Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Legislation - why we need it sometimes

Posts

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#26

Boy, I could sure have used PocketKnifeStop

Henry Higginbotham

>. . . back when I was growing up. Sometimes now, too. ;-)

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#27

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

Rob Stokes in N. Vancouver

>A Riving knife is a generic product, not held by the bounds of a patent.

Sawstop is a proprietary device with one patent holder and one manufacturer.

Sawstop entered the "competitive world" by trying to have their product legislated and shoved down the throats of consumers. It didn't work - regardless of the number of attempts they made.

Sawstop is now gaining market share because they're playing in the competitive marketplace according to the "rules of capitalism". This is the way it should be, and this is the way I'll work to keep it.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#28

Re: US Constitution

Al Stokka

>Mark,

I'm not sure which constitution you're referencing but, the U.S. Constitution, article 1, section 3 pertains to the Senate (elections, meetings, and impeachment). There is no section 18 in article 1.

Al

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#29

They Also

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Brought you that yummy California e-coli spinach salad . . .

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#30

Try

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Article 1, Section 8,

clause 3:

"To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes;" AKA the "Commerce Clause"

clause 18:

"To make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof." AKA the "Necessary and Proper Clause"

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#31

ebd

I DON"T need no stinkin' mommy, Def not the gov.

ebd

>

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#32

Some Explanation

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Congress has the power to regulate all aspects of interstate commerce including the products and things sold across state lines and even products sold inside a state that are contemplated or expected to then cross state lines. From tomatoes to hockey sticks, Congress has the power to regulate them with minimum standards, and prohibit offending products being sold. If Congress determines that non-SawStop machines are unreasonably dangerous, or the costs from injuries (direct or indirect) are a burden on interstate commerce or a threat to the "General Welfare" (or both), it can mandate either directly or through various administrative agencies, that all machines be so equipped.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#33

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Of Course It's Hindsight

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>What I'm really getting at is that the SawStop device is a safety feature that is much like the safety on a gun--it's a mechanical device that can fail. That's why we have the rules of gun safety we do: every gun should be assumed to be loaded, always point it in a safe direction (or at what you intend to destroy), and keep your finger off the trigger until ready to fire. After all those rules are followed, if the safety fails, the gun goes off, and the bullet heads on a harmless trajectory.

So, in the case of flesh contacting a saw blade, something else that was preventable (and probably more than one something) went wrong first.

Some pilots fly with parachutes every time. Most never don one. I've been around the world several times in jets and never had a chute on my back, just like I've run thousands of feet of wood through a table saw without a guard, splitter, sometimes no fence, and never with a SawStop cartridge. If I don't feel 100%, I don't use the table saw, and I do a number of other things that protect my digits. I just don't need the SawStop, nor do I want anyone telling me that I need one, because I've accepted the small risk of my actions. Driving is a far greater risk...

Jason

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#34

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Some Explanation

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>And many would say that is a gross misinterpretation of the commerce clause, and Congress is overstepping its Constitutional bounds.

Jason

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#35

Maybe not the best example

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>When Volvo started instituting safety features ahead of the rest of the auto manufacturers, the car-buying public did NOT stop buying cars from everyone else and flock to Volvo, although a lot of people who did buy Volvos made the decision based at least partly on the safety features.

Congress passed and the President signed legislation mandating some of the safety features because the public put pressure on them; absent that mandate, we might well still have steering columns that don't collapse in an accident, thus impaling the driver on the column, and other jolly features of older cars that have long since gone away under requirements of the laws.

I believe - though I haven't looked up the statistics - that the fatality rate in accidents has gone down over the years, not up. Dustmaker Mike's argument would imply that the fatality rate should have gone up, what with people feeling they're invulnerable due to all these safety features (I am willing to bet, by the way, that the percentage of drivers who can describe any of the safety features that now exist but didn't used to - other than airbags - is pretty low. So, really, I don't think drivers feel any invulnerability due to safety features that they don't know about).

I don't have a stance one way or the other on whether SawStop should be mandated; I just felt Mike's argument wasn't founded on the right comparison. I'm inclined to agree with Mark Mandell's argument that - like automotive safety, lead in toys, and other things like that - Congress can pass laws on table saw safety if it finds that existing safety hazards compromise interstate commerce or the general welfare. But this is always a tradeoff - life is risky, and the decision on which risks to mitigate always should be thoughtful.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#36

Cradle to grave . . .

steve mackay

>soon individuals won't need to think, decide or make choices at all.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#38

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Or, as Mom used to say,

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>"I can't protect you from yourself."

I heard that often. As a result, I learned how to have a strong sense of self-preservation.

Jason

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#39

Then patition your parliment

davhamm

>AND LEAVE US THE HECK ALONE.

But for the fun of it your country is south of me.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#40

Re:Riving Knives

Howard Acheson

>>>> Last time I read somewhere all new tablesaws (after 2011?) sold in the US must have the riving knife feature.

I think you will find that what you are referring to is that UL will require a riving knife on all new tablesaws in order to get their label. It's not a federal regulation or requirement.

While unlikely, a saw manufacturer could elect to make a saw without a riving knife and take their chances that folks would still buy it.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#41

Speak To

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The U.S. Supreme Court, Jason.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#42

Just a wild thought...

doug f, san clemente, ca

>If the government is so concerned about the health and welfare of it's citizens, why is smoking still allowed??

Doug

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#43

Riving Knives

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Strange, given their superiority proven by the Europeans, that U.S. manufacturers (or "sellers") continue to refuse to equip their machines with anything but the cheezy "splitters" that are most often left to gather dust in the corner of the shop because people get tired of putting them on and taking them off.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#44

Bill Please

Dustmaker Mike

>How dare you. OK just JOKING.

I was referring to a news story I saw last week about the two sports and the reason for the difference was the protection. I am with you on the car safety stuff, but that I think is not the same as personnel safety equipment.

I know if I am wearing a hard hat I always seem to hit my head at least once. When I am not I make sure my pumpkin head is safe and watch for low hanging stuff. The conclusion to the news story was not to clear but they are looking at the way the players hit with and with out protection on. When they are not wearing protection they are less likely to lead with their head.

If I can find the story I will send it on if you would like. I have been trying to figure out where I saw it or read it.

Merry Christmmas

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#45

Re: Bill Please

davhamm

>Mike,

The reason for Head injuries, is with the padding on it doesn't hurt as much to hit the other guy, so they hit harder, unfortunately their is no airbag or cushioning for the head. It takes that harder hit and just rattles around inside.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#46

Steven Antonucci

It's a great idea

steve antonucci

>I think most people that have an issue with SawStop only have an issue with the way they tried to capture the market via legislation, not the actual device itself.

Seems kind of stupid, but if someone goes through the R&D effort to improve life, shouldn't they be somewhat rewarded for their innovation? Before you know it, their patent expires, and then the Chinese manufacturers will all have it since they won't have to pay for it...

S

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#47

Re: Just a wild thought...

Richard McComas

>I think we all know it because smoking bring money to the government.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#48

OT Foootbrawl

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>There's something of an on-going discussion by a number of sports commentators about "why there's no 'tackling' anymore" in the NFL but rather just high energy collisions ("hits") of large bodies at high speed.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#49

Not To Worry

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Last time I checked, in order to use the SawStop device, manufacturers have to scrap and retool their trunnions and all their castings. Not likely the Chinese or anyone else are going to trash all their patterns and tooling unless forced to do so.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#50

They Tried That

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>It was called "Prohibition". Didn't work, but made bunches of money for criminals.