Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

Posts

OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#1

OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

Barry Irby

A friend mentioned today that the volcano in Iceland was spewing 75,000 tons of ask a second. That's an unimaginable and incomprehensible number to me.

My question is where does the dust/ash come from? Is there a giant quantity of dust that is already there and the volcano is just blowing it into the air or is it being created as it is blown out?

And a woodworking question. How much sand paper could we make out of the dust?

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#2

Re: NOT a Vulcanologist, but . . *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Volcanic "ash" is actually rock dust formed from erupted magma. Most Plinian eruptions such as Mt. St. Helens, and the current Icelandic event, are powered by a combination of 2,300� magma ("lava" once it reaches the surface) and water, or in this case, ice. Push a million tons of boiling hot molten rock into several million tons of 0� ice (the glacier/ice cap) and the fireworks will start as the ice flashes into steam and explodes the bits of lava into micron-size particles that are then blasted miles into the air. The heavier (larger) bits of ash settle to the ground in the short range; hence the pix you see of Icelandic farms covered in dust. The rest of the ash, propelled up to 9 miles into the atmosphere, floats with the high speed winds, and can actually circle the entire globe before being precipitated out by rain.

Consider in contrast, the eruption of Kilauea on the big island of Hawaii that's been going on continuously since 1983 or so. The Hawaiian volcanoes are shield-forming types that extrude or erupt broad lava flows with very little ash being formed because there is no water source to create the steam explosions that both fracture the lava and propel the ash high into the air.

If you'd like to learn more, follow the link to the USGS site, click on volcanoes, and spend some time browsing.


Geology

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#3

How volcanoes work

Bill Tindall

Way down below is a pool of molten rock. The rock has a lot of water and other volatile stuff dissolved in it, kept in solution by the high pressure from being buried way down below. When this liquid rock has a path to the surface (crack or what ever) the effect is the same as unstoppering a soda bottle after shaking it. The volatile stuff becomes a vapor as the pressure is released and it pushes the molten rock up and out. In the case of the current volcano the molten rock is hitting ice and fracturing into doodle dust which is injected into the atmosphere by the vaporizing water water and other stuff dissolved in the molten rock (magma). Again, think shaking a soda bottle but in this case the liquid is molten rock.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

Jesper, Denmark

Yes Barry, the numbers are staggering. The Eyafjalla volcano is underneath a Glacier, so the heat melts the ice and the water explodes to steam as it hits the hot lava.

The effects of the ash clouds carried to Northern Europe by the Jet stream has stopped all air traffic for nearly a week. I happened to be in Northern Italy last week and fortunately had decided to drive the trip rather than flying. Otherwise, I might still have been there, as all public surface transportation is completely overloaded.

Sulfur smell and haze was noticeable as I came down from the Alps in Suthern Germany.

The Eyafjalla is a rather small volcano, but the fear is that eruptions there have usually preceded the eruptions of the nearby much larger Katla volcano, which also lies under a much larger Glacier. Katla has typically erupted every 50 years or so, the last one in 1918, so she is overdue.

So far, Katla is not showing any activity.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#5

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

John in NM

As others have said, the ash is the result of lava being released at very high pressure and cooling immediately into very fine glass particles. Imagine your paint sprayer has too much thinner and the paint is drying before it hits what you're painting.

The odd thing is that this type of volcano is not typically a big ash producer - being a basaltic-andesitic volcano on a mid-ocean ridge, they are much more often like the Hawaiian volcanoes in behavior than like Mt. St. Helens or Vesuvius. I believe the glacier is causing anomolies in this one, introducing significant water where there would not otherwise be much. But that is just speculation, I was an ore geologist when I did that sort of thing.

Volcanos like Mt. St. Helens typically have a water component in the magma at very deep levels - theoretically resulting from sea water captured as an ocean plate is subducted beneath a continental plate. This water is a crucial part of moving, concentrating, and precipitating many of the ore minerals that are exposed millions of years later thanks to erosion and then mined and turned into the motors and switches that drive our tablesaws (and cars, fridges, computers, etc...).

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#6

what grit ??

del schisler

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#7

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

Larry in NW Ohio

The only Vulcan I know is Spock, last name unknown because you can`t pronounce it anyway. Sorry I thought I better do it before someone else does and the Colonel must be in the hospital yet, has anyone heard from him. I hope he`s doing OK. Larry

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#8

The good old soda bottle of Science

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#9

Impact on the economy

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

This is going to hit Europe's economies pretty hard. It seems like there may be two exceptions:

1. The hotel industry, where all those folks who can't fly home will be staying, and

2. The air filter industry. I suspect a lot of air filters will get changed over the next few weeks, as that fine ash clogs them.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#10

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

Barry Irby

Larry, I wondered about that myself. Ran Google Spell check on Vulcanologist and volcanologist and Vulcanologist wins.

I went to Dictionary.com and apparently either is acceptable. Ain't Engerish Grand? On the other hand, this is a cheap computer, so maybe its wrong.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#11

"grit" effect on jet engines

Alexandre Grigoriev

To see what ash does to a jet engine, search for 03_NASADC8AshDamage.pdf document. It's a report titled "Engine Damage to a NASA DC-8-72 Airplane From a High-Altitude Encounter With a Diffuse Volcanic Ash Cloud".

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#12

A link to it  *LINK*

Dan Donaldson


Damage to a jet engine.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#13

I assumed the damage would be to the bearings

Bruce, a MN Galoot

not to the blading. Uffda!! I'm going to circulate this to our crew. We run a couple turbines.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#14

what I read

Bill Tindall

The melting point of this ash is such that it can deposit on the blades. Also, the ash and or gases are rich in fluorine. This element is especially corrosive to high alloy steels.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#15

I've heard that one too....

John in NM

About the ash melting, but I'm fairly skeptical of it. The ash particles would probably melt around 700 C or a little more, though of course I've no idea how hot it gets in a turbine engine, I'd still be very surprised if it were that hot as that would make the engine tremendously inefficient. I'd expect the real concern to be abrasive wear of the blades.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#16

It may be possible

Bill Tindall

I worked on a coal fired boiler project once. The ash was removed as a molten slag in this boiler (in most power generating boilers the ash does not melt and it is removed as dust). A special grade of coal was required for this boiler, whose ash would melt and form a molten slag at what ever temperature coal burns at. So, at least some kinds of rock melt at coal burning temperature, which could be similar to the flame temperature in a jet engine.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#17

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

From the report...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

"The engines were being operated in the �long range cruise� mode at the time of the encounter.

Figure 10 shows estimated temperatures through the engine. Thrust was about 4300 lb per engine, and

HPC discharge air (used for HPT cooling) temperature was 779 �F (415 �C). The combustor exit and

HPT inlet temperatures were estimated to be well above the 1832 �F (1000 �C) ash melting temperature

(ref. 3). The ash would have been expected to melt and fuse to the HPT vanes and blades both outside and

on the inner cooling passages. The second- and third-stage LPT temperatures were estimated to be below

900 �F (482 �C), and since those blades are uncooled, no damage would be expected."

Note that they report indicates a typical ash-melt temperature of 1000�C, and while not all areas of the turbine exceed that (including the exhaust), two areas do even in normal cruise--the combustor exit and the HPT (high-pressure turbine).

An interesting part of the report is that it notes later on that immediately after an ash encounter begins, the turbines actually run MORE efficiently--due to the abrasive effect of the ash particles cleaning off the lower temperature parts. However, this effect is short-lived, as it then begins to damage the turbine shortly thereafter.

Jason

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#18

True enough...

John in NM

I just haven't seen it backed up with any kind of empirical evidence, and so remain fairly skeptical - which is my standard state of mind when science meets the news media.

I find the whole situation fairly fishy, as it seems to have devolved to a tug of war between airlines panicking over their cash flow and bureaucrats defending the initial flight bans with any tid bit they can find. At this point I doubt anyone will ever know which was the right decision.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#19

thanks for pointing it out....

John in NM

I hadn't gotten to that pdf yet....

Even at first glance, I can see why they'd be more inclined to ground planes if they'd read that report - and given the 2003 date I think its likely they did.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#20

I've looked inside our main turbine

Bruce, a MN Galoot

while it was running, a GE LM6000, essentially the same as the 747 uses, except it has two compressor stages. Anyway, the blades are glowing bright orange at operating speeds, approx 10,000 rpm. It's pretty hot in there.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#21

Re: True enough...

Carol Reed

Decision right for whom? If you were running a business, would you knowingly operate in a manner that had proven to be destructive to your equipment?

I did not add that to add fuel to the fire here. Methinks we have become so indulgent to our own desires that we have decided anything we want we have a right to. Lots of folks were inconvenienced at the least. But no airplanes crashed killing hundreds because the engines destructed due to volcanic ash ingestion.

Let us count our blessings.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#22

Right in the abstract...

John in NM

As in "correct" by definition of achieving the desired result of safe air travel. I'm personally inclined to think that the airlines are too inclined to gamble on safety in this case. But there are obvious drawbacks to grounding indefinitely, the airlines would go bankrupt, and that would do immense harm to the European economy. Its a sticky situation, and I'm glad I'm not the person who has to make the decisions.

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#23

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Safe, yes.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

But costly. The article goes on to state that the 4 turbines ended up getting overhauled to the tune of $3.2M. They did put on an additional 68 hours of flight time before the overhaul, but indicated that total failure would have been thousands of hours away had it not flown through the ash, versus total failure was likely to be in the low hundreds of hours in the future after having flown through the ash.

Even spreading the $3.2M over a couple hundred hours of flight time would mean some pretty hefty additional repair costs per person per flight.

Jason

Re: OT Do We have a Vulcanologist?

#24

The hard part

Dan Donaldson

The hard part is knowing at what level the ash will damage engines, whether this is the type of ash that would do that, and finally, exactly where is the ash and how it can or cannot be avoided in flight.

If you err too far on one side, people die, and too far on the other and industries and possibly countries go broke. Where is the line? (I agree that I am sure glad it is not me making the decisions)