Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

Posts

OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#1

OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

Barry Irby

Has everyone paid attention to the lawn mower class action settlement? (May not be the correct phrase, but you get the idea.)

Apparently someone has discovered that many of the lawn mower manufacturers misrepresented the horse power of their engines and they are putting forth a settlement. You can get "up to" $35 for a walk behind and $70 for a riding mower. You can check out the details at WWW.lawnmowerclass.com. Filing for the claim is simple. I have had my mower for about fifteen years and it qualified.

It will be interesting to see if they send me anything and how long it takes. Oddly, I was never disappointed in the power. Pretty much everything else, but not the power.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#2

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

Stuart Johnson

I received a post card advising me about the class action. It was one of those that on first glance you would throw away. I'll fill out the information and send it off. You can get all the information from the web site you posted.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#3

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

I tried the link and got an interesting result - Firefox said it was untrustworthy and refused to go there. I attempted to add and exception and was told the "whatever" was false. Again I was refused.

(No passport and no Visa. I guess Homeland Security and the TSA, FBI, Old Uncle Tom Cobbley and all will be looking for me.)

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#4

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

Stuart Hough

The older lawnmowers ratings had nothing to do with actual horsepower. They were rated using an old (archaic) leftover from the British motoring "Golden Age", where small engines were assigned an HP rating based on bore, stroke and cylinder swept area. Even now, the small engines are not rated by actual HP, but by their torque rating, which may actually give you a better idea as to how strong they are, given their ability to swing the blade though that most heinous of substance...lawn turf!

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#5

SCAM

Pat Evans

Another gross abuse of the legal system enabling lawyers to get filthy rich while victims (none of whom suffered any damages in this case) get a pittance. All this will do is drive up the price of lawn mowers.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#6

use google it will work

del schisler

bring up google and put this link in and it will take you their

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&source=hp&ie=ISO-8859-1&q=WWW.lawnmowerclass.com

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#7

Re: SCAM

John Lucas

My thoughts exactly. And then to get around any further lawsuits they will add some other useless gadget to the mower that will break or fall off and require more expense and agravation to the owner.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#8

Reality Check

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Nothing's getting "bolted on" to the mowers. The companies were sued for misrepresenting the horsepower of their engines, thereby appearing to justify the inflated prices they charged to consumers.

So when do we see Sears and the other electric power tool maker/marketers sued for the same BS they've been using to gouge consumers for the last 15 years? Oh wait, they call it "peak" horsepower, so that makes it all okey-dokey, right?

"Garsh, Marge, I got this here 8.7 Horsepower vacuum on Secret Sale at Sears for only $699.95! Argh! Argh! Argh! The best part is, this sucker'll run on ordinary house current. Ain't technology wonderful?"

BTW How are all those 5hp air compressors that run on 115v doing guys? Anyone interested in some South Florida real estate? How 'bout a nice bridge . .

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#9

Re: SCAM

Carol Reed

And they have your contact information! So what do they do with that? That is fresh updated accurate information available for sale to "real" scam artists, and we gave it to them willingly. Sad how easily we are swayed for few bucks.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#10

Re: Reality Check

John Lucas

Mark 30 years ago my wife worked for Sears. I bought a lot of my power tools back then ( I still have the belt sander and circular saw). Horsepower was grossly overstated back then just as it is today. A good example. I had a 3hp Sears router and eventually replaced it with a 1 1 /2 horse Porter Cable. The Porter Cable would run circles around the Craftstman. My Makita 3hp router barely beats out the Porter Cable in power.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#11

Re: Check, Please

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Thanks, John, you've made my case.

Now all we need is some "scam-artist" lawyer to start the class action with no fees or costs up front, put in a thousand hours of work, pay for experts and engineers to document the rip-offs, and maybe, just maybe, those "honest, hard-working" power tool makers will change their fine-print fraudulent marketing scams and stop misleading the millions of customers who, unlike the people on this board who know better, spend more than they should based on phony ads and gotcha labels with testimonials and "approvals" by fictitious entities masquerading as impartial testing organizations.

Rant Off :\

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#12

Re: Reality Check

FredD

Geez Mark,

there you go again, deflating some of the Citizens favorite delusions with those pesky facts.

FredD

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#13

Re: Check, Please

Alexandre Grigoriev

Thanks for sober words.

It always amuses me when people think they have simple answers.

"Lawyers are scum!"

Unless you need to navigate the laws and/or argue your case in the court. Or just write a bullet-proof contract.

"But the laws don't have to be that complicated!"

Well, life is not simple. There are too many cases. If you know why the law was written, and what happened before it was written, most of the time it makes complete sense.

"This is screwing the customers! They're lying!"

Sue them. You'll have to spend money you can't afford. This is what class action suits are for.

"These were doing and the government did nothing!"

Because there was no law to prevent that.

"The congress is writing too many laws"

Because you people keep asking for that.

"The government keeps issuing regulations for contractors and businesses! And requiring licences! It's ridiculous"

OK

"The contractor/business screwed me up. Why can't the government keep those jerks away!"

Because this type of contractor didn't need a licence and was not regulated. Sue him. Spend the money you don't have.

....Et cetera.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#14

Re: Reality Check

Brian in SLO

Did the mower you bought cut your grass like you wanted? If so, then stop your whining! What more do you want?

If not, take it back and get one you like. Simple.

Our society has become a bunch of litigious, whiny, little sissies that wanna whine and cry everytime they don't get their way. It used to be that calused hands were a sign of hard work, now it's a medical condition. Go figure!

Stepping down from soapbox....

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#15

Have you read the suit before making a judgement?

DCinSTL

Everyone is entitled to an opinion, but a portion of the suit reads as follows, "�falsely advertising and selling lawn mowers containing identical engines that produce the same horsepower as different products with different horsepower labels or ratings at different prices�higher prices for falsely represented higher horsepower�while concealing, suppressing and failing to disclose material information, including the facts that the engines are identical, and the true, significantly lower horsepower of the lawn mowers."

A class action suit of this type is not to make anyone rich; it is to send a message to the manufacturers. After all, how else can we convince a manufacturer that this is unacceptable?

Regarding air compressors. There was a time that their size was referred to by their horsepower, i.e., if a compressor produced 4 SCFM, it was 1 HP compressor, 8 SCFM was a 2 HP compressor, etc. Then, 30 odd years ago the two major catalog companies began bastardizing their ratings. At that same time they also began whoring the HP ratings. Now look at what we have -- you can't trust what you're told.

In this case, I think it's a valid suit.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#16

Re: Have you read the suit before making a judgeme

Dan Donaldson

Not sure, but I don't think the issue was the validity of the suit, but rather that the members of the class get almost nothing and the lawyers get everything.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#17

Who Gets

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Let's be clear on this as well. In a typical class action case the "class" will receive over 90% of what the defendant(s) will pay. That may well translate to relatively small payments to individual class members (provided they file their claim), but that is the very basis of the concept of the "class" action. The 3 or 4 "named" Plaintiffs, for all that they must go through in terms of actual time dedicated to the case, usually receive the same share of the proceeds as others who are "similarly situated" but do nothing to support the case.

A pat of butter does well on a slice of bread, but spread it on the whole loaf and it gets pretty thin.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#18

Re: Who Gets

Larry in NW Ohio

It really boils down to the only ones that get any real money are the lawyers. In class action suits, I think, they get around 33% and the rest get divided up. The more people that file the less each gets. In such cases the lawyers should only get around 10-15%. IMHO Larry

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#19

Re: Fees

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You are mistaken in your percentages, Larry. Nothing like 1/3 or any other set formula. Last case I looked at, the main counsel received 2 [t-w-o] % of the recovery. In such cases, an application is made to the Court where the judge does a detailed cost/benefit analysis and makes an award that can, in turn, be reviewed by the appeals courts independently from any appeal of the case in general. Such applications involve detail examinations of time records and disbursements. Litigation costs (not fees) can literally run in the millions of dollars for experts and scientific tests, all of which the law firm must lay out from its own "pocket" hoping to be repaid at the end. In other situations, the defendant(s), in addition to what they pay to the class members, agree to pay x-amount to the class attorneys as part of the settlement. When you hear about a firm being awarded $2 million or more from a class settlement, what you don't see and understand is that a great deal of that sum has been or will be paid by the firm to others who have assisted in the case.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#20

Re: Fees

Larry in NW Ohio

Mark My apologies. I did know that the attorneys did pay for the experts in advance, but the rest was new to me. I guess that is how bad information gets around, by me. I still think they get paid to much at times. Larry

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#21

Re: Fees

Howard Norman

I will submit that you are much more knowledgeable than I in what the attorneys receive in class action law suits. However, the returns must still be very lucrative or they would not be filing so many of them.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#22

Objection,Your Honor!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

S'ok, Larry, you're not alone in your misunderstanding.

Such fees and costs, properly known as "common fund" fees, are often hotly contested. Class members are given notice of the fees applications, and everyone has the opportunity to object. However, objections must be specific and point to a line-by-line dispute. If you find yourself as a member of a class, like if you bought a lawnmower in the present situation, you can object to both the settlement and the fees application, but just saying "too much for fees" in general will get you nowhere. Most class members do not wish to take the time to make objections and then travel to the Court and appear before the judge in support of their position.

I know several attorneys who have been approached to do class action cases, but who have declined because of the massive amount of work and the tenuous prospect for getting paid enough to make it all worthwhile. Such cases are not the "gold mines" many people think they are. Counsel can often make more money representing private clients in other matters.

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#23

Time To Get Back To Woodworking

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Discussions like this can go on forever, and we really don't need to be taking up Ellis' bandwidth pounding the table over differing views of the American Justice System.

Now if I could just get some shop time . . .

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#24

Re: Who Gets

Dan Donaldson

I wasn't making any judgment on the suits, and if you take normal billing rates, the lawyers are probably just getting their normal fees. You are right about it being spread thin, but I think what upsets many people is that the actual class members typically get only a token amount while the legal profession gets their full pay.

One way to look at it though, is that if the purpose is to punish those that caused the problem, and not necessarily the "profit", the you could say that the class is just paying the lawyers to get the punishment administered without having to take the money out of your pocket..

Re: OT Lawn Mower Class Action Suit

#25

Re: Objection,Your Honor!

Chris Friesen

Mark, while it may be true in general that class actions aren't "gold mines", there are exceptions.

There's a firm (with a somewhat sketchy reputation) in a city nearby that seems to specialize in class actions. They're currently litigating a huge number of them, as can be seen at their website:

http://www.merchantlaw.com/classactions/