Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Posts

Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#1

Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

Talked to Carter today, they said they have never heard of this problem before with my saw, but they said it happens all the time with current saws coming out of china. I pulled out a file, and elongated the screw slot long enough for the screw to fit through, and then everything fit perfect! No issues putting the thrust bearing into place.



Alright! Back on track! Spent a whole bunch of time with a wire bursh and thoroughly cleaned out the top and bottom wheels, then gave the saw one last go over with the vac, compressed air, and boeshield where bare metal was showing and not already coated. Opened up my brand new 1/4" timberwolf band saw blade, cleaned it with mineral spirits, and then put a coat of dry lube, let it dry, and wiped off the excess. Slid the blade over the top wheel, then the bottom, spun the wheel by hand several times until it found the spot it wanted to ride on, and everything appeared good to run well, just looking at the top wheel. I plugged her in and fired her up and boy is she a lot quieter now! The blade does not move on either wheel and has very little vibration in it all even with the guides pulled far from the blade. I shut her down, and then noticed that the blade on the lower wheel was tracking on the wrong side of the wheel. So here is my next problem to figure out. Tomorrow I will check to see if the lower wheel is secured properly to the shaft, or if someone shimmed it out before, other than that... anyone else have an idea about what to do here? It looks like the last blade that was on did the same thing because the center of the lower tire is chewed up a lot more than the upper tire.

Upper Wheel


Lower Wheel


I appreciate any help, suggestions, or comments! To bad I still have to work the day job tomorrow, would love to have a full weekend to finish off this project and get back to making sawdust!


Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#2

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Barry Irby

With all the work you have done have you checked to see if the wheels are co-planar? Mine (14" Delta with riser) ran with the blade on opposite sides of the wheels until I shimmed the lower wheel.

You getting there. This will be a great bandsaw.

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#3

My Thoughts Exactly, Barry

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#4

Tracking Suggestions

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You didn't mention how much tension you put on the blade before running. Planarity of the wheels can change depending on how much tension is on the blade.

Also, before you finish setting your wheels, you should put your table on and check the blade for plumb and square (both axises) with the top surface. This should be done before you set your guides.

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#5

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Marv

Ken,

Do you have a long enough straight edge that will span both wheels? They should be even and plumb with each other within at least 1/16". Check this before doing any shimming.

If you need to adjust the bottom wheel and it won't slide easily on the shaft, check to see if the motor can be moved in or out. It appears that the bottom wheel is mounted on the motor shaft?

Marv

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#6

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

I am now trying to determine if the wheels are coplanar or not. If there is no easier way to do it, I will have to cut up some plywood to span the wheels to make this check. I was trying to figure out a clever way to do it with a chalk line laser and a tilt box. I figure if I put the tilt box on one of the wheels, and shim the band saw so that one of the wheels is plumb, then I can set the laser to mark an offset plane off that wheel, and then use a good rule to measure from the laser line to the other wheel. Offset from the laser plane should then be the same for both wheels if they are coplanar. Just got back from work and need to get some errands done before getting back into the shop to try it.

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#7

Re: Tracking Suggestions

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

Haven't touched the guides yet except to install them. Both the upper and lower guides are set to wide open and as far back as possible until I get everything else sorted out.

This bandsaw has a tension gauge on the tension wheel that just states the sizes of blades. I put a 1/4" timberwolf blade on, which is about 6.4mm. The tension guide has ranges for 6mm blades and the next one up is 10mm blades. I set the tension to the higher side of the 10mm setting.

I will check the table next, after getting the blade to track right on both wheels, thanks for the tip.

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#8

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

I do not have a staight edge long enough to make that measurement, I may cut up some plywood to make that check, if I can't get a laser setup to work for me.

The motor is on a different shaft. I have a link belt spanning the two.


Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#9

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Thomas S Stockton

The lower wheel shaft goes into a steel tube that has 4 adjustment bolts and locking nuts so you can adjust the wheel up/down or left/right easily, I don't remember if it can be moved in or out but I bet it can or you can figure out a way too. The bolts are on the back of the machine you first need to remove or loosen the cover washer that is held on by a separate bolt.

I had to adjust mine when I first bought it but haven't touched it since

Tom

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#10

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

Are you talking about this bolt on the back of the saw? If I remove this there will be four hidden bolts for adjusting the lower wheel?


Here is what the lower wheel looks like from both sides.


Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#11

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Thomas S Stockton

That's totally different than the way my wheel shaft mounts. I've never seen that method on a mini max

Tom

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#12

Re: Tracking Suggestions

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Not sure I read that right but it sounds like you have a 6.4 mm blade and instead of tensioning it properly for a 6.4mm blade you over tensioned it for even a 10 mm blade. It is more common to start off with the correct amount of tension and as the blade gets dull you increase the tension to counteract some of the blade drift caused by a dull blade.

When setting up a bandsaw the first thing you should check is the blade itself. After installing the blade and tensioning it check the back of the blade across the weld using the longest straight edge your saw will allow. An incorrectly welded blade will make it difficult to tune the saw properly and I have gotten badly welded blades before.

To check for tracking you start by spinning the wheels by hand then close the doors and adjust the tracking under power. You can only check the wheels for coplanar once the blade is tracking properly.

Co planer means that both wheels are in the same plane. This is actually not nearly as important as some people make out to be. What is important is that the wheels be in parallel planes. If they are not in parallel planes the blade will be slightly twisted and this can cause the blade to not track a line while cutting. Wheels that are not co planer but are in parallel planes will track a blade just fine if they are only out by a small amount. How small is acceptable depends on the width of the blade the width of the wheels and the amount of crown on the tires.

Band saws are more forgiving than most people think. Good crown on the tires, the correct blade tension, and properly adjusted guides will get you more than acceptable results. Add the right blade and you can cut 1/16" veneer.

Robin

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#13

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Charles in Mtl.

doesn't that bolt only hole the wheel shaft in place? if it's loosened then can the wheel be shimmed outward?

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#14

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

Shimming the wheel would push the blade out further on the wrong side. I need to get the wheel to go the other way. So, unless there are shims in there already that I can take out, I don't know of a way to do that to the lower wheel.

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#15

Co-planarity of the wheels?

Charles in Mtl.

If you took a piece of plywood and span across the wheel is there a noticeable misalignment? Or is the top wheel too far out? There must be some way to make an adjustment.

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#16

lower tire?

John K Jordan

>...the center of the lower tire is chewed up a lot more than the upper tire

If the tire is chewed up enough to remove the crown on the tire, the blade may not track properly even if the wheels are coplanar. Remember to double-check the plane after the blade is installed and tensioned.

Proper tension is often a problem. I bought a Starrett tension gauge which removes the guesswork (justified with three bandsaws here). There are cheaper gauges too.

If you haven't seen it, get the free Iturra Design catalog, full of tips, tools, blade, and more. They don't have a web site AFAIK, but do have a phone number. I'm not looking at a catalog at the moment but I had these two numbers in my notes: 888-722-7078 and 866-883-8064

JKJ

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#17

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Marv

Ken,

It appears that your saw was designed for all the blade tracking adjustments to be made with the upper wheel. I would check out every adjustable part of the upper wheel assembly before doing anything with the lower wheel.

Marv

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#18

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

I only had a couple minutes to work on the saw tonight. I adjusted the tracking on the upper wheel to both extremes. That is, as far as I could go before the blade would pop off the wheel on either side. I now have it set so that blade runs dead center on the top wheel, and on the bottom wheel, it runs so that the flat side of the blade is about 1/8" - 3/16" from the edge. It does look like the previous owner ran the saw quite a bit with the teeth of the blade running on the center of the wheel on the bottom, but it still looks and feels like the lower wheel has a crown to me.

I didn't have enough time to test the wheels to see if they are coplanar, hopfully I will have time to do that tomorrow tonight. When I put a tiltbox on the lower wheel, zero it, and then place it on the upper wheel, it shows the wheels are within .1 degree of each other, but that doesn't tell me if they are coplanar.

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#19

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Marv

Ken,

Sounds like you've solved the problem. As long as the blade is tracking center on both wheels, it means the wheels are in alignment with each other. If the bearings are not worn much the tracking should stay put. Wouldn't hurt to replace the tires though. But even with the old tires, with some use of the saw, the roughness on the lower tire will wear in to some degree. When you tension the blade, tighten it just beyond where it is loose, so it is straight, turn the wheels by hand until the blade is centered on the tires, then tighten it a bit more. It doesn't have to be super tight. If you feel that you are stretching it, it is too tight. You'll get a feel for how tight is tight enough as you use different size blades.

You've done a lot of work to that saw and it looks fantastic.

Marv

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#20

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

I do not think I'm there yet with the wheels. The blade runs dead center on the top, and the flat side of the blade is on the edge of the wheel on the bottom. I do not have a straight edge long enough, so I shimmed the band saw till it was dead level. With the band saw dead level, the top wheel shows that it is exactly 90deg to level. I set up a self leveling laser and shot it just outside the doors to the wheels, and used a rule to measure the offset of the tops and bottoms of each wheel. Here is what the setup looks like.


Taking measurements like this...


I get the same measurements for the top and bottom of the top wheel, 2 7/16". The lower part of the bottom wheel reads 2 5/16" and the top of the bottom wheel measures 2 3/16" from the laser line.

So, it seems the bottom wheel is tilted by 1/8" across the 18" diameter of the wheel. With the info above can someone with more experience tell me if I need to straighten out the bottom wheel, or replace the tire, or if it is close enough?

Any help would be greatly appreciated, I know the time I put into tuning this saw will be worth it, but I am very ready to move on now!

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#21

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Charles in Mtl.

so the top of the lower wheel is tipped inward by 1/8 of an inch? maybe it is possible to shim this to reduce the offset?

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#22

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

Tomorrow I will take off the lower wheel and see what is going on in there. Maybe there is some kind of adjustment I cannot see with the wheel on, or there is some other way I can fix the problem. Yes, there definitely appears to be a good tilt in the lower wheel. If I shim the bandsaw so that the lower wheel is plumb to the ground, the bandsaw very noticably leans to one side.

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#23

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Marv

Ken,

Adjusting the wheels to line up or be plumb or level to the ground might be leading you to the wrong point of reference.

Of course you wouldn't do this, but you could actually lay the machine on it's side and still align the two wheels with each other.

You do need a point of reference though. I would make every effort to use the lower wheel as the reference point. If there isn't enough adjustment with the top wheel, I would attempt to increase those adjustments and not move the lower wheel. It is possible that the machine was manufactured inaccurately or the large sheetmetal parts of the machine has warped. In any case, it appears that all the blade tracking adjustments were intended to be done at the top wheel.

A long enough straight edge is best for checking the top wheel against the bottom wheel. I'm not sure that a laser line is going to be as accurate because you might not be referencing off the bottom wheel which should be your main point of reference. The most accurate part of the bottom wheel will be across the outer edge of the wheel, not the center area. When the wheel was machined, the center shaft hole was bored in relationship to the outside edges or visa versa.

Good luck,

Marv

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#24

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

Running a straight edge across the lower wheel, I would have to have the upper wheel almost out of the case up top to be parallel. I'm thinking there is going to have to be some adjustment to the lower wheel.

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

#25

Re: Another Night of Tinkering with the BandSaw

Marv

Ken,

Sounds like you have a problem that is outside the realm of just normal adjustments that the machine provides. We are all limited with our recommendations without seeing it up close and personal. If you would like to haul it out to California, we could fix it here. :D

Take care,

Marv