Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

Posts

GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#1

Lee Grindinger

GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

Lee Grindinger

This is a one hour radio show. While the economic meltdown is a product of many causes this explains a large chunk of it in easily understood terms. For those interested in what happened and why, as well as the current efforts to regulate institutions so it doesn't happen again this may be an hour well spent.

Click on "Stream Episode" for the program.

http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/405/inside-job

Lee

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#2

Better yet...

John in NM

An oldie but a goodie, the world economy explained in terms of cows....

Figured anyone following that link needs a bit of humor.... :D

SOCIALISM:

You have 2 cows, and you give one to your neighbour.

COMMUNISM:

You have 2 cows. The State takes both and gives you some milk.

FASCISM:

You have 2 cows. The State takes both and sells you some milk.

NAZISM:

You have 2 cows. The State takes both and shoots you.

BUREAUCRATISM:

You have 2 cows. The State takes both, shoots one, milks the other, then

throws the milk away...

TRADITIONAL CAPITALISM:

You have two cows. You sell one and buy a bull. Your herd multiplies,

and the economy grows. You sell them and retire on the income.

AN AMERICAN CORPORATION:

You have two cows. You sell one, and force the other to produce the milk

of four cows. Later, you hire a consultant to analyse why the cow has

dropped dead.

A FRENCH CORPORATION:

You have two cows. You go on strike, organize a riot, and block the

roads, because you want three cows.

A JAPANESE CORPORATION:

You have two cows. You redesign them so they are one-tenth the size of

an ordinary cow and produce twenty times the milk. You then create a

clever cow cartoon image called 'cowkimon' and market it world-wide.

A GERMAN CORPORATION:

You have two cows. You re-engineer them so they live for 100 years, eat

once a month, and milk themselves.

AN ITALIAN CORPORATION:

You have two cows, but you don't know where they are. You decide to have

lunch.

A RUSSIAN CORPORATION:

You have two cows. You count them and learn you have five cows. You

count them again and learn you have 42 cows. You count them again and

learn you have 2 cows. You stop counting cows and open another bottle of

vodka.

A SWISS CORPORATION:

You have 5000 cows. None of them belong to you. You charge the owners

for storing them.

A CHINESE CORPORATION:

You have two cows. You have 300 people milking them. You claim that you

have full employment, and high bovine productivity, and arrest the

newsman who reported the real situation.

AN INDIAN CORPORATION:

You have two cows. You worship them.

A BRITISH CORPORATION:

You have two cows. Both are mad.

IRAQI CORPORATION:

Everyone thinks you have lots of cows. You tell them that you have none.

No one believes you, so they bomb the hell out of you and invade your

country. You still have no cows, but at least now you are part of a

Democracy....

WELSH CORPORATION:

You have two cows. The one on the left looks very attractive.

AUSTRALIAN CORPORATION:

You have two cows. Business seems pretty good. You close the office and

go for a few beers to celebrate.

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#3

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

Bill Tindall

No doubt the people that received loans they had no hope of repaying will be held blameless. Or the loan originators that made these loans to people that they knew had no hope of repaying them. Sachs just repackaged them.

Paulson picked loans to bet against ever being repaid. He was right on 99% of them. The "story" to be told is why Paulson was able to clearly see that some home loans were unsound while others were unable to do so.

Sachs will be found guilty (very unlikely according to Wall Street Journal) only if they deceived two large banks that bought some of the repackaged loans.

The fact that somebody profited from others stupidity/greed bothers me not. Most money is made by people knowing what someone else doesn't.

An AZ subdivision was surveyed recently on the news. The frugal family that bought a house and paid off their original loan was financially sound. The others , one of whom refinanced something like 10 times to drain equity from their house, defaulted. It looks to me like greed began with some homeowners/borrowers.

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#4

Lee Grindinger

It's clear

Lee Grindinger

It's clear you did not listen to the show or understand the game that was afoot.

I'm sure Sachs will feel the money it's spent on it's media blitz has been worth it. After all, they were only looking out for their investors best interests..., right? Of course.......

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#5

Agree with Doug

JohnT

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#6

Had a relative in the investment banking business

Joe Pack

I have a relative who earned his MBA from University of Chicago, then worked for a MAJOR investment bank on the east coast. He was extremely good at what he did, moving up the ranks quickly. He was also quite blunt and not easily intimidated (he once challenged Lou Holtz to a game of pool at Notre Dame and also walked into the Notre Dame president's office to demand that the sidewalks in front of his dorm be shoveled just like the president's sidewalks).

With this kind of moxy, it didn't take him long to begin asking in corporate sales strategy meetings why the people who were briefing them on the investments they were being told to push did not own those investments themselves, but were recommending them to customers. The short answer was that the investments were being recommended because they offered the greatest profit potential for the investment company and to the sales staff whether or not they were best for the client. And he soon came to believe that this attitude was the rule in the brokerage/investment bank world.

He did not care for that answer and told them so, challenging them to either buy what they were recommending or change their recommendation. He refused to recommend anything he would not buy himself, which did not make him very popular, but did make him very successful in the eyes of his clients.

He now runs his own very successful value investment company, with many of the same clients he had when he was with the "name" firm. He not only believes in his recommendations, he literally "puts his money where his mouth is;" he is fully invested in the same portfolio that he invests clients' money in, which is the way it should be.

I doubt very seriously if the creators of so-called "synthetic" investments put any of their money into them. Or that they told investors that they (the company) were actually betting that the investor would LOSE money! Sort of like dealing a hand of poker, but being able to pick the cards you want to give everybody.

But we wouldn't want to regulate anything like this. Let the customer beware. Paraphrasing one of the execs in the hearings today, it is the customer's responsibility to due their research, not ours.

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#7

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

charlie belden

A GS executive said that investing in the stock market - and other Wall Street "instruments" and "products" is a gamble - like in Las Vegas. The representative from Nevada pointed out that the gentleman was insulting casino owners and noted that in a casino a) you know the odds and the casino doesn't get to change them whenever they feel like it - and not tell you the rules have changed until after they have your money, nor do they rig the wheel or dice because there are folks who keep an eye on them and check to make sure things aren't rigged.

When asked if putting together billion dollar "financial instruments" - getting paid to do that - then selling them under false pretenses - AND THEN - placing a bet by taking out insurance that you'll profit from when the "instrument" goes belly up - isn't a conflict of interest - the response was "If someone wants to buy and we can sell it to them - we will." Hell, at least the drug cartels sell drugs - not oregano or powdered milk or sugar.

I'm for upside down, naked crucifixion of a dozen of these "gentlement - during the half time show at the Super Bowl would go a LONG ways towards cleaning up Wall Street.

(I swore I wasn't going to get into this thread . . .)

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: Had a relative in the investment banking busin

Moses Yoder

Well if it is up to the customer to do the research then why hire a broker? This is just an excuse for greed. Another example of the meltdown of American ethics. A person with ethics is responsible for doing the best they can for their customer, not taking advantage of them. This is also simply good business sense, because it will lead to repeat customers and therefore a profitable business for everyone.

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#9

Steven Antonucci

Wall St does equal a casino in one sense...

steven antonucci

in that most people don't belong in either!

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#10

Giant Pool of Money

JohnT

Thanks for the link -

This American Life actually did an even better show, which (I think) won a Pulitzer, which really explained what the meltdown was about in terms anyone could understand. Listening to this, I found myself just shaking my head in disbelief several times....

http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/355/the-giant-pool-of-money

Sorry - can't figure out how to make the URL into a link, but cut and paste - its worth the effort (and another hour of listening).

-John-

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#11

Re: It's clear

Mark Nowicki

I listened to the show and, in return, I would like to offer my favorite explanation of the sub-par crisis.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UC31Oudc5Bg

As far as the game that was played, IMO, it was the same that has been played in the past and will be in the future, regardless of what the govt tries.

Most people are greedy and selfish, and the smarter ones figure out the way to use the greed and selfishness of the dumber ones to their advantage. Hopefully that will never change. I would hate to live in a society where the the educated, entrepreneurial, and ambitious are blended with the "hope I make it to get my full defined benefit pension" crowd.

Thank you for an interesting link.

Mark

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#12

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

Tom Rex in TX

Whos has hurt us more finacially GoldmanSachs or Congress?

Shoudn't the punishment for Congress be more than double what GS gets?

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#13

Ellis Walentine

Mark, you need a profile to post a link

Ellis Walentine

Hi Mark,

You recall that this post was not displayed immediately when you posted it. That's because you haven't registered a profile. Only registered users are permitted to post links without moderation. Creating a profile takes only a minute and is completely secure. Just click the "My Profile" link in the gray navbar at the top of the message list.

When you create your profile, you must include a *valid* e-mail address. This assures that when you request e-mail notification of message replies, that the notification doesn't bounce. (Guess who gets those bounce notices and must follow up with you?) The profile is off-limits to spam bots and/or prying eyes, so you don't need to worry about your privacy. And, when you post a message, you retain the option to leave the "Your E-Mail Address:" box blank, so your address cannot be picked up by any web crawlers. Our new system is much better protected from these bots anyhow, but not totally immune.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#14

Lee Grindinger

Thanks

Lee Grindinger

I'll listen tomorrow.

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#15

Lee Grindinger

Ethics be damned

Lee Grindinger

Profit trumps ethics..., it's how the game is played these days. These pension seeking sods living reasonably ethical lives showing up for work every day and paying their bills are merely fruit to be picked.

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#16

Re: Had a relative in the investment banking busin

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

I knew a man who was an executive with one of the Wall St. firms and his advice to me was "if you can't afford to lose the money, don't play the market", I never could afford it.

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#17

Re: Ethics be damned

Stuart Johnson

Profit trumps ethics..., it's how the game is played these days.

These days has nothing to do with how the game is played. About 25 years ago I blew a whistle that put a stop to a very profitable (for the broker, client and top management) and in my opinion violation of stock trading practices. When everything was unwound the firm (stockholders) took about a $40,000,000 loss. The upshot to the whole mess is I lost my job but did receive a nice settlement in exchange for not talking to the WSJ. I could go on and the trading is written up in a couple books but my point is nothing is going on now that hasn't been going on probably since trading began. Profit has always trumped ethics when the whole picture is taken.

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#18

Lee Grindinger

It seems the stakes are bigger

Lee Grindinger

GoldmanSachs cries about losing a bit over a billion dollars in the mortgage meltdown but omits that they made over 3 billion in shorting the same CDOs they lost this money on.

Since GoldmanSachs is but one player in this game it seems the stakes are larger than they were 25 years ago and the consequences are larger too.

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#19

Sorry..."do," not "due"  Typing before thinking

Joe Pack

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#20

Lee Grindinger

I disagree and here's why

Lee Grindinger

But we wouldn't want to regulate anything like this. Let the customer beware. Paraphrasing one of the execs in the hearings today, it is the customer's responsibility to due their research, not ours.

The consumer has no say or input or chance to be involved with these deals. Large companies create these funds, look for risky assets to put into them, then bet they will fail. The consumer is out of the loop.

It would be akin to me selling canned tomatoes to restaurants that I know contained botulism with a money back guarantee. Sure, I'd lose money on the tomatoes but I'd make a killing on the medical stocks I'd bought knowing all the patrons would end up in the hospital with botulism.

It's easy to tell where a company stands on the funds it's selling to buyers, just see if they have more invested in the fund's failure or success, in the case of Sach and many others they had shorts (bets the funds would fail) to the tune of 3 or more to 1.

I feel the banking industry does need over site and transparency because the real people affected are often unable to be informed consumers because their pensions and investments are managed out of their sight.

Lee

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#21

Re: Ethics be damned

Larry in NW Ohio

Good for you Stuart, I`m happy to know that there are honest people out there yet, it`s just to hard to find them. Larry

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#22

I'm too good at sarcasm, Lee.

Joe Pack

I completely agree with you, Lee. I was being sarcastic, maybe not blatantly enough.

To fail to regulate Wall Street is akin to allowing the foxes to police themselves while dealing with the chickens. I do not trust corporations to do anything more that act in their own best interest. They call that "profit." I call it taking advantage of clients who hire "experts" to act in their interest, but who unethically line their own pockets.

I know there are honest brokers and investment bankers out there, but, unfortunately, the bad ones do not come with a bright red "CROOK" stamped on their foreheads.

Strict regulation should only be feared by those companies and individuals who are acting unethically.

One, and I think the best, cure for this kind of behavior is not fines on the company that are passed on to customers anyhow, but actual jail time for offenders. Paying a fine is inconvenient, but a cost of doing business. Spending a couple of years with Big Buford as your roommate is a deterrent.

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#23

Re: I disagree and here's why

FredD

"I feel the banking industry does need over site and transparency because the real people affected are often unable to be informed consumers because their pensions and investments are managed out of their sight."

That above quote is the exact reason the financial markets which include Banks need oversight and regulation with teeth.

This already exists with the authority invested in the SEC but it has been gutted like most of the safe guards the American public has depended on for years.

How many of you would feel safe eating meat without Federal inspection and just leave it up to the packer to provid disease free product from healthy animals?

It remains with the consumer and the voter how long we are willing to be treated like second class citizens .

FredD

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#24

Exactly, bout time someone put their finger on it.

Marv

The biggest crooks are elected officials in responsible positions who are not doing the job they are being paid huge salaries, plus life-time benefits.

It all started in the early 90,s when regulations were lifted that allowed banks to ease up on their loan qualifications, hence, "Stated Income Loans. These are loans that were made to people who didn't even have to have a job. Loan officers where paid commissions, so of course they were going to let anything go through. These loans at the other end of the trail are referred to as "Subprime loans". These loans were included in the Synthetic CDO,s "Collateralized Debt Obligations" that companies like Goldman Sachs used for their gambling purposes.

If the Chris Dodds and Barney Franks didn't push to deregulate the banks, non of this economic desaster would have occurred. Lets guess why they did it and who paid them off? Could it have been the banking lobbists?

What we need to do is to get behind the Fair Tax movement that is going on right now. Congress is trying to ignore it. Instead they are about to consider a VAT tax. If this happens, look out folks, we will experience economic downturns like we've never seen. I'm coming to the conclusion that our government is purposely doing everything they can to destroy our country. "Change We Can Believe In"....yeah, right! Looks what has happend in only the past ten years and consider what they will do during the next ten years.

We are paying China billions of dollars for their cheap products, then China loans that money back to us at huge interest rates. Our unions have our cost of manufacturing forced up so high we can't compete in the world market place. Our attention seems to be focused on sports and other frivelous time wasting crap, we don't focus on what's going on around us that is eating our lunches. The news media is reporting on Tiger Woods and Jesse James and the Octamom and a million other unimportant useless blab and not paying full attention on our unsecure borders, and our 70,000 page IRS tax code and Obama flying all over the country wasting money on kissing babies and shaking hands instead of staying in Washinton and fixing some of the things he's screwing up.

I have more, but my fingers are getting tired.

Marv

PS..OPPS...sorry, forgot we're are not supposed to discuss politics.

Re: GoldmanSachs/CDO and Economic Strife explained

#25

Lee Grindinger

One more comment, them this thread can die

Lee Grindinger

Oversite and how it's done is problematic in this business, but at the heart of it is transparency. It's impossible for a consumer to make an informed decision without adequate information. If regulations are to be changed they must make information available to the consumer.

This is from Bloomberg News,

"Blankfein (GoldmanSachs CEO) told Levin�s panel (Senate subcommittee on investigations) that market-makers have no obligation to tell clients about their own position in a security. Blankfein said the nature of the principal business often puts the firm on the opposite side of customers."

I'm happy to let this thread die now.