Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

New Shop Dust collection

Posts

New Shop Dust collection

#1

New Shop Dust collection

jonathans

I am finally setting up my "Dream Shop" that is 38' x 46'. In my previous basement shop, I have been using a Jet DC1100c 1.5HP cannister dust collector.

It did ok considering I ran everything with corregated hose. Didn't do so well with the 12" Jointer though,maybe because it was at the end of the line.

The new shop is bigger and will have one post 23' out from one end. I plan to use this post as a singular drop point for the dust collection and electrical, as much as possible. So the ducting will run 30' from the dust collector to the post and then down to the floor where it will branch in one direction to pick up the Jointer, bandsaw, RAS, and Miter saw, and the other direction to pick up the 13" planer, 16" belt sander, table saw, spindle sander, and router table. From the same T that it heads from the ceiling to the floor at the post, it goes along the ceiling 18' over to the panel saw.

I will use rigid ducting or PVC this time around, and lone ranger gates at each tool. Yes, I know about the "risks" of PVC.

The question is whether I should invest in a new higher HP collector, or whether I can pick up a powered first stage to go inline with what I currently own?

My second question is, where I must run the ducting across the floor, as I do not want any drops at the tools, I would appreciate ways to make this more ameniable, if at all possible, short of busting up the slab to run it subgrade.

Since I'll be running short distances across the floor from the post to the tools, I'll utilize the same runs for the electrical so I don't have electrical drops at the tools. Naturally none of this is an issue for tools against the walls, only the tools in the middle of the shop.

I tried to upload a file scan of the shop. Not sure whether it worked.

Any constructive insight would be appreciated.

Jonathan


Re: New Shop Dust collection

#2

Why eschew drops

Bill Tindall

What could the disadvantage be for a drop at a jointer, band saw or many tools?

I would stick the table saw by some wall and drop down the wall and across the floor on what ever side has less traffic.

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#3

Re: Why eschew drops

jonathans

The tablesaw is 15' from one wall which is 49' from the dust collector, and 31' from the other wall which is close to the dust collector. The post however, is only 10' from the tablesaw and in line with the dust collector which makes it the logical place to drop down. I prefer not to have drops as much as possible. Seems they always get in the way when swinging around long lumber. Ideally, my mid shop dust collection and electrical would be in the floor, but this is not new construction.

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#4

Re: Why eschew drops

Jesse Cloud

You might consider splitting the DC between your current machine and the new one you plan to buy, enabling shorter runs (49 feet is a long run). I presume the long ranger has channel selection ability so you could run two independent systems...

The traditional solution for covering wire and duct on the floor is to build a false raised floor, but that costs $$$ and takes up vertical space.

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#5

Re: Why eschew drops

Larry in NW OHIO

Jonathan Instead of the long ranger, I used air cylinders with selonoids to activate them. It only cost me about $150 with buying everything off Ebay. This works very well. Don`t be concerened about the PVC, I`ve had it for over 20 years and not a problem and it gives you better air flow. Best of luck. Larry

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#6

Re: New Shop Dust collection

mdclor

Jonathan,

I would suggest that you consider the info in some of the sources available. One example is that it is recommended that the DC be located close to the center of the shop to minimize the length of the various runs. They can also give you the size of ducting and required air flow for the various tools you intend to attach to the system. Here is one of (if not the) best sites available:

http://billpentz.com/woodworking/cyclone/index.cfm

Also, Oneida will design a system for you. I believe that the service is free if you buy a DC from them. However, I would not buy duct work from them; use PVC instead.

http://oneida-air.com/shop_plan_design/shop_plan_design.php

Then there is Setting Up Shop if you are interested:

http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_ss_i_0_15?url=search-alias%3Dstripbooks&field-keywords=setting+up+shop+by+sandor+nagyszalanczy&sprefix=setting+up+shop

With a shop that size, I wouldn't be concerned about turning long boards-you have plenty of space available. It will, however, be a real pain to have to step over a DC run or to have to go the "other way around" if you start putting your work in progress on a cart to move it from one tool to another.

Finally, if you look in the Shop Shots section here on WC you will be able to get good ideas from the "collective wisdom" here. I don't mean to be critical of your plan because I can see that you have put a lot of time and effort into it, but since this is your dream shop you need to consider all the available options.

HTH,

Merle

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#7

Re: New Shop Dust collection

jonathans

Thanks,

I just picked up "Setting Up Shop". Very good book with lots of insight.

The two area I chose to run the ducting across the floor are ony 3' long and one is behind the jointer. Not critical areas, but will have to be stepped over.

I am thinking about using extruded rectangle aluminum with the same volume as equivalant ducting for the sections run across the floor. This would be lower to step over and structurally sound as well.

I am going to try to get used to the idea of drops for the DC and electric, but they have always got in my way before. But then everything got in my way with a low ceiling crowded shop. I would like to hear how others have no problems with, or problems with drops to centrally located equipment. I would also like to hear how much of a problem ducting on the floor presents, or not. The ideal is everything below the floor, but thats not available to me unless I decide to do some concrete cutting.

Thanks for the re-enforcement to use PVC!

I am considering selling the 650cfm Jet cannister, and picking up a JDS 3100-ck with 2000cfm and a low clearance height (only have 8' ceilings).

I really want to do this shop right, and appreciate everyone's help.

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#8

good thoughts, and more

Bill Tindall

At a recent club meeting we had an engineer experienced with air flow issues (AKA fluid mechanics) talk about setting up a DC system. I almost didn't go because "what more does one need to know about DC, right". I quickly learned that proper DC design is a complex matter and it is definitely not something you add as an after thought to the shop. Rather, you design the shop around the capabilities of the DC, unless one is willing to over capacity the DC blower (at $large cost$) such that design flaws are overwhelmed. The amount of money most of us spend on the blower leaves us needing to carefully optimize the plumbing to avoid pressure drops and velocity degradation that will render the DC ineffective, and/or motor loading that will overheat the motor.

Among the counter intuitive things I learned was that there is a substantial pressure drop at the end of a pipe. Terminate the pipe at a flange or better yet at a cone(trumpet shaped affair) and this pressure drop becomes negligible. No wonder a hose laying on the bench is ineffective in sucking up stuff from any distance.

Another: When idling the DC close all the inlets for this situation will result in the least current draw at the motor. This recommendation presumes the piping will handle the pressure gradient. The typical heavier stove pipe used for DC will handle the pressure differential.

PVC has one significant disadvantage. There will be substantial pressure drop at each bend, far more so than a gentle bend that can be obtained in "stove pipe". I don't know what the attraction is for PVC in the home shop. The heavier gauge "stove pipe" is best from the point of minimizing pressure drop, it is easy to work with and not prohibitive in cost. Its light weight made installation easy. I bought mine from Oneida because at the time it was as cheap to get it there as anywhere local. It was what the Oneida tech staff recommended.

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#9

Re: good thoughts, and more

Barry Irby

Bill Tindall is right, Lots of good advice. And, You can spend a month reading Bill Pentz site and the time would not be wasted.

One important thing is to remember that the air flowing in the ducts must have enough velocity (energy) to keep the debris flying until it reaches the collection bin. This is the "Engineering" part and where good design pays off. If you double the size of the pipe, the velocity of the air drops in half. One idea is to have larger trunk runs to allow for several branches to be open at the same time so you can run more that one tool or run tools that require higher cfm, but it you only run one tool, the debris may settle out in the long larger runs.

What about putting the DC in the middle of the room to shorten the runs? (OTOH, I put mine outdoors to be RID of the dust and noise)

I have PVC pipe and have had no problems, but I have a very small shop. I used the thin wall S & D stuff and am very happy with it. But I also think Bill Tindall is correct. You could also use heavier gauge (Closer to 20 gauge than 30) ducts for your runs and it would be OK or even better. I did take some effort to minimize the friction in the bends. I used 2 45's in stead of an elbow and a wye and a 45 rather than a tee.

Do a pretty good job of sealing the leaks in the system. Tape the seams or caulk them. I like being able to take mine apart and rearrange it, but the joints still need to be air tight. If you don't believe me, punch a 1/16" hole in a soda straw and try to suck water through it.

I have the pickup for my TS running out from the wall on one side and it does not bother me.

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#10

Long Ranger suggestion

Rod Peterson�Ormond Beach, FL

(also applies to equivalent competing products)

I recently purchased a 240V Long Ranger unit. There are a couple of reasons I did so—one was for possible (although unlikely) future expansion, which given the size of your shop is more likely a good possibility.

The principal one was current draw. At 240V the current draw is half that at 120V. That makes it more reasonable in terms of running at the same time as one of the other tools (saw, planer, jointer). Note that it doesn't change the amount of power consumed—watts are watts, after all—refer to I²R calculations.

The three tools mentioned in the preceding paragraph are the only ones for which I regularly use dust (chip) collection, and I manually change hoses to do it. However, in my cramped shop, it was inconvenient to get to the On/Off switch on the DC, so remote control was the obvious solution. Since my Jet DC-650 is capable of running on 240V, that version of remote switch was a natural.

I'm glad I did it. A quick hose change, a punch of a button on the controller hanging from the power drop, and I'm in business. There's virtually no reason not to run the DC now every time I run one of the tools, even though I'm "just making this one cutoff" as I was wont to do when On/Off was inconvenient.

Rod

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#11

Re: New Shop Dust collection

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

"I am thinking about using extruded rectangle aluminum with the same volume as equivalent ducting for the sections run across the floor. This would be lower to step over and structurally sound as well."

This is another one of those gotchas. I would rethink using rectangular duct unless it is a short section like the inlet to a cyclone. Rectangular duct is much less efficient:

1. For an equivalent cross-sectional area, round pipe has less internal surface. A 6" pipe has a circumference of (pi * D) 18.8" and a cross-sectional area (pi * R sqrd) 28.3. sq in. A square duct (the most efficient rectangular duct) with the same cross sectional area would have sides of 5.3" for a perimeter of 21.2" So you can see that when you multiply the circumference of round and perimeter of rectangular by a given length of duct, there will be more internal surface in a square duct and hence more static pressure resistance than with round duct.

2. Air doesn't as flow smoothly through a rectangular duct, you get all kinds of turbulence from the four corners. Also, dust will settle out of the air stream much easier that will reduce flow or even clog the duct.

3. If you use rectangular duct in some areas, you will most likely need fittings at one or both ends to transition to round ducting, flex hose, etc.- MORE static pressure resistance!

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#12

Re: New Shop Dust collection

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

"The question is whether I should invest in a new higher HP collector, or whether I can pick up a powered first stage to go inline with what I currently own?"

Break out your wallet- the size of the shop, the long duct runs, and types of machines screams for a 3 - 5 hp DC with a minimum 14" impeller.

You are also wasting a system like that if you try to use it as a single stage unit without a pre-separator. You will clog your filter in a flash and will dramatically reduce CFM. Since this is your dream shop you need a cyclone.

Also, I hope when you say "T" you in your other post you really mean "Wye". T's are a big NO, NO in DC ducting- they add way too much static pressure resistance.

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#13

Re: New Shop Dust collection

Larry in NW OHIO

Jonathan Your getting excellent advice, I hope you these peoples advice. They all have a lot on hand experiance, the best advice to get. I have a 3hp oneida cyclone and I would not go any smaller, and my shop is probably 1/2 the size of yours, so I wouldn`t go any smaller than a 5hp cyclone. With all due respect to anyone who has a bad DC, I would not due without a cyclone. So as they say spend your money once and do it right. Read Bill Pentz site as much as possible. Best of luck Larry

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#14

Re: New Shop Dust collection (long)

Grant in Iowa

Johnathan,

I think one of the best ways to reduce/ minimize the number of drops is to group machines together into groups that both make sense from a workflow and a DC demands perspective.

For example, a planer, jointer, and bandsaw can be grouped together and utilize a single drop. This is what I plan to do in my shop soon when I add the dust collector ducting. My jointer and planer are back to back, with the bandsaw off of one end and between their infeed areas. The bandsaw is oriented so that its in and outfeed areas are adjacent to and over the infeed areas of both jointer and planer. This arrangement allows the power and duct routing to be supplied from the ceiling above and behind the bandsaws spine to service all 3 machines. To be sure, dropping power and ducting from the ceiling can cause an inconvenience when handling long lumber, so I minimize the issue by using groupings of machines. In this way we have fewer ceiling-to-machine obstacle locations. Before I install the ductwork, I plan to add my drum sander between and perpendicular to the outfeeds of both jointer and planer to create a grouping of 4 machines in one area.

My 52" table saw will likely be positioned with its extension table near a wall so the power and ductwork can come down that wall where it is unlikely to interfere with material handling.

All of my other machinery is positioned on a wall so the ductwork simply runs down that wall to the machine.

To summarize, I think you are on the right track, but you might consider locating both the DC and all of the major dust producers around that same post in order to improve the collection and perhaps negate the need to upgrade. You could still run a 4" line to an adjacent wall to serve Drill Press, Miter saw, etc.

If noise is an issue, consider placing that DC in a closet built next to the post. It might actually be handy to have say a 6x6 closet in which to house a DC and an air compressor so noise is less of an issue. I say this because I find in my 34x45 shop that I don't have enough walls on which to hang things or locate machines that are best backed up to a wall. This situation is the origin of my grouping machine grouping idea. More walls can be a good thing in such a large space. You could even use the space above that room for lumber storage if you ceiling is high enough.

Also, human nature is to arrange things in aisles or rows. However, a grouping or square can often make more efficent use of infeed and outfeed space by sharing it between tools.

I would encourage you to get some graph paper and make scale models of your machines (including desired infeed and outfeed space) so you can easily play with different layouts before you do it for real. Indeed, when I moved into my shop, I held off on the DC ducting until I was sure I had things where they were likely to stay (which has been about 3 years of cutting long boards, large pieces of ply, etc). If I had done the ducting when I moved in, I would be cursing myself for poor layout and moving machines and ductwork. As it is, the ductwork is just now making it to the top of the list, but I am glad I waited until the machines declared where they "wanted to live".

I had to "rough it" for those 3 years by moving the flex hose from machine to machine, but I now have the experience to be sure that I am installing ductwork where it needs to be.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#15

The bottom line of this topic

Bill Tindall

Designing a "dust" collection system that works is a highly technical endeavor, way beyond the scope of most people. It involves understanding the capability of the blower to move air as a function of horse power, calculating losses from every part of the plumbing, and design of efficient capture at the sources. We call these things dust collection, but in fact we are designing for chip collection. You can stick a filter in the middle of the shop and circulate air through it and get dust collection. Chips with kinetic energy shooting away from the collection port require sufficient air flow to turn them around to be captured. Ensuring that air velocity requires calculations and data most of us will not have or be able to do.

The bottom line is that one begins with the capability of the blower/fan and the velocity one needs at the collection source. Then by optimizing the plumbing and distance you figure out what can be where.

I became convinced at the club presentation that you design the dust collection first based on what you can afford for a blower/cyclone and then build the shop around it.

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#16

Re: New Shop Dust collection (long)

mdclor

Just a couple comments regarding Grant's post. I wouldn't put a compressor in a closet because of all the heat they can generate. Outside the shop in a shed would be better IMO.

Secondly, I used this tool from Grizzly to design my shop. You have to use currently available Grizzly tool models, but they will get you close enough to the dimensions of your machines.

http://www.grizzly.com/workshopplanner.aspx

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#17

Re: New Shop Dust collection (long)

jonathans

My original post has a pdf of my shop plan. It was made by moving cutouts around and then on Grizzly's tool.

Re: New Shop Dust collection

#18

Control with a Handkerchief!

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Certainly its nothing to sneeze at, Bill.

George :D