Re: Slightly OT Geothermal Heating/Cooling
Grant in Iowa
Tommy,
We built a new home 3 years ago and decided to skip it. Here's why:
1. Initial cost of system would (in our case) be financed for many years. Think of any added costs in building a new home as going on the end of the mortgage. So we added that interest cost to the balance sheet when deciding. Your mileage may vary, but in our case this was a big factor, perhaps the deciding factor. Also consider that to qualify for rebates, you may have to have a submeter, or even a separate electrical service installed. Some I have talked to have had to have the service upgraded to handle the turn on surge of the system, which is not likely free from the utility.
2. Much of the advertising information compares a geothermal system to an outdated existing furnace in an older home. The Geothermal loos like a no brainer in that case. Much of the information I have seen tends to avoid comparing one to a high efficiency gas furnace and water heater in a well insulated home.
In the end, we decided to superinsulate our home in Iowa, taking care to caulk common loss areas ourselves. We insulated beneath the basement slab, outside the poured walls, and insulated the rim joist well. 2x6 walls, caulking and vapor barriers, and a heavy dose of blown in insulation in the attic. We did splurge on a wood burning fireplace by Kozy Heat, which fits well with my logs to lumber hobby.
Our home is a one story ranch with a finished basement 1800 square feet on the main floor. Gas heat, tank type 50 gal gas water heater, gas clothes dryer, and a 1400 square foot shop building that I always keep above freezing in winter with natural gas. I do burn wood when I am home, burning around two cords last winter. Our high natural gas bill was two years ago. $180 with four adults in the house during a record cold month. I estimate that our house is costing around $110-120 month to heat in the coldest month with our current habits. About $80 or so in an average winter month. It is hard to justify the up front expense with bills that reasonable, IMHO.
As I have said. Do the math. Your mileage may vary depending on the costs of energy in your area and the size and type of home you hope to build. Either way, I am a firm believer in being involved heavily in the building process and especially insulating yourself.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa