Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

Posts

Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

#1

Chuck Jones - West TN

Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

Chuck Jones - West TN

>...did I just pick a bad piece to start with? I haven't worked with cocobolo before, but I recently acquired a fairly large amount of it. Naturally (against good advice) I started making a peppermill with what is probably one of the sorriest pieces. It's a beautiful piece of wood from a distance, but under close scrutiny it's easy to see bunches of small checks, or open grain, or whatever the correct term might be. It's not dull tool tear-out. I've used a razor sharp spindle gouge, skew, shear scraper, and sandpaper and just get more of the same.

Is this characteristic of cocobolo, or just a bad piece? Is there any solution? It's not like I don't have another blank, but I like the shape of this one darn it and would like to fix it.


img

Re: Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

#2

Ellis Walentine

No

Ellis Walentine

>That piece of yours appears to have a lot of surface checks. It may have been brought green into a dry environment too quickly. Not much you can do about the checks unless you can turn past them.

Ellis

Re: Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

#3

Re: No

Barry Irby

>I'm no expert, and, I don't like trying to identify wood from an Internet photo, (check out some of the posts about Identify this piece...its pine, no walnut, no austro pithecus...) but that does not look like cocobolo to me.

I have not seen much cocobolo, but all I've seen has been reddish, tight grained, hard, and oily. Polishes up beautifully. Maybe there are huge variations in it. I would take that piece to someplace that had some "known" cocobolo and compare.

Other than that, not much to do with the piece you have, like Ellis says.

Re: Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

#4

Ellis Walentine

Looks like cocobolo...

Ellis Walentine

>... but very washed out cocobolo. I've worked with plenty of it over the years, including doing contract resawing for Wm. L Marshall Co. in New York. They sold it to pool cue manufacturers. I chewed through a lot of carbide bandsaw blades in those days. :-)

Cocobolo is purplish white when you open it up. From there it progresses through light orange to red-orange to blood red to vermillion and eventually to a fairly deep burgundy, all in the space of a year or less. The grain is variable, but the texture is pretty consistent -- usually very creamy. The grain may be bland like this sample, or have dramatic black swirls and landscape patterns. It is a much smoother and denser rosewood than Brazilian, though it doesn't have the same tonal qualities for instrument making.

To ID this sample, I'd see if it is purplish white in the middle. If not, it could be Honduran rosewood, which is usually much less dramatic in figure and of uniform color throughout. The black swirls I see here suggest that it is cocobolo.

Ellis

Re: Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

#5

Re: Looks like cocobolo...

Barry Irby

>Ok, I would go with what Ellis said. He has seen many times as much as I have. Orders of magnitude more. Should have stayed out of it. I said I did not like doing wood ID on the Internet.

Re: Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

#6

Some epoxy maybe?

John in NM

>We use some white epoxy at work that is perfect for filling as transtint dyes go right in and don't impede the cure.

I'd look for a similar product (I think PC11 is similar to it) and see if it'd work. Though those dyes are also kinda spendy, you might not want to go that route.

Re: Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

#7

ebd

Re: Is all cocobolo crappy, or... *LINK*

ebd

>Here is a link to pictures of nearly every variation of cocobolo.


cocobolo

Re: Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

#8

Ellis thought......

Barry Irby

>I might have taken offence at his response to my post. I did not. I jumped in over my head and should not have. The piece of wood did not look like Cocobolo to me, but I have not had much experience, in fact nearly none with cocobolo.

I'm just glad he did not call me short.

I am short, but he doesn't know that and there is no reason to spread it around. Don't tell anybody.

Re: Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

#9

Re: Ellis thought......

Dan Donaldson

>I am not short, just attitudinally challenged;-)

Re: Is all cocobolo crappy, or...

#10

Wow, nice link!

Gary Evans--Tallassee TN

>I have seen a number of pieces of cocobolo, but I had no idea of the amount of variation in color and grain.

Beautiful stuff! Somebody spent a lot of time and trouble to put that together.

Gary