Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

Posts

OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#1

OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

Barry Irby

I need to buy a vacuum cleaner for the house. Went to Costco, but they were closing, so I took a fast look. They had a Hoover upright that was a "Platinum" model that appears to be a knockoff of a Dyson. It had a hose on it for getting high stuff and was about $200.

The had a Dyson DC 14 that appear similar and was about $400. Both of these were bag less.

They also had an Oreck and it was about $375

I don't even know what questions to ask. Help me out here and make up some good ones and answer them.

I guess the general one is....What to buy??

Upright or canister? Bag or bag less?

Is the Dyson really worth double the money?

I tried looking on the Internet, but could not find a rating on the Hoover Platinum. Was not wiling to pay $30 to join Consumer reports, I may go to the library.

There is a wood working connection. Mysteriously, sawdust tracks up out of my shop.

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#2

Barry, Consumer Reports

Mike Farinella

conistently rates Dyson at the bottom or near the bottom on their ratings. I believe a canister or an upright is a matter of preference. Good luck.

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#3

Clint Searl

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

Clint Searl

Check out Consumers Report; they probably have the best advice. We have two Dysons that my wife loves. I think they're overrated , underpowered, and inconvenient. I prefer a high end canister.

Clint

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#4

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

Larry in NW OHIO

Barry My WIFE just bought a Dyson, after over having Kenmore for over 30 years, and very, very little trouble with them. Consumer reports rate the kenmore at the top most of the time. Myself I like the cannester,but my wife likes the upright. As for the dyson my wife got a good deal on it. After all was said and done I think she only paid something like $250 for it. She got it at Khols Department store, sometimes they have dollar points, buy so much and get so much dollar points with the sale of 20% or so off then had a coupon for so much off, it all added up. Barry I wouldn`t get a Dyson if they gave it to me, with all respect to the people that like them, I`m just very different I guess. The so called hose contraption really sucks, and not the vaccum way. Our cleaning lady does not like it also. Good luck Larry

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#5

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

Dave Paine

I purchased a Dyson style bagless upright vacuum couple of years ago. A few weeks ago the hose plastic gave way at the coupling.

Went out to get replacement. I thought the Dyson's are too expensive.

I ended up with an LG UV300B "compressor" upright model, which is fancy name for a paddle which tries to keep the dust somewhat compressed so less frequent emptying.

The LG is a "vertical" cyclone. Just tow compared to the Dyson et al several I prefer the dust remains stationary (just moves with the paddle.

There is an LG version without the "compressor" paddle which is cheaper.

Only been using a few weeks, but quieter than other model, longer cord (40 ft) and better suction on carpets. So far so good.

I had cannister still used in the basement. Upright is more compact.

I really like bagless, in the old bag models, the bags were getting expensive.

I did convert my Fein Turbo III to use paper bags. Expensive but worth it for shop vac use.

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#6

I really, REALLY wanted a . . .

steve mackay

Dyson. Just 'cause it was cool. Did my research. A LOT of it. Not only the Dyson. Thing was, try as I might, I just couldn't come up with enough good reports to support the price. Maybe one or two comments out of ten were remotly good. Had to go with the Sears Kenmore for $375 (I DID pay for the service / exrended warranty. Thank God !). Had to turn it in for a switch awhile back. It went from El Paso to ALBQ, switch replaced, and trucked back . . . in FOUR days ! Darn thing sucks like a shopVac. Quality, service, dependability . . . the place we all love to hate.

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#7

I understand.....

Barry Irby

I could not bring myself to pay twice as much for the Dyson as the knock off, but then I couldn't believe the half price knock off was as good.

Have you seen one of the "air blade" hand dryers Dyson came up with? It blows out tow sheets of air with such force it literally blasts the water right off your skin. Wow! A hand dryer that actually dries your hands! Amazing. then I noticed that it had blown all the water onto my pants. So now I just go low tech and wipe my hands on my pants like I used to.

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#8

Always thought . . .

steve mackay

thats what pants were for !

But, yea, I saw that hand dryer. Neat stuff.

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#9

Go to a repairman

Ray - Middletown, IN

He will tell you everything you want to know. Just go to one that repairs only and not sells. My wife grew up in a Hoover household (her father was a district rep) but when she needed a new one about 10 years ago she went to a repairman she knew from her childhood. He recommended a Panasonic and it has stood up very well. I have no idea which is best today but I know who does, and he is still in business.

Ray

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#10

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions *LINK*

mdclor

Barry,

I had been looking at shop vacs for a year or more and finally found the Nilfisk. They were previously known as the WAP line. Anyhow, for a shop vac I have been blown away by the Nilfisk Attix 30. So I would offer that the vac at the link below is the best available. You might not need this level of clean if allergies or asthma etc. aren't an issue.

Another option would be to take off your shoes when you exit the shop and not track saw dust through the house. :D

HTH,

Merle


Family Vac

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#11

Re: Go to a repairman

Kneale Brownson..Back enjoying CO snow

We've been using Panasonics for more than 20 years. Started with one to replace the first vac that broke shortly after we bought a 45-room motel. I could get parts and fix them myself. Kept replacing broken other brands with Panasonics. Got out of the motel in 1996, but have had kept Panasonics for the house ever since.

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#12

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

Tony - Memphis

We had a Kenmore "drag behind" that worked fine for many years. I never liked having to drag the thing around. We had several friends that bought Dysons and I made fun of them for spending so much, but they all loved them. a while back, we decided it was time for a new vac and my wife was interested in the Dyson. I caught a deal at Target via Amazon and got $100 off. We got the ball version. I was very impressed with how well it worked and how nice it was to use. I push it around a few times a week and I really like it. I still think they are too expensive even at the deal we got, but ours has performed very well. It's amazing what the thing picks up. I bet none of the name brands are junk. Sears seems to have lots of sales on such items.

Tony

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#13

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

Jerry Samsen

A little late in responding but...

We have an Oreck and love it. Mainly because it creates a lot suction (did not want to say it sucks alot... :) ) and it is very light and easy to push around. Also comes with HEPA filtering bags.

Simple, light, powerful -- works for me.

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

#14

Re: OT Buying a vacuum cleaner questions

Nat Robison

I have a $65 Bissell Bagless upright that work fantastically, in my opinion. The big issue with bagless vacuums is to keep up on the filter cleaning/changes. The foam filters run $5-$10 and I maybe change them once a year, but I clean them every couple of weeks.

I only have wall-to-wall carpeting on one floor of the house (and that's only about 500 sf). It picks up a ton of stuff.

I could conceivably own 4-5 more of these in my lifetime and still not invest what one Dyson would cost.