Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Bad experience with Steel City (long)

Posts

Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#1

Bad experience with Steel City (long)

David A Dircksen

>I bought a Steel city 1 1/2 hp dust collector in March of 08 from Woodcraft in Ft. Wayne, In.I brought it home and set it up and hooked it to my table saw and router table.I used it maybe a month or so and didn't use it all summer.In the fall ran duct work and hooked it up to four other tools. I started using it more and it started giving me trouble. It would try to start when I hit the button but then it would kick out. I called S C and told them about it,they said it was the capasiter and sent me one. That didn't help so I called them back. They said they sent the wrong one and would send me another. I got it and it worked for awhile then started doing the same thing.I called them again and this time they said it was the reset button and would send me one. That didn't work either so I callded them again. This time they asked for the sn on the motor, I told them there wasn't one. I thought that was strang when I registered it. They told me that it could be a motor that was supposed to be repaired but got back in the system somehow. They said they would send me a new motor. I was waiting and waiting for the motor and it wasn't comming,so I took it to a local motor shop and they put a new capasiter in it for 50 dollars. Every time I would call they said it was comming from China. Finaly after about three months I got home from work and the box was sitting on my front step.The sides were all caved in. When I opened the box they sent the motor and impeller all dented. The fan on the motor was caved in and wouldn't turn. I took pictures and called again. A month later no motor yet so I called again and complained. About a week later I got a call from Woodcraft, they said SC sent them a dc for me and they didn't want the old one back. I thought I was finaly going to get satisfied. I drove 1 1/2 hour one way to pick it up. I looked at the box and it had a big hole in it, so I opened it up to check out the motor and blower, it looked ok. When I got back home unpacked it and the three supports were missing and you couldn't make out thesn on the motor. Called them again and they said they would ship them to my house. Waited two weeks and called them back. They said that since I have two dc I could use the supports off the old dc. I told them that with all the trouble I had with the old dc I would need it for a backup. I hope nobody else had this much trouble with Steel City.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#2

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

Brent Smith in Montreal

>Sounds like you bought a kit that they're shipping to you piece by piece!

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#3

JL

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

JL

>I'm sorry you have had this experience.

I've got a couple of the larger Steel City pieces - the 5 hp industrial cabinet saw and the 8" industrial jointer. I've had no problems with the equipment at all.

The DCs are made in a different factory by a different supplier. I am presuming that they haven't shaken things down yet. I would suggest you keep trying. The SC folks have treated me decently when I've asked for advice and sent spare parts (zero clearance inserts) quite quickly.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#4

A contrarian view

Rod Peterson * Ormond Beach

>While I'm sure it's frustrating to not have a completely functional tool, I'm not so sure it's fair to paint Steel City with such a broad brush. I think it's fair to say you've had a bad experience with one of their products, but let's review:

  • …they said it was the capasiter [sic] and sent me one.
  • They said they sent the wrong one and would send me another.
  • …I called them again and this time they said it was the reset button and would send me one.
  • They said they would send me a new motor. Finaly after about three months I got home from work and the box was sitting on my front step.
  • I got a call from Woodcraft, they said SC sent them a dc for me and they didn't want the old one back.
  • …they said they would ship them (supports) to my house.
  • Waited two weeks and called them back. They said that since I have two dc I could use the supports off the old dc.
Seems to me they did a lot, trying to make it right.

> I told them that with all the trouble I had with the old dc I would need it for a backup. I hope nobody else had this much trouble with Steel City.

I don't know—not changing the parts over from the old to the new because you want it for a backup sounds more like trying to get two units for the price of one, when in actuality, SC has essentially given you about one and ¾ for the price of one. Not the best experience, granted, but I'm not sure what more you want Steel City to do.

Rod

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#5

Re: A contrarian view

Randy Johnson

>I have to say I agree with you.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#6

Re: A contrarian view

Ron in Sterling, CT

>While they (SC) have tried a lot, they still haven't satisfied the customer with an operational piece of machinery, and in my mind that is the true test of a good supplier. I would have given up on them a long time ago, and asked for my money back. Only my opinion.

Ron

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#7

Re: A contrarian view

Fred Davis

>I agree, one shouldn't give kudos to a company for trying to rectify a issue as simple as this one is , if every try is wrong.

It could actually be a series of goofs , but why should one wait for "three months " for a motor that looked like it was air dropped , in the literal sense of the phrase.

FredD

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#8

Re: A contrarian view

Thomas S Stockton

>David got a bad product, Steel city ran him through the ringer, he has every right to be frustrated at them. It sounds like he tried hard to keep his cool and work things out.

Imagine you have a car that needs to be repaired under warranty and the companies response is to send you parts and expect you to diagnose the problem on your own, I think it would be a fairly frustrating experience.

I think the other dynamic is that steel city markets itself as having a high quality product with great customer service that you are willing to pay extra for and expect the company to stand behind its product.

Tom

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#9

Ellis Walentine

I've passed your story along

Ellis Walentine

>... to some folks at Steel City who promise to help resolve the issue.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#10

Re: A contrarian view

Randy Johnson

>Maybe the reason I'm willing to give Steel City the benefit of a doubt on this is that I can remember some simply awful customer service over the years.

Two that stand out.

A Ruger Old Army black powder revolver that had a hole between two of the chambers. Turn around time, a little over six months.

A Dodge truck with a little over 15,000 miles that would only shift into reverse if the engine wasn�t running and shifted in the forward gears with difficulty. Still under �bumper to bumper� warranty, the problem cost me almost five hundred bucks out of my pocket to fix due to some convenient loophole.

Steel City sent a brand new unit and didn�t expect to have the old one returned. I have a hard time finding fault with that.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#11

what about the dealer?

mike from american sycamore

>I sold tools for years and I always took responsibility and took care of the customer. I would have delivered a new unit to the customer or repaired his unit or replaced it right away even if I had to replace it with another brand or a more expensive unit. The dealer should be held responsible....then the dealer needs to deal with Steel City. Why is the customer stuck dealing with the problem?

What about WoodCraft? The customer did not buy the machine from Steel City....he bought it from Woodcraft. Woodcraft should have stepped up.

Poor service from Woodcraft in my opinion.

Mike

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#12

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

Barry Irby

>I am having trouble with this. Neither Steel City or WoodCraft stepped up here. This was not bought as a do it yourself kit of second rate parts thrown into a box. It was supposed to be dust collector, probably with minimal assembly required. The customer expects to buy it in a box, take it home and assemble it and have it work. Clearly the company expects that too, because they give a warranty. Both sides expect it to work for at least the period of the warranty. To expect the customer to replace switches and capacitors and the motor gets to be ridiculous after a while. Then to expect him to rob parts from the old unit to make the new unit whole adds to the air of ridiculousness. To expect him to wait three months for a motor because they are made in China is ridiculous. He did not buy it in China. We should have a reasonable expectation that the company has replacement parts locally, even if they have to take it off another machine.

Steel City has a lot to learn here. Sounds like it might start with their packaging and shipping. They should be able to deliver these machines without holes in the packaging and damage to the machines. Quality control might be next. The Chinese can produce reliable products, but Steel City needs to Press them to do it.

It might not be unreasonable to expect the customer to replace the switch or the capacitor, but at some point it got to be a Yoda moment. Not Try, Do.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#13

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

Larry in NW Ohio

>First off I have to say is I know Dave very well, he`s my BIL, he has alot more patience than I would have had with SC. Also for the ones who may be thinking he may be streching the story a little, think some more. He`s telling it as it happened. My opinion would have been to give him a new one, with a good serial # on the motor, after the the third or forth try. Let`s not forget after waiting quite awhile he spent $50 of his own money to get the motor going so he would not have to eat the dust. Think if this would have been you. I would have went off the deep end after being put off after the third or fourth so called fix. I`m done Larry

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#14

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

Chuck in ND

>Not that I'm sticking up for Steel City, but aparently it has gotten to the point that an import is an import, and quality control in most cases is little to none. It really shouldn't be a big suprise. I had a small problem with a Delta 50-760 dust collector. The motor cover was dented, but no visable outside damage to the box. Delta couldn't send me just the cover, so they send me a new motor but they wanted the other one back. It seemed like a waste of shipping, anyway, the new motor came in a wooden crate, and guess what ? The cover on that motor was dented as well. If you read the customer reviews in Amazon, alot of people complain about a dented motor cover and think it's poor packageing. From what I seen it's just plain poor quality control. The motors are being assembled with covers that are dented. Anyway, I agree that Woodcraft and Steel City droped the ball with his DC.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#15

EXACTLY!!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>It's one thing to expect an importer who does direct marketing to fix a defective unit, but its a bit strange to me to think it'll get done with phone calls, and even stranger (to me) not to insist that the guy I bought it from to either send out a tech with parts or have it picked up for repair or replacement. Sure, if I buy Asian Iron from a company website (to save money), then I probably should be prepared for less personal service after the sale in case I get a lamer. But when I go to a local store and purchase, I expect that vendor to take care of what they sell. They may use a service firm, but it's still their obligation.

DON'T SEND ME PARTS unless they're delivered by the guy who's going to put them in. I'm a woodworker, NOT A FREEKIN' MECHANIC. I have no obligation to fix what you got wrong!!!

Years ago, I bought my JET cabinet saw from Amazon. I knew going in that it would be JET's direct service obligation, and part of my decision was the company's excellent reputation. Turned out that JET was having a problem with the saws' doing a "bang start". I got one of those, but JET had a tech in my shop within 2 days of my call. After a motor replacement failed to fix the issue, they had a new saw delivered, placed in my shop, and the "old" one removed.

Woodcraft should have taken care of this machine. Woodcraft should have delivered and installed whatever parts were needed rather than the importer having more damaged parts delivered by UPS with the expectation that the purchaser is an integral part of their service network.

Doesn't matter whether I know how to install a motor capacitor, it's improper for the manufacturer to expect me to do so. If you're not prepared to fix what you've sold me, find another business. Asking me to do it merely sets up either an excuse of "you did it wrong", or an excuse for the telephone "service person" for having sent the wrong part. Meanwhile, the product I bought with the (unreasonable?) expectation that it would work, doesn't. (Have they paid back the $50 trip to the repair shop? No? Hmmmm)

If we, as consumers, want good and proper service, we need to conduct ourselves accordingly. If the manufacturer under review (Steel City or anyone else) is unwilling or unable to establish a functioning service network, either directly or through its dealers (aka "resellers" aka Woodcraft), then their success should be commensurate.

I don't single out Steel City or anyone else in this. This business model based on quantity rather than quality appears to be spreading and IMHO needs to be changed.

[rant off]

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#16

Re: A contrarian view

David A Dircksen

>I don't want two machines, I want one that I can depend on. I probably should have contacted Woodcraft first but I was thinking the manufactrer should be responsible.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#17

YOU'RE NOT ALONE DAVID(long)...

Mike in NC

>I had a very similar experience with Steel City back in April/May of this year. I actually posted it here on WC. I had purchased the 17" drill press from Woodcraft in Raleigh, NC and the capacitor burnt up in it after about the 6th press of the "ON" switch. Called SC and was told they would send me a new motor. Week after week, for about a month and a half, I called and emailed Terry at SC as was multiple stories that all ended with "It's being taken care off." I was initially told that they were in the middle of moving from Tenn. to Calif. but they should have one in the warehouse. Then I was told that it was probably on a shipping trailer that had not yet been unloaded in Calif. In the last contact that was made, I was told that the request was never put in for the motor. After this, I had a verbal agreement that they would send me a mortising kit along with the motor for my troubles - still haven't seen it. I finally received the motor on my front porch one day with the box in very similar condition as David described. The motor looked as though it had been removed from another machine - the wires were actually cut on the other machine and were still wire nutted to the motor. Installed the new motor - HORRIBLE VIBRATION! Watched the pulley as the motor ran and it wobbled all over the place. Ended up swapping the armature and pully from the old motor and this took care of most of the vibration. In the end, I guess I did get the issue resolved. Wish it could have gone smoother though.

I guess in retrospect, I should have been warned when the salesman at Woodcraft said they were experiences problems with SC and they had a long list of back orders that were yet to have come through. By the way, has anyone else noticed that Woodcraft has dropped SC from its catalogue and website? Haven't been to the store to notice if they are still there or not. In one of my conversations with SC they said they had a meeting with Woodcraft that day. Guess it didn't go too well.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#18

Re: what about the dealer?

Mike in NC

>Woodcraft has a policy printed directly on the receipt that states something to the effect of, and don't quote me on this, issues with malfuntioning or defective power tools are to be taken up with the manufacturer and not returned to Woodcraft. I don't blame Woodcraft for a manufacturer who produces a faulty product and then has trouble rectifying the issue.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#19

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

Pete in Holland, MI

>Dave -

There were too many things wrong with that situation. Although Steel City is the supplier, if it was bought thru Woodcraft, they are the ones who should be held accountable for the product. If you had an issue with your new car, you would go directly back to whom you bought it from.

By not bringing Woodcraft into the picture, they do not get the full picture of the products that they are handling. Also, as you were replacing motors, capacitors & such, if you would have crossed a wire & shorted out something, you would be liable for the product.

Although our tools can be big & heavy, they need to be returned to the place where they were purchased, or a representative come to your house. You paid for a product and expected it to work.

Yes, this issue all goes back to how the quality systems of an organization are run. Good quality costs money up front, but pays for itself later on. Some places just don't see that picture.

This thread, I'm sure, is helping prospective customers in their future decsisions.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#20

Re: YOU'RE NOT ALONE DAVID(long)...

David A Dircksen

>That reminds me , on the new dc they sent me I thought I would try the motor before assembling it. I tried to push the start button and it wouldn't push in. Took it apart and found a small screw behind the on button. That really upset me. By the way, Woodcraft in Ft. Wayne told me they wern't doing bussines with SC.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#21

Re: what about the dealer?

Fred Davis

>that is a common practice.

I had a new pickup that I could see the tack welds in the quarter panels a block way, when I pointed this out to the dealer

salesman , he said "we don't make them , we just sell them".

Well I wore it out and sold it and traded brands and dealers.

That probably didn't register with the dealer , but I get a lot better service from this one .

It took a year to get the former dealer to take me off his mailing list .

FredD

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#22

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

Fred Davis

>If Steel City is loosing it's retailers ,then the writing is on the wall.

FredD

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#23

Re: Grizzly and other service almost identical

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have a 3 hp Grizzly cyclone dust collector. I installed it and used it for about 6 months in a hobby shop. Ran maybe an average of 30 minutes a day for 4 or 5 days a week. Then the unit failed to start and produced a puff of smoke from the capacitor box. I called grizzly. They sent me a new cap - it ran a week and blew. I ended up disassembling the motor cover and starting switch assembly. They did send a new set of capacitors and the new starting switch assembly. However part of the new switch assembly wouldn't fit. By using some new parts I reassembled and adjusted the starting switch, replaced the caps and the problem was solved - ran for over 3 years now. I also lost the 5 hp motor in my Yorkcraft planer. Wilke machinery sent me a new one from China in about a week and a half. I had to replace it myself. Now I do order most of my equipment from the internet, and do expect to have to replace parts myself. I know it would be too expensive for any internet distributor to have servicemen available across the country - and I wouldn't want to pay for that service either in the price of the equipment or as a separate charge. In fact I wasn't disappointed in the service I received in either case. Right now I have a problem with my Powermatic PM2800 drill press. The chuck has fallen out of the spindle several times and also "locks" up forcing me to use channel locks to remove drill bits. I haven't contacted them yet - mean to in the next few weeks.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#24

Then why buy from them?

Phil Joines Krum,Tx

>They're over priced on just about everything anyway.

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

#25

Re: Bad experience with Steel City (long)

Jerry Samsen

>This policy of "don't return defective products to our store but contact the manufacturer" is common. This is the reason that I will buy electronics at Costco rather than BestBuy because Costco has great customer policies on extending warranties and returns.

Of course, they are able to do this as they have such buying power they can strong arm the manufacturer to play by their terms. You can bet that a TV returned to Costco is packaged and shipped from that store back to the manufacturer on that manufacturers arrangement and nickel. Not Costco.

Woodcraft probably didn't have such terms with SC.