Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

Posts

Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#1

Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

Mike Nichols

>I'm almost done building a house and will soon be able to have a wood shop at home. I'm a novice woodworker and interested mostly in building simple pieces of furniture, like a wall cabinet for the bathroom, a bench, a simple desk, etc. I don't expect to get into wood turning or things like that. I am looking for advice on what power tools to get to start out. I prefer better quality tools that will last a long time, but don't want to break the bank in the process. No more than $2,500 is my budget. I'm thinking I should start with a good table saw, a jointer, a biscuit joiner, and perhaps a small planer.

I went to Woodcraft today to look at some options since they have a 15% off sale on Jet and Powermatic products. The sales rep recommended a Delta Hybrid table saw (Model 36-717B) to me instead of the Jet and that'll be on a 10% off sale through 12/12.

My father, who is an accomplished woodworker suggested I reach out to you all for recommendations of what products to buy. I appreciate any thoughts you might have.

Sincerely,

Mike


http://fallschurcherdhaus.blogspot.com

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#2

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop

Larry in NW Ohio

>Micheal We have/had the same problem with woodpeckers over the last 30 years in a new house we built. So some of the knowledge that we picked up over the years was, that woodpeckers don`t eat the wood, as it sounded like in your letter. They see something on it when they are flying around and they think its food. So you more than likely have bugs under your wood. We have the stucco siding and rough sawed ceder boards on the seems. Makes a great place for bugs. The things we tried was to put bug killer in with the paint when we painted, and whenwe replaced the stucco, we put hardi board on. I don`t think the birds like either one. the bug juice kills the bugs and the woodpeckers have no reason to land, there`s nothing to eat. If this interest`s you I can give you more infor. Larry

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#3

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop

Barry Irby

>You will get at least as many opinions as there are members here.

I agree with your starting lineup with one minor exception. I might omit the biscuit joiner. I have one and have used it, but it is not an essential tool and you may not need it or you can get it later. Biscuits have somewhat fallen out of favor. (A big topic that can be discussed in great detail later.

I have a Delta/Rockwell contractors Saw and it has served me well. I added a Biesemeyer Fence and that has been a joy. I think a Jet saw will be about equal. Pay attention to the fence. Get which ever saw has the better fence. If I had the money, I would look at the Sawstop Contractors saw. That might blow your whole budget, but if the sawstop feature saved a finger it would be worth it many times over. (Another topic that yields much discussion, but the Sawstop is the first game changer to come along in table saws in forever. Google SawStop if you are not familiar or go to YouTube and look it up.)

Get the widest longest jointer you can afford. I think the old style with the dovetailed and gibbed ways are more reliable than the ones that have the parallelogram adjustment, but that's not a scientific opinion. If you are going to work with rough lumber a jointer is essential. It allows you to straighten and flatten wood. Yes, there are workarounds and you can do it with hand planes, but a good jointer can be a workhorse in a furniture shop.

I have a Dewalt lunchbox planer and I like it. I would not hesitate to buy it again. Mine is about ten years old and the newer ones are two speed. Even Better.

Those three tools are probably the back bone of a work shop. You will want to add a router or two, or three. Plenty of hand tools, drill, etc.

A drill press is useful and you can add a mortising attachment. You can also buy a bench top morticer and The Domino is now available. I don't have one, but it is like a biscuit jointer on steroids (excuse the crude description Domino owners) and will cut mortises all day long.

You may want to add some sort of compound miter saw, but with a sled or miter gauge, you can get a lot of that work done on the TS.

For years I had a TS, jointer, shaper, and drill press. The lunchbox planer was a Real upgrade. The bandsaw, not so much. I have had a shaper all a long, but I think I would actually recommend a router table. Check out the tool reviews in the mags. Much depends on what you want to do, how you want to approach it, how much room you have, and how much you want to spend.

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#4

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop

mdclor

>Mike,

You will get a lot of great advice from the members of WoodCentral. I agree with Barry's comments. Additionally, I read "Setting Up Shop" by Sandor Nagyszalanyzy which I still use as a reference. Also, Fine Wood Working has their annual Tools & Shops issue which has more good info. Finally, consider buying used tools. Since your father is woodworking knowledgeable, he can help you pick quality tools that might range from 50-75% of buying new.

HTH,

Merle

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#5

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop

Jerry Gibbs

>I recommend Grizzly products in your situation. They also give excellent service. Don't get excited about 10% off at Woodcraft. Jerry Gibbs

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#6

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Used Powermatic and Delta commercial duty table saws and jointers are commonly available. there isn't much that can go wrong with them and you could get both for the price of one new machine. You will also need the means to make mortise and tenon joints. The biscuit joiner is a poor substitute for a M&T joint.

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#7

JL

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop

JL

>I managed without a jointer for many years - of course now that I have one, I don't know what I did without one.

I would say table saw (hybrid if possible), planer, a reasonable dust collector (roll around 1.5 hp or better), router (and router table) and then maybe a jointer.

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#8

Stay flexible and open minded

wilbur

>"I don't expect to get into wood turning or things like that."

This is exactly what I said when I first got into this woodworking thing. Boy, was I wrong.

Even if you don't ever expect to make bowls, turned boxes, or pens, having a lathe can be a real boon when it comes to making furniture. Think making table legs, accents, finials, knobs, etc.

As far as tools and equipment, I would strongly urge you to pick those up on a per project basis, otherwise you run a very real risk of being stuck with a tool that you don't really have a use for.

The two other things that I know that will be absolutely true are to put in one and one-half as many lights you think you need, and twice as many 220V circuits as you think you will need.

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#9

Re: Stay flexible and open minded

Mike Nichols

>All the advice that's been offered so far is greatly appreciated and I look forward to any and all other thoughts. This board's a great resource and I appreciate everyone taking time to share with a newbie like me!

Mike

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#10

Ellis Walentine

Some thoughts

Ellis Walentine

>Hmm. My theory in questions like this is to start with a list of everything I would like to have and then work backward to my budget. On the list would be a tablesaw, a jointer, a planer, a sliding compound miter saw, a bandsaw, a drill press, a random-orbit sander and a router. You'll also need hand tools (a block plane, a bench plane, a couple good chisels, etc.), marking and layout tools (combo square, decent ruler, marking knife), a bench (the heart of the shop, really), a work table, clamps, dust collection, not to mention the infrastructure of your shop (lighting, wiring, heat, etc.) and all the supplies you will use (lumber, adhesives, abrasives, finishing supplies, for example).

The cost of all these things will put you well over your budget no matter how hard you shop, unless you find some kind of amazing deal like someone willing to liquidate a shop for a fraction of its value. By all means, keep your eyes open for auctions, classified ads, Craigslist and other deals on used equipment.

For what it's worth, there is a valid alternative, which I'm sure our members on the Hand Tools forum would be happy to discuss with you, and that is to gear up with hand tools. If you're mostly working on small projects, there's no reason you can't get there with hand tools. You may in fact be well suited to this approach. If so, you must be willing to substitute hand tools and elbow grease for at least some of the machinery on your list. There's no crime or sin in that.

Good luck.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#11

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>Good Day, Mike, I have read all of the comments from others relating to you desires for woodworking equipment setups. Mine are: router table with lifting capability for your router elevation settings, and a very good supply of router bits; benchtop planer; corded and cordless drills; bandsaw; and of course the table saw. My own choice for a small workshop was to buy the Shopsmith....it is a woodworking machine with 5 tools combined into one machine....just takes a little time to switch over to another function( have had mine since 1978 and it is still operating as new and does everything I can think of).

Check out Craiglist or Ebay for bargains on these items.

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#12

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop

Jesse Cloud

>Good thread. Craigslist is a big part of the answer. Be patient. Pay no more than 50% of retail. Unfortunately, lots of commercial woodshops are going out of business in these hard times, so some very good tools are available.

I would also recommend taking a class. When I lived in your area, Arlington county had a beginning woodworking class in their adult ed department. Woodcraft also has some good classes. The classes will help you discover your likes and dislikes, e.g., do you prefer power tools over hand tools or the other way around.

Don't know if they still do this, but the Woodcraft in Rockville used to rent time in their huge shop by the hour. A great deal for someone just getting started. You could put off buying a jointer and use theirs for a while.

Hope you will keep us posted on progress! Happy woodworking!

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#13

very cool house and...

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>I'm returning to woodworking after about five years away, so I conveniently have tools - though it's a bizarre mix of cheap and expensive and why did I buy that?

The list of furniture you want to build is mostly what I think of as "flat work" - lots of flat surfaces, right angles, probably minimal if any curves. For that, the tools you list - tablesaw, jointer, biscuit joiner, maybe planer - sounds pretty good to me.

There are lots of reasons people don't like biscuit joiners, and I'll certainly agree that they aren't any where near as solid as a mortise and tenon or a dovetail. Despite their flaws, though, they work well on a lot of projects, especially what I think of as "cabinet-like" work. I used mine today after a few other approaches had failed, and it was exactly what I needed for the simple project I was making.

I would definitely get a router, though. They have pretty much infinite uses.

And I'd consider Ellis' suggestion of going for handtools instead of power, though over the long run I'm not all that convinced they're cheaper.

I'm getting back into woodworking using the mostly power tools I have to reacquaint myself with how all this works and knock the rust off my skills. But then I hope to explore hand tools a lot more, though they aren't great for cutting biscuit slots.

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop *LINK*

#14

Re: Seeking Advice for New Home Wood Shop

Jim Dillon

>Mike,

Agree with much of what has been said. Here are a couple of references that helped me 15 years or so ago. I think the advice given in these has not aged much:

"The Small Workshop" in The Best of Fine Woodworking Series by Taunton Press. In particular, the chapter on "Setting up a Shop" with advice provided by Peter Korn, Mario Rodriguez, and Mark Duginske; and

"The Workshop Book" by Scott Landis, Taunton Press. More for ideas in shop layout, storage, etc..

And later advice can be found in the following:

"Set Up a Shop for $5,000", in FWW Tools & Shops Annual Issue, Winter 2006/2007; and

"Tools for Woodwork", in Woodworking, Autumn 2008.

The last reference lists these as "'The Necessary Power Equipment'":

10-inch table saw;

8-inch jointer;

12-inch benchtop planer;

1/2-inch drill;

random-orbital sander;

drill press or hollow-chisel mortiser;

jigsaw or bandsaw;

two-based router kit (2hp); and

10-inch miter saw.

Have fun shopping!

Jim