Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Another Glue question

Posts

Another Glue question

#1

Another Glue question

Barry Irby

Bill has been posting about how glue works.

I want to know how long it lasts???

Lets say I do an excellent job of gluing up a top or even an M&T joint with yellow glue. I have no issues with gaps, temp, moisture content, its a "perfect" joint.

How long will the joints last before the glue fails? 20 years, 50, a 100? What?

Not just yellow glue, others too. Hide, white glue, epoxy etc.

Re: Another Glue question

#2

Clint Searl

Until the twelfth of never

Clint Searl

Re: Another Glue question

#3

Clint Searl

And that's a long long time!

Clint Searl

Re: Another Glue question

#4

impossible to answer generally

Chris Friesen

Gluing up a panel is a pretty straightforward scenario, and if done properly that glue joint is unlikely to fail in the forseeable future. If the panel is restrained improperly and not allowed to contract with moisture loss it may crack, but it's just as likely to be in the wood itself as at the glue joint.

A M&T joint is different. You have crossgrain movement, racking forces, moisture/temperature effects, etc. Particularly for yellow/white glue, you can't clamp it effectively so the glue line is likely thicker than ideal. On the other hand, PVA glues have a bit of give so an abrupt shock isn't likely to crack them.

There was some discussion on this topic related to the repairability of glue joints. One school of thought was to use PVA for panels where the joint is not likely to fail and would be fairly straightforward to repair if it did fail, and a repairable glue like hide/epoxy/plastic resin for joinery.

Re: Another Glue question

#5

Re: Another Glue question

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Pieces of furniture have been removed from the pyramids in Egypt that are still in good shape. These are intricate pieces with M&T joints and intricate inlay. The key here is that the storage conditions were very constant in temperature and humidity.

PVA glue is only 90 years old and epoxy has been around for less time I think there is some compelling evidence that PVA could have a similar lifespan if stored in constant temp and humidity, and epoxy could perform the same.

Real world conditions however are not constant and that will be the test for any glue. Fluctuations in temp and humidity as well as craftsmanship are likely to contribute more to a joints longevity that the type of glue.

Robin

Re: Another Glue question

#6

Longer than I will

Jesse Cloud

Re: Another Glue question

#7

JL

Depends on the environment

JL

If the piece is in a changing environment with constant shifts of humidity and temperature, all bets are off. I just recently "rehabbed" a piece that had been stored in an attic in North GA. Just about all of the glue joints had failed. I am uncertain as to the type of glue - but the piece was built in the 1920s.

I helped a friend rehabilitate a piece that dated from the 1870s (so I am assuming hide glue). Just about all of the glue joints were intact except for the ones on the stretchers joining the front and back legs. The chair had been kept indoors.

Re: Another Glue question

#8

Perfect!, My plan is to live until the 11th....

Barry Irby

of Never and then drop dead. If everything I built fell apart 48 hours alter I think that would be pretty funny.