Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

OT - Census Gottcha

Posts

OT - Census Gottcha

#1

OT - Census Gottcha

Carol Reed

At the time of the 2000 census, a friend got a part-time job tracking down those who did not answer and those who failed to answer completely.

He loved the many people who felt the government didn't need to know... the more people who took that attitude, the longer his part-time job lasted! In his case, it lasted nearly 2-1/2 years.

The fox guards the henhouse with regard to tort reform. The lawyers make the rules and the penalties. No matter the case, we pay. Remember the old Fram filter commercial? "Pay us now or pay us later?"

Being arrested, jailed, or fined for thwarting the government might be a long shot, but in the end, it costs us all money! And more than it needs to when we make it harder for them to get what they asked for, and passed laws so we must comply. Not suggesting they are "right." Simply saying that until we effect changes, that's the way things are. And they are betting we won't go to the trouble of effecting changes. So far they are winning.

Pogo had it right. We are the enemy. For those of us old enough to remember Pogo!

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#2

Why the census is important

wilbur

For anyone who might have the idea that the census is not important to our system of government, the census was important enough to the Founding Fathers to make it the sixth sentence in the Constitution. The Constitution talks about the census even before talking about the Senate, the President, or the Supreme Court.

The results of the census are used to determine how resources are allocated. For example, if enough low income people in an area decide to not report their income, or over report their income, it will look like not many lower income people live in that area of the country.

So when it comes time to decide where to implement programs to help lower income families, that area will get passed over because the data will show that that particular area doesn't need any help.

In other cases, roads don't get built or maintained, because not enough people get serviced by the road. Cable companies decide not to extend service to an area, because not enough people live there. Or a state might lose a representative or two in the House of Representatives because not enough people live in the state.

So it's in everyone's best interest to completely and accurately fill out that census form. After all, you only have to do it once every 10 years. If it takes you two hours to fill it out, that works out to 2/1000 of 1% of that period of time.

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#3

Re: Why the census is important

George, Oxford, NC

There must be more than one census form. It took me ten minutes to fill out the one I received and there were no questions about income.

George

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#4

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

There is more than one form.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Someone on another forum I frequent posted a link to a .pdf file of the long form. The first few pages look identical to the short form, then there are questions about income, age of the residence (building), and so on.

I should also mention that no "census" is directed in the Constitution--only an enumeration.

I thought the short form was too intrusive, and I had to use the "Other" checkbox for my race because they didn't have "Human" listed. They didn't get our names or my telephone number.

I'll stop now, because this one really gets my blood boiling.

Jason

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#6

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

I have, in the long ago past, spent many happy hours in the stacks of the Wisconsin Historical Society Library using US Census material to bolster papers, etc., with personal and manufacturing statistics. It is an excellent source of information on all sorts of esoteric subjects. The material is invaluable when tracking trends on almost, not quite, every subject. Everything in anonymous. No names at all of people or companies. This material is needed and used, not only academics, but by manufacturers and other businessmen as well.

By law the Census Bureau cannot give out names to anyone including other government agencies.

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#7

12 people in my house

John Lucas

When I filled out the form I noticed that they had room for 12 people so I wrote in the names of 10 Mexicans to fill it up. :)

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Heh-heh.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I wonder, after this census, how many Elvis Presleys and Jimmy Hoffas there will be in this country. :D

Jason

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#9

Re: OT - Census Gotcha

Barry Irby

Robert, You said "This material is needed and used, not only academics, but by manufacturers and other businessmen as well."

As an aside to the argument about whether the government should be collecting the information or not and how much etc, I read an article about the guy that really put Sears on the map. He was an army officer (General?) stationed in some remote location (Philippines?) back in the day, about a 100 years ago. He had no reading material except for some reason he had a copy of the Census. Out of boredom he studied thoroughly. After getting out the army, he got a job with Sears and because he was intimately familiar with the Census, he knew where they should plan for growth and where to build stores. He is the on who put them on the map. And now I can't remember the name. Wonder if it was Roebuck?

While all this information is valuable to companies, academics, and the government, I still have mixed feelings about it.

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#10

Re: Heh-heh.

Barry Irby

I read the book Freakonomics. If you haven't looked at it, it is fascinating.

One of the things they reported on was that back in the day you did not have to get a Social Security number for your child until they were 18. (Whatever) They decided to require them at birth. That year thousands and thousands of kids disappeared. They just went away. Turns out, people were claiming imaginary children on there taxes to get the deductions but when the crack down came, the kids left this astral plane.

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#11

I hate to be the one to tell you... *LINK*

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

The government already has your name, address telephone number, social security number and lots of other info on you. You are also easy to locate on the internet. Here's where you live....and that's not even from the government :b


Here's where you live!

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: I hate to be the one to tell you...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Nah, Lee, you didn't tell me anything new. The point is the principle of it. I'm tired of everybody needing to know everything about me for simple transactions, and "for my convenience". This includes the government. So, on my part, I will continue to gently resist, according to what I believe to be right. Would I like others to do the same? Sure. Do I think they should? That's up to them, I won't get pushy.

Besides, that link you posted got my age wrong. ;)

Jason

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#13

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

AZ, Colorado Springs

The constitution directs an enumeration of the people because the house of representatives is based on proportionate representation of the popluation. You gotta know where the people are to draw the boundaries fairly.

There have been ads on the radio lately talking about the census and the number of traffic lights, and the number of schools, and the number of libraries in the community. I don't think Franklin, Madison, and the others were worried about traffic lights in 1790.

The ads are designed to prevent us thinking about how the politicians are going to use the census information to try and bolster their party's standing.

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#14

How to complete a census *LINK*

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

The census people really missed to boat in not using this for their PSA.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7XtuPvwBa2U

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#15

Not just an enumeration

wilbur

It is constitutional to include questions in the decennial census beyond those concerning a simple count of the number of people. On numerous occasions, the courts have said the Constitution gives Congress the authority to collect statistics in the census.

As early as 1870, the Supreme Court characterized as unquestionable the power of Congress to require both an enumeration and the collection of statistics in the census. The census is one of the methods whereby the national legislature exercises its inherent power to obtain the information necessary for intelligent legislative action.

In 1901, a District Court said the Constitution's census clause (Art. 1, Sec. 2, Clause 3) is not limited to a headcount of the population and "does not prohibit the gathering of other statistics, if 'necessary and proper,' for the intelligent exercise of other powers enumerated in the constitution, and in such case there could be no objection to acquiring this information through the same machinery by which the population is enumerated."

(Paraphrased from the Census 2010 website. That may not be an impartial source, but the findings in these court decisions are as described.)

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#16

oxymoron?????

Stuart Johnson

intelligent legislative action

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#17

Re: Jason,  you need the clean the pool :-)

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#18

Re: I hate to be the one to tell you...

davhamm

Good news Jason, Whitepages / zillow and google maps all point to different houses for your address.

But zillow tells us its estimate is $167,500 and your house is 3,088 sqft and Built in 1974.

all free and available in seconds... So you can pay lots of folks at the government to collect and gather this info, or just tell them. Either way their gonna get it. And who really cares.

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#19

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: I hate to be the one to tell you...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Well, the year built is correct (as far as I know)...the other two aren't even close. ;)

I won't say anymore, because we're not supposed to go political here, other than I don't think it's necessary for the gov't to have all this info, even if it's to "help" us...

Jason

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#20

Re: Why the census is important

Larry_In_Lima

You are only required (by the Constitution) to provide the number of people living in your household. That is all. Good, bad, or in-between - that is the way it is. How much you make, what race you are, etc., is all "stuff" that has been added - "because it is important". Baaa Baaa Baaa Larry

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#21

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

Larry_In_Lima

How do you think Japanese-Americans were rounded up? There have been several other instances where census information was used - for something other than that which it was collected for.... Larry

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#22

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

Howard Norman

How do you think Japanese-Americans were rounded up? There have been several other instances where census information was used - for something other than that which it was collected for.... Larry

If FDR rounded up all of those Japanese-Americans in WWII what makes one thing that the currant administration would not round up a group that they disagree with also?

I am 75 years old so I have participated in a lot of censuses in my lifetime. This is the first time that I am having second thoughts about filling out the form. When the Whitehouse decided that it was going to get more involved in the census this year is what started the bells to ring for me.

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#23

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Gotta wonder why the 'race' question gives six different choices for Hispanic, one for white, one for black, and about a dozen for Oriental.

How about just two choices: American or Non-American.Then they can decide what to do about the Non-Americans later...

Jim D.

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#24

Re: Why the census is important *LINK*

wilbur

You are only required (by the Constitution) to provide the number of people living in your household. That is all. Good, bad, or in-between - that is the way it is.


Actually, according to the courts, that is not true.


Court decisions on questions beyond a simple count

Re: OT - Census Gottcha

#25

Dave

Re: 12 people in my house  WHY is this funny

Dave

I don't understand your post.

Is this intended to be amusing? It seems xenophobic at best and racist at worst.

I assume that you and yours are full-blooded American Indians?

The tone of the anti-census, black helicopter paranoia in this and similar threads is truly alarming.