Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Bed Construction Questions

Posts

Bed Construction Questions

#1

Bed Construction Questions

Barry Irby

I promised my son and new DIL I would make them a bed for their wedding present. She has chosen a Morgan bed from Ethan Allen. Dark stained quarter sawn ash With very square straight severe lines. I have walnut from the family farm I would like to use.

So, How can I execute this style with walnut? Do you figure it has to be veneer? The head board for a King sized bed would have to about 6' 4" wide right? And 42" tall.

http://www.ethanallen.com/product?productId=957&categoryId=8028

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#2

Re: Bed Construction Questions

FredD

If your Daughter in-law is knowledgeable about wood and how each specie differs in appearance , why make yourself a headache in trying to make Walnut look like Ash.

Ash is a favorite of mine for a lot of reasons and a excellent wood for furniture.

You would have a far better chance of using V.G. Doug Fir to make it appear like QS Ash or even better Hackberry, but you wouldn't do that , .....would you ?? ;-))

Then there is the rapidly disappearing Ash Forrest to consider down the line if the bed is really solid Ash , she and mostly likely you will see Ash go the way of Chestnut , unless a miracle happens.

FredD

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#3

Re: Bed Construction Questions

Tom Dunlap

Do you have a single sister or older daughter? I'd like to marry into YOUR family! :D

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#4

Re: Bed Construction Questions

Dave Paine

I expect the Ethan Allan items to be veneered over particle board, or MDF.

For the headboard your options may be :

a) Cut the boards to 42 in length and glue up side by side. Will look good, but take a long time. Need good alignment. I prefer dowels for such duties.

b) Use Walnut plywood. Means not using family boards.

c) Attempt to cut veneers from your walnut and glue to other plywood. I have had mixed results in cutting 6in - 8 in veneers from stock. I am not sure if this is my technique or the bandsaw setup or blade. Perhaps all the above.

d) Use other plywood and attempt to stain to look like oak. Ethan Allan using ash since very good to stain to look like other woods.

Good luck with the project. You are taking on quite a task. Keep the group updated on progress.

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Bed Construction Questions

Moses Yoder

You really can't see the construction details in the picture, but I would assume they banded a piece of mdf with solid then veneered the front and back in a vacuum press. If I was bulding it I would change the design slightly and use a frame and panel construciton with horizontal grain on the panels. The head board would be constructed with 5 panels with the panels on the end being short enough that the mullion would end up at the edge of the mattress, and the night stand would cover it. The foot board would have 3 panels in it. The simple lines of the design would still give it a contemporary look, just not quite as clean as the one in the picture. The frame and panel construction would allow you to use your solid wood without a bunch of bandsawing and splicing of shop made veneers or such. I would draw it up then aproach your daughter for aproval of the design and the idea that the wood would be from the family farm.

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#6

Re: Bed Construction Questions

Barry Irby

Fred, I agree with you. I will probe further to see if the grain or appearance of the ash matters to here at all. I don't think it does, because in the pictures on the net I can't tell its anything other than brown.

My motivation is, I have lots of walnut and its free. I am under employed at the moment and would rather use what I have (time and materials) and make it work. And then there is the sentimental nature of the wood. (Think she will buy it?)

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#7

A lass? Not!

Barry Irby

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#8

Anybody tried Veneering a Door?

Barry Irby

Thanks for the thoughts.

The sad thing is I have some walnut boards that are 15" wide. I could make the headboard out of three pieces and the rest of it out of one piece each.

Has any one tried veneering a hollow core door? I don't have a vacuum press system but have been thinking about setting one up. Can you vacuum veneer a hollow core door? Seems like it would make an excellent head board. But I suspect it would cave in or get rippled in the vacuum press.

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#9

I've been thinking about panels also...

Barry Irby

Just got to get back to her and see exactly what it is that she locked onto in the design. Wonder how much flexibility I have?

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#10

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

A king size mattress is 76" wide, so the headboard on this bed, assuming 24" wide nightstands on either side, is probably more like 10'-4" wide. If you want, you can scale the height based on the known width, but there's nothing magic about 42".

Constructionwise, I'm sure the Ethan Allen bed is veneer, although I doubt they laid it on 2" thick MDF because of the weight. It's probably a lightweight plywood hollow core of some sort. I am not a big fan of thin sliced veneer for projects like this, but it's perfectly legitimate. Sawn veneers would be better, but would involve a lot more work than I suspect you are prepared to invest in this project.

Frame and panel construction would let you use your lumber and avoid veneer, but, to my eye at least, it would defeat the whole aesthetic of this design, which is totally minimalist, featureless wood surfaces with the grain running vertically everywhere. Whether or not your daughter has articulated this about the design, she might not be as happy with a frame and panel version.

You could make this bed with vertical boards glued together, perhaps in three separate sections screwed to three or four horizontal cleats in the rear. Seasonal movement in a 6'4" headboard could add up to a fairly sizeable swing. You might overlap the headboard over the end panel so that the gaps wouldn't ever show. I think you could get away with this modification without defeating the design. I'm more concerned, though, about the random grain patterns you're likely to have to settle for if you use your walnut. Quartersawn ash is chosen for its featurelessness, which is part and parcel of the design. Flatsawn walnut wouldn't reflect this quality at all, and again, apart from the color similarity, it would probably be noticeably different to your daughter. Not that you couldn't convince her that your solution is acceptable...

Vertical solid wood for the sides and footboard would also be a construction challenge, so I would personally plan on doing the whole job with a very straight-grained veneer of whatever species you like, stained to whatever color works for your daughter's bedroom decor. If you do so, I would strongly suggest using solid wood edges, especially on the sides and foot of the bed, and I would apply them to the panels after they are veneered, so that they overlap the edges of the veneer. This is your best defense against catching endgrain fibers and chipping the veneer.

It is a very exacting project, and very ambitious. If you don't have a very large veneer bag, you might want to consider having a local shop do the layups for you using a commercial hot press. That would save you the biggest and most specialized chores. It's the only way I would do this project.

Ellis

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#11

Re: Bed Construction Questions

Jesse Cloud

Before you get too far down the road, talk with your 'customer' about color. If she is looking for exactly that color, you will need to work out a finishing plan with some dyes and glazes. Looks like a lot of red in that wood...

I think plywood would be your friend here. You can get several species with very straight grain.

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#12

Thanks Ellis, I appreciate the thoughts

Barry Irby

I have found my DIL to be less than forthcoming about most everything, including this bed. It will be a challenge to get from her EXACTLY what it is about this bed she likes. Is it just the form? Or does the grain matter? Or does she even know why she likes it?

Wonder how I can find a commercial shop that would be wiling to do the glue up?

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#13

Re: Bed Construction Questions

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Barry, I have to agree with Moses about the decision of how the bed will look and the design features, etc. I am getting the impression that the future-DIL

is one of those people that cannot visualize something until it is finished, and then have multi complaints about almost everything.

She is getting the bed FREE so should not have too much to say about how the bed is designed and built. Ask your son what HE wants....and do not let her start off the marriage by being so dominate....problems will develop over the years if she is allowed to do this.

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#14

Re: Bed Construction Questions

FredD

I understand the supply side Barry, but predicting a woman's preference is problematic , at least for me ;-))

FredD

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#15

Clint Searl

Re: Bed Construction Questions

Clint Searl

The headboard appears to present several tecknical challenges that aren't compensated for by its boring appearane. How about a big sheet of MDF covered with an equally big sheet of Formica in a walnut grain? :b

Clint

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#16

Re: Bed Construction Questions

Barry Irby

Clint, I actually thought about that. I am trying to leave my personal opinion out of this, but this is one butt ugly bed. I apologize to any who may like it, but this is a waste of fine materials. How about just a coat of brown paint? Is this going to be a family heirloom? Sheesh!

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#17

Whew!  For a minute I thought it was just me...

John E in SC

Can't say I'm a fan of that particular bed at all! I would have a hard time spending my precious free time making something I didn't love, even if it was for someone I did. I certainly wouldn't waste "heirloom" wood. It would be plywood all the way for me if I were doing this. How about plain ol' birch plywood? Can be stained / dyed pretty well, and is fairly straight-grained.

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#18

Re: Whew!  For a minute I thought it was just me..

Bruce, a MN Galoot

You can get some pretty good walnut plywood from a good supplier, too.

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#19

Re: Bed Construction Questions

Barry Irby

I will do that, but my son is out of town for a few days. People are funny. My other son, whom I like, and I have almost nothing to say to each other. This one, who gives me all manner of grief can carry on quite long conversations. But his wife and I can't get past OK.

My son, having realized his wife was driving the decision is stymied also. He does not want to take the time and effort to build a family heirloom that everyone except her ends up hating. Worse yet, if she hates it too, then we are really stuck. What do you do with an albatross after you build it?

We had planned to pick a plan and build it and if she did not like it and came up with something else, move the one we built into the guest room and then build hers. I just don't want the one she has picked in he guestroom.

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#20

Re: Bed Construction Questions

Larry in NW OHIO

Barry You may try something like that there is something about the bed you can`t do because you don`t have the right tool, or you don`t have the right wood or something or another. When my kids ask about me to make something, they at least ask me, "Can you build this." I only had to say no just once. My oldest asked if I could take apart the changing table I made for their first born. They wanted to cut the one half off, so they would have two storage cabinents, Imagine cut it in half, a family heirloom. Larry

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#21

Did you volunteer or did she ask?

Gary Smyth

I'm betting that her tastes will change in a year or two. If only for its size and the space required that bed style is less than optimal. The price of the bed retail from Ethan Allen is $2400. I believe also includes the mattress which can easily cost $1500 for a California King high version. I appreciate that that money and value could be put to better use than buying from EA but that may be the better solution if you have to deplete prime stock, spend as many "engineering" and preassembly hours as building and finishing hours on it and then... buy the mattress and, possibly, face the "homebuilt" tag that comes, sometimes, from people who don't understand what was involved or appreciate the effort. You may be stuck and committed to the build but I would consult with her for certain that this is not just something she wants, but something she will appreciate as a work that is given as granting her full acceptance into the family. If you find that this is a way of her "saving money" for a bed, even if underemployed, it will be far less drama to buy the bed. You can build them something else until they get settled -- just don't make a beautiful but totally useless and wasted space hooded cradle.

Re: Bed Construction Questions

#22

Re: Did you volunteer or did she ask?

Barry Irby

I volunteered to give her and my son the bed as a wedding present. My son is already exasperated with how difficult it has been for her to pick out a style she likes. My response was that we would build what ever she likes and if it doesn't suit her, we would put the first one in the guest bedroom and build another, hopefully more to her liking. My son has already realized the difficulty of building an albatross family heirloom.

I will have to check on the mattress. I was not aware it came with the bed. That is really something to think about.