Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Hand tools vs router

Posts

Hand tools vs router

#1

Hand tools vs router

eliot d

I purchased a fancy router lift set-up at a woodworkers show, and now I want to fit the roughly 9x12 inch rectangular plate with curved corners into a flat MDF board. I figured , surely, I would use things like a template, plunge router, and one of those router ring kits to get a good fit. But I ran into a superb furniture maker at the Smithsonian Craft Show in Washington, DC the other day who told me that if I really wanted a near perfect fit, I should knife around the plate and go from there with hand tools. I should have asked him just how to do it, but I didn't. It's hard for me to believe that doing it by hand could POSSIBLY be better than using a router. But I am intrigued. Can any of you hand tool fanatics set me straight? Just what do you do here, if you want to use hand tools?

Re: Hand tools vs router

#2

follow up on that silly suggestion

Bill Tindall

I was in a seminar with Alan breed, master carver. He was demonstrating carving the edge of a recessed table top. Toward the end someone asked him how HE wasted out the flat center part of the recessed table top. "I take it to a shop with a CNC router, was his reply. The gasp from the purists in the room was audible. Alan explained that he got no satisfaction wasting out centers; he liked the carving.

Re: Hand tools vs router

#3

Re: Hand tools vs router

Dave Thompson

I'm pretty sure he wasn't talking about making your MDF router table top as most neanderthal purists just don't do MDF, let alone the fact that following a large template like your router table insert is the domain of a router.

I thought the hand tool vs power tool polarization died down a decade ago.... Seems silly to divide it such when the various tools can complement each other so well regardless of whether they have a cord or not.

While routers are noisy, very messy and hard on the lungs and nose, compared to a plow plane, rabbet planes, moulding planes, router planes, dado plane, etc. routers are much more forgiving of grain changes, less demanding on sharpening, and general fidgeting. However, if you need to tweek a cut to make it perfect, it's often easier and often more precise to take minute shaving with the appropriate hand tool, rather than adjust your router/jig etc. YMMV depending on application.

I'm a heavy user of hand tools, though would never give up my arsenal of routers and router bits.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Hand tools vs router

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Hand tools vs router

Moses Yoder

I think MDF would be kind of crumbly to chisel to a line, but it might work with a chisel that is really sharp. If I was doing it I would run a test piece first, or cut the recess for the router plate into the table top before I do anything else. The best way to do it would be to waste out the center portion with a router then trim the edges with a chisel. You would need a gouge to do the 4 corners if your router plate has rounded corners. Another thing I would do is glue a piece of laminate on the MDF for the top.

Re: Hand tools vs router

#5

Very Simple

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

to make a rail & style template that will precisely match your plate.

As stated, you should first laminate the MDF top (BOTH sides to prevent warping).

2 ways to proceed:

Waste out the main hole to the specs that came with your lifter leaving enough to make the step. Clamp on your template whose inside dimensions match the outside dimension of your plate, and route the final opening to the depth of your plate's thickness with a bearing-guided bit. This leaves a clean precise ledge for your plate to rest on. If you cut a bit large, it's a simple matter to shim the opening to lock the top plate tightly.

Second method is to make your template for the smaller spec opening for the main hole, then use a bearing-guided rabbeting bit to rout the step using the first cut as the guide. This will require a bit of work at the corners to match the plate.

Note, if your plate "floats" in the top, but has adjustment set-screws on the corners to keep it flush with the top surface, you will need to inset a small steel disc in each corner for those screws to ride on. Otherwise, they'll simply dig into the MDF or other material.

Last note, when routing the final step, I suggest you do so with several cuts so that you can "sneak up" on the final depth cut to meet specs. Corner adjusters will compensate, but it's always best to leave as much meat under the plate as possible. Speaking of meat, consider making your top from a double layer of MDF. Does great for vibration.

Re: Hand tools vs router

#6

Re: Hand tools vs router

Tony - Memphis

I'm doing that now on the arm supports for a set of chairs I am building. Much more precise and quicker than trying to build a jig, etc. It is a good technique to get good joints. That said,I wouldn't do it for a router table! What I usually do is mark my joint lines while I still have a good reference surface, then I remove the bulk of the waste with the router or ts (ts in this case). I then chase my line around with a chisel. Ideally, the surface would be perpendicular to the tenon, but I'm not that good, so I force it to be slightly undercut. Makes adjusting easier too. I'll employ the same technique for making the tenons on the top of the arm supports as well. I have a "special chisel) for this. Its an old 750 that someone had used and there was not but a couple of inches left. But I like the short length for this job. Makes it easier. Anyway, it is a great technique to have in your arsenal, but like I said, I would use a router for this job.

Tony

Re: Hand tools vs router

#7

Re: Very Simple

Barry Irby

I Agree with Mark on this. I made mine out of two sink cutouts given to me by a cabinet shop. Glued them together back to back so there is plastic laminate on both sides of a particle board core.

I routed out the recess for the plate as Mark suggested Except that I cut the opening out completely/ all the way through. Then I installed some hardwood rails around the inside of the opening to form a ledge for the plate to rest on and left that low to allow for leveling screws. I put the hardwood there to give the screws something to bite into better than particle board. Mine fits snugly but I have had one that was slightly loose. Didn't seem to matter. Within seconds a little crud would fall into the cracks and lock it up nicely.

Personally, I am confident I could do this job quickly and accurately with a router. I'm equally sure it would take longer and be much more difficult FOR ME with hand tools.

Re: Hand tools vs router

#8

Re: Hand tools vs router

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Sure you can do it with a router plane, a gouge to match the radius of your insert's corners and some careful chiseling. That and a substantial amount of time spent on the project.

But why would you? This is one area where a tailed apprentice can do the job faster and at the very least just as good.

Besides, only the sides of the insert have to fit snugly. The corners just have to be close. It's the sides that hold the insert so it can't move. Anyway, that's how mine is.

Make sure you have something that will help prevent sag in that MDF top, because it likely will sag over time. Any stiffener will help.

As a disclaimer, every one of my projects is at least half hand tool work.

Re: Hand tools vs router

#9

how I did it using hand tools

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Ok I did the lions share of the work with power tools including a router and then the final tight fit was done with hand tools. I marked the MDF with a marking knif but then clamped boards to it and cut the rabbit with a plunge router. since the edges of the opening of the hole really don't matter I used a jig saw to cut the actual opening. The corners of the rabbit are defined by the radius of the 3/4" bit and the corners on my insert are just slightly larger in raduis at 7/8" so there is a small gap. For the edges I fine tuned the fit using a side rabbit plane, a set of Stanley 98 & 99. this gave me a fit with absolutely no movement.

Robin

Re: Hand tools vs router

#10

furthermore, what I did was

Bruce, a MN Galoot

just rout to the corners of the outline using a 1/2" bit. That naturally leaves a round corner. Then I rounded the corner of the insert to match. My insert is 1/4" phenolic, easily machined and filed.