Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

very small router recommendation

Posts

very small router recommendation

#1

very small router recommendation

Bill Tindall

I use a router for wasting out hinge mortises and the like. For this application the router needs to have good balance, and not be top heavy, as often one is teetering on a 13/16" edge. Good visibility is essential because I like to route right to the scribe lines. Power is inconsequential because I use at most a 3/8" bit. I am currently using a DeWalt trim router. It is a bit top heavy and isn't easily grasped. Anything better?

Re: very small router recommendation

#2

Re: very small router recommendation

Andy Wright - Allen, TX

you could try a dremel tool router base. Several different companies make them.

Re: very small router recommendation

#3

Re: very small router recommendation

Norm Knoxville

Bill, I have a small PC cut out tool that might work for you. You are welcome to try it out if you like.

Re: very small router recommendation

#4

Clint Searl

Re: very small router recommendation

Clint Searl

I use a DeWalt laminate trimmer with a 1/4 straight bit for that kind of job.

Clint

Re: very small router recommendation

#5

I love my Porter-Cable 310

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

low center of gravity and the sub-base is designed so that you could make a transparent one easily (yet another project waiting for a round tuit). Its only two flaws, as far as I can tell, are that the collet sometimes needs a little persuasion to release the bit (not a big deal, you just loosen the nut, set the nut down on the bench, and whap it with a chunk of wood), and they're pricey ($180 and up). On the other hand, they were production routers, so used ones are likely still to be working well, and I suspect it'll last forever in a home shop.

Re: very small router recommendation

#6

New Ridgid 2401 laminate router

Jim in N. Va

You might want to check out the new model of Ridgid's laminate trimmer. Very good visibility, clear base (actually comes with 2 bases--a square one and a round one), and has a built in light. Micro adjust for depth. Definitely not a production router like the PC 310, but also only costs about $100. I think it comes with Ridgid's lifetime warranty. I'm not sure it is any less top heavy than the router you are using now, tho'

--Jim

Re: very small router recommendation

#7

Re: very small router recommendation

Jesse Cloud

Hey Bill,

I have the same issue. I have tried most of the laminate trimmers on the market and haven't been satisfied with any of them. I mostly use a Bosch Colt, but would open my pocketbook quickly if a better alternative were available.

Sounds like an opportunity for someone out there. Any tool companies listening??

Re: very small router recommendation

#8

Ellis Walentine

Microfence Base with Colt *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

I've been lusting for one of these gizmos for a long time. I've heard nothing but good reviews.

Ellis


MicroFence Three-Axis Mill

Re: very small router recommendation

#9

Re: Microfence Base with Colt *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

wow that is really nice...but....I'll be lusting for a long time at $400+ the router.

Good news is I just picked up 3 more PC 310's at a estate sale for $100.

If anyone has a use for a Betterly Sizing Base please let me know.

Andy


http://www.betterleytools.com/

Re: very small router recommendation

#10

Re: I love my Porter-Cable 310

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Unfortunately the 310 is out of production. For anyone who has never had the pleasure of using one of these they are as solid and bullit proof as the venerable 610. I tried a bosch colt and really liked the way it felt in my hand at the store. once in my shop I could not get the depth adjustment to stay when the base was extended near the max. no mater how nice a tool feels if it won't stay adjusted it is worthless so back it went. I was able to locate a new 310 and after my experiance with the bosch the price was worth it. In use the 310 is very comfrtable even though it lacks a thermo molded grip. I think part of the comfort comes from the solidness and low center of gravity and the confidence that inspires.

The single slit collet is the achillies heel of these routers and was the one of the reaons I turned to the bosch initially. You can minimize the collet sieze up by not inserting the bit till it bottoms out before you tighten it. Also it generaly does not need to be gorilla grip tightened. Another option is to buy extra collets and collet nuts. I have a friend that went this route and I used to make fun of him till I had a 310 of my own. the solution a lot of shops went with as to just buy several 310's and use them till they brake and send them to be fixed with the bit still in. The solution I chose was to use Her-safe arbors and carbide insert tooling.

Due to how nice and solid the 310 is you will find yourself reaching for it rather than a larger router when ever you can. the nice thing is that the 310 has the power to pull off more tasks than most small routers. Some guys like to have a small/laminate router mid size router and a larger 3+hp router for mounting in a table. With the 310 you can opt out of the three router system if you are willing to use your big router on those few occasions you need a large bit used in a freehand application.

So why did porter cable discontinue this great router? I am guessing there was some cross over in management from GM.

Robin

Re: very small router recommendation

#11

Re: I love my Porter-Cable 310

Ilja Burkoff

I as many others loved my Porter Cable 310. Now someone else loves it. (was lifted from a job sight) Last week went to replace it and was informed of the 310 no longer being available. On the other hand, was told that any day now, Porter Cable would be shipping the new and improved version of the 310. Now I have not seen it, but the tool shop owner said, the new version had some improvements.

Re: very small router recommendation

#12

It may be out of production

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but Amazon is still listing new ones.

I've been intrigued, over the years, by how gutsy this and the Porter-Cable Mdl. 100 router are, relative to the amps they draw. We're taught that there's a direct relationship between amperage draw and power in universal motors, but these two seem disproportionately powerful. The 310 draws less than 4 amps, and the later model 100 router just 6.5, but they'll swing some big bits for their size and amperage.

Re: very small router recommendation

#13

Microfence Base with Porter Cable 310

Scott in Montana

I have the microfence fitted with the Porter Cable 310. I couldn't live without it! I have twin LED lights for seeing my progress and often use the Amana collet reducer to get down to 1/8" or smaller bits.

This has super visability and is perfect for inlay work as well.

Scott in Montana

Re: very small router recommendation

#14

PC 310 complaint

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

I have a PC 310. It's tough to freehand rout with this machine because it is very difficult (for me at least) to see the cut. The housing surrounds the bit. There's a small opening for waste. It lets in very little light.

For light duty work like hinge mortising my Dremel with a router base works well but it is in no way a production machine.

Re: very small router recommendation

#15

I've never understood

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

why it took so long for (some of) the router makers to realize that sub-bases should be transparent, not black.

Re: very small router recommendation

#16

Re: very small router recommendation

Kelly Anderson

The new Rigid trim router is pretty nice. It has a clear base and an LED to light up the cut.

Re: very small router recommendation

#17

Re: very small router recommendation

Joe Burke

I have a Dremel with a router base that I'm sure I purchased at Lowe's or somewhere similar, so it's nothing special. I refit it with a 1/4" plexiglass base plate, and I use it in just the manner you describe. Whenever one of the machine tool companies has a sale on carbide end mills I'll buy two or three 1/8" end mills and I use those to cut hinge gains. You can find an amazing array of tiny end mills with 1/8" shanks for inlay and the like.

I haven't run into anything yet that a sharp 1/8" end mill can't handle. I usually cut as close to the line as I dare and chisel the rest. Having said all that there are some downsides to my setup. While a sharp 1/8" end mill works you simply can't hog out a lot of stock at a time. Patience is a virtue here. Since I'm not routing hinge gains daily it's not too much of an issue for me. The Dremel router base I have works, but it's depth of cut adjustment is not ideal. Okay ... it's awful really. It gives new meaning to the word coarse. I'm pretty sure Dremel, and others, have new and better bases available now. I think of getting one every time I cut hinge gains but have yet to follow through.

The Dremel works well for me, but like I said ... Find a decent base and accept that removing the waste is a nibbling process.

Re: very small router recommendation

#18

Here is a good one *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

Expensive, but nice.


Dremel and 310 bases

Re: very small router recommendation

#19

Re: very small router recommendation *LINK*

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

This is the one I use.


Stew Mac Dremel router base

Re: very small router recommendation

#20

Re: PC 310 complaint

Ken

Ed,

If you are not willing to make your own clear base then try this link:

http://www.patwarner.com/pc310_special.html

Re: very small router recommendation

#21

Re: PC 310 complaint

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

Ken.\,

Thanks for the link. I do make transparent router bases and usually find them helpful but the PC 310 bit is still in darkness with one.

As Pat says in the blurb for his bases "The base casting of the 310, more than 1/2 of a cylinder, does not allow a lot of work/cutter visibility nor stability. My subbases will make up for some of that ..."

I might try one of those LEDs mentioned elsewhere in the thread to get some light inside the cave.

Ed