Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

wooden shop floors

Posts

wooden shop floors

#1

wooden shop floors

Carol Reed

So as not to hijack the other shop floor thread... which is about wood over concrete.

I am planning a wood floor, basically 3/4" sturdi-floor over engineered I joists on stem walls.

My question is about the rated load. What do you knowledgeable folks recommend for a live load for a shop floor? No extraordinary machines, just the usual stuff. No old, heavy iron.

I know I will need the floor engineered (and certified for the county inspectors), but right now I am drawing the shop in Sketch-Up and estimating costs.

And FWIW, the planned building is 20' x 30'. Best I can do without cutting trees down.

Re: wooden shop floors

#2

JL

Re: wooden shop floors

JL

My friend Mike built his using 3/4" flooring over engineered joists. He ended up doubling all of his flooring material and staggering seams.



It's been a couple of years with no sag.


I'm not saying you have to double the flooring. He preferred doing it that way to compensate for his heavier tools (15" planer, 3 hp Grizzly, 16" band saw). He got his flooring material at a surplus place for a very reasonable sum ($10/sheet or less).

Re: wooden shop floors

#3

Re: wooden shop floors

Ray - Middletown, IN

Your engineered flooring supplier will calculate your loads for you. When I got my quotes all the box stores figured the load requirements and all came up with similar results. A couple warned against making the floor too stiff but I don't remember why. I can't imagine it being a problem in the shop though. If I were putting down a wood floor for a shop I would use the 1 - 1/8 stuff, just because.

Ray

Re: wooden shop floors

#4

think vertically 

mdclor

Re: wooden shop floors

#5

Re: wooden shop floors

Carol Reed

I know they will, Ray.

However, they will also try to sell me what they have, meaning what I am asking for will be dismissed. School of hard knocks. Woman shopping for men stuff class 101.

The county is being very specific with regard to a permit that this building not be habitable. And I have not yet asked them about floor loads. They did have specified roof loads for snow and wind.

Home Depot, basically the only show for a 100 miles around, is reluctant to get me any information without an order. A catch 22 situation. I am going to push them for direct contact with the supplier. It irritates me mightily that I have to go through a person who knows even less than I do!

So I wanted to know going in what I should be asking for.

Re: wooden shop floors

#6

Re: wooden shop floors

John K Jordan

Carol,

You might ask an architect or architectural engineer. I am fortunate to have an architect friend. When planning my shop, I told him what I planned to put on the wooden floor. This will have a 20' span using engineered trusses over a basement. They specified two layers of 3/4" t&g ply, the second layer arranged so the seams do not line up with the first.

Another time, I contacted a local architectural engineer to verify the beam size I would need to support a 16' roof span. He charged a reasonable fee to do the calculations and send me a drawing. Although he was local, our contact was by phone and email so I'm sure you could work with someone any where in the country.

JKJ

Re: wooden shop floors

#7

Re: wooden shop floors

Carol Reed

Thanks, John, but no architect friends here.

And the county is far to myopic to accept the opinion of someone outside of the area. That came clear while I was at the permit office asking questions. There clearly is a 'local network' of builders who are not questioned about what they do, and who advise the county workers about what ought to be.

True story - from a county worker in the permit office, female yet, "Honey, why don't you just have one of the local boys build it for you?"

Re: wooden shop floors

#8

Re: wooden shop floors

Barry Irby

Carol, I'm sure its worse for women, but that attitude is not gender specific. Sometimes I get better treatment if I show up wearing "work" clothes than if I am wearing a suit and tie. (What would and idiot in a suit know abut truss joists? We can tell him anything or nothing.)

What is it you want to know about the floor system? If you want info on Truss joists or floor trusses you can download the Manuals for them. See if you can find out what brand HD is selling and then hunt them down online and download the manual. It will be fifty pages or more. It will have span charts and all kinds of installation details that are largely ignored by "them local boys, Honey."

These materials are sold as "Engineered" products. You submit your plans and HD submits them to the engineers who look up the product in the charts and tell you what to use. This creates something of a conflict. If the Engineers are to sticky on the fine points, the local good ole boys will tell them to stick it and buy their stuff from some place not so touchy. The joists are somewhat expensive anyway, so they are under pressure not to over engineer them.

A common problem is they leave out the "squash blocks" and or web stiffeners. (ask me if you want more details)

Another problem is they won't give specific answers. A local builder built a house for a friend of mine (Honey) that is up on pilings at the river. The beams and joist are clearly marked "For Interior Use Only". and yet, there they are, ten feet up holding up her house but exposed to the weather. Water drools off the perimeter ones every time it rains. They are squirming in every direction. No one wants to clearly define "Interior".

Your joists will vary in size according to the span, the spacing, and the load. This is not a calculation, but if you use two layers of 5/8" Plytanium OSB over joists on either 16" or 24" centers you will be fine. I know this from experience. The 1 1/8" stuff might work as well, but I have no experience with it.

Unless you have heavy old iron I don't thing tools will be a problem.

Watch out for storage. If you happen to have a thousand feet or more of lumber to store you should design it into the structure. Be sure to check out the roof trusses. They are not always designed for storage, but they can be. and put in those square block even if you do it yourself. Very little cost, easy, and good insurance.

Re: wooden shop floors

#9

safe vs rigid

Bill Tindall

I am not an engineer and fortunately don't have to contend with governments to build anything. That said, there is a great deal of structural difference between a floor strong enough to not collapse and one that doesn't vibrate/bounce.

Unless you pile a few thousand bdft of lumber in the shop nothing you would put in there would challenge typical house framing which if I remember correctly is rated 50lbs/sq.ft. A table saw is no more load that two fat people dancing at a party. I've stored several thousand bdft of lumber on 2 x 8 joists.

Depending on your tolerance to bouncy vibrating floors you may want to substantially increase the rigidity of the structure by various means. Old fashion "bridging" is a cheap way to stiffen a joist framed floor and I am sure there are other means to the end.

Re: wooden shop floors

#10

Re: wooden shop floors

Carol Reed

Thanks, Barry. You understand perfectly.

I did download Weyerhauser's pdf on I-joists. I am trying to figure out what applies. I will check with HD to see who they order from.

Can you help a little more with live load and dead load? The minimum seems to be 40 PSF. I had expected to use the 1x12's 16" OC with one layer of 3/4" Sturdi-floor, with ample bridging and their manufactured 1 1/4" rim boards. These would perch on concrete block pylons. The building will sit on 12 (3 rows of 4 each) pylons to conform to the undulating land. I live on a mountain. Think rock!

I took that set-up from my house which is built the same way, except for solid wood joists. I did read about the pinch blocks. I take that to mean that mid-beam supports remain tight to the beam.

Thanks for the heads up on exterior applications. As for the roof trusses, they will be a scissors truss so I can have ordinary 8 foot walls but enough overhead turning over room, if you know what I mean. The exterior of the building cannot look like an RV garage! In fact, it cannot even have a garage type door. Falls under another code.

And for the record, the next time I hear 'honey' I would prefer that it be whispered in my ear by a hunka hunka under the sheets. Certainly not a female clerk at the county planning and permit department!

Re: wooden shop floors

#11

Re: safe vs rigid

Carol Reed

Thanks, Bill.

If I had a "few thousand board feet" of lumber to store, I'd need a license for operating a lumber yard here in Arizona! :D :D

I planned on bridging, it being highly recommended for the I-joists.

Re: wooden shop floors

#12

Re: wooden shop floors

Barry Irby

Carol, I have reached the age (I guess) where they are starting to call me "Hun" pronounced Hunnnn. It would be a lot better between the sheets, not through the speaker at Wendy's.

There are a number of applications of pinch/squash blocks etc. These are I joists, right. Top and bottom chords of wood or laminated wood about 2 x 3 with a web of OSB. They are light and strong and excellent in span, but not so good in direct vertical compression. If you put enough load vertically on the tip end of them, the OSB fails and compresses. In the early days they did not have the rim joist and you were supposed to install a vertical block of 2 x 4 beside each one (in some circumstances) to support the weight of the structure above. They were to be abut a 1/16" taller than the height of the joists. (This is framing, so what's a 1/16 among friends, just ignore it). The rim joists are manufactured now and generally solve that problem The weight of the sidewalls is borne by the rim and the tips of the joists only support the joists and created the bearing necessary to support the floor load. (Web blocks did the same thing, but they were cut to fit beside the web and support the to Chord.)

There are lots of cutting details and details for holes. If you are not having ducts and plumbing penetratign them you should not have much concern about that. Most of them come with knock out plugs stamped into the webs for wiring. The essential rule is, do not cut or otherwise mangle the top and bottom chords.

If you are supporting the perimeter on piers, you need a structural rim joist. I am not sure but I don't think the rim joist you mentioned is meant to span from pier to pier. Double check that. They do let them span across the door through the crawl space, but I think they are just ignoring that. You may need to go to LVL beams. You may also need to use hangers to hang the joists off the beams. Unless you put the beams on the piers and then the joists on top of the beams, but this has the effect of raising the building. This is also the circumstance (lower but similar) my friend had at her house. You can buy the beams made of treated laminations if necessary. It would be cheaper to use regular treated lumber or the beams and I joists for the floor. Might actually be cheaper to use regular lumber for all of it.

One of the problems with the new engineered lumber is that it really does have so "quirks" about how you use it and install it and a lot of it gets done by good ole boys who have never seen the manual. If ole whats his name can use them, me too.

Re: wooden shop floors

#13

Question about "engineered" floors....why?

Bill Tindall

What is the advantage of an "engineered" floor over convention joists, or truss roof over rafters for that matter?

Perspective: I have built numerous structures (houses, barns, sheds, etc) over the years and they all have been built with conventional framing, floor joists and rafter roofs. I know that lumber will last for ever and I don't know that the glue holding some composite together was done right or will last. Witness the number of sheets of plywood construction material I have seen delaminate in use. As far as a roof, if it is framed with rafters it becomes useful storage space. I have 2 000 bdft of lumber sitting on rafters as we speak. A great place to "kiln dry" lumber in the summer.

I have heard the argument of cost but every time I have run the numbers convention framing was not significantly different, especially considering the time to rebuild mis-constructed trusses and other factory parts issues. Someone that knows what they are doing can roof a simple hip or gable house roof in two days or less, not a huge labor difference by my reckoning, and decking a joist house floor is a day job, or less. The last trusses I was involved with for a neighbors job involved 1/4 of a day fixing them. If the floor is at ground level one can use 2 x 8 with center piers and the result will be rigid as concrete. We have stored 10,000 bd ft of lumber on 12' x16'- 2 x 8 joist floor with center piers.

Framing lumber is exceptionally cheap right now. This is what I would be using to build roofs or floors, presuming you can find an old carpenter that knows how to cut rafters on the ground and hand them up to someone to nail to the ridge pole.

Re: wooden shop floors

#14

Re: Question about "engineered" floors....why?

Carol Reed

Bill, you live in a lumber rich area of the country. And I think in an earlier post you admitted that you don't have a permitting process. Having said that...

I don't like the permitting process either, but a fire insurance policy is money flushed down the toilet if a new structure is not built with the permit. Right or wrong! And I live sandwiched between two badly managed national forests. It is hard to even get fire insurance and if for some reason you lose it, it is near impossible to reinstate it. No right or wrong about it. Just a fact of life living hee.

About the lumber: The structural lumber we get here is a sorry lot to say the least. It is shipped in wet, and once the band is snapped, its turns into pretzels within minutes. Processed in the wet NW and used in the arid desert of Arizona. And beyond 8' 2x4's nothing is available kiln dried.

So engineered lumber is more stable. The roof trusses are 2x lumber with the metal webs stamped in on both sides. They have the engineered specs which also have to be on file with the county.

Then there are the workers. What we have for framers are English speaking challenged folks with no training and very bad habits. They listen to what you want and then do what they want. I just went through this with my kitchen re-do. The old talented guys are just that - old. And retired!

What's a poor girl to do? :\ All I wanted was a new shop! And I discover I have to be up for a continuing string of battles to get what I want. But I cannot fight without knowledge and that's where all you talented folks come in!

So thanks, guys and gals.

Re: wooden shop floors

#15

old carpenters

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"...presuming you can find an old carpenter that knows how to cut rafters on the ground..."

There are a few young ones that know. A few.

Re: wooden shop floors

#17

Re: Question about "engineered" floors....why?

FredD

"I have 2 000 bdft of lumber sitting on rafters as we speak. A great place to "kiln dry" lumber in the summer. " ??

A couple of things about rafters cut and stacked versus Factory built Trusses.

While I like cut and stacked roofs , mainly because it keeps the Carpenter work on site and because while a seven gable roof can be a many splendored thing , it is a nightmare for Trusses.

That being said , Carol is going with a scissor truss which a rafter/joist can't do to increase her ceiling clearence.

My shop has ten foot side walls and scissor Truss roof framingfor that reason.

Trusses also eliminate the need for a continuous ridge with support every ten feet minimum.

Trusses come with a engineers calcs for the building department, rafters don't

and rely on the builder / inspector for maximum strength for the span.

About the floor material , two layers of 5/8ths plywood is not near as strong as one course of 1-1/8th plywood , unless you want to go to the trouble of bonding the two layers.

Even then two layers of anything is twice the work of one layer of construction grade 1-1/8th plywood installation wise and if you use the best grade of that called 241 because it has no voids and is suitable for direct laying of sheet goods like Linoleum without a layer of underlayment, you do two operations with one installation.

About the Building departments concern of it's being a habitable structure, in the areas I have built , this is generally taken to mean , no Kitchen setup because it would violate the single family zoning in providing another residence.

The building department should allow for Hobby shop buildings , even allowing a WC and laundry tray room.

If the zoning prohibits any other structure besides a storage building , you have your work cut out for you.

It may work in your favor to subtly suggest that you may not be getting the same and equal service from them that they offer male contractors which of course as you are aware, is a no - no, State and Federal.

Lots of luck

FredD

Re: wooden shop floors

#18

Framing Square

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

A real-world example of an oxymoron. They are prominently placed in lumberyard tool displays but sold exclusively to homeowners to perpetuate the myth that one was ever used by the idiot/alcoholic/drug addict who built their residence.

Re: wooden shop floors

#19

Re: wooden shop floors *LINK*

Galen Vetterick

Carol

Think you can sure do your floor with conventional lumber and to me it would be easier. You might look at the attached link. Setting on 12 piers your beams only need span 10 feet so 2 x 8 grade 2 pine sufficient and the girders setting on the piers can be 6 x 8 treated beams as they will carry your beams ends over 10 feet. All easily carry 50 psf and 15 psf dead load.

Just for thought. If you do not wish to set on treated beams if a hight issue then double up 2 x 10 as perimeter and triple center support and hang joist with metal hangers.

Just rough thoughts.

Galen


http://www.raisedfloorlivingpro.com/spantables.shtml

Re: wooden shop floors

#20

Re: Framing Square

FredD

Not a myth Mark, Carpenters and Stair builders use them everyday.

If you can't use one or the Essex board measure table on one or know which way to hold one ,that's alright , if your limited to what sounds like rehab programs faking housing , I could see how you might have a dim view of the industry in your bailiwick.

Framing squares aren't all created equal.

Right off the bat many are not true nineties , if they are Aluminum or thin steel , they basically useless.

If they are about 1/8th " thick steel and have the Essex Board measure table and the peening marks where Stanley or Starrett adjusted them for true right angle in a dark room with light on the side away from the factory quality control guy, who places the square against a Granite block and adjusted until no light shows between the square and the Granite and if the square has a inch divided into hundredths , then you can say ,you have a Framing Square.

Or you can buy a Swanson Speed Square made from Aluminum and useful forcutting most used roof angles on Rafters.

Or if you cut roofs for a living for awhile like I did , you would use a Saw Protractor to set precise angles in degrees rather then rise in inches to foot of run that a Square uses, but I digress.

FredD

Re: wooden shop floors

#21

A couple points...

John in NM

1. Find a different lumber yard. Some of the best framing lumber I've seen since I lived in Maine came from the Mogion Rim. I bought it at a small yard run by a guy who was interested in lumber. Now you may not get that lucky, but if you shop around down in Phoenix, I bet you can find a place that will beat HD on quality.

2. If your potential carpenters are that bad, find a different contractor, get and check references. An experienced crew that knows their business is well worth paying a little extra for. If you're handling the permitting yourself, you may be able to find and hire good carpenters on your own if you ask around.

Biggest thing with engineered joists is to control the bounce. The span tables used for selecting a product will have a ratio of deflection over span, and since the spans tend to be huge with these things, the deflection can be large and still be within spec. I'd suggest going with the smallest deflection possible on a 20' span, over that kind of span you will notice it.

Our house was basically the same as what you describe - 20' wide joist over crawlspace. I went with a central beam on piers and 10' 2x10 joists, 16" OC if I remember correctly, it ended up being cheaper than engineered lumber and well within code. You wouldn't even need it that beefy, as you probably aren't putting tile in your shop :D

Re: wooden shop floors

#22

Re: Square Framing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Not to worry, Fred, I know how to use "squares". Wish the wastrels who built my house had, however.

I live in a mid-80's "kit" house where all the exterior framing was factory made and trucked in. Unfortunately, that didn't help the bozo nailpounders who couldn't even figure out how to put "Tab A into Slot A" with written directions and an architect's plans, let alone frame a partition wall. When I gutted and redid the master bath, I had to sister a stud for every joint in the new rock because the existing framing was racked almost 1-1/2" out of plumb in 8' of height, and it was rare to find studs 16oc. It was also interesting figuring out how to hide the differential of walls that spread almost 1-1/2" in 15' from their opposites. Not too surprising, however, after finding four roaches and a couple of Bud cans left on the wall plates.

I have yet to find a corner in my house that is actually square.

Re: wooden shop floors

#23

Correction...

John in NM

If you're still in Snowflake, look to Flag for lumber (I should have hauled up a map sooner). You might not be able to get it delivered free, but you might find better results worth the delivery cost. The only lumber I buy at HD is 2x4's and then only when they have good ones.

Building in a rural area, I bought a horrible old flat bed truck from a friend, and I'm glad I did - it gave me a lot of supply options I would not have considered otherwise, and I'm probably about even on delivery charges vs purchase price and gas, even with it being such a gas hog.

Re: wooden shop floors

#24

exactly

Bill Tindall

Lumber is a national commodity. The "SPF" lumber we get here, or my brother gets in NY, could easily be from the same northwest mill that supplies yards in the southwest. If her area is typical, the contractors are not buying from a national chain store, but from some local or regional source that caters to the needs of contractors. There is little question that this source(s) supplies lumber that can successfully used for floor joists and rafters.

And your point on stiffness is spot on. If the structure can accommodate a center beam(made up on site) and piers, a 2 x8 joist floor will provide rock solid rigidity. 2x10 on a 10' span would be overkill, but little additional cost. Even if what my brother refers to as wet spaghetti joists (those limber plywood I-beam things) are used I would go to great effort to get some piers in the center of the span to control the bounce and vibration. I can picture a table saw with a bit of vibration resonating with the floor like a drum head.

Re: wooden shop floors

#25

Late response

Jorge Casta�eda

Carol,

I am a pro builder, I had to use engineered I beams in a recent job, at owners demand, they thought they were saving money. The sales people talk them into those and 1/2" chipboard for underfloor and a thin bamboo finish floor; I protested and suggested a true and tried floor structure and underfloor, 2" x 10" spruce and 1 1/8" underfloor plywood, explaining that, first they are big and heavy and what they were asking for was to be very bouncy and would fail eventually.

They did no listen and my prophecy came true on the house warming party, when a bunch of big people dancing got the scare of their lives when some of the I beams fractured and the floor sag.

Call me old fashioned, I stick to what I know it works, 2"x10" fits the bill for me, in short spans even 2"x8" in long spans go to 2" x 12".

Jorge