Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Walnut Bar Top Finish

Posts

Walnut Bar Top Finish

#1

Walnut Bar Top Finish

Alan

I'm remodeling our kitchen and have purchased a wide slab of walnut for a bar top. I was planning on finishing with Behlen Rock Hard varnish and was wondering if I need to use a paste filler and if so, what you would recommend. Thanks

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#2

No filler

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mountain

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#3

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

For filling walnut I'd suggest the Bartley Dark, although I've used Crystal Lac.


Fillers

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#4

Ellis Walentine

Filled vs. unfilled surfaces

Ellis Walentine

The reason to fill pores is so that the finished product will have a dead-smooth surface in the shortest possible time. (Well, I suppose you could use one of the decoupage style finishes and get that thick syrupy shine in one pour.) So, it's your choice. If you decide not to fill, then your finish will sink into the pores and give you that open-pore look. The open-pore look is a moving target, though, as it changes (the little indentations get smaller) with each successive coat of finish. Usually, the surface looks best when either just barely filled (as with a couple coats of a thin finish like lacquer) or fully filled and glass smooth. The intermediary coats don't look as good, to me at least. If you're using a thick varnish finish for this bar top, a filler might be a good choice, because you don't want to use two coats of the varnish and then have the pores be half filled.

Those are my perceptions of this. I'd advise "finish firewood first," as Michael Dresdner would say, meaning run a few samples and see if you see what I'm talking about, then go from there.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#5

Trade-off

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

One consideration for a working "food" surface is cleaning. Open pore woods like walnut will, even with finish applied, tend to gather spilled/dried substances in the unfilled pores. This can show up as a shadow or spot defined by the pores holding the foreign material. Not impossible to clean, but still more of a chore.

OTOH, a filled or "piano" finish will be much easier to keep clean, but will show small scratches and wear patterns more easily.

Of course, as Ellis mentioned, there's always the poured epoxy route, but I've seen some truly hideous "pour" jobs.

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#6

Re: Trade-off

Alan

This isn't going to be a work surface, but people will be eating at it and crumbs will be an issue. I think I'll take the good advice I've gotten here and do some tests to see what looks best. Thanks

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#7

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

Jesse Cloud

I used Rockhard on my dining table and the accompanying buffet and chairs. After lots of testing, I decided to fill the pores (used Behlen pore-o-pac) on the tabletop, but not on the other pieces.

Another issue with filler is that it will not take on color the way the wood does. If the wood is fairly consistent, I would just use a dark filler. If there is a mixture of light and dark, then you either have to use a light filler and have light spots on the dark wood or the other way around. The alternative is to color the filler to look like the wood will after the varnish is on.

Couple of comments on Rockhard - thin that first coat about 50 percent (use the Rockhard reducer) for better adhesion. The varnish dries very slowly, so try to get the area as dust free as possible. Once dry, the varnish cures slowly. I don't put Rockhard pieces into service for two weeks. Don't rub it out, if thats in your plan, for 2 weeks.

Having said all that, Rockhard is a great product. My dining table is 3 years old and gets lots of abuse at least 3X daily, but it still looks great.

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#8

Ellis Walentine

Tip for slow-curing varnishes

Ellis Walentine

Many years ago, when my father was still alive and well and spending a lot of time in the shop, he came up with a partial solution for the problem of dust settling into slow-drying varnish: He would rig up a plywood (or other sheet good) cover over the piece, suspended about an inch above the finish table surface. Of course, the plywood needed to be scrupulously cleaned before being deployed. This simple trick really reduced the amount of dust that landed in the curing varnish.

2�

Ellis

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#9

Filler Color

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

While others use tints and colored bulk, Crystalac becomes invisible when the finish is applied. I've used it on walnut, oak and mulberry to do "piano" finishes.

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#10

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

FredD

I always use a filler on Walnut horizontal finishes, for years I used Sherwin - Williams natural oil based filler and tinted it with stain , if I was using stain on the project.

Then along came Crystal -Lac and it goes much faster, less work and so on..

The Behlens Rock Hard is a excellent Varnish and I would use a flat sheen rather then a gloss for a Bar top.

There are some Bar top finishes called that , but they are heavy duty plastic and look like it.

FredD

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#11

General Finishes arm-r-seal top coat

Grant in Iowa

Alan,

I have had good results, and good longevity from about six coats (early ones brushed with a foam brush, and last few wiped on) of General Finishes arm-r-seal top coat. I blocked the first few coats until I was satisfied with the flatness, then added a few build coats, and wiped on a few finish coats.

I applied it to a Hickory dining table destined to a home with young boys. The finish has held up well. No complaints.

I am sure there are other good finishes too. I think the key is to choose a "short oil" finish so it will be hard enough to stand up to the banging of dishes.

Another issue you may want to ask about here will be water stain resistance in a finish. Though the hickory table I built shows no sign of this type of damage, it may show up more easily on Walnut.

Make sure you balance your wide slab by applying at least a couple coats of finish to both sides so it is less likely to warp on you.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#12

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

Alan

The crystalac sounds perfect. Thanks everyone.

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#13

a couple of other methods

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I use a lot of walnut and use three different metods for filling the grain depending on the finish I will be using. the simplest is to just let the finish build and this is the method I use when I am using General HP poly. I build up about 4 coats and then sand down and build another 4 coats and sand. It usually takes about 12 coats to get a water smooth finish sanded and rubbed out. I often only do this on horizontal surfaces and fiish the rest of the same piece with half the number of coats. This is possible with General HP poly since it is nearly water clear and dosen't yellow.

The next method is pretty old school but I like it for its simplicity and since I use hot hide glue exclusively it works for me. To both raise the grain and fill the pores I thin hot hide glue 10:1 and apply with a rubber squeegee. You work it across the surface and as it cools and sterts to gel you will see it fill the pores. if done right it will only require a light sanding to remove the raised grain. an advantage of this method is that there is no problem with color not being taken up if I use a stain.

This method is my least favorite. I thin Jasco brand tung oil just a tad to give me more working time before it gets tacky. I then use 220 wet dry sandpaper with the finish which creates a slury. as I rub this into the wood it fills the pores.

Good luck

Robin

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#14

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

Howard Acheson

Let me suggest that Waterlox Original is a more water resistant finish than the Behlens's. I like Behlens a lot but it is made with linseed oil. Waterlox Original varnishes are made with tung oil which is more water resistant therefore a better choice for your application. Both are made with a phenolic resin which provides a hard finish and imparts a dark amber tone which looks very nice on walnut IMO.

Keep in mind though, no finish will be completely impervious to water and water vapor. Placing cold or hot items directly on the finished surface will have a high probability of leaving rings or gray areas. Always use coasters, trivits and place mats to maintain the nice appearance of the walnut.

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#15

Walnut Bar Top Finish - Another Option

Al

I picked up the slab today from the shop that planed and sanded it, at 22" it's bit too wide for my shop. Anyway, they suggested/offered spraying it with a conversion varnish (Plastofix). They indicated that they would sand between coats, the pores would be filled, and it would be a nicer finish than brushing. They had some examples there and I would be hard pressed to equal the look of that finish. Would this be as durable? Thanks

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#16

Re: CV *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I've included a link to info on Woodweb. While CV's have been great as kitchen and architectural finishes, I'd think twice when it comes to a bar top, mostly because of the hassle to repair or renew the surface.


woodweb

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#17

Re: CV

FredD

Mark, that site compares the durability of Conversion Varnish with standard Nitro-cellulose which is not anywhere near a fair comparison.

While it notes the toughness of CV it knocks the finish because it is hard to repair and on the other hand notes the easy repairability of Lacquer which is true , but not in the same class as Pre-catalyzed Lacquers for toughness and they are also easy to repair and you don't have the cleanup chores that you do with CV.

I use Pre-cat lacquer over the recommended Vinyl sealer for nearly all of the stuff I make and the difference between it and standard Nitro-cellulose lacquer is amazing.

The Pre-cat would make a good finish for the bar top and be considerable easier to repair then any Varnish, though a good Varnish job is a thing of beauty, but the Lacquer will need to be sprayed.

FredD

FredD

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#18

Re: CV

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Fred,

Alan's "shop" is pushing CV, not pre-cat. Pre-cat is easier to redo, but not anyway near as easy as an oil varnish will be to take care of the inevitable wear. The link was to show him the drawbacks of CV, not get into the comparisons discussed.

I've not, however, seen pre-cat hand-applied to good effect, and it's all too easy to get too much finish on resulting in cracking of a too-thick film. Several pro shops around me shoot CV or pre-cat (or even polyester) for kitchen/bath cabinetry, but they're not doing work surfaces which then use stone or composites on the installs.

I personally would not use either CV or pre-cat to fill grain and then build a coating for a working surface like a bar top, but I'm sure you and others here have more experience with them than I.

Peace

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#19

Re: CV

FredD

I thought somebody posted whether Varnish was a good finish for Bar Tops , particularly Behlens rock Hard andif you will note I agreed with that way to go.

Then you posted a site that went off on a tangent and got off the Varnish use and compared Apples and Oranges finish wise.

About the use of finish for grain filler , it is a waste of expensive finish and does not do a good job compared to Grain filler and judging from the posts here that advocate many coats of finish sanded back to nearly the first one it also adds a hell of a lot of unnecessary work to a relatively straight forward phase of your wood working.

As for Alan's project I suspect he is on the right track and I stated that Pre-cat is sprayed .

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#20

You Missed The New Question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

About Alan's "shop", who was preparing the 22" wide top, trying to push CV on him instead of other finishes. See "Other Option" a few posts above, just before my Link.

My response was to move him away from CV.

We on the same page now, Fred?

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#21

Re: You Missed The New Question

FredD

Hard to say Mark , I am on the same page I have always been concerning finishes and how they are applied and how they compare with durability and ease of ding repair.

Pretty basic in my opinion

Having said that and I am sure we are at least in the same Chapter , when you spend a lot of time and effort getting the wood part of your project complete, it only seems like common sense to take a equal amount of care in the finish , since that is first thing to attract attention.

FredD

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#22

Okay, I'll Try it this way . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

"I picked up the slab today from the shop that planed and sanded it, at 22" it's bit too wide for my shop. Anyway, they suggested/offered spraying it with a conversion varnish (Plastofix). They indicated that they would sand between coats, the pores would be filled, and it would be a nicer finish than brushing. They had some examples there and I would be hard pressed to equal the look of that finish. Would this be as durable?"

Now do you understand my response to his question?

Hint: "Al" is also "Alan"

Re: Walnut Bar Top Finish

#23

Re: Okay, I'll Try it this way . . .

FredD

He missed a golden opportunity when he didn't adcept that generous offer.

FredD