Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Legislation - why we need it sometimes

Posts

Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#1

Legislation - why we need it sometimes

North of the Border

>To those who responded to my last call that the SAW stop feature should be made mandatory. Last time I read somewhere all new tablesaws (after 2011?) sold in the US must have the riving knife feature. I'm all for it, legislation or not, as long as it brings safety to the shop. By the way, when every machine has the SAW stop feature (I also heard that SAWstop is working or researching to put that feature into other machines), the price will go down a lot. Stability control systems, All wheel-drive , etc. will be standard features for many new models even though they cost a little bit more. If you want that model of cars, you can't say I want the cheaper (and less safe) version. SSC has been credited with saving lives juts like SAWSTOP saving fingers (and more). We all know for some matters (safety is one of them), legislation is a powerful and effective tool to move builders and makers towards better (if not) practices. This applies to almost all industries: oil & gas, hospitals, and whatnot. I'm not for legislation per se but when people say that legislation is a bad thing, I'd tell them to find out why they need their gov't (or Congress in the case of my friends south of the border).

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#2

Power is a 2 edge Sword!

Dave (PacNW)

>How many pieces of legislation that were passed "for our own good" have done what they were intended? They never stop with one item, but are used to push their own agenda. Beware of those who seek power they all have hidden agenda's!!

Dave (PacNW)

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#3

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Much as I hate political discussions, this is one I have to respond to.

My biggest concern with making SawStop mandatory is the inevitable legislative position that if one type of moving blade can be made saver, why not make them all safer? How about BandsawStop, JointerStop, Drillpress stop, CircularsawStop? Where does it end?

SawStop is a great product, but do I want to spend an additional $500 to buy it on a table saw? I don't know, but I think that should be my choice.

If you like the product and can afford the price, buy it! It's been proven effective; but then so is common sense, and common sense is a lot more affordable.

Ah, I've got to back to making sawdust on my unguarded, free spinning Laguna saw.

Rant off.

Doug

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#4

I don't want any of them.

Phil Joines Krum,Tx

>

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#5

Frank in Colorado Springs

Personal Responsibility...why we need it

Frank in Colorado Springs

>The last thing I want is more 'do gooder' interference in my life. There is the arcane concept of personal responsibility that has fallen way out of favor in our culture. I, for one, resent the suggestion that we need more caretaking by 'big brother'. The cry goes out to save fingers, save toes, save eyes, save the children!! Will the charade never stop?

Having become a Sr. Citizen some time ago, I increasingly recognize two distinct people groups: those who desire to control others (for their own good, of course) and those who thrive on personal freedom. Reminds me of something Patrick Henry said. Can you guess what it was? He was one of those fellas 'south of the border'. My kind of guy.

There! I feel better now!

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#6

Re: Personal Responsibility...why we need it

Chuck

>It was "Give me Liberty or give me Death"!

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#7

Re: Personal Responsibility...why we need it

Richard McComas

>The problem with more government regulations to save us from ourselves is, every time they do this it somehow or other cost us some of our freedoms.

Any time you give up freedom for safety/security you loose.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#8

Competition works better

Randy Johnson

>If someone comes up with an idea that a lot of consumers want, others who make similar products will have to follow suit as soon as possible. That�s the main reason for patents.

I do not own a Sawstop. I have been impressed by the ones I have seen, but not so much that I would have spent the extra money to buy one. Enough people have bought one that I would be willing to bet a similar system will be in place, at least as an option, a few years down the road.

I remember reading Eddie Rickenbaker�s autobiography years ago. He made a car that had four wheel brakes, an innovation unavailable from other maker�s at that time. More established companies mounted a campaign claiming that four wheel brakes were unsafe and eventually drove his company out of business. Of course, within a few years, four wheel brakes were an industry standard. And Uncle Sam didn�t have a thing to do with it.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#9

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

Al Stokka

>I'll accept your promotion of legislation mandating SawStop's tablesaw safety device when you show me the section of the United States Constitution that grants the Government the authority to create the mandate. Don't even think about suggesting the general welfare clause!

Al

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#10

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

mike from American Sycamore

>Is this the same government that passes a law that I must wear a seat belt when I DRIVE MY CAR BUT I DO NOT HAVE TO WEAR A HELMENT WHEN I RIDE MY MOTERCYCLE...JUST MORE OF WHO HAS THE MOST MONEY TO BUY A CONGRESSMAN, SENATOR OR A JUDGE. I want less government...get out of my shop!

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

Moses Yoder

>I think they should totally back off of legislation that concerns safety. That way all the stupid people will eventually die off and they won't be able to breed any more.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#12

Article 1

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Clauses 3 and 18.

Then there's OSHA, Consumer Protection.

Americans live by the rule of law, and thus believe, shouting the old cry of "There aughta be a law . . .", that making something "against the LAW" will somehow make them safe. Most curious for a people who are so quick to denegrate the legislators and lawyers who work to make, refine, and enforce the laws and rules so vociferously demanded.

Then, of course, there's the Wood-chipper Doctrine. Ever look at one of those orange monsters covered in labels? Every sticker represents a different law suit by people (or their surviving heirs) injured or killed by those machines.

I've been hurt on a table saw. I've known several people who've lost fingers, hands, or suffered serious injuries on these machines. There is not one to whom I've spoken who would not have gladly paid the extra money for the SawStop if they had known it was available. NOT ONE.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#13

Re: Article 1

lewisdodd

>Hmmmm! The word hindsight comes to mind here!

Some people shouldn't be allowed anywhere near a shop, "there oughta be a law"! (;>o)))

Lewis

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#14

Choice

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Before or after you cut off a thumb and two fingers because the "safety" push stick slips?

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#15

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Hindsight is always 20/20...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...as it is said. I would suggest that far greater is the number of people who have used a table saw who can also still count to 10 on their hands.

It's easy to say that a SawStop-esque device would have saved many a maimed tablesaw operator from serious injury. That's true. What is also true is that every one of those injuries resulted from contact with the blade--something that can be prevented by that lump above and between everyone's shoulders. SawStop is simply another layer of defense against injury, and it also happens to be the most expensive. There are many other options of prevention that can and should precede flesh contacting a spinning saw blade.

Jason

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#17

Aussy football and American Football

Dustmaker Mike

>Look up the stats on the two of them re-guarding Head injures. In American football we have the best head protection gear and we have at least one if not two head injures a week. In Aussy football they do not have head gear and do not have the injures. If you have ever seen a Aussy football game it is pretty intense. The more you protect some one the more chances they will take because they have the protection. I believe in being Safe but Government should not force it nor is it anywhere written (at least in the states) that they can.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#18

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes-not

John Lucas

>You bring up all the safety features on cars. I have not been able to buy a new car for last 15 years. With all that extra stuff they are simply too expensive for someone in my wage bracket and I don't do that bad compared to many people in my town.

Not only that but it's getting almost impossible to repair the used ones yourself. Has is saved lives. Probably but have you noticed how much the speeds have gone up on the interstate. I'm guessing everyone is assuming the airbags, anti-lock brakes, etc, will save them.

I'm not against the saw stop. I think it's a wonderful idea. It just simply adds too much to the price of a saw and would be beyond the price of most new woodworkers. And as I said before it only stops injuries on the table saw. Not any of the other tools in the shop.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#19

Football  *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>


Read

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#20

Of Course It's Hindsight

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>But that's what creates the perceived need for new rules and regulations; to remedy bad situations and PREVENT new injuries.

If everyone was highly intelligent, alert and focused 100% of the time, possessed of high skills in using these machines, and possessed of some measure of prescience to be able to see several minutes into the future, few, if any of these injuries would have happened, and the safety rules would never have been needed or made.

Too easy to say stupid, unskilled, inattentive people should not be allowed to have or use power tools (or anything sharp). Either this is a New Law (that can't possibly be enforced), or we can start limiting peoples' human rights and freedoms by way of IQ tests or genetic screening.

Hmmm, lets see, average "IQ" is 100, so how do we get to determine the minimum cut-off? 90? 120? Oh yeah? Says who?

"Okay, everybody who's been cut by a power tool, line up for your smarts test!! We'll find out who can be trusted in short order." [Blonds need not apply]

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#21

Clint Searl

John Stuart Mill

Clint Searl

>John Stuart Mill offered this thought that sums up my opinion.

Clint

�That the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others. His own good, either physical or moral, is not sufficient warrant. He cannot rightfully be compelled to do or forbear because it will be better for him to do so, because it will make him happier, because, in the opinion of others, to do so would be wise, or even right...�

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#23

I have three, but I don't care for them

McKay

>I have three saw stops here at the school shop. In my own shop I will take the old uni over any of them. (mechanical movement and simple operation is still smoother than the saw stops.) I ride the kids all of the time about safety and I do feel better about having sometimes brain dead high schoolers using the table saws. However, there is no safety device that will override common sense.

In thirty years of teaching, the only table saw injury (not too serious)was because a student violated common sense safety rules that he had been taught.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#24

Safety Record

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Don't discount your personally "riding them" and your watchful eye as the key parts of the safety devices employed in your classroom.

You can but pray they'll all remember and use what you've drilled into them when they're alone in the garage shop with the Crapsman table saw.

Re: Legislation - why we need it sometimes

#25

on my enlightening trip to NZ

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>A few years ago we spent a month in the rural areas of the south island of NZ. Wife commented that it was like she remember(most favorably) the US 50 years ago. To wit:

In one of the national parks there were two caves that could be hiked to. When we arrived there was a small sign at one entrance that said this cave was dangerous to enter, so we didn't. The other we explored at will.

At the glacier there was sign warning that pieces break off the wall of ice at its toe and indeed there were pieces to be seen. We explored the toe prudently.

If one wanted to hang glide, bungy jump or sea kayak, and felt competent to do so, these thrills were available.

At some sea side cliffs was a sign warning that if you fell off that you would not be rescued and the waves would grind you to doodle dust. The sign was in German suggesting this was a problem with some more than others.

There was a report in the news that a rafter from CA (are you surprised) was attempting to sue the rafting company because she fell out and suffered brain damage when she almost drowned. What was newsworthy was the fact that someone would sue for such a thing. Clearly these news people had never been to CA.

I concluded that the governments of the south island didn't discourage people from thinking, making judgments and taking responsibility and as a result it was an attractive place to live/or visit.

Having said my piece I need to go back to taking the restrictor plate out of the shower head that the state of CA has judged to contain something that will give me cancer should I eat enough shower heads.