Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

Posts

Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#1

Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

doug f, san clemente, ca

I share my shop with a car, sometimes two, in a three car garage. I've become concerned about the risk of fire in the shop and what it can do to tools, the house, etc, etc.

I have been told that there may well be a problem with the detector in the garage since exhaust fumes may set it off repeatedly.

How do you folks handle the problem? Is the concern with false alarms legitimate or am I taking a risk that I can mitigate with a detector? Opinions on the internet vary all over the place, but I would like the views of folks who actually do woodworking in this situation.

Advice would be most helpful.

Thanks.

Doug

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#2

I do.  Both smoke and Carbon Monoxide

Gary Smyth

Better to have it wake me than let me permanently go to sleep. I've had no problems with fumes. But I can set off the smoke detector if I band saw or drill something really dense. I'm thinking the car is out of the garage in a minute or so. How long does it take to open the door, turn the ignition, and back it out?

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#3

Carbon Monoxide detector important for house too

Craig Daymon

I knew someone who died in his sleep (along with the other residents) because a squirrel got lodged in the furnace flue pipe causing the house to fill with CO. No one woke up.

Probably even more important in the house than the shop, but easily important for both and worth the expense.

-Craig

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#4

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

Jim H

After an attic electrical fire that almost went through the roof before the detectors went off (they were below the fire) we now have heat detectors in the attic and garage shop. They trip from extremely high temps or sudden rise in temp. They are not affected by dust, and are tied into my alarm system.

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#5

Ellis Walentine

Couple variables...

Ellis Walentine

A typical smoke or ionization detector wouldn't have saved my shop because nobody was home when the fire started. If I had had a detector that was wired to dial up a central alarm service, they might have been able to dispatch the fire company fast enough to save at least part of the building, but sadly, that didn't occur. I'm just happy they got there fast enough to hose down our house, which is only 100' from the shop. So, one factor is that you have to consider who will hear the alarm.

False alarms are common with many smoke detectors, so you may have to try some and see how they work in your specific situation. Every time I cook something in the kitchen I seem to set off our kitchen alarm, which may say more about my cooking than the sensitivity of the detectors. I have always heated my shop with a woodstove, so it's not uncommon for a downdraft or a closed damper to blow some smoke into the room. I guess false alarms are better than none at all.

Ellis

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#6

In a Sense

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

When I was trying to rip cherry on the "old" BT-3k, I had to disable the smoke detector as it would be going off half way through the cut.

Got a cab saw and reconnected to alarm. But SWMBO's nose was far better. Slightest scent for the basement shop and she was down the stairs looking for the fire, long before the buzzer made a peep.

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#7

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

Bill Howatt

Yes, shop is in basement though. Cutting pine will often trigger the alarm but it has a button to silence it for a short period of time.

For the very low cost of detectors, I'd say it would be worth the money to try it in your situation. I would look for one that has a momentary silence feature as a minimum. You may be able to find a location where it offers protection and have minimal false triggers.

Bill

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#8

Louie Lovas

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

Louie Lovas

When I built my shop I had an alarm system installed, they told me standard smoke detectors would not work because the dust would set them off too. So they installed heat detectors. I have three of them in total, two on the main floor and one in the 2nd (storage) floor. They are all wired into the alarm system which is connected to the phone system which is monitored by an alarm company (along with my house).

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#9

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

Doug Ridley

I have one in my shop and it even has a name, Doug. If I am not there a smoke alarm wouldn't help anyhow as it is too far from the house.

Doug

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#10

Yes, have a smoke detector in my shop?

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I've had a smoke detector in my shop for a long time. It goes off when I use my branding iron to mark a finished piece or when I would burn some lumber while ripping before I learned to tune up my saw. Now that the saw is tuned up I rarely get burn marks. I've never had my smoke detector go off due to dust and I've had plenty in the air once or twice.

The detector I have has a radio transmitter in it so that if the one in the shop goes off there is a remote unit in the house that will also go off. I also have a fire extinguisher right by the door to the sop that has never been needed.

Lee

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#11

There is more than one kind. And for Ellis...

Barry Irby

There is the type which uses an electric Eye. They look for the smoke passing in front of the eye. In this case, smoke is "dust". anything which interrupts the eye's view of the light would set it off. These are the ones that go off outside the bathroom door because steam comes out and gets into them. Dust would set them off too.

Another type uses an Ionization detector. (probably more expensive that those above and they have a little radioactive isotope that must be disposed of properly when the time comes.) These detect the fumes of the fire. So, the byproducts of combustion would set them off.

These two types are commonly available as either battery operated or hard wired for home use.

I think the heat detector versions are reserved for alarm systems.

There are also units that can operate remotely. Any of them can be wired through a third wire to set off all of them if any of them goes off. But, you can also buy them (at about triple the cost) that have a function that allows them to set off others without being wired directly to them. I checked recently and these are available at the Borg. Be careful though. If you set them off frequently, you may drive the people in the house nuts.

And to add more permutations, most of these can be combined with CO detectors. Early CO detectors were too sensitive. They would go off if you started a car in the garage. Now they have a momentary delay built in to allow you to get the car out without going off. The good ones with digital readout also record some history, so you can review what the levels have been. And they will go off if you have a low level for a long time or a higher level for a shorter time.

And Ellis, these things are smoke detectors, not oven thermometers. The proper way to tell when the roast is done is to cook a big roast and a little roast at the same time. When the little roast burns the big roast is done. On the other hand, Indian cooking always sets off the smoke detector.

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#12

Re: There is more than one kind. And for Ellis...

Bill Howatt

I believe the ionization detector ones are the most common and are the cheapest. Because they have a very small radioactive source, americium, in them they need to be replaced after about 10 yrs because the source has "run down". The amount is very small, 1 gram of americium oxide is enough for 3 million smoke detectors.

Bill

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#13

Re: Yes, have a smoke detector in my shop?

Larry in NW Ohio

Lee I`ve been looking for a detector thar has a remote in it like you have. Where and what kind is it. Thank You. Larry

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#14

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

Larry in NW Ohio

Yes I also have a detector in my shop and being the strange person That I am, I also put in a couple of fire sprinklers in. One above the dust collector and one above the gas heater. So I`m kind of covered. Larry

Re: Do you have a smoke detector in your shop?

#15

Just to let you how this turned out

doug f, san clemente, ca

The alarm company is installing a wireless heat detector on Wednesday. It transmits to the alarm panel and bingo, the fire department is on the way.

I feel much more comfortable now.

Thanks for all the advice; this place is great.

Doug