Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

wooden shop floors

Posts

Re: wooden shop floors

#26

Another correction...

John in NM

It wasn't Snowflake now that I think of it.... Can't remember the town. :\

Re: wooden shop floors

#27

Re: Square Framing

FredD

Mark ,

I am sad to say , that is often the case where builders get away with cutting corners and inspectors get rewarded for looking the other way.

That is a excellent reason for having a Carpenter check out you house construction.

They have no axe to grind or fee to earn , I do it often , though not as much here because of a less dense population (not a pun George) .

You and your wife are lucky that you can handle the remodel aspects, most home owners couldn't.

FredD

Re: wooden shop floors

#28

Re: Late response

Barry Irby

Carol, I have read the responses and they are good.

Let me try to explain a couple of things. Most people want strong really solid floors. Those two things are not necessarily the the same. A floor can be plenty strong without being really solid. In other words a bouncy floor might be strong enough to not collapse.

The stiffness of the floor framing is related to a number of things. The species and grade of the lumber. Southern Yellow Pine is considerably stiffer than Spruce. No. 2 lumber is somewhat stiffer than No. 3. Also, the "deeper" the joists are the stiffer the floor. A 2 X 10 creates a deeper floor than A 2 x 8. The span of the joists ahsa huge effect. Putting the beam down the center and cutting the span in half increases the apparent stiffness by a factor or 4. So halving the spans quadruples the solidness of the floor.

It would surprise most people to learn that the Code permits floors to deflect quite a bit. The Deflection is based on the Length or "L". There are the standards. L/180, L/240, and L/360. So, if your floor joist were 20 feet long (240 inches), and the deflection you chose were L/240 the floor could neglect and inch and still meet the code. Even if you chose L/360 it could deflect 240/360 or 3/4" and be acceptable. If you put that center beam in the the acceptable deflection would be cut in half.

Another factor is the weight of the floor. We have discovered that what many of us perceive as a bouncy floor is the shock wave created when our foot hits the floor, Sort of like the ripple in the pond thing. TWo sense the returning shock wave and find it disturbing. The truss joists are really light and Engineered to the minimum. If you used lightweight plywood on top (one layer of 5/8") then the the whole floor structure might weigh a few hundred pounds. A 100 to 200 pound person walking on a very light floor is entirely different than the same person waling on one that weighs twice as much. This is an advantage to the conventional framing. The weight adds to the perception of solidness.

Another thing that helps all out of proportion to the cost is to glue the subfloor to the joists. Some studies indicate you might get a 25% increase in strength. Use and excellent adhesive such as BF Goodrich PL400. Screw the subfloor to the joists. Stand there and watch. Its worth it. Another thing that would help is to glue and screw a layer to the underside of the joists if you can. Turns the floor into box beams. Dramatic improvement. They can nail first and then screw, but the screws are superior. The glue also eliminates squeaks.

As I mentioned before, I have no personal experience with 1 1/8" OSB/plywood. Not common locally. Never seen any that I am aware of. Sounds like a good product. What I do is glue and screw a second layer of 5/8 over the first layer. Tedious and time consuming, but very effective. Also allows you to put and "unweathered" layer in, but in your case, that should not be an issue. Your building should be under roof quickly enough to not worry about weather on the floor.

About bridging. Unless the joists are really deep and close together the bridging probably does not do much good. The Code does not require them until you get to 2x12's on 16" centers. What this does is make the pieces steeper so that when you step on one joist and try to defect it, the force is transmitted to the joists on each side and they share the load. If the joists are shallow and far apart, the bridge pieces are flatter and can not transmit the forces to the adjacent joists nearly as well.

My choice for your situation would be 2x8's on 16" centers with 1 1/8" OSB glued and screwed or two layers of 5/8 glued and screwed. Even with low quality crappy lumber it would work fine for what you want. Having said that, I think you could substitute the truss joists and still have a satisfactory floor.

Re: wooden shop floors

#29

Re: Square Framing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

The house was built on spec at the top of the '86 bubble. Mono-pour basement, 12's on the ground floor, 10's on the second. I bought in '90 and have put in a fair amount of time correcting/upgrading stuff (but not moving walls), including the finished basement, full guts on the MB and kitchen, plus decks and walks, and complete re-plumb on the supply side. House is a multi-roofed contemporary. Took me 10 years to track down and fix all the *&#@! leaks before I put the new roof on. Fortunately, I originally "stole" it when it went into "relo" and the holder was desperate to unload. Otherwise, I'd be way upside down on the net. Told SWMBO that "next time" (last time) I'm inspecting during the build.

Re: wooden shop floors

#30

disagree on bridging

Bill Tindall

You provided a wonderful discussion of the stiffness topic which I hope Carol considers carefully. And I never heard of the 1 1/8" stuff either, not do I consider it necessary for a shop floor to add stiffness or strength, presuming 16" centers. The only reason I would add anything to 3/4" floor is to provide a finished surface, which could well be desirable. Try deflecting 3/4" across a 14 1/2 space- near zero with any contemplated load.

However, I disagree with the part on bridging. I am a great proponent of old fashioned 1 x 4 x XX lumber bridging. I have nailed miles of it and it works to vastly stiffen ANY joist floor. I attached 2 rows of bridging to a 22 foot span of 2 x 8 SPF ceiling joists above a garage and turned the "attic" area into valuable storage and ditto for a 20' span and I have 2000 bd ft of lumber sitting on it. The stiffening provided on the 2 x 8's was phenomenal. Well not really, as I expected the result I got. I was wary walking on the 22' span before it got bridging; it felt like a trampoline. After bridging it just vibrates for the reasons you so clearly described.

Technical stuff. When a beam is loaded it at first deflects but its typical failure mode is to then twist. The crappy (in my opinion) metal bridging is primarily suited to prevent the twisting. I don't consider it stiff enough (completely undocumented opinion) to provide the other benefit of bridging which is to couple the beams so that a deflection of one is transferred to the adjacent beams, thereby distributing a point load to a larger area.

Re: wooden shop floors

#31

Re: Another correction... Strawberry

Carol Reed

Quite a ways from Snowflake, but Flagstaff is a 100 miles. The Foxworth closed in Payson last December, leaving us with just HD. Most engineered stuff like trusses comes from Prescott. HD charges $79 for delivery. Prescott is maybe 80 miles. That's cheap enough for me. Beats owning another vehicle.

Re: wooden shop floors

#32

Re: wooden shop floors - back on topic

Carol Reed

Well, that was an interesting exchange of information!

Tomorrow HD will provide the engineering specs and costs for I-joists.

However, I will also spec out - cost wise - 2x8x10' with a center beam on stems spaced 10 feet apart. The floor will still be 3/4" Sturdi-floor. It is a T&G OSB product with a shellacked finish side. I have in other areas and it is a reasonable product.

I will plan on bridging between the joists and gluing (PL 400) and screwing the sheet material down.

The scissored roof trusses will still be engineered.

How am I doing so far? :)

Re: wooden shop floors

#33

Thats right...

John in NM

Now I remember, got the "S" right anyhow :D

Re: wooden shop floors

#34

I've seen that subflooring for sale...

John in NM

years ago in Tucson before HD completely took over the retail market there. I've frankly never needed a product as stiff as the 1 1/8 plywood, because as you say, the deflection of 3/4" plywood between 16" OC joists is minimal. I suspect the thicker product was designed to add stiffness to a minimally built floor structure so that tile could be laid without it cracking. I further suspect that it is rarely seen any more compared to 3/4" T/G ply or osb because overbuilding the joists rather than the sheathing just works sooooo much better :D and doesn't cost that much more.

Re: wooden shop floors

#35

Re: Late response

Jorge Casta�eda

Barry,

The 1 1/8" Plywood, is not OSB, is regular plywood, it may very well be 2 - 5/8" glued together and have tongue and groove edges, and it is flat, no curly stuff here, just flat; makes a very nice substrate and is not meant to stiffen an undersized floor structure, around here, I mean anything I build is 2x12" for the first floor and 2x10" for all floors above, all covered with the 1 1/8" plywood, (it is actually 1 1/16"). This creates a nice solid floor that feels right underfoot and is stiff enough to lay ceramic tile on it without cracking.

The one exception is when using big beams that are going to stay exposed, then the floor is made with 2"6" t&g spruce wicich has a v match in the bottom side and can be used as a finish floor or covered with something else, but looks really good from the underside, (ceiling.)

Re: wooden shop floors

#36

A Little Short

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Your structure is 20' wide and you're putting in a center beam for a 10' span. Unless you're hanging them (not good here), seems like 10' joists are going to be a bit short. I would not use an OSB material as the final floor surface in a wood shop. Not a durable surface, and that shellac, while a good waterproofer, will wear through before long. I'd put in a few more piers to get increased rigidity on your long axis. In my area, beam supports are set 7' maximum, but that's with a full foundation. In your situation I'd look for 6' max which translates to 6 piers in each row rather than 4.

Re: wooden shop floors

#37

PS - Piers

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

(or pylons)

Since you mention "rock" and "mountain", have you checked with the local office on your frost line depth for how deep you're going to have to drill for the sonotubes?

Re: wooden shop floors

#38

Re: PS - Piers

John in NM

"Since you mention "rock" and "mountain", have you checked with the local office on your frost line depth for how deep you're going to have to drill for the sonotubes?"

If its bedrock, there's no need to get below a frostline. So few people build right on bedrock that the code office often does not understand this, but the field inspectors usually do.

Re: wooden shop floors

#39

What we did...

John in NM

Was nail and glue a cleat on each side of the beam to conserve height. Between the beam thickness and the rim board Carol could do it easily with 10' joists.

I don't especially like joist hangers either, but more because of the cost than any fear they'd fail. I did use a few in my roof structure where they were the best solution.

Re: wooden shop floors

#40

Cleats

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Yes, she could butt two 10-footers with a plate joint provided the center beam's of sufficient width. But I'd not wish to rely on I-joists sitting on an 1-1/2" ledge which assumes that she's going down the middle with a pair of sistered 2x. I may be old-school, but I'd rather see some overlap as used in "traditional" stick. I also missed any mention of how much material she's using for the perimeter. With no foundation, this whole structure will only be as strong and rigid as the platform it's built on.

Re: wooden shop floors

#41

typical beam construction

Bill Tindall

Building techniques seem to be highly regional, influenced by tradition and codes. The picture shows what is standard practice in the places I have lived. Many in my family are in construction so I have seen a lot of houses. That doesn't mean its right, best, or up to a specific code. But for damn sure it does hold up a house or shop just fine.

The center beam, typically running the length of a 24-30' wide house , is made up of 2- 2 x 10's and a 3/4 piece of plywood glued in between. In the case in the picture the span is long so we went with an additional layer for the beam. The joists are notched to sit on a 2 x 2 nailed to the bottom of the beam. The beam is assembled in place with one set of joists nailed with nails driven through the first element of the beam and the joists on the other side are toe nailed to the beam with 6- #16 nails. Alternatively, the beam is made up, set in place and the joists on both sides toe nailed.

In cheap spec house construction I have seen 2 x8's used instead of 2 x 10's for floor joists on 12-14' spans. These floors are bouncy but plenty strong.

I have never seen a house built with piers or posts supporting the center beam as close as 7'. For this shop application every 10' along the center beam would be more than adequate to provide stiffness.

That said, it is difficult and risky to persuade a framer to do anything out of what they consider normal from their experience. If I was to hire a shop to be made and I wasn't doing it myself I would hire a competent framer and let them do what ever they were accustomed to doing so long as a 20' span had some kind of a center beam for stiffness.

Framing lumber is the cheapest part of a house and I never skimp there. A crummy floor covering can be easily replaced, but it can be impossible to fix a framing deficiency.

Re: wooden shop floors

#42

Differences

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Beams in my house are full span (up to 24') nailed glue-ups of four 2x10 No. 2 Doug Fir set on 7' oc lollies with the first floor joists of 2x12 that are lapped 2' either side of the mid-line and angle-nailed.

Bill, your picture seems to show your joist notched where it meets the beam, and I'd have to wonder why since support-wise, it would turn a 2x10 into a 2x8. At least you're using KD stock rather than that green crap HD sells

Re: wooden shop floors

#43

I believe you are over simplifying...

John in NM

"Bill, your picture seems to show your joist notched where it meets the beam, and I'd have to wonder why since support-wise, it would turn a 2x10 into a 2x8."

Doesn't work quite like that structurally, since the effect in this case is very localized (being adjacent to a larger supporting member), and only reduces the depth in terms of local shear rather than the bending moment of the joist as a whole.

I do not have a code book handy, being at work for a couple more days, but I recall the standard for notching like this to be no more than 1/6th the depth of the joist - which would be over 1.5" on a 2x10 joist. That may be more a case of "cumulative wisdom" than actual code, I couldn't say without research - I'm sure one of our construction professionals could provide a deeper insight on the subject.

Re: wooden shop floors

#44

Re: The Notch

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I understand the notch, to bring the joist level with the beam, but doing that way you put most of the load on that 2x2 and the nails holding it on the beam. In post and beam construction (rare in my area) the joists are notched into the beams which are, in turn, notched into the posts.

Perhaps we have a slight confusion in terms, because what I've been referring to as a "beam" may also be known as a "girder". Frames that I've done and seen around here carry the joists on top, not butted up to them.

Were I doing a post and beam frame, similar to Bill's picture, I'd be looking for some moosey hangers to transfer the full load on the joist to the beam.

Re: wooden shop floors

#45

Re: I've seen that subflooring for sale...

FredD

Some things about 1-1/8th plywood decking which while it is the subfloor of choice on the west coast , must not have made it's way back east.

It's very available here in Kansas.

The reasons it is so popular are two fold , one ,because of it's thickness makes it legal subflooring for any spans up to 48" OC.

I would for a shop, drop down to 32" or 24 " depending on the anticipated floor load.

The second reason and the one that makes it a labor efficient product is that in the 241 grade , you need not purchase underlayment , thereby doing two jobs with one pass.

Because of the size of it , it is more costly then interior grades of ply, but when you subtract the number of joists or beams needed because of it's span capability and not have to purchase underlayment for finish flooring , you have the most cost effective and strongest wood decking available for your money.

There is nothing out there that comes close in comparison and that makes it the subflooring of choice for subdivisions and one off housing when a suspended floor is part of the building.

FredD

Re: wooden shop floors

#46

Re: The Notch

FredD

Mark is correct about the notch reducing the joist load carrying down one size and in addition to that notched joists are frowned on because of the tendency for a split to start at the point of the notch and continued down the lenght for some distance and ruining the joist.

Any competent building official or builder will require a ledger placed under the notched joists, which restores the joist back to it's original load bearing capacity.

Mark is also correct about maximum spacing for pier supports under beams or girders, 7 feet is the max.

AS for confusion in terms, a true post and girder or beam support system is far and away the most used on the West coast and it consists of posts set on concrete piers to carry 4x6 girders , which in most cases are set 48 " O.C . to accommodate the aforementioned 1-1/8th subflooring.

Also I believe you will find that OSB or wafer board makes a pitiful subfloor unless it is covered with a sturdy finish flooring.

FredD

Re: wooden shop floors

#47

Re: wooden shop floors - What an education!

Carol Reed

Thanks. You guys are incredible! What an education I am getting! I talked with a licensed contractor today. He is coming up Wednesday to look at some interior work I need done. We have visited at length in different settings over the past year. We have also begun talking about the shop building. He is amendable to building it with the features I want and spread out over the time span I hope to have the money coming it to pay for this out of pocket. The idea for right now is to have a weathered in shell done before next winter.

Today I ran into him, which is why he is coming to finish my interior work with regard to the kitchen reno. I have seriously aggravated my back and nerve issues from the car wreck nine years ago and am restricted with regard to arm and shoulder movement. Unfortunately I cannot help with this shop building if I expect to be able to use the shop when it is finally done. Or, maybe that is a good thing! :\

He told me he would not even consider an I-joist floor. And he told me why. He also said it was my money and if that is what I wanted he could do the job, but he considered it an inappropriate application of that particular product. Think I will listen to whatever else he might have to say.

Thanks, guys. You have been most informative and I have learned a lot. Now I get to do yet another Sketch-Up drawing! :D :)

Re: wooden shop floors

#48

Excellant Idea

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Besides, it doesn't sound like you're in shape to be lumping 2x, pounding big nails, or hoisting trusses, let alone sheathing and roofing.

Your builder should give you options on most everything from materials to methods. Feel free to come back here for input on weighing them.