Re: Hard Experience
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Having spent a number of years (30+ years ago) selling vacuum cleaners ("seveepers") door-to-door, and come up "against" about every make and type in the residential setting, I can speak with a bit of knowledge.
Start with the basics:
1. Generally, a canister (portable or "whole-house") will have more suction than an upright. Suction is measured, not in watts or horsepower (real or imagined), but rather in inches of water lift. What this means is that if you hook the hose to the top of a clear pipe that's 1" i.d., stick the pipe vertically in a bucket of water, and hit the "suck" switch, how far up the column will it pull the water level is its rating. Back in the day, the champs at this in domestic cleaners were Constellation and Electrolux.
2. Suction, while great for picking up surface litter and dust on bare floors, is not enough to pull fine dust out of carpeting and clean upholstered surfaces. Carpeting is where uprights (with a revolving brush) shine because they comb and separate the fibers allowing the moving air to get to the embedded dirt. Problem with the usual upright is that they use a belt off the motor to drive the brush while the same motor spins the fan(s) to create the suction. As the brush touches the carpet, the motor must slow down a bit, which robs suction 'power' and air speed because the fans slow down as well.
The real answer was invented by Electrolux in their 2-motor system that uses the canister and the powered brush on the wand. Great machines (I sold them) but stupidly expensive due to the huge amount of commissions and overrides for the direct sales plan that were pulled out of the sales prices. They basically priced themselves out of the market for a number of years. It was a good job, though, if you didn't get yourself arrested for peddling without a license by some small-town gum-shoe.
BTW, as to the Dyson, comments I've heard about it are "gimmicky", "expensive", and "repair-prone" except from a couple of people who bought one and didn't seem to want to admit their mistake.
Bottom line Larry, which machine is best for your home depends upon what your cleaning needs are. You have pets? Carpets? Hard-surface floors? Upholstered couches that the cat and bird share? Draperies?
Talk to the cleaning person, whomever that may be, and get a sense of what they need the most, then try to fit the machine to that need. You can also check Consumers Reports as to ratings of the various types. Last time I looked, they didn't think too awfully much of the Dyson brand.
PS: Our house as a central vac system with great suction, but, because the unit and installation don't allow a powered head brush, we need a separate upright to properly clean the carpeted areas and a turbo air-powered upholstery tool to deal with the pet hair/fur/etc.