Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

How glue works

Posts

How glue works

#1

How glue works

Bill Tindall

I am not an expert on glue but I know people that are. The following is what I have learned from them, presuming my understanding and memory is correct.

A good glue/ adhesive has two properties. First it must wet the substrate. In this context wet means flow on its surface as opposed to beading up like rain on GorTex. Anything that wets the substrate will stick the two surfaces together if they can get close together, either because they are flat or they get mashed flat by pressure. For example water will stick two pieces of glass together as good as anything. This phenomena is called adhesion. But adhesion is only half the story.

What ever does the sticking must have some mechanical strength or what is stuck can be slid apart. Take the example of water and glass. The glass "can't" be pulled apart because of the adhesion provided by the water wetting the glass, but it can be easily slid apart because water has little mechanical strength. A good glue not only wets the substrate , it also is tough (it has good cohesion). If the stuff wetting is tough, the two substrates can not be slid apart, or pulled apart. These two properties are essential for a good glue.

There has been discussion about to role of penetration of glue into the wood and fastening the joint together by this mechanical interlocking mode. If the adhesive wets the wood penetration of the glue into pores is not required to get a strong bond. I had an opportunity to ask one of the adhesive experts at Virginia Tech whether the penetration mode was important to gluing wood with PVA glue. "Hard to say" was the answer, as I remember it. A good adhesive does not need to penetrate and form a mechanical bond. But wood is porous and glue will penetrate if it wets the surface. It is not possible to separate adhesion from the mechanical bonding mechanisms in porous wood. Either could result in a good glue, and typical wood glue will have both properties.

I don't entirely understand gaps. I know if the gap is big then the strength of the bond depends entirely on the strength of the glue, and most glue is weaker than wood. At some distance of approach of the two substrate surfaces the bond strength due to adhesion depends on closeness, which is why precision joinery and sufficient clamp pressure is important to yield a thin glue line, and hence an optimum bond. I suspect fully understanding the details is complicated. No doubt there are books on the subject but I have not studied them. Maybe if enough people assail this post I will be motivated to do so and report back.

Re: How glue works

#2

Re: How glue works

Marv

Bill,

Did you read my post "What is Adhesion"? Scroll down the page a ways. I was attempting to explain why things stick together. We are on the same page, so to speak. I was responding to your post regarding over clamping.

I think that once people understand why things adhere to each other, they will better understand the glues they use and why they work or don't work.

Marv

Re: How glue works

#3

Re: How glue works

Barry Irby

I was told somewhere along the way that we don't really know how glue works.

I wonder about the adhesion and the mechanical bond. If you tried to glue two really rough surfaces like lumber directly from the sawmill, the surface contact would not be good, even if the edges were perfectly straight. Once the edges are "smooth" much more of the surfaces are in close proximity, giving the glue a chance to rely on adhesion rather than cohesion. But even a smooth edge is not really smooth if you look under a strong lens or microscope. I would assume glue molecules are pretty small and would compare in size to the "roughness" left even on a smooth edge. Babie this is where the wetting really comes into play and the molecules fill the small cavities and form polymers (?) that link everything together.

What the people told me (the ones who said we don't know how it works) was that they were sure it did. We all know that. We all have done enough everyday tests to prove that we can make decent joints and that they work.

I personally have never had a joint fail because it was starved. At least not one I was sure was starved.

Common sense tells us that a nicely fitted joint will close better and will probably be stronger and even if it is not stronger, it will be strong enough and look better.

Re: How glue works

#4

the standard for joint strength

Bill Tindall

A well made joint with a good glue will be stronger than the wood, ie there will be 90-100% wood failure and little glue failure when the joint is broken. This is the strength we should strive for in joints.

Yellow and white glue are already polymers. They cure by water removal and coalescing of the polymer particles (like latex paint) to make a film. Epoxy and Gorilla are not and the gluing process involves polymerizing the stuff in the bottle to make a tough film.

Re: How glue works

#6

Re: How glue works

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

It sounds like you are lumping all glues in the same boat so to speak. The way PVA glue works is very different from how hot hide glue works and knowing these differences van help in achieving good results with either.

You have touched on some of the properties of PVA glue. I think it is very important to understand that PVA glue penetrates not just the pores of the wood but also the cells and more importantly the cell walls of the wood. By penetrating the cell walls the glue actually becomes part of the wood. This is both good and bad. The glue itself has very little actual shear strength; you can test this by taking a dried drip from the outside of the bottle and seeing how easily it breaks. by having a joint with the cell walls as close together as possible you are using the cohesion principle to hold the two boards together and with the glue penetrating the cell walls you are using a mechanical bond to hold the glue to the wood. The bad part is that the wood without the glue in the cell walls is more elastic and capable of expanding and contracting with changes in humidity over a greater range than the wood with the glue in the cell walls. This means that over time there can be risk of the wood structure tearing at the joint between where the glue has penetrated the cell walls and the natural cell structure.

Hot hide glue by contrast does not penetrate the cell walls and relies only on cohesion for its holding power. If you have any doubt about how effective this can be or if you think it is not very effective try pouring some hot hide clue on a piece of glass and let it dry. As we all know glass is not porous and as the glue dries it will shrink. The cohesion bond is so strong between the glue and the glass that as the glue shrinks it will take the glass with it and pop off a chip.

Most people are not familiar with a toothing plane but it is a type of plane that roughs up the surface of the wood to effectively create more surface area for the glue to bond to. It isn't a mechanical bond of the teeth but a greater surface area that makes a toothed surface better for gluing with hot hide glue. This is in contrast to a PVA glues joint with rough surfaces which has less strength than one with smooth surfaces

The strengths and weaknesses of the properties of the two glues are most strongly illustrated in an end grain to side grain joint application. With PVA glue the pores of the end grain will wick the moisture and glue away from the joint and prevent it from penetrating evenly into the cell walls of the two surfaces and the dried joint will have little strength, it will in effect be glue starved. With hot hide glue if you apply glue to the end grain and let it dry before gluing the two pieces together you will have a joint with enough strength that in a destruction test will tear wood from the long grain board in the joint. Yes the gluing procedure was different for the two glues. but sealing the end grain with the PVA glue and letting it dry before assembling the joint would not add any strength to that joint since PVA glue does not adhere very well to dried PVA glue.

I'm not making a case for one glue being superior to another but rather trying to illustrate how all glues can not be thrown in the same boat when comparing them or discussing how they work. For those with knowledge of different types of metal welding processes a good comprising would be that Hot hide glue is like brazing and PVA glue is like arc welding. Sometimes one is better than the other for an application and at other times the other is the best choice.

Re: How glue works

#7

JL

Re: How glue works

JL

I'll argue with the penetration of the cell walls. While PVA glue does penetrate into the pores, crevasses and surface imperfections of the wood, it does not penetrate into the actual cells. You don't have enough of a pressure head to cause actual penetration.


You can get penetration of cell walls with the cyanoacrylate glues, if they are thin enough. A LONG time ago, I used to work for a firm which impregnated wood with methyl methacrylate monomer and made a copolymer of the MMA and the wood. We did some long and rather exhaustive studies on the penetration of various substances into wood. If the molecular weight of your substance is much over 500, you won't get penetration into the cell walls. The penetration is also contingent on the properties of the molecules in question.

My $0.02.

Re: How glue works

#8

Re: How glue works

Bill Tindall

There is little in your discussion that agrees with what I have been told by adhesive experts.

To take one example, PVA glue is a latex. That is, it is a suspension of micron sized polymer balls in water. It is not possible for a micron sized polymer ball to penetrate a cell wall. In fact, it is not possible for any polymer sized molecule to penetrate a cell wall.

Hide glue cures by loss of water, same as PVA, as quoted in the Franklin adhesives manual. The fact that it can chip glass has no relevance to gluing wood. It simply means that 1. it shrinks when it dries and 2. it wets glass well.

Hide glue enthusiasts seem to need to promote claims that it is generally better for gluing wood, in spite of the facts indicating otherwise. The facts are that PVA glue forms a bond stronger than wood, so how can anything be "better" in terms of strength? Note the 100% wood failure of the PVA joint posted earlier. PVA glue makes stronger mortise and tenon joints than hide glue (published data). Furthermore, it is rare to find a professional shop that uses hide glue. Hide glue has some advantages in special applications, but for routine wood gluing plain old Titebond or its equivalent, is what most professional shops and factories are using, successfully. And as I showed previously, a PVA joint can be disassembled just as easily as one made with hide glue.

Re: How glue works

#9

Re: the standard for joint strength

Jesse Cloud

I remember the first day of my Fine Woodworking class in community college. The instructor had each student edge glue (original titebond) and clamp two pieces of poplar. We left them clamped for only 30 minutes, then were told to break them apart with a hammer. Even with very inexpert users and only 30 minutes clamping, not a single glue joint failed. All pieces broke when wood away from the joint broke.

Re: How glue works

#10

Re: How glue works

Marv

Bill,

I'm not an expert either but what I've learned from those who have expertise on the subject of bonding agents is, cohesion is the attraction of molecules to each other that make up a particular bonding agent such as Titebond glue for example. Adhesion occurs when the bonding agent's molecules are attracted to the molecules in the substrates being bonded. This action can be referred to as wetting. When there is no wetting, there is no bonding or adhesion. All the elements must be brought very closely together in order for the attraction to take place. Clamping helps make that happen.

Books have been written on the subject that explains the interaction between many different materials and how a particular adhesive reacts to each material, etc. We can only touch on some of the aspects here in this forum. It's a very lengthly but fasinating subject.

Thanks for your insights.

Marv