Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Slightly OT Geothermal Heating/Cooling

Posts

Slightly OT Geothermal Heating/Cooling

#1

Slightly OT  Geothermal Heating/Cooling

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I am exploring ideas for a new home and workshop I hope to build in (hopefully) not too distant future. Likely the site would be a wooded site out in the country. I have been looking at information about geothermal heating and cooling of homes (and maybe workshop). But I'd like to see if I could hear from folks who have it or know of it. Pros? Cons? Things to consider? Does it really save on bills? Etc.

Thanks in advance.

Tom

Re: Slightly OT Geothermal Heating/Cooling

#2

Re: Slightly OT  Geothermal Heating/Cooling

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The current ("Houses") issue of Fine Homebuilding has some interesting articles on both sides of this subject. One author argues that heat pumps are less efficient than other forms of heating.

Re: Slightly OT Geothermal Heating/Cooling

#3

Re: Slightly OT  Geothermal Heating/Cooling

Larry in NW Ohio

Tom My daughter and SIL put it in and so far like it. They just moved in last Sept. and at least the winter went well, need to wait for the cooling bills. Our school put it in and a couple others and I guess their bills are something like 1/2 is what I heard. Our school never had AC and they had it put in with the geo and They say they can afford it now, it`s a Catholic school. Larry

Re: Slightly OT Geothermal Heating/Cooling

#4

Re: Slightly OT  Geothermal Heating/Cooling

Ray - Middletown, IN

When I built my place 5 years ago I considered Geothermal. I got bids from 4 different HVAC guys in my area and the info I got back was that it was about 40% more expensive than a conventional system for starters. Also that with an open system I would see maintenance issues in 7-10 years. Open system being one drawing water from the ground, withdrawing the energy and then returning it to the ground. The problem being that the ground water contains too many minerals that are not filtered out and that wears on the systems quickly. On the closed loop system I would see maintenance in 10-12 years with pumps, seals and such. I decided that I did not want to see any of that in my 70's and 80's. Had I been 15-20 years younger I think my decision would have been different. I quite imagine that 5 years have made for a great deal of improvement to the systems so my info may be irrelevant today.

I do wish that I had put in an in-floor hot water system in the shop to remove any ignition source for stored solvents. I have to be careful in the winter with the open flame heater when spraying lacquer. It also gets rid of the cold floor quickly if you keep the heat turned down during the week. Downside is it takes a bit longer to warm the area but I can wear a sweater for a while but my feet wouldn't get cold quickly.

Ray

Re: Slightly OT Geothermal Heating/Cooling

#5

Re: Slightly OT  Geothermal Heating/Cooling

Barry Irby

The thing to compare is the efficiency of Air to Air heat pumps in your area. (Where is Mount Level and do A to A heat pumps work well there?)

There are a number of ways to 'couple' a geo HP to the earth. I believe that most areas have outlawed the open systems because they don't want you handling the water and returning it to the aquifers.

You can use a "slinky loop" where you dig a deep trench and install a coil of pipe. A straight loop requires many feet of ditch with the pipe laid out in straight lines. These need to be four or five feet deep or deeper. Vertical loops use wells with pipes inserted into them. Fluid circulates through the pipe and takes heat from (or too) the water in the well, but does not take the water out of the well. Huge variables here. Does your soil make it easy to dig deep trenches or are you in rock? What do wells cost in your area?

This is the expensive part of the systems. Adds thousands or tens of thousands of dollars to the install cost.

The current wisdom seems to be that if air to air heat pumps work reasonably well in your area, you can come out ahead by installing a super efficient model and super insulating the building.

I recently discussed a 10,000SF house with the builder. They are spending $80,000 on Geo HP's. Strikes me as outrageous. Seems to me you could spend $40K on the insulation and A to A equipment and use the interest on the other $40K to pay the utility bills forever.

Re: Slightly OT Geothermal Heating/Cooling

#7

Re: Slightly OT  Geothermal Heating/Cooling

Grant in Iowa

Tommy,

We built a new home 3 years ago and decided to skip it. Here's why:

1. Initial cost of system would (in our case) be financed for many years. Think of any added costs in building a new home as going on the end of the mortgage. So we added that interest cost to the balance sheet when deciding. Your mileage may vary, but in our case this was a big factor, perhaps the deciding factor. Also consider that to qualify for rebates, you may have to have a submeter, or even a separate electrical service installed. Some I have talked to have had to have the service upgraded to handle the turn on surge of the system, which is not likely free from the utility.

2. Much of the advertising information compares a geothermal system to an outdated existing furnace in an older home. The Geothermal loos like a no brainer in that case. Much of the information I have seen tends to avoid comparing one to a high efficiency gas furnace and water heater in a well insulated home.

In the end, we decided to superinsulate our home in Iowa, taking care to caulk common loss areas ourselves. We insulated beneath the basement slab, outside the poured walls, and insulated the rim joist well. 2x6 walls, caulking and vapor barriers, and a heavy dose of blown in insulation in the attic. We did splurge on a wood burning fireplace by Kozy Heat, which fits well with my logs to lumber hobby.

Our home is a one story ranch with a finished basement 1800 square feet on the main floor. Gas heat, tank type 50 gal gas water heater, gas clothes dryer, and a 1400 square foot shop building that I always keep above freezing in winter with natural gas. I do burn wood when I am home, burning around two cords last winter. Our high natural gas bill was two years ago. $180 with four adults in the house during a record cold month. I estimate that our house is costing around $110-120 month to heat in the coldest month with our current habits. About $80 or so in an average winter month. It is hard to justify the up front expense with bills that reasonable, IMHO.

As I have said. Do the math. Your mileage may vary depending on the costs of energy in your area and the size and type of home you hope to build. Either way, I am a firm believer in being involved heavily in the building process and especially insulating yourself.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Slightly OT Geothermal Heating/Cooling

#8

I have had one for 26+ years

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Our house is all electric and had baseboard heat. Room temps varied 5 degrees due to the line voltage thermostats. We had an unheated addition that we wanted to use that was going to add 50% to our electric bill which at the time was $100/month balanced billing. We couldn't get gas and oil wasn't an option. We installed a geothermal heat pump system that was an open system (two wells). Our total installation cost was just under $9,000 including duct work. The system worked flawlessly from day one. After 22 years I replaced one submersible pump, one solenoid valve and one contactor.

Our house stayed at 68 degrees day and night and our electric bill remained at $100 per month despite adding 1/3 onto the heated area of the house. I figure the initial pay off was less than 10 years and after that it was all to the good. It often gets below zero here in the winter and we get a full 4 months of below freezing temps.

Two years ago we decided we wanted A/C which the original system didn't have. Since our heat pump was 24 years old we decided to replace the heat pump with a dual purpose unit. We turned our A/C on July 5th and ran it that summer until the end of September, keeping the house at 72 degrees. We used the same KW's running the A/C that we had used the previous summer running fans and a dehumidifier and were much more comfortable. After the past winter we are already running ahead of our payback on the balanced billing so we won't hesitate to turn on the cooling when the time comes. Our new unit has a variable speed fan, two stage compressor and is capable of aiding in making domestic hot water. It cost $8,000 installed and running. If we had purchased our system this year it would have qualified for a 15-30% energy tax credit.

With regard to hard water wearing our parts, that is mostly myth propagated by conventional heating system installers. The inside of my 24 year old unit looked like new when it was uninstalled. It had never been internally cleaned. The water valve that failed did so because of silt contamination not hard water. The water pump solid state starter died possibly due to a nearby lightning strike.

Initial installation cost is about 30-40% more than a conventional heat system. However, your savings start from day one. My heat pump is working at a 4:1 advantage most of the time which is where they are most efficient.

My electric bill now is about $110 per month including heat, electric hot water, stove and an outdoor light. My house is about 2,000 square feet of heated area.

Lee

Re: Slightly OT Geothermal Heating/Cooling

#9

Re: I have had one for 26+ years

Howard Norman

>With regard to hard water wearing our parts, that is mostly myth propagated by conventional heating system installers.<

That depends on location and how hard the water is. Here it would be a disaster but I have lived at places where it would not be a problem at all.

Re: Slightly OT Geothermal Heating/Cooling

#10

Re: Slightly OT  Geothermal Heating/Cooling

Buddy Forshee

We installed a geothermal system when we built 12 years ago. It costs around $4000 more than a conventional system at that time. It has the ability to assist with the domestic hot water. We moved in November. The water heater had not been wired for electricity when we began cleaning for the move. We had enough hot water to clean the entire house just from the geothermal system. We now have more than twice the house that we had in our previous home. The utilities are about the same as our previous home. We did use 6" walls and a good insulation package. In our situation, it has already paid for itself and then some.