Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

You don't need a huge motor on a bandsaw?

Posts

Re: You don't need a huge motor on a bandsaw?

#26

Re: Apples and oranges

wilbur

I could use a 1/2" x 3 tpi blade. I don't have one of those. I do have a 3/4" x 3 tpi Timberwolf blade.

But I don't think that it needs to be that complicated or that controlled of an experiment. All I really want to know is how fast does resawing go when you have a more powerful motor, and for my present purpose, a ballpark figure for a 9" wide board is fine. Even a guesstimate of how long it would take for your bigger bandsaw with the 2-3 tpi carbide tipped blade to resaw a 9" wide board 24" long would be fine with me.

The reason that I keep asking is that there have been a few comments about how my setup wouldn't be suitable for a production environment, which I can fully accept. But I still don't have any idea as to how fast resawing goes if you do it at production speeds, other than the comment about how a powerful bandsaw would rip a 9" board like my bandsaw would go through a 3/4" board, which I do have a bit of a hard time believing, since that would mean that a big bandsaw could go through a 9" resaw of my cherry board at a feed rate of about 5 seconds a foot. If it really can, that's great, but either way I'll be learning something.

Re: You don't need a huge motor on a bandsaw?

#27

data, of sorts

Bill Tindall

1954 vintage Delta 20" saw with 1 HP old style motor. Dull 3/4 x 3 tpi blade (in fact I had retired the blade but put it back on for an alignment purpose when I changed tires yesterday (Article coming on how to change tires on this saw) . Poplar 6" tall x 13-1/2 " long. 6 seconds to cut the 13". Was speed limited by the motor bogging down. Well, was fundamentally limited by the combination of dull teeth and motor HP.

What would have limited the feed rate at 6 tpi would have been gullet clogging, not the motor. If after resawing sawdust pours out of the kerf the gullets were clogging and not carrying chips from the cut. One can certainly saw with a fine tpi blade but the feed rate will have to be slowed to accommodate the smaller gullets. The smaller rate of chip formation will enable a proportionally smaller motor to drive the blade.

Re: You don't need a huge motor on a bandsaw?

#28

Size does matter

Phil Smith

My first bandsaw was a Delta with 1/3 HP motor. I did the usual things to up performance, cool blocks, 1/2" woodslicer blade from Highland Hardware for resawing. 4" maple really taxed the motor's capability. Motor eventually gave up and replaced it with 1.5 HP motor. Made a world of difference in resaw capability of the saw. With the upgrade I would routinely resaw 6 to 8ft lengths of 6" poplar. Never got around to putting the riser block in the saw. Moved on to saws with bigger table and motor. Both larger table and higher horse power are useful.

See picture for comparison of original 1/3 HP motor with 3 HP motor on Yates American direct drive bandsaw. The Delta is single phase 1800 rpm motor the Yates is 3 HP 3 phase, 860 rpm. With this set-up on 30" wheel give blade speed of just under 7000 fpm.


The second image is original Delta motor sitting on pieces of 3.5 inch maple that was about the limit of the 1/3 HP motor.