Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

Posts

O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#1

O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

Stuart Johnson

We were luck enough to obtain a rebate voucher for a new dishwasher. Now comes the decision on which one to purchase.

What do you recommend or which one should we not consider.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#2

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

They start at about $300 and go to $2,500. What's your voucher "worth" and "how do I get one?" :D

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#3

If quiet operation is important

Neal in San Jose

I installed a new Bosch about 6 months ago, and it is so quiet that it is hard to tell when it is running. It does a good (but not great) job of getting things clean, but don't believe them when they say you don't need to rinse the dishes before you put them in. I know that's a pretty weak recommendation, but I haven't been blown away. After lots of internet searching I got it for about $900.

On the other hand, my GF put in a new high-end GE, and has been very disappointed. It is pretty quiet, but you really have to pre rinse and it is picky about how much soap to use. Too much and it doesn't all get rinsed away, too little and things don't get clean. She got it at the orange box on a close out for about $600 installed, but I'd recommend staying away from this brand. BTW, she insisted on white, which limited her choices - it seems everything is stainless steel.

Sorry I don't have model numbers with me here at work. I'll be interested in what others have to say.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#4

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

Tony - Memphis

We are on our 2nd GE and have had lots of problems. Won't ever buy one again. We got the second one because of a recall on the first one - we got a decent rebate. I had to replace the pump on the first one and the control one the second one. The upper rack on the new one doesn't slide well. It has the feature where you pour in a whole bottle of detergent...except it dodn't work from day one. I fixed that one myself too. Oh yeah, service, warranty? What a joke.

Tony

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#5

Bosch

Joe Pack

We had to make the same decision a year or so ago. After reading reviews, getting opinions, comparing features and prices, we ended up with a Bosch. I had to swallow a couple of times before spending $100 more than a GE, Sears, etc. would cost, but, like any good tool, I have never regretted the price I paid. It does a great job cleaning, and is so quiet that I sometimes have to look for the red light to make sure it is on. Unlike our old Kenmore, you don't need ear protection to be in the kitchen while the dishwasher is running!

FWIW, the appliance store we bought our Bosch from said, percentage-wise, they had fewer problems with Bosch than any other brand they sold.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#6

Addendum...we do rinse first

Joe Pack

To be clear, we do rinse dishes before putting them in the dishwasher...just a swish to remove anything thick or dried on. I don't believe the claims of cleaning 3 day old dried on food that some manufacturers make.

One feature I do like, but doesn't really come into play because we do rinse first, is the Bosch filter which is extremely easy to snap out and clean if you need to do so.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#7

happy with Bosch, but we rinse the worst off

Chris Friesen

We've got a Bosch. Nice and quiet, you can visit in the dining room with the dishwasher on--you can hear it (especially when it drains) but it's not intrusive. No exposed heating element so you can put plastic on the bottom rack. It's pretty good about cleaning things although you do want to be careful stacking it. Plastic will have water condensation on it, but this is par for the course on any high efficiency one--the heated air dry sucks power.

I like the idea of the cutlery drawer, but they're only on Miele and maybe a couple others.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#8

'nother Bosch vote

paul in AZ

for all of the above reasons.

The Bosch dishwasher came with the house and is a minimum of 6 trouble free years that I've had the house. I don't know how old it is but love it anyway.

Stay away from GE or their alter-labels. The current generation of GE appliances are garbage with the cheapest possible components according to one of the GE service guys who made one [of several] repair trips for a new frig. I wound up ditching the GE frig and replacing with LG.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#9

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Gutted the kitchen a year ago and SWMBO went for the whole deal in ELECTROLUX stuff. The double oven had to be replaced when they couldn't fit it on site. The Mic blew a switch that took two guys to fix. The dishwasher is silent (we'll see after I get the hearing aids), but, like others is picky about soap and doesn't like dirty dishes. Lots of wiz-bang options we'll never use.

Couple of things learned from service guys:

Use granular enzyme detergent.

Use no more than half of detergent cup amount.

To get "Energy Star" ratings, the manufacturers all have reduced the amount of heat generated by the lower (drying) coil which no longer works to heat the water. Thus run your tap 'till you get full hot water before hitting "start". Since most water heaters are now set at 115� to reduce scalding and energy usage, you'll get less performance out of your washer. Even less if you let it draw cold water out of the line.

One guy actually suggested installing an in-line instant hot water unit for the DW to be set at 140-150�.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#10

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

Stay as far away as possible from LG brand. Also Kenmore is made by LG.

They have a very bad mold build up problem.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#11

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot ID

We went shopping for a dishwasher on Saturday. Our old one hadn't been working well lately, and we figured it was time. Before heading out I Googled "appliance rebate" and found my way to the Federal rebate page for my state. I "reserved" my rebate, then we headed out. We looked at a couple of places, and ended up back at Home Depot, and bought a Maytag MDBH969. Home Depot had 10% off, we'll get $50 from the Federal rebate, and Maytag has a $50 rebate as well. So we will reduce the eventual cost of the machine by almost $150 right off the bat.

We went with the Maytag primarily because that's the one my Wife pointed to. She said the racks were better than the other models we looked at. Bosch dishwashers have the reputation of being the best, but we will likely only be in our current home a couple of years, and I couldn't see pushing for a dishwasher that would be at least twice as much when we would only enjoy it for a couple of years.

We have washed two loads of dishes through this Maytag, and it has cleaned everything we put in there. We don't let a lot of crud dry onto our dishes, but we don't exactly rinse everything off either. I am quite satisfied with this dishwasher. My advice? Don't overthink this too much. Go to a couple of stores, see what strikes you as ones you like. You will find yourself drawn to one or two for whatever reason seems important to you, then make your best deal!

Scott.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#12

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

Question for you Bosch guys...

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

The Bosch units I've seen do not have a heated dry system. How dry are your dishes when done? Do you have to air dry them overnight or ???

The only thing wrong with the dishwasher I have now is the heating element is shot and I have to let them sit overnight to dry. Even then, plastic items are still wet. I could replace the element, but our plan is to upgrade several items here in the near future.

I saw a Kitchen Aid, with heated dry, that I'm interested in but have not done any research yet.

Jim R.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#13

Ditto the hot water tip....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

We replaced the 20 year old old dishwasher with a Kitchenaid unit. Was a bit disappointed with the performance. Discovered that the old unit's built-in water heater was missing. LOML discovered that running the hot water in the adjacent kitchen sink until good and hot made all the difference in the world.

We like the Electrolux line. Just put a new 5-burner stovetop in the island with separate motorized pop-up downdraft and she absolutely loves it. They don;t give those things away. In fact, we couldn't find ANYONE who would discount them. Seem to be fair traded.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#14

we have a pair of bosch dishwashers in the kitchen

Andy Wright - Allen, TX

very happy with them - quiet, get the dishes clean, and we never rinse.

In our last house we had a stainless steel Kenmore which was made by Bosch. Internals were identical to Bosch, but it was a slightly lower price (I think we bought it on sale at Sears)

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#15

Re: Question for you Bosch guys...

Andy Wright - Allen, TX

our Bosch has a heated dry cycle, and the dishes dry just fine

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#16

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

For all you members....whichever appliance you buy...get this website and SAVE it for future questions on any appliance you have: www:repairclinic.com

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#17

Re: Bosch

iew

Our Bosch is great. My wife and I sometimes ask each other if we turned it on, it's that quiet.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#18

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Followup on appliance repairs: www.appliancerepairs.com; and a few others listed in the online popup menu....DIY has some good tips on most everything.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#19

Re: 'nother Bosch vote

Larry in NW Ohio

Another vote against GE, had one for 4 years and was ready to get rid of it a week after we got it. JUNK. Larry

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#20

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

Do you know the model number?

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

Andy,

If you get a chance, please let me know the model number of your dishwasher.

I'd be interested in buying one if I can get the heated drying option..

Thanks,

Jim R.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#21

Re: PS

FredD

The guy that recommended 140 degrees is correct.

Typical setting for a Hot water heater in a house that uses a dishwasher for the following reason.

Most DW's and all top of the line models have a sheath heater that makes up the difference between the incoming hot water and what the manufacturer set the requirement at.

Sick people in a house need that hot water during the wash cycle for sanitation and prevention of sickness spreading though contamination.

The sheath heater is electric , which is a very expensive way to heat water.

Luke warm water is a epidemic waiting to happen.

FredD

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#22

Before you buy, check your plumbing connections

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Some brands are plumbed to the back, some to the front. You may end up having to re-plumb your DW space at an additional cost.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#23

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation Thanks

Stuart Johnson

Thanks to everyone for your input. It looks like Bosch is the way we'll go. The amount of the "cash for clunkers" will take care of the having it installed. The only house maintenance I hate worse than plumbing is painting. I'll do it if I must but I would rather get my aches and pains from doing something I enjoy.

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#24

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

FredD

Late reply, but some useful things to know.

Regardless of the brand chosen , new dish washers discharge pump is so powerful, that a substandard in size sink drain will not handle the rush and will back up into the sink.

Also if you have a disposal , run the discharge line from the DW through it.

No disposal , now is a good time to get one.

I am assuming you will have a competent Plumber install it as opposed to a installer from the store you bought it.

If you live in a state that requires a sink deck mounted air gap , make sure he does one, if not make sure that the discharge line is looped higher then the bottom of the sink drain , this prevents back flow from the sink into the DW which is highly unsanitary and illegal everywhere.

The sink mounted air gap is the better way to do this though a wet loop as described will do the job if the Plumbing code accepts it.

There are so many thing that can go wrong for a homeowner installation that you will be well advised to use the Plumber.

FredD

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

#25

Re: O.T. Dishwasher Recommendation

Bill Wilkinson

We have had a Bosch for several years, and it works quietly and well. It is so quiet that I have mistakenly opened it a few times while it was running and got a surprise when the water sprayed out.

We do not rinse the dishes. Period. Sometimes they are dried on for a couple of days.(Stuck like glue) They come out clean. (Almost) Period. (I feel that for the once a month where something comes out with a bit of stuff on it, we can put it back thru the cycle, and save all the rinsing water for that month.

I agree with the idea of pre-heating the water by running the hot water into the sink before starting the DW - our unit uses so little water (3-5 liters I guess) and our sink is so far from the HW heater, (Yes poor house design) that only half the water coming in is hot. I understand that the DW soap requires a certain temperature to activate the enzymes properly.

My sister bought another Bosch with the bells and whistles. I think she wasted her money.

A repairman told us to skip the extra features; as they rarely if ever get used. Just get the basic unit.