot water line trouble

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Larry, I am saying that you have sediment buildup in the bottom of the heater. The dip tube goes down toward the bottom with the cold water and they down breakdown and need replacing every so often. Since the heater is 12 yrs old it might be time to replace. When you put in a new heater....every three months or so place the garden hose on the drain valve and flush out the sediments.

I think you have some hard water in Ohio too which causes some of the problems.

Re: Hot water line trouble

#4

Re: Is it a Rheem?

John Veerkamp

Not only Rheem, for awhile, about half of the heaters around then had this problem. The dip tubes disolved after a few years, causing the very problem you describe. You might need to open the lines by removing valves and flush. At worst some water valves in washing machines and dishwashers become fouled.

Good luck,

John

Re: Hot water line trouble

#5

Re: Hot water line trouble

FredD

Larry, a twelve year old gas fired WH is well past its usefulness economy wise.

Less then 50% efficient.

Time to replace and if you can in your area , get one that is electric ignition , so your pilot light isn't on all of the time, saves you about seven or so bucks a month.

FredD

Re: Hot water line trouble

#6

As Long As You're Saving $

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Have your output hot water line piped with a convection loop. This prevents passive radiation of stored tank heat saving even more money by substantially reducing the amount of energy needed to "maintain" the stored hot water at temperature.

Re: Hot water line trouble

#7

Idea on that

Larry in NW OHIO

Thanks for the replys, I think you got it. Awhile back when the heater would fire up, and in a couple of minutes I would hear a little banging. The first thing I thought of was the tube that is in the tank. I didn`t know what it was called but now I know, the dip tube. When I first got it I always flushed it out every couple of months or so. As I could see I couldn`t see anything come out. So I waited longer. Then after a few years I couldn`t close the valve, so I tightened it up to stop it and quit draining it. So I probably have the build up and broke dip pipe. Instead of replacing the heater, I`ve been thinking of maybe puting in a "on site heater" I figure I would need to put in 3 more heaters, and that way I would get away from the storage type system, and also have hot water quicker at the outlets. What is the opinion of the collective on that? I may need to put in a new, bigger service. I need one anyway. Larry

Re: Hot water line trouble

#8

No Personal Experence

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

But from what I've read and heard, I'm not getting rid of my storage heater. The in-line units may be nifty for the instant hot water at the kitchen sink, but as primary heaters I'm unconvinced.

There is, however, a "hybrid" system which heats at point of use but tapers off as the temperature of the line water from the storage heater increases.

There are a number of plumbing forums on the NET, I suggest you post on several as well.

Re: Hot water line trouble

#9

Re: Idea on that

Barry Irby

Larry, I am a home Inspector but I have no experience with in line heaters or on demand heaters. Here are some random thoughts.

There was an episode of failing dip tubes. The various manufacturers bought dip tubes form the same source. (Not all of them bought from the defective pile, but a lot of them did.) I don't have any reason to believe that not draining the unit caused the failure of the dip tube, if it failed.

I tell people to look in their toilet tank and if there is silt, sediment, crud in there, they need to drain the water heater occasionally, If the Toilet tank is clean, don't bother. I have no proof this is good advice, but it makes sense to me.

The dip tubes that failed crumbled up and fell apart in to tiny pieces of plastic. At least, the ones that I saw did. There were recognizable bits of curved pieces of white plastic in the strainers.

If the dip tube fails, you get a short circuit or cross over. The dip tube forces the cold water to go to the bottom of the tank. Its heavier than the hot water and the hot water floats on it until it rises out the top of the tank into the pipe. If the design is good, there is remarkably little mixing of the hot and cold. This is why you run out of hot fairly suddenly. If the dip tube completely fails (disintegrates) The cold comes in, flows across and goes out the other side and you get much less hot water, even if the tank is hot.

Don't know what your globules were, but it might have been flux if you did any recent soldering on the system.

I am still skeptical of the whole house on demand heaters. A typical gas water heater has a 35,000 to 45,000 BTU heater. A medium sized gas furnace is 64,000 to 100,000 btus. Some of the whole house in line water heaters I have seen are 175,000 btus or more. If your tank water heater is efficient, maybe 75 0r 80% of the energy ends up in the water and the rest goes up the flue. I would expect the majority of the heat from a tankless heater goes up the flue. Am fairly sure they are not nearly as efficient at actually putting the heat into the water. They try to make up for that by not having tank losses. Consumer Reports did a report on them recently and said it would take something like twenty years to compensate for the additional cost.

Re: Hot water line trouble

#10

Re: No Personal Experence

Larry in NW OHIO

Mark Do you know of any of the hybrids, ho makes them, also do you know of any plumbing site. Thank you Larry

Re: Hot water line trouble

#11

Re: Idea on that

Larry in NW OHIO

Barry You gave me alot to think about. I don`t remember anything like you said in the water lines or the filters of the washer. The filters were clean when I took them out. Thank you Larry

Re: Hot water line trouble

#12

Re: My experience is similar

Glenn Madsen---in SF Bay Area

I thought the problem was somewhere else, and kept fighting it. When the water heater started leaking, and got replaced, the crud in the plumbing lines went away. With no other work, either.

Once I replaced the fixtures that were clogged, the problems stopped.

Maybe seven years back, now? And a kitchen remodel, two bathroom lavs, two toilets and a shower stall later...