Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Hollow mortising chisel questions

Posts

Hollow mortising chisel questions

#1

Hollow mortising chisel questions

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greetings all

Today I became the proud owner of a very lightly used Powermatic 719T floor stand mortiser. :D I have some pretty serious plans for this tool, like building some exterior doors, and lots of windows to replace the aging ones in my 200 year old farmhouse. Note: I am not looking for people to write in and tell me how cost effective it will be to buy windows instead. I have been through all that already.

I received several Jet hollow chisels with the mortiser. Where would I look to find the appropriate tool for keeping these chisels sharp? Next, how long can I expect them to last in mildly hard wood? I am planning on using heat treated poplar for the window frames. I have not yet decided on the doors, although they may be made from the same wood.

Are there other chisels on the market that would be significantly better in regard to longevity or keeping an edge?

Any other tips anyone cares to share from experience in using one of these machines? I had a Delta tabletop for a brief period about six years ago, and only used it a few times before selling it to a friend of mine who needed one a lot more than I did. This machine seems to be way more than head and shoulders above that, and all I have done so far is play around with some of the controls so far.

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#2

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

Randy Johnson

>If you look around at any other brands make sure they will work with the 719. I am pretty sure that on most chisels made for bench top morticers the shanks are too short for the Powermatic.

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#3

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

Barry Irby

>I saw some of the heat treated poplar at Wood Craft Recently. It actually smelled like caramel. Bad Caramel, but caramel just the same.

I bought a sharpener from WoodCraft for my Chisels which are forty year old Delta Chisels. Mine got nearly no use for the first thirty five years and light use since then. I have not worn one out, so I can't help you with the longevity.

I have a friend who used some heavily for years and wore out many sets. I think his conclusion was to buy cheap (at least cheaper) Grizzly chisels and make some sort of sleeve to make them work on his machine. They were less expensive than whatever else he was buying and nearly as good.

What I know from my little experience and his is that it is VERY worthwhile to hone the chisels inside and out. Get them sharp and keep them sharp and polish the outside. I found that polishing them in the vertical direction on the outside paid off. If the even very slight scratches were cross wise it added greatly to the difficulty of inserting and removing the chisel.

The other thing that was not obvious to me at first was that you should punch the two ends first and then punch every other "hole" in between and then go back and punch out the webs left in between. If you try to move from one end to the other cutting the "next" piece the chisel will distort and bend toward the opening, the bit will bind in the curved chisel and heat up. Something will break fairly quickly.

I'm sure you know how to set up the chisel and bit. So Set it up correctly, keep it sharp, and cut the mortise as I described and you will get the maximum life out of the sets.

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#4

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I got my conical diamond stones from either Lee Valley or Rockler (forgot which...) several years back. They'll keep your chisels nice and sharp on the inside.

'Scary sharp" techniques using ever finer grits of sandpaper will polish the outside, and as was already suggested, polish lengthwise to avoid cross scratches.

The bits can be sharpened using the same files and stones used for auger bits.

Unless they're abused, chisels can last nearly forever. Not so the bits. Highland Hardware used to carry replacement bits. Been a while since I've ordered any, though.

Jim D.

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#5

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

Kirk (KC) Constable

>Bill, I used JET chisels to cut lots and lots of deep mortises in mesquite table legs (54 tables, 6 legs each) a few years back. I did try a Forest City branded one, and didn't find it any better than the JET, so that's what I used at home also. I've never 'honed' a mortise chisel, but I do clean up the outside edges occasionaly with some 400g paper on the bandsaw top. In other words, they work well for me right out of the box, and with precious little attention.

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#6

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

charlie belden

>When I was looking at chisel and bit mortising machines the unit you got was one of the two on my short list. Iwent with the General International 75-075 because for the same money it had the tilting head and fence rotation capability.

As noted, the chisels and bits that come with mortising machines suck - out of the box - burs on the bits and chisels and the sides of the chisels look like they were done with a belt sander (slight exaggeration - but close)

Three hours with a jewelers file and japanese slip stones - and india and hard arkansas stonesgot the outsides of the chisel polished - without changing the outside dimensions to any really significant degree. Polishing

definitely makes the chisels cut better - with less binding. The diamond coated cone burs - mine are from Lee Valley - and there are TWO - do a nice job at sharpening - from the inside of the hollow chisel - don't mess

with the outside to sharpen.

I soon replaced the chisel and bit sets that came with the machine with Fisch sets - which came more ready to use out of the box.

Looking at your intended list of things to use this for - try and keep your expectations in line with reality. None of these units will let you slap a chunk of wood in it and let you cut all the way through a 2x4 in one effortless pull of the handle - even in doug fir or pine - and probably not in kiln dried poplar either.

The head ache generating component is the poor chip clearing from the hollow chisel - and it doesn't seem to matter what the bit configuration is. So expect to spend some time now and then stopping and removing the bit from the chisel and resetting things.

And with deep mortises - the wider the chisel - the more and tighter it WILL bind. CLAMP THE PART TO THE TABLE - the Hold In/Hold Down (sort of) do a good job of holding the part firm against the fence. Not so good for keeping the part ON the table if the chisel binds much at all. This is more likely to happen if you go all Rambo when cutting - going for full depth in one plunge. A series of steps will get you there almost as fast - with less binding. Note I said "less" and not "no" binding. Patience does pay off when using hollow chisel mortisers.

And don't let the big heavy casting and the 150 to 200 pounds of the unit give you the impression - or expectation - that you can really crank on this sucker. Remember that the weak link is the bit. And getting the bit to chisel setting right can make life a bit easier. The FORTY CENT METHOD works and is easy to do. Eyeballing on the other hand probably won't - and your likely to either break the bit, or burn it - it's not high speed steel usually and heat will destroy its ability to hold an edge.

Frankly, with the projects you have in mind for this thing - and knowing what I know now - I'd have gone with a horizontal mortiser with a dedicated motor and chuck - and long mortising bits for it. Set ups take about the same amount of time - but much less fun and games. The router based version are OK - but probably not for exterior door work where you make wide, tall and deep mortises. And while hollow chisel mortisers CAN NOT cut mortises in end grain - horizontal boring/mortisers CAN - which means you can go with Loose Tenon M&T joints. They're as strong if not stronger, lower risk if you screw up since repairs are as easy as plugging the hole with a piece of loose tenon stock and some glue. With a true mortise and tenon - a tenon screw up can be hard or impossible to fix and thus require making a whole new tenoned part. When you're playing with thick stock - like on exterior doors - that can get expensive - and take time running down more stock.

I still don't understand why hollow chisel morotisers are still being bought since there are quicker and easier and more accurate ways of doing loose tenon mortises - FMT, MultiRouter, Horizontal Boring/Mortiser and the DOMINO. You can do six - or eight if you want - smaller loose tenon mortise in place of one BIG one - and get the same or maybe more strength - in less time and with less muscle.

You're new PM WILL do the jobs you have in mind, if you prepare it and allow it to. Force it and it will let you know that it objects. Show it consideration and you'll find it more cooperative. BTW - if you give it a nice name and talk with it - more likely than not that will help as well ; )

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#7

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

FredD

>Bill, my mortiser is the PM 719 A and it does everything you can expect from a good machine .

You asked for tips so here are some I have found over the years to make it fun rather then a chore for Mortise cutting.

I had a Delta bench top that was less then satisfactory for what I wanted and when I got the PM , I ordered a set of chisels from Clico, a English company and the conical stone they make that chucks in a hand brace for the inside honing of the chisel.

The chisels are a grade or two above any I have seen made here.

For ease and less wear on the machine and chisel ,especially in hardwoods and wide mortises , use a slightly smaller diameter spur bit to hog out most of the wood on the drill press before you finish up on the Mortiser.

When cutting narrow mortises without predrilling , cut the right end and then the left end before you cut out the middle , overlapping each cut about half.

This method ensures you get true ninety degree vertical ends in the mortise.

Layout the mortise full size before you cut it, especially if your centering the mortise in the stock.

If you cut mortises in a curved leg for instance, cut the mortise before you cut the curve ;-))

I use a block of paraffin wax to keep the sides of the chisel slick when using and do not let the chisel heat to the stage of discoloring or you lose the temper in the metal.

Other have said it is faster to use a router, but not near as much fun and a whole lot quieter to use the Mortiser, think of it as a body building exercise, you will get tired of pulling down the lever.

Also it is not necessary to remove the chisel from the machine to clear chips.

Use a Dime to set the the distance the bit will clear the bottom of the chisel.

Your instructions with the machine should tell you this , also Clico , Jet and Delta recommends it for their chisels.

Note which side of the chisel is the chip clearance slot and cut in a sequence that leaves you a clear view of the layout each time you down stroke.

For the Clico's I have this means I cut from right to left once I have each end cut.

The backside of the PM at the depth setting makes it difficult to use a ruler to set the depth, so I cut a small wood block about a 1/16th inch thicker then the length of the Tenon and use that to zero the cut depth by setting the depth rod on the block and locking the setting.

Have fun , you will enjoy the process once you get the hang of it.

FredD

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#8

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

bill sams

>Bill, here's a pic of a way I sharpen my mortise chisels. You will need a 3/4" chuck on the tailstock to hold the 5/8" & 3/4" shank mortise bits. Any honing cone will work, diamond or not, slow rpm and slow back and forth feed of the bit into the hone. Very very lightly remove the burrs on the outside with a fine stone, otherwise you change the diameter of your chisel.

The initial setup for getting the bit parallel with the wood and fence...is to set your bit and chisel in place, then lower the chisel/bit within range of the fence, then slowly move the fence toward the chisel until the fence actually touches the mortise chisel. Loosen the screw that holds the chisel, wiggle the chisel, move the fence closer if need be until there is no wiggle left, tighten the screw, back off the fence. Be careful not to put too much pressure otherwise bending/flexing the chisel.

Now you should be cut parallel mortises without it looking like a sawtooth pattern.

Sometimes the bit will be cutting a larger diameter than the chisel, slightly hand filing the bit diameter will resolve that issue. The bits flare at the bottom edge, so we're talking only filing the bottom lip, not the whole shank.

Take care


Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#9

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks for the responses everyone. It looks like the best thing is to tune up the chisels I have, and then decide what to do about replacing them as the need arises. I will need to find some cones for sharpening.

Charlie, I am well aware of how these things work, what their strengths and weaknesses are, etc. I have been building furniture longer than I have been turning. I own a Domino, and I own a mortising table that fits on my Mini Max CU 300 Smart. Neither is applicable for what I want to do and the way I want to do it with this particular machine. I haven�t seen anywhere in this thread where anyone stated the chisels suck out of the box either. Maybe I missed something?

Fred, thanks for the operating tips, and Bill for the picture.

Jim, thanks for the sources. I may be out your way soon. I have to make a delivery to the kids. When I do, I will get in touch with you.

KC, thanks for the testimony on the lifespan of your chisels.

Randy, there is an extender in the parts box. I think that is supposed to be for the shorter bits, but thanks for the heads up.

Barry, my local mill started carrying this �burnt wood� as I call it. It is supposed to be dimensionally stable, and rot resistant. I am going to give it a try. With a good coat of paint, it should last long enough that it won�t matter to me.

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#10

Poplar?

Jorge Casta�eda

>Bill,

Unless the poplar you are thinking is a diferent species, poplar around here rots readily so we don't use it for exterior work, mostly as secondary wood, the wood we don't see in cabinets and such.

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#12

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

Barry Irby

>Bill, a couple of things.

One, pulling on the handle give my shoulder a fit. I'm using an attachment on a drill press and am a little nervous about using a cheater bar. I'm also a little suspicious of my shoulder, but I suggest you do these in small batches until you build up your mortising muscle. Tuning up the chisels and bits will pay off for this as well. I see it as 30 minutes or an hour very well spent.

I have done a few hundred mortise and tenon joints. I like them but find the fiddling to get the fit perfect to be tedious. Then I found good quality epoxy (West System or System 3). I like to get the joints very nice and then use epoxy anyway as a little insurance. And, its waterproof.

Wonder what the glue characteristics of burnt wood are? Don't suppose it impacts the glue do you?

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#13

Bill and Jorge.....

Barry Irby

>Google: What is heat treated wood.

They "autoclave" the wood to modify the fibers and the sugars in the wood. The process apparently makes the wood less palatable to rot fungi and insects. (You don't like burnt toast do you?) It makes the wood harder and changes the color to a darker brown. Some of the other properties are changed also. You have to drill for nails or screws. It may not be a rot resistant as chemically treated wood but much better than the poplar in this case. And what I saw really did smell like caramel.

Hopefully it will have less tendency to warp than treated pine. I'm sure Bill will tell us.

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#14

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Bill,

Looking forward to seeing you again!

Regarding the sharpening cones, they're from Lee Valley. Item 77J81.22. Current cost is $22.50.

Jim D.

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#15

Re: Poplar?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Jorge and Bill, what Barry wrote. I would never consider "regular" poplar for an exterior application, just for the reasons Jorge mentions. But this stuff is heated in a vacuum and it changes the properties, making it rot resistant and dimensionally stable. It is not supposed to move around like regular wood. Add a couple coats of paint, and it is good to go. I think it was less than $4.00/bdft too, making it a reasonable price. Apparently it takes glue like regular wood. It looks just like poplar with a dark walnut stain. In fact, the first time they showed me a sample, and asked me what it was, I responded "poplar". I was then told I was the first person to get it right on the first try. Most people were guessing walnut.

Barry, I have started paying more attention to my shoulders in recent years, but I am not too worried about this machine. My height relative to its height makes it look like I might do more pushing than pulling, and if I get tired, I go away and rest up a bit. That's what I do with the lathe. There is nothing I am working on that makes it worth getting hurt because I am working tired or pushing myself.

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#16

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I use a craytex cone in my fordom grinder to hone the inside of the chisels. having the inside of the bit polished to a mirror shine helps tremendously in reduceing the force needed to punch a hole. My mortice machine is also a foot operated dedicated machine but it still benifits from having polished chisels. pay more attention to the inside than the outside because the out side is slightly tapered to provide a bit of clearance.

I need longer drills for my machine and clicos are one of the few that fit. If Jets chisels will fit your machine they are actualy made by fisch and good quallity and only need minor polising.

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#17

Thanks Barry

Jorge Casta�eda

>I learn something today.

Time will tell

Jorge

Re: Hollow mortising chisel questions

#18

thrilled to hear you're building windows

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>Let us know how it works out!

(I want to do the same.)