Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

router table flatness

Posts

router table flatness

#1

router table flatness

les winter

How flat should I expect a router table to be?

I'm going to build a new one, larger than my old Woodhaven job. Looking around my shop, the flatest wide surface I have to use as a clamping table is my cabinet saw. But clamping around the edges would be a bear. My next flatest surface to use as a clamping table is a 2" thick laminate covered counter. But it has a 0.010 sag. That seems excessive to me.

The new table will be a two layer mdf sandwich with several steel straps in grooves, on edge, epoxied inside for stiffness. Laminate on top and bottom.

What deviation would be acceptible in the finished product? I'm thinking 0.005" is about right.

Thanks.

Re: router table flatness

#2

Re: router table flatness

Larry in NW Ohio

Les I built my router table about 30 years ago and it is made out of particle board, at least I think that is what it is, and laminated and it has stay straight as a board, so to say. It is about 1" thick. Larry

Re: router table flatness

#3

Ellis Walentine

Reasonably flat

Ellis Walentine

It is reasonable to expect two layers of MDF to be flat enough without benefit of steel reinforcement. That said, most substrates (all?) will deflect more as the span and the load increase. If you structure the compartment around the router chamber reasonably, I wouldn't expect too much deflection. As for actual numerical tolerances, I dunno -- maybe .005" is about right. You have to consider the kinds of operations you will be doing -- quite precise, I imagine, but how precise to they really need to be? As long as you can apply enough pressure to the workpiece to keep it flat to the table and the fence, a little bit of flex or deflection or even warp in your table top will not be an issue, except in the most critical operations.

Another thing to consider is the flatness of the router plate itself. There are a lot of plates out there, and not all of them are stiff or flat enough to support a heavy router perfectly, especially in cuts that exert counterforces on the bit. No recommendations here, but I'm sure some of our visitors can testify about their experiences with router plates.

Finally, you might consider an old trick that some folks use to keep table tops flat: Shims. A couple well-placed shims can straighten out most table tops.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: router table flatness

#4

Re: Reasonably flat

les winter

Ellis you are the voice of reason.

thanks

Re: router table flatness

#5

Clint Searl

Re: router table flatness

Clint Searl

How will a couple hundredths of an inch sag or hump across the table affect the work?

Clint

Re: router table flatness

#6

Ellis Walentine

Actually, ...

Ellis Walentine

... a couple hundredths (.020") could very easily affect the work, depending on the workpiece characteristics. Say the router plate sags at the center. As you feed your workpiece, it will be in contact with the plate until it rises back up out of the sag. This has an analogous effect to a jointer with the outfeed table a little high. It might not matter, but if you're trying to rout fluted pilasters or something, it could really be noticeable. It wouldn't matter much in a t&g joint, but it might easily louse up a round-over or chamfer cut.

Another situation would be routing with a miter gauge. If you set your bit height based on the projection at the center of the plate, but the surrounding table is a little higher or bellied a bit (I can relate to that), the piece won't be in close contact with the table at the cut, so the depth will be off by that amount. It could also screw up box joints and dovetail joints, where there is almost no margin for error.

A couple thousandths, though, shouldn't pose any noticeable problems.

Ellis

Re: router table flatness

#7

Re: router table flatness *LINK*

del schisler

this table and plate are flat I have these for a couple yrs and still like new I use these every day and the router stays on the plate I bought these instead of making one I wanted to get started Nothing wrong with building one


http://us.oak-park.com/catalogue.html?list=RT01--

Re: router table flatness

#8

Re: router table flatness

Carol Reed

The router table top is a reference surface in relationship with the router bit. The goal is dead flat. .005 is reasonable.

The reason is as Ellis stated. Especially so if you are making joinery cuts.

That said, the trick is to keep it dead flat. First, assume nothing. Measure everything. That includes plates and inserts. BTW, dead flat also means nice and smooth.

Second, use thick material. Doubled MDF with plastic laminate on both sides and the edges has worked for decades.

Third, box support around the router as close as is practical as possible.

And fourth, don't store your router in it between uses. Even cast iron will sag under that condition. BTDT.

Been the standard Router Lady advice for more than 20 years.

Re: router table flatness

#9

Re: router table flatness

FredD

Ellis mentioned in passing about the router plate insert.

This is the place to go for strength, I bought a Woodpecker router table and upgraded it considerable.

The first thing I changed was a custom made by a Machinist friend of mine, a 3/8ths thick Aluminum insert. it doesn't sag and if it did I would toss it because changing out a 3 1/4 HP Stanley router every time I used it is not what I would have in a machine.

Double 3/4" MDf ina plastic sandwich will be all of the stiffness required in a machine that is not intended to approach Shaper construction and use.

FredD

Re: router table flatness

#10

Re: router table flatness *LINK*

Normp

Table flatness was also a concern of mine when building my router table. What I did was attach the top to a torsion box system with a boxed area around the router itself. The torsion box syste is light and will keep the top flat or at the very least prevent sagging.

The router table was a fairly quick build so it doesn't quite look like a piece of furniture but the table has remained flat for 3 years counting now.

I used baltic birch for the table.

You can see what I am referring to at the link below if you wish.

Norman


Router Table

Re: router table flatness

#11

Clint Searl

Re: Actually, ...

Clint Searl

That's why I avoid work that demands tolerances less than the width of my thumb.

Clint

Re: router table flatness

#13

Rousseau inserts too .... I see a problem

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I have a Rousseau in my table and it works fine for my uses. But I can see where this could be a problem when using profile sets for rail and stile cope and stick routing. The end cut on the rails may not be properly registered to the stile profile, depending on the degree of "hump" in that slightly convex plate.

Not a problem for me since I've never used a cope and stick set, but for those that build frame and panel doors, this can be an issue. No?

Re: router table flatness

#14

Ellis Walentine

Better a hump than a dip

Ellis Walentine

A slightly convex top is preferable to a slightly concave one because you can keep pressure on the work at the bit and know that you are registered on the table. (Of course this has limits; you don't want the hump so big that the piece rocks noticeably.)

Ellis

Re: router table flatness

#15

Re: Better a hump than a dip

les winter

thanks everybody. great info.

regards

Les