Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

OT furnace filter

Posts

OT furnace filter

#1

OT furnace filter

Jerry Gibbs

>We will be gone Jan-April from our home in Michigan. The gas forced air furnace will be left on keeping the house at about 50 degrees. Would it be better to remove the filter? My thinking is that the furnace will be more efficient and I don't care about the air quality. Jerry Gibbs.

Re: OT furnace filter

#2

Re: OT furnace filter

steve mackay

>Good question. With my limited knowledge of the system, I thought the filter was to keep out airborne "stuff" so it doesn't burn inside and produce harmfull gases and heat and damage my furnace.

Re: OT furnace filter

#3

Re: OT furnace filter

Barry Irby

>Do you have AC? Filter is more important for AC than the furnace. The filter keeps the fan and the furnace clean also. I would say leave the filter in it. It should be fine over that period of time in an unoccupied house. I normally change mine once a month, but they used to change them once or twice a year. I doubt the small decrease in efficiency will have much effect. Actually, if it keeps the heat exchanger and fan clean it might increase the efficiency.

Re: OT furnace filter

#4

Amen Barry!!!

Frank on Chestnut Hil

>

Re: OT furnace filter

#5

Re: OT furnace filter

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Unless your dust bunnies are playful when you're not around, the airborne dust generated in an empty house is likely to be minimal, especially in Michigan, where the chance of earthquakes is relatively low.

Change it before you leave, and look at it when you get back; then you'll know, for future reference, how much dust gets generated.

Re: OT furnace filter

#6

Re: OT furnace filter - According to my

North of the Border

>energy supplier, changing the filters regularly will improve the life and efficiency of your furnace. Even if you're away, your furnace is still working. Based on such logic, I'd keep the filter on. Disclaimer: I'm no expert here on the topic.

Re: OT furnace filter

#7

Re: OT furnace filter

Howard Norman

>If it was me I would replaced the filters just before I leave and look at them when you return. In an unoccupied house I would not expect any problems with that procedure. Of course you never know until you try something like that. I would not want to leave the house for an extended period without the filters in place. With the thermostat set at 50 degrees the furnace will be operating a lot less than if you were there with it set at 70 degrees or so.

Re: OT furnace filter

#8

Re: OT furnace filter

Alexander Grigoriev

>Make sure also to drain your water pipes, to prevent pitting.

Re: OT furnace filter

#9

Re: OT furnace filter

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>I'm no HVAC expert, but I would also vote for putting on a clean one, and leave it.

The filter is supposed to make the furnace more efficient, and should extend the life of the furnace.

Since there won't be any dust kicked up, it should remain fairly clean.

Re: OT furnace filter

#10

Re: OT furnace filter

rbrandt2

>Filters definitely make a furnace more efficient ***IF*** there is an air conditioner condenser in the air flow. Without filters, the fins on the condenser coils will clog with dust and can soon eliminate any air flow at all. Without a condenser, filters help clean the air in your home and keep it cleaner overall.

A note on a comment above - return air doesn't go thru the conbustion chamber, so the dust bunnies won't burn under any circumstances. This is a byproduct of the requirement to not allow exhaust gasses (including carbon monoxide) back into living space.

Re: OT furnace filter

#11

Re: OT furnace filter

Barry Irby

>You are correct that the return air does not go through the part of the heat exchanger that handles the combustion air. The exchanger has passages that allow the combustion air to flow through and up the flue without mixing with the return air, but they both pass through the heat exchanger in separate passages. The surface area of the passages allows for the exchange of heat without mixing the "fumes" into the room air.

If you run a furnace without a filter, some of the dust may coat the surface of the exchanger and cook or burn off. This is most noticeable if you run the AC without a filter, get a good coat on both the heat exchanger and the AC coil and then turn on the furnace. Sometimes they actually produce a cloud of smoke. (In mild climates the backup coils in heat pumps seldom come on and they smoke or stink the first time they do in a couple of years.)

That's the reason I mentioned the AC. I should have been more clear. Furnace filters are important, but AC filters are essential. The coil in the AC looks like the radiator in a car. Lots of tightly spaced fins. A much better filter than either the heat Exchanger or the fan. Does a really fine job when running as AC. The coil is wet at that point and really packs up with dirt.

On my Home Inspections I have seen fans so dirty the vanes were completely packed with dirt. This seriously reduces their effectiveness. They depend on the "scoop" shape to move the air.

Systems are designed to run against the "head" or resistance of a filter. I don't think the filter will get very dirty in an empty house so I would not hesitate to leave it in place for four months.

Re: OT furnace filter

#12

Re: OT furnace filter

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I installed furnaces and serviced them on my side job for over 15 years. I would NOT run any furnace without a filter. The filter stops the lint, hair and dust from entering the furnace and ducts. I have seen furnaces ran without filters (for extended periods). I had to remove the blower assembly on a couple, wrap the motor and wiring and clean the fan at a high pressure car wash before it would move half the air through the system that it would normally. As Barry has said the Air conditioning coil is even more susceptible to clogging. Another issue is that the ductwork itself may become coated and produce dust even after you replace the filter. Installing a "long life" pleated filter would more than adequate for 3 months in a empty house and insure the whole system is kept clean for your return. The pleated filters have several times the surface area of the standard flat filter and are advertised to be efficient for 3 months in normal use. Don't know if that is accurate but certainly it would last longer that that in an empty house. They do cost more - around $5 to $15 depending on the quality and filtering capability - some are even made to remove sub micro particles to prevent allergy reactions.

Re: OT furnace filter

#13

Re: OT furnace filter

Tony - Memphis

>I use the pleated versions and I do leave them in for three months. They never "look" dirty when I replace them. Not sure that means they aren't but they sure don't look bad. I get the middle of the pack 3M filters at Lowes. Can't say if they are any good or not to be honest - no way to compare. When they replaced our coils a few years ago, they looked shiny and clean though. I have a rig on my shop ac (wall unit) that uses the same filters and I can really see how much they collect and the shop ac stays nice and clean too. So, I assume they are doing a good job.

Tony

Re: OT furnace filter

#14

Re: OT furnace filter

Larry in NW Ohio

>Jerry One extra thing I did to help keep the furnace and duct clean was to put a thin carbon filter behind the air return grate. That really catches alot of dust and about every month I take it out and replace or clean it out. I also put one on the refridgerator right in front of the coils, that REALLY catches alot of dust and especially if you have pets. Larry