How glue works
Bill Tindall
I am not an expert on glue but I know people that are. The following is what I have learned from them, presuming my understanding and memory is correct.
A good glue/ adhesive has two properties. First it must wet the substrate. In this context wet means flow on its surface as opposed to beading up like rain on GorTex. Anything that wets the substrate will stick the two surfaces together if they can get close together, either because they are flat or they get mashed flat by pressure. For example water will stick two pieces of glass together as good as anything. This phenomena is called adhesion. But adhesion is only half the story.
What ever does the sticking must have some mechanical strength or what is stuck can be slid apart. Take the example of water and glass. The glass "can't" be pulled apart because of the adhesion provided by the water wetting the glass, but it can be easily slid apart because water has little mechanical strength. A good glue not only wets the substrate , it also is tough (it has good cohesion). If the stuff wetting is tough, the two substrates can not be slid apart, or pulled apart. These two properties are essential for a good glue.
There has been discussion about to role of penetration of glue into the wood and fastening the joint together by this mechanical interlocking mode. If the adhesive wets the wood penetration of the glue into pores is not required to get a strong bond. I had an opportunity to ask one of the adhesive experts at Virginia Tech whether the penetration mode was important to gluing wood with PVA glue. "Hard to say" was the answer, as I remember it. A good adhesive does not need to penetrate and form a mechanical bond. But wood is porous and glue will penetrate if it wets the surface. It is not possible to separate adhesion from the mechanical bonding mechanisms in porous wood. Either could result in a good glue, and typical wood glue will have both properties.
I don't entirely understand gaps. I know if the gap is big then the strength of the bond depends entirely on the strength of the glue, and most glue is weaker than wood. At some distance of approach of the two substrate surfaces the bond strength due to adhesion depends on closeness, which is why precision joinery and sufficient clamp pressure is important to yield a thin glue line, and hence an optimum bond. I suspect fully understanding the details is complicated. No doubt there are books on the subject but I have not studied them. Maybe if enough people assail this post I will be motivated to do so and report back.




