Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

ROS air sander

Posts

ROS air sander

#1

ROS air sander

Larry in NW Ohio

>I`m thinking about getting an air sander. Which one would you but? Also does anyone remember any magazine or so that did a review on them? TIA Larry

Re: ROS air sander

#2

Re: ROS air sander

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>IR makes several, palm-held and right-angled, in the 6" range. Prices I've seen are in the $100-$200 range. You will, however, need 16 CFM to run one of them, so plan on upgrading your compressor and electric service. There are smaller ones that are being sold to turners, "Grex" brand comes to mind, and the discounters (HF, Northern, etc.) sell cheaper knock-offs that will run on less air, how well, I can't tell. Be sure to get REALLY GOOD hearing protection as the high pitched turbines are particularly effective at causing permanent hearing loss.

Re: ROS air sander

#3

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Be wary of the cheap stuff. Once place they save big is on the bearings. Cheap bearings mean more vibration into your hands that does wonders for your carpal tunnel syndrome. Cheap & low CFM also translate to slower turbines with a lot less torque; ain't so great when your sander stalls when you push down on it. Get 1st person advice from a busy body shop in your area. Remember too, that sanding wood takes more power than taking paint off sheet metal or buffing up hardened resin.

Re: ROS air sander

#4

My experience.....

Bill Tindall

>There is good reason that commercial shops and factories use air sanders. They do a superior job and do it quicker.

I now use an ARO Elite -RS25A-PSV. It weighs 2 pounds, spins 12000 rpm and fits in the palm of my hand.

If there is a local cabinet shop, or factory, visit them and see what they are using and like. I think the only things of importance are where it is made(quality product), weight and how fast it spins.

If you want to try this idea inexpensively I have a retired Sioux #690 that some years ago was preferred by all the cabinet shops in my area. It is larger and heavier. It's $50 if you want it. In a weak moment I bought the ARO at a show. I do like its small size when I have a lot of sanding to do, but I need to stay away from shows where I have made several unnecessary trendy purchases.

Re: ROS air sander

#5

PS- it's 5" diameter

Bill Tindall

>I have not had occasion to need anything larger than 5". If I remember correctly it eats 7 or 8 cfm at 90 psi. In any case you would need a 5 HP compressor to run it effectively if you were sanding enough to warrant air driven sanding. My machines are not noisy. I expect muffler technology has improved. If you can stall the machine with an 80 grit pad then it is not a quality machine. The HP these little things deliver is astonishing.

Re: ROS air sander

#6

Ellis Walentine

I wrote a review for CWB... *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>...about ten years ago on random-orbit sanders. (Click link below to see the article.) The top air-driven models that we tested at that time were 1) Dynabrade, 2) Master Power and 3) Aro, in that order. I personally owned an Aro for many years and had to agree that the Dynabrade and Master Power tools were smoother. Dynabrade, in particular, has their bearings engineered just about perfectly. I think there are four sets of bearings (ball/roller/needle?) in those sanders, and the vibration is almost nil. They really do sand faster, smoother and better than any electric ROS I've ever tested, and I own two Festools.

Regarding the cost-effectiveness of a pneumatic sander, as I mentioned in the article, it takes a big compressor -- in the 5HP to 7HP range -- to deliver the 14 - 18psi @90CFM that you need to keep them from bogging down, so if your compressor can't handle that volume and pressure, you'll find the sander running out of steam quite frequently. Then you have to wait until the compressor recovers. For production work, this is not an acceptable arrangement.

Ellis


Random Orbit Sander Article

Re: ROS air sander

#7

Re: I wrote a review for CWB...

Larry in NW Ohio

>One thing I wanted to ask and forgot, there`s something new, was if any of them ever put a dust collection outlet on them. That would be a great improvement. Larry Also Thanks everyone for posting

Re: ROS air sander

#8

Yes, Larry

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>they come with and without vacuum fittings, and several use the exhaust air as a kind of venturi vacuum assist.

One thing that Ellis' excellant article did not mention in sufficient detail is proper conditioning of the compressed air. When you're using air in the volumes these sanders require, you should be looking at not just CFM on the compressor, but also oil-carryover ratings. That pretty much mandates a 2-stage compressor and several coalescing filters to remove any lube oil vapor from the air stream lest you wind up with oil and condensate water spots on your wood.

Re: ROS air sander

#9

I have different experience

Bill Tindall

>Mark, your experience with this means of sanding is worlds apart from mine. I have used this means of sanding for about 20 years. If you hate sanding this means of sanding will help you get over it. Quick, no swirl marks. When I saw it demonstrated on a piece of maple, 80 grit and no swirl marks I was sold. (BTW, the no swirl marks is some dependent on quality paper. )

I have a foreign made 2 stage 5 HP compressor bought at Sam's club. I am running an Aro now, but used to run a Souix, both 5". This compressor described above will enable me to run these sanders continuously. What more does none need? The sanding rate and quality of finish is incomparable to other means of sanding. You shouldn't bear down on the machine for optimum finish but I don't think I could stall the ARO with an 80 grit disk. I have a colleague with similar compressor and similar experience.

I have a 3/4" "air hose" line from compressor to a sanding station with a cut off valve and manifold. I can reduce pressure and filter at this stage for spraying finish, etc. or run straight to the sander.

I have never seen oil on a sanded piece. Indeed some tiny amount comes out over time but it get sopped up the the clouds of sawdust and tends to stick on the muffler. I wipe it off every year or so.

Re: ROS air sander

#10

Re: Yes, Larry

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>I must agree about the Dynabrade. I picked up a couple on Ebay a few years back and haven't touched any of my PC electric sanders since. You do need a good water separator at each drop, and if you typically spend a lot of time sanding, you might consider a homemade or commercial refrigerated air cooler/dehumidifier on the outlet of your compressor. I think my air system filter/separators catch most of the oil and a lot of the moisture in my air lines.

If the conditions are right, however, the action of the air expanding at the sander will, like opening a can of soda, can cause the air to rapidly cool and moisture to condense. The compressed air is confined to the turbine chamber so oil/water can not come out through the pad, only the exhaust port so is not a problem unless you exceed the ability of the Dynabrade's little fiber exhaust filter to trap and retain it.

This provides one good argument for Dynabrade units with "self-generated" dust collection (using a venturi) as opposed to one of their "central-vac-ready" units (same basic unit with quick, inexpensive parts change-over). The dust port and exhaust port are combined into one port with a venturi. For better suction you can connect a vac hose to the single port on the "self-generated" unit that will remove all dust, oil, and moisture from the work area. The "central-vac-ready" configured Dynabrade has separate vac hose connection and exhaust port (with filter).

I wrote letters to the editors of most of the major WW mags (Wood, PWW, FWW, WWJ )when they all ran ROS reviews in the summer and fall of '08. NONE of them even mentioned pneumatic ROS. Mark Schofield, of FWW responded saying was an apples to oranges comparison- however I believe it is more like BMW to KIA.

Re: ROS air sander

#11

Re: different experiences

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I've used air tools in a foundry, a body shop, and a sculpture studio. The foundry tools, die grinders, cut-offs, and disc sanders were always getting excess condensate on stuff, but it didn't matter all that much. In the body shop it was SOP to wipe down all surfaces with thinner after sanding and before priming to make sure any oil from the sanders was removed. Sprayer air was pulled off a special line that had several filters and a large condensing dryer in the line; lacquers don't do well with wet/oily air. Small reciprocating carving tools are becoming more prevalent now, but I was using pneumatic drivers to carve wood and stone 40 years ago; that's just plain FUN!

Make no mistake, Bill, I know that the industrial tools are workhorses, but very few people on this board are prepared to install and run real 5+ horsepower compressor systems. Guys read "air-drive ROS", find some POS knockoff at the local harbor freight, and proceed to have a "bad tool experience." Remember, we have readers on this board who believe that the 120v 20 gallon compressor they bought at Sears is actually a 5 horsepower unit. They'll find out differently when the thing internally hemorrhages trying to keep up with an air sander. My comments are something of a reality check on the issue so that somebody here doesn't waste money on junk tools that won't perform up to the level of what yours do, brake, and/or ruin projects because of defects or deficiencies in the set up.

Peace

Re: ROS air sander

#12

Re: My experience.....

Larry in NW Ohio

>Bill That sounds like a good deal, but I just don`t know what I`m after as of yet. If I want it I`ll let you know. I have it marked down, so I don`t forget, as long as I don`t lose the paper. Larry

Re: ROS air sander

#13

Festool has pnuematic sanders w dust collection *LINK*

Andy Wright - Allen, TX

>They look like great tools (but as with everything Festool makes, they are expen$ive)


Festool air sanders

Re: ROS air sander

#14

I agree with Ellis *LINK*

Rick Christopherson

>I too did a review on sanders many years ago and drew the same conclusions as Ellis did (although I haven't seen his article). I've been using Dynabrade sanders for around 20 years, and my father has a pair of the Master Power sanders (left over from the review).

If you are curious about what is under the hood of a pneumatic sander, I wrote a review and rebuild guide for a Dynabrade sander. The original review was written 10 years ago, but I recently updated it to include new graphics and the procedure I went through to rebuild one of my oldest sanders.

The image below is from my review. I reverse-engineered the motor in the sander in SolidWorks to create this exploded view model.


img

Dynabrade Review and Rebuild Guide