Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Way (OT) Sweepers

Posts

Way (OT) Sweepers

#1

Way (OT) Sweepers

Larry in NW Ohio

>My wife wants a new sweeper. She whatches QVC to much. She wants one off the Dysons. If antone has one out there, what do you think of them? I go by what people here think of them more than any other place. Thank you. Larry

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#2

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

John K Jordan

>Larry,

After many decades with our Nilfisk canister vacuum, a few months ago we got a Dyson upright, model DC28. It's a little pricey but not too bad if you catch it on sale and have a 30% off coupon. :)

You can find lots of reviews and comments on the web with a google search.

Dyson has a good reputation and was recommended by several people we know who have had one for years. This one seems to be good quality, has good features, and certainly works well. I've never been sorry getting quality tools, whether for the shop, the farm, or the house.

JKJ

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#3

We thought we wanted one too...

Grant in Iowa

>About two years ago we had to replace a Hoover windtunnel vacuum because of the company not providing parts for it. So we began searching for a good well supported vacuum.

I was intitilly thinking Dyson, because of the publicized philosophy of the inventor. But after asking around and reading on the subject we discovered that there are limited parts available, and that a couple friends had bought them and found out the bagless technology machines don't clean very well long term. Another thought is that as woodworkers, we know that it takes considerable horsepower to spin the air through the bagless machines. This power has to come from somewhere, as there is only so much power available from a 15A circuit.

So I focussed on trying to find a company that I could order any part for the machine, and one with HEPA filtration, since that is the real objective.

So we ended up with a Panasonic upright commercial model. It looks like an old school machine, but it is very well made, has HEPA filtration, and all of the parts are available. I ordered it online and got it delivered for about 60% of the list price. We have been using it for over a year and are very happy with it. it gets the carpets very clean very fast.

Anyway, very satisfied. i don't have the model number handy (not at home), but it is a commercial model upright.

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#4

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

steve mackay

>We went through this last year. I asked about the Dyson a lot of places including here on WC. I never did hear anything like " It changed my life $500 worth !". Anyone who DID have one told me it worked BUT they wish they hadn't spent THAT much. Went down to Sears and (much to the young sales girls annoyance !) did a "combat" side by side test. We left with the $300 Kenmore and are getting our money's worth. Its got neat filters AND a bag. I like bags. Remove bag, drop bag into AFEES bag, out to trash. Hate carrying a canister out to the trash in the dark. I'll admit, a Dyson looks wicked cool but $200 cool ?

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#5

Clint Searl

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

Clint Searl

>We've had a Dyson for at least 5 years. My wife loves it. I think it's overpriced, underpowered, and user unfriendly. The hose and wand are a real PITA to use. I bought a Kenmore drag-around for another property, and it's much less expensive, more powerful, and more user friendly.

Clint

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#6

Chet Kloss

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers - not a Dyson Fan

Chet Kloss

>We went for the high Dyson with special filters for pet hair. When it works it's good but it breaks down quite often. We got to the point that we needed another vac to have on hand because of all the downtime of the Dyson. In the end, we stopped using the Dyson. Our vacuum repair guy says Dyson's alone have kept him solvent during the recession...

They look cool - but it's been my experience that they are neither durable nor reliable.

,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Chet

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#7

Two words

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

>Central vacuum.....

LOML loves hers, just a hose and two plug in locations to do the whole house.

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#8

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

Barry Irby

>Larry, I don't own a Dyson. I was attracted to them and went to a local shop. The owner kept steering me away from them. It became very clear he thought I should not buy one. I finally pressed him and he said they were over priced, under powered, and they kept his repair business alive. I repaired my old Hoover and did not buy the Dyson.

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#9

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

Stuart Johnson

>After a lot of research my wife bought an Eureka smartvac. I don't have any idea what it cost but she likes it as much as she would like any vac.

Just a word or two of caution...Think about what your life will be like if you talk your wife into a vac she doesn't want. :\

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#10

Re: Hard Experience

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Having spent a number of years (30+ years ago) selling vacuum cleaners ("seveepers") door-to-door, and come up "against" about every make and type in the residential setting, I can speak with a bit of knowledge.

Start with the basics:

1. Generally, a canister (portable or "whole-house") will have more suction than an upright. Suction is measured, not in watts or horsepower (real or imagined), but rather in inches of water lift. What this means is that if you hook the hose to the top of a clear pipe that's 1" i.d., stick the pipe vertically in a bucket of water, and hit the "suck" switch, how far up the column will it pull the water level is its rating. Back in the day, the champs at this in domestic cleaners were Constellation and Electrolux.

2. Suction, while great for picking up surface litter and dust on bare floors, is not enough to pull fine dust out of carpeting and clean upholstered surfaces. Carpeting is where uprights (with a revolving brush) shine because they comb and separate the fibers allowing the moving air to get to the embedded dirt. Problem with the usual upright is that they use a belt off the motor to drive the brush while the same motor spins the fan(s) to create the suction. As the brush touches the carpet, the motor must slow down a bit, which robs suction 'power' and air speed because the fans slow down as well.

The real answer was invented by Electrolux in their 2-motor system that uses the canister and the powered brush on the wand. Great machines (I sold them) but stupidly expensive due to the huge amount of commissions and overrides for the direct sales plan that were pulled out of the sales prices. They basically priced themselves out of the market for a number of years. It was a good job, though, if you didn't get yourself arrested for peddling without a license by some small-town gum-shoe.

BTW, as to the Dyson, comments I've heard about it are "gimmicky", "expensive", and "repair-prone" except from a couple of people who bought one and didn't seem to want to admit their mistake.

Bottom line Larry, which machine is best for your home depends upon what your cleaning needs are. You have pets? Carpets? Hard-surface floors? Upholstered couches that the cat and bird share? Draperies?

Talk to the cleaning person, whomever that may be, and get a sense of what they need the most, then try to fit the machine to that need. You can also check Consumers Reports as to ratings of the various types. Last time I looked, they didn't think too awfully much of the Dyson brand.

PS: Our house as a central vac system with great suction, but, because the unit and installation don't allow a powered head brush, we need a separate upright to properly clean the carpeted areas and a turbo air-powered upholstery tool to deal with the pet hair/fur/etc.

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#11

Re: We thought we wanted one too...

Alexander Grigoriev

>I'm not sure why you think "bagless technology doesn't clean well long term". The point is that it doesn't suffer from the filter plugging with dust. The suction doesn't get worse as the filter loads. and its initial suction is better because there is no filter resistance. THough there is a HEPA filter after the cyclone.

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#12

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

Carol Reed

>For my part, don't get an Orick either. Worse machine I have ever had and I thoughts from the beginning.

I have a very old Airway that works fine except the brush on the carpet head is worn out and I can't find another, or for that matter, another head.

Finally I dropped $25 at WallyWorld for a mostly plastic Eureka. No bag technology but it sucks up dirt, sawdust and cat hair just fine. It was right after Christmas and I think they were just getting them out the door. A week earlier they had been $35. I procrastinated and it save me ten bucks!

Whatever works! :D

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#13

PS, Another view point...

Barry Irby

>Just talked to a friend who got a Purple Dyson (Pet hair Version) as a gift. He had a Wind Tunnel before that. As a test, he tuned up the Wind Tunnel one last time and cleaned an area rug thoroughly. Then put the Dyson together and ran it over the same rug. Got enough additional crap to fill the Dyson. Threw the old one away and has not looked back. Likes it, no problems, no crappy parts. Likes the snap together technology because it is easy to disassemble if necessary.

Also mentioned there is an internal HEPA filter inside the machine. Take it out and clean it about every six months. Don't forget the filter.

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#14

Me too

Tony - Memphis

>I was very leary about them becaus eof the price. We have several friends who have beenusing them for a few years and swear by them. I just happened to see a deal for $100 off, so I ordered one. We did the test where we first cleaned with the old vac, then tried the Dyson and were shocked by how much it picked up. As an engineer, I am impressed with the design. Oh, we got the ball version. I've also been impressed with how well it steers. This model has two or three washable filters in addition to the can. Very easy to empty the can btw. I really like the extendable hose too (it is very long). Not real impressed with the attachments, but that isn't a huge deal to us. We've had ours for six months or so with no issues. I know several folks who have had them for several years with no problems.

Tony

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#15

Re: Me too

John K Jordan

>The Dysan we got picked up an amazing amount of dirt from carpets which had already been vacuumed by another machine. Like anything else, I wonder if any of the problems some people have reported were due to not reading the manual (like my wife!) and failure to do basic maintenance like keeping the brush, airways and filters clean. I am extremely sensitive to fine house dust in the air (I usually leave the house during vacuuming) but this one outputs none that I can detect and my dust allergies are not aggravated.

The only problem we've had was the strong suction makes vacuuming throw rugs tricky. We love the wand and extension - quick, simple, no fumbling like others I've used. We'll see if the first impressions linger this time next year.

JKJ

Re: Way (OT) Sweepers

#16

PS - Dyson a la Consumer's

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Having gone up and pulled the issue, I should amend what I said before as Consumers did acknowledge that the Dyson ("Animal"@$600) did well in testing and carried a low frequency of repair. They said, however that it's performance was beaten by a $140 Hoover units and a number of other machines in the upright class at prices significantly lower.