Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

OT - Photo editing software

Posts

OT - Photo editing software

#1

OT - Photo editing software

Darrin

Okay All,

I rarely post, prefering to lurk. I am looking for your opinions on which editing software is the best. The full Photoshop package is out of the running, I can't afford it. I have been looking at PS Elements 8. I have been using the freeware version of Photofiltre. Any suggestions, before I pull the trigger. Thank you.

Darrin

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#2

What do you want to do with it?

Gary Smyth

I had a similar question recently and I ask because what I wanted to do turned out to need full Photoshop. Most of the suggestions offered here were very helpful for part of what I wanted, but none except Photoshop and a drum scan could get me the grid lines, scalability, noise reduction, and manipulation. If dollars count (and rarely do they not) photo storage might be one software, enlargements another, and editing manipulation still another. In many cases, megapixels really do matter. For the present I'm hanging in storage mode by a fingernail with Picasa but I know that that is just a "hold".

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#3

Re: OT - Photo editing software

Dan Donaldson

As mentioned, it depends on what you want to do. GIMP has a lot of the capability of Photoshop and has the advantage of being free.

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#4

Re: What do you want to do with it?

Darrin

Gary,

As soon as I hit the post button, I knew that there was a lack of info. For the most part, Photofiltre has done what I needed. As I found the other day though, as I was working on a black and white shot, I wanted to burn in the sky on a shot with some prairie grass. I could adjust contrast, but it didn't allow the option to edit elements of the photo. In short, I want to be able to work on details in the photo without affecting the entire shot. If this helps, this is what I shoot. If this is not appropriate, Moderators or Ellis please edit.

http://www.dsnyderfinearts.com/

Thanks,

Darrin

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#5

Re: OT - Photo editing software

Darrin

I want to be able to go in and edit parts of a shot, burn in the sky, etc. When I searched the archives, there did not seem to be much in the way of detail description. That's fine, it's OT. I have been leaning towards getting Elements 8 and seeing what that does for me. Thanks.

Darrin

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#6

Clint Searl

Re: OT - Photo editing software

Clint Searl

Elements is comprehensive enough and easy enough to use that I would make it the first choice. I used it for several years before moving to the full PS because Adobe offered an upgrade for under $200. Don't know if they will ever repeat it.

Clint

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#7

Re: OT - Photo editing software

Howard Norman

I am using PS Elements 6 and it does what I need.

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#8

Re: OT - Photo editing software

Ken Krawford

I've been using Elements for the past 6 months and really like it. The more I use it the better I have become. I took a class a couple of month ago and got a lot out of it. I'd be willing to bet that it would do 98% of what you want.

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#9

Re: OT - Photo editing software

Bob Lemon

If you download 'Photofiltre' (free) (spelling is correct!), you will have a very powerful, easy to use, photo program. After importing an image, right click the mouse, one of the options is 'size'. Increase or decrease in either pixels or inches the size., Next change the number of pixels per inch. Change it to 72.00. This gives good resolution on a computer screen. Also adjust the brightness, contrast, sharpness, etc. When you have the picture looking the way you want, right click again, click 'save as'. It will ask for a destination, I usually save to the Desktop. The image does not go directly to the desktop, instead you get another window which allows you to check and set compression. After setting, click OK and the picture will go to the destination folder. It will still appear in photofiltre. You can click on the 'x' to close the picture.

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#10

Re: OT - Photo editing software

paul in AZ

For what sounds like dodging and burning-in of selected areas of an image you might look at Nikon Capture NX. It has what they call 'control points' where you can define an area you want to alter and then manipulate the usual things without altering the rest of the shot. Useful for things like backlit, over/underexposed or contrasty areas. The altered area is automatically blended into the original image so you don't see any transition. The rest of the program is a decent editing program, easy to use and pretty intuitive [for me]. It does tend to be slow though.

I'm one of those who tried Photoshop, hated it, went to Elements but could never get my head around their arcane programming and finally gave up on both.

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#11

Re: OT - Photo editing software

John K Jordan

Darrin,

I too think Photoshop Elements is a good choice. I have used the full Photoshop for many years and could not work without it, but the Elements version has most of the features and will do what you mentioned. I've bought Elements as gifts for friends and it certainly is cheap enough.

One advantage of Photoshop over some other capable programs is PS is the "standard" in the industry - help and tips and books are available everywhere. And because it is the software of choice for professionals everywhere, it's continued development is pretty much assured.

JKJ

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#12

Re: OT - Photo editing software

Darrin

Thanks Guys.

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#13

Re: OT - Photo editing software *LINK*

Kevin Stanbary in McHenry, IL

FWIW Adobe lets you install a 30 full featured free trial of Photoshop Elements; I am running a trial now in hopes I can get it to tag photos the way I want.

I'd say install it and try it out - if it works, buy it.


Photoshop Elements 8

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#14

Re: OT - Photo editing software

Bill Howatt

Tagging photos is one area I would be very careful about because you can literally put in many, many hours going through all your photos doing it and possibly finding out down the road that the program is inadequate and a better one means starting over from scratch.

There are some protocols such as IPTC that write the tags into the header of the photo file and hopefully can then be imported into a different program lthat will be able to use them. I am using a program, PicaJet, right now that is actually quite good but it seems to have fallen off the radar in terms of upgrades which is unfortunate. I am now considering a switch to IDimager possibly but not sure when I'll make the move.

I wish I could be more informative but I've been down the "re-do the tags" road before and I never want to do it again.

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#15

Re: OT - Photo editing software

David Hay Denver

Picking a photo cataloging program is, in some ways, more important than picking a particular editor to use, for the reason you suggest. It can be difficult to move from one catalog to another. In the case of Photoshop Elements, it has a way to write all your keyword tags into your photos (not sure if it uses IPTC or the EXIF fields) that most good cataloging applications should be able to read.

David

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#16

Re: OT - Photo editing software

Mike in VA

What Paul in AZ said, on Nikon Capture NX2. I've been using it to edit scanned 35 mm slides and negatives, and it works very well.

It works faster if you have a lot of RAM installed (I have 4 GB).

Nikon offers a free, full function trial, that is good for a month or so.

Amazon had the best price.

Re: OT - Photo editing software

#17

Re: OT - Photo editing software

Jim Dillon

Lots of good advice and suggestions. I currently use NX2, LR2, and to a much less extent PSCS4. In the past, I have used PaintShop Pro, SilkyPix, and PSE7. No question, CS4 will get the job done - at a price. For what you are considering, I would vote for NX2 and its incredible U-point technology. It is reasonably priced, but does need a lot of RAM and CPU horsepower to work efficiently - especially when you are batch processing. But for one-image-at-a-time, it is hard to beat, IMHO. It is available as a trial, which I suggest you try as some do not like its GUI. A more complete package, though more expensive, is LR2. Like NX2, it will allow you to dodge and burn selected areas, plus many other editing options. I find its local editing to be cumbersome, compared to NX2's U-point technology, but it has a LOT of nice features other than image editing; I especially like its Library (browsing) and Printing modules. LR3 is due out this spring, maybe. Although I am a NX2 advocate (especially if you are editing Nikon NEF files), LR2 offers a more well-rounded program - at roughly three times the price of NX2, and is much faster as it handles image files differently than NX2. Having said all this, if you want to remove Aunt Clara's head and substitue Aunt Jane's head in the picture, CS4 is the tool to use. Hope this helps.

Jim