Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

Posts

OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#1

OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

Barry Irby

Costco has Magellan and Garmin. The Magellan has a bigger screen and a slightly higher price.

Any specifics on features? Or model?

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#2

I have a Garmin, but...

Grant in Iowa

I would suggest you do a little poking around the two company web sites. Pretend you are going to download new maps for each and determine the cost. Might consider the lifetime cost of each, since at least Garmin wants something like half of the lifetime cost of new maps for one update.

I really don't know how the two compare, other than to say that I like my Garmin a lot. If I had it to do over, I would have bought a higher end model, but I wouldn't change the brand I bought, as I am very happy with my Garmin. The reason for my reconsidering the model is that mine is a low to mid range unit (Nuvi 350W). I didn't consider the lifetime purchase option on the map updates when I made my decision. I am finding it hard to justify the cost (something like $130) of the lifetime maps on a unit that I'd like to someday upgrade. The lifetime maps aren't transferrable to another unit so far as I know.

This is kind of like shop equipment in that it makes sense to get one that you can live with for several years to justify the cost of the lifetime map subscription.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#3

Steven Antonucci

I have a TomTom

Steven Antonucci

and it works well enough for what I use it for. I think they are under $100, and I can't recall the last time I updated it with anything?

Steve

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#4

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

Jerry Nicholson

No matter what you get, don't assume the maps are perfect - they aren't! They will, on rare occasions, lead you astray. I have a Garmin 350 (several years old) that I am happy with. Since my bicycle speedometer/odometer went out, I mount the Garmin on the bicycle. It does a great job of showing speed, distance, and time.

Jerry

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#5

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

paul in AZ

As with any tech gadget the current offerings change quickly. I would suggest a search for GPS reviews to see what is current.

I've had two. I looked at magellan but didn't like the interface all that much for what thats worth to you. First i got a Tom Tom which is supposed to be the gold standard for Europe and not quite as good for US maps. I quickly returned that and bought a Garmin which has been very satisfactory so far.

My thoughts on the Garmin: I like the larger screen more than the 3[?] inch version. costco is not the best place to get one. At the time they didn't have the most recent models and their price was on the high side. Updating maps is expensive but I have decided not to bother. Here in AZ with all the new development there are occasional places where newly built streets don't show up but that is minor. In most of the country they aren't adding new streets very often so it is an even smaller consideration. The search function for gas stations, motels, & food is generally very good to excellent but this could be the one function that justifies buying upgrades.

I guess the answer is to fiddle with various demo models to see what seems to feel good and then look for a good price on line.

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#6

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation? *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Barry,

I bought a TomTom One 130S back in Feb. from Best Buy. I needed a new unit since someone else decided they really liked the one I had in the truck(nextar from Newegg.com) .The Tom Tom is a nicer unit than the Nextar and is easy to use once you use it a couple times.I chose the smaller screen 3.5 as I like to throw it in my pocket/briefcase when I am in strange cities travelling,usually walking in downtown areas with no idea of restaurants etc,it helps their too.

best Buy had it on sale for less than $100 before tax and seemed to have all the features I needed.With my new job working in foreclosed homes it has been invaluable showing me the side streets and neighborhoods around Metro Detroit.

I haven't looked too much at the TomTom site to find out about map upgrages but the City of Detroit streets are fairly well established.

Andy


http://www.bestbuy.com/site/TomTom+-+ONE+130S+Portable+GPS/8774427.p?id=1204331807929&skuId=8774427

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#7

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

David Hay Denver

I can't comment on specific models, but I do have a few things to consider:

1. Play with a model to see how fast it starts up and acquires satellite locks. The one we borrowed on a recent trip took so long to start up that we were almost at our destination!

2. Check into how much it costs to update the data, especially if you plan to use it to check around for nearby restaurants, gas stations, etc.

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#8

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

Bill Howatt

I have a Garmin Nuvi 750 with the 4.3" screen. It also plays MP3 files through the car radio if you want.

I have used a borrowed ? model with a 3.5" screen and I prefer the larger screen and would pay the extra to get it.

Haven't updated the maps yet but I know they aren't cheap. Note that even the lastest maps can still be a year or so behind - they are just the latest that have been converted by the vendor for GPS use.

One thing that I think is neat but a lot of people wouldn't see it as anything to get excited about is that I took it with me when I cross-country ski. When I get back I can copy a file from the Garmin and import it into Google earth and it overlays my track onto the Goodle display. Not all GPSs let you extract and load info but like I said, it might be a useless feature for many.

Bill

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#9

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot ID

Hi Barry!

If you keep seeing the name Garmin pop up, there is a reason. They make really fine GPS units, and seem to have pretty good routing. I have two Garmin units, one for the car, and a handheld for geocaching. Whenever we go on vacation we take our GPS with us, and it helps us find our way around. I would buy another Garmin, and highly recommend them.

Do a little research and compare the models you like. Pick one you like the best and then search the net for the best price. Good Luck!

Scott.

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#10

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

Paul Vander Woude

I spent a lot of time comparing Garmin models and other manufacturers, and ended up buying a Garmin 265WT. It has a the wide screen, and comes with a lifetime traffic receiver and subscription. Works very well as a hands free bluetooth device with my cell phone as well. Current price at Amazon is about $175. The user interface is very good. I'd buy it again.

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#11

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

John McGaw

I have a two-year old Magellan (can't recall the model) but there was little science involved in the choice. I simply looked for the cheapest refurbished GPS that didn't have totally abysmal ratings in on-line reviews I could locate. The Magellan came out on top with better-than-average reviews and a $69 price tag from Tiger Direct.

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#12

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

Del Williams

I have owned both a Magellan and Garmin GPS. I prefer the Garmin because the interface is more useful for me. The ability to update map files is simpler for the Garmin system in my opinion.

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#13

Name the streets

Tom Dunlap

I bought a Garmin that is going to be returned. It doesn't name the steet..it says 'take right' or 'bear right' Then I have to look at the unit to read the street name. Since I need cheaters to read my eyes have to refocus. The whole point of having Gypsy along is to let her tell me where to go.

My other Garmin would giveme directions and put me at the door hinges of my destination. This one gets me within two to five houses and claims that I've arrived at my destination. My other one died but was about six years old and I loved it!

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#14

How to name the streets

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

Depending upon the model, the street naming feature is turned on or off in the menus. The garmin site FAQ'a will give you the right steps if your model will do it. Most of the Nuvi series will

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#15

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation? *LINK*

John McGaw

I mentioned my theory of "recertified and cheap will do the job" in an earlier post. Here are some examples to mull over:


Cheap Recertified GPSs

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#16

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

Jim Dillon

Barry,

Everyones needs will vary. Based on a WC thread a year or so ago, I got a Garmin 355WT. I had no need at that time, nor now, for the more fancy features. I am very happy with it.

I would look for a model, regardless of brand, that is 4.3 inchs, and has the voice announcement of upcoming turns. Other than that, I would shop for price. Amazon sometimes has one-day hot deals on GPS units that might be attractive to you.

OK, now the downside. This unit sometimes "says" turn left, when the upcoming turn is to the right. This sometimes happens about a mile from the upcoming turn, but corrects itself when one gets closer. No big deal, but it could lead to some frantic last minute lane changing, especially if you are in unfamilar terriority. And after eight months, the in-car charger broke. I got a new one from Amazon and everything is fine. Other than that, I would get another Garmin if I needed to replace this one.

Jim

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

#17

Re: OT Any recommendations on GPS Navigation?

Rob Lee

Hi Barry -

I have two Garmins, and old 2610, and a 7200.

You can't wrong with any of them, really - but there are features to be aware of...

If you like to plan routes - make sure you can set waypoints, and load routes... otherwise, the GPS will determine how you get from A to B. Garmin has routing software (PC based) that comes with some models that lets you do this. Not all models have routes!

Remotes - both my units operate with remote controls, in addition to a touch screen. I believe the remote is safer to use while underway - in something like an RV - you really have no choice, as you can't reach the touch screen.

City driving - the "lane assist" feature would be one I'd like to have (don't have it now)...especially for complex freeway interchanges.

Cheers -

Rob