OT: End of an Era: NYC Tavern on the Green closing
Ray Newman
>On 12/31/09 "Tavern on the Green", a NYC icon fades into history:
http://www.tavernonthegreen.com/
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT: End of an Era: NYC Tavern on the Green closing
Ray Newman
>On 12/31/09 "Tavern on the Green", a NYC icon fades into history:
http://www.tavernonthegreen.com/
That's no loss
Clint Searl
>I took my daughter and her friend there around 1978 and experienced the worst surly service and most mediocre food in my dining experience.
Clint
Re: That's no loss
Howard Norman
>>I took my daughter and her friend there around 1978 and experienced the worst surly service and most mediocre food in my dining experience. <
Sounds typical of NYC to me. I have refused to be in NYC for the last twenty years because of the attitude of the residents of the city.
howard
Re: That's no loss
Barry Irby
>Never been to Tavern on the Green and sorry to hear of any business passing. OTOH, my dining experience in NYC was the opposite of yours. The service was astounding compared to what we get locally. Locally we don't have professional wait staff. All of them are people who think they are a waiter because they can't get their real job and they hide from the work. You about have to shoot one with a dart gun to get them to come to your table. I have had them take my order and then go home, leaving me sitting there.
In NYC if you looked past the perimeter of your "space" somebody came up and asked what you needed, Not my waiter, just one of them. I was telling a story and held up my hands in the "it was this long" gesture and a waiter appeared on both sides. Dishes disappeared and new ones appeared as if by magic. Dropped a spoon and a new one was there in seconds. Maybe I got ALL the good service they had to offer, but the locals could sure use a lesson.
I agree. It happened on Mulberry Street
Victor P
>Window seat in a second floor restarant.
Re: That's no loss
David
>As a longtime resident of Long Island, and a person who has worked and played in NYC for decades, I find your attitude silly, ignorant and insulting.
NYC is a great place, filled with warm, friendly and giving people of all races and creeds. Not only that, it can boast of the best restaurants, the finest entertainment, and the most amazing architecture of any place on earth.
So, stay away. Believe me, it's your loss, not ours.
Re: That's no loss
Clint Searl
>I worked in the city long enough and intimately enough to appreciate its high and low offerings. My comment was directed at one restaurant experience, which is all I grant to any restaurant to qualify it for a second visit. TotG didn't pass the test. I've dined on the street outside Central Park and atop the WTC. Lunch at TotG is particularly memorable as the nadir.
Clint
Re: That's no loss
Stuart Johnson
>David, I'm sure your are right. However, many of us from out of town are stuck at the hotels and encounter some very rude waitstaff. Unfortunately that is our impression which brings up an important point. If we all act as if the person we are meeting or greeting is the most important person we will ever meet we might just get along much better. Someone stopping for a cup of soup that runs into the "Soup Nazi" or the lady at James Coney Island in Houston that yells at you to place your order or get out might not appreciate the local charm. If one goes out to eat twice and twice meets rude people that is the lasting impression.
My wife and I didn't go to Olive Garden for over five years based on one encounter with a waiter that felt it was proper to sit down an put his arm around her shoulder while he took our order. Yes,I spoke to the manager and was informed the waitstaff was trained to be "friendly".
Re: That's no loss
Howard Norman
>The attitude expressed in your post is exactly what I was referring too. I am sure that there are decent people living in NYC. I have just never met any of them.
NYC restaurants
steve antonucci
>As a life long new Yorker, I am always amazed by some perceptions of NYC. I think it's more an image than reality.
I was in the subway yesterday, and I didn't have change for a $20. the MetroCard machines don't take $20, and the kid behind me swipes his card and tells me to go ahead. That's the kind of people I meet in NY almost every time I am in "The City" (which, by the way, NYC is the ONLY place entitled to being referred to as THE CITY).
Folks in restaurants fight over "locals" because we tip better than tourists and we don't complain about the prices. They also know that if they do a terrible job, a terrible tip follows (like the $10 we left on a $250 bill for a waiter that didn't deserve $10, but we wanted to make a point.)
In NY, if you want to know which restaurants are good, just follow the locals. If you look like a tourist, you'll be treated like one. Don't wear your soccer jersey or U of T sweatshirt. And for god sake, look down form the big building before you cross the street!
out in the farmlands of NJ...but covering NYC
Steve
Re: That's no loss
David
>BTW, NYC is filled with museums, galleries and specialty shops filled to the brim with the finest examples of woodworking craftsmanship anywhere in the world. Now and then my wife and I spend the day searching out some of the more obscure places to see what is going on at the high end of the market. It is fascinating to see what is for sale and how much it costs...and to experience the originality, the beauty and the sheer elegance of great hand-made furniture, carvings and other works of art made from wood.
I feel sorry for Mr. Norman. He apparently doesn't know what he's missing. I hope others don't follow his example. There is so much to do and to see in this glorious place...especially for woodworkers (like myself) who love nothing better than to see, touch and feel the best examples of our craft ever fashioned by the hand of man.
Re: NYC restaurants
Howard Norman
>>In NY, if you want to know which restaurants are good, just follow the locals. If you look like a tourist, you'll be treated like one.<
Steve, I think that is true in most cities. My favorite city in the US is San Francisco. Many of the so called "name restaurants" are tourist traps. Over priced with bad service if you give an indication of being a tourist. Over all I would rate San Francisco restaurants as some of the best around.
My home city, Phoenix, is the 6th largest in the US. I don't live there any more and rarely eat out when I am there since all of my children and grandchildren live there and I usually eat in one of their homes. A 50 year old restaurant is a rarity in Phoenix and many of the old ones are family owned hole in the wall type of places.
Re: family owned hole in the wall type of places
Carol Reed - home in Strawberry
>30 years ago I used to know where they are. Let me know where there is a good Mexican family owned hole in the wall type, and an Italian one, too. I get to Phoenix once or twice a month and have to eat out when there. Usually for lunch. Rarely for dinner.
Looking for some place other than Subway!
Re: family owned hole in the wall type of places
Howard Norman
>Try La Palma on the west side of town. It is on 43 Ave just north of Bethany Home or El Charro in Mesa a couple blocks north of Main on Country Club. The El Charro was my first Mexican place to frequent on a regular basis going back to the 50's when it was in a different location in Mesa. My experience with La Palma goes back to the '60s when it was on the east side of Phoenix.
Unfortunately I don't know any decent Italian places anymore that fit the criteria of good and decent with reasonable prices. They probably exist, I just don't know where they are Carol.
Re: family owned hole in the wall type of places
Carol Reed - home in Strawberry
>Thanks, Howard. I'll try the El Charro. I am usually in east valley when I go.
Oh For The Days
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>of the Big Boy at Thomas & Central!
Re: Oh For The Days
Howard Norman
>I graduated from Gilbert High School in 1951. I well remember going to the Big Boy at Thomas and Central in Phoenix on a big date around 1950.
Re: family owned hole in the wall type of places
Howard Norman
>Carol, I am not in Phoenix very much anymore but I should mention that the restaurant part of El Charro used to close on Monday. You could still get served in the bar however.
If you like BBQ and are in the east valley try Joe's Real Barbecue in Gilbert. It is in one of the historical buildings in Gilbert. When I moved to Gilbert as a kid in 1946 the building was used as a movie theater. It is on Gilbert Road almost due east of the old water tower, NE corner of Gilbert Rd and something. (As a kid growing up there we never used street names in town so I don't remember them.)
No place for name calling. Merry Christmas!
John E in SC
>
Re: Oh For The Days
Carol Reed - home in Strawberry
>Hey, I remember that! Moved to Phoenix in 1964. To CA in 1979 and back to Arizona in 2004. I even ate there a couple of times - back in those days!
Re: Oh For The Days
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>North High, '64, GO 'Stangs!!
Re: Oh For The Days
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Nuthin' like a burger and CVC on a tray hangin' in the window!!
Unless, of course, it was the fried bread and General Alarm at the little roadside stand on the way to Eloy . .
Or was it the mesquite smoked lamb with mickies after a day of tubing the Salt?
Decisions, decisions
Re: Oh For The Days
DP
>North High '58. Jordan's Hacienda on Central Ave, now moved but still owned by the same family. Don't know if its any good. Is Macayo still on Central just south of Indian School?
Re: Oh For The Days
Howard Norman
>>Is Macayo still on Central just south of Indian School? <
Haven't been on that part of Central for several years so can't answer the question. I do know that there is a Macayo's in the Prescott Gateway Mall. I have eaten there a couple of times.
Re: Oh For The Days
Howard Norman
>Carol, another good Mexican place on the west side is the original Garcia's. It is on 35th Ave somewhere around Thomas or Indian School, west side of the street. When the family sold the chain they kept the original place which as far as I know is still run by the family.
Another good place that is in Scottsdale is Los Olivos. It is in Old Scottsdale about a block east of Scottsdale Rd.