Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Will this thing kill me *LINK*

Posts

Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#1

Will this thing kill me *LINK*

davhamm

>A few people have questioned the strength of this. I think its more than fine. Just wondering what some woodworkers think.

Its all 2x12 top and bottom with 2x12 studs every 12". The small boxes have OSB closing out both sides, the one long one only has OSB on the other side.

Attached one pic, and a link to a photo album.


img

Photo's

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#2

Ralph Nader said it will

Henry Higginbotham

>Oh, wait . . . you're talking about the risers, huh?

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#3

Re: Ralph Nader said it will

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>After all, it is unsafe at any speed - ANY speed!!! Therefore if you are under it and killed when the risers give way, the car is at fault, just as Nader said.

(and to think I spent years and years in college and grad school to learn that kind of logic!!)

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#4

Re: Ralph Nader said it will

chuck

>It was only the first 2-3 years of production that had the suspension problem. After the ralph nader book they modified the suspension to make it as safe as any other car on the road.

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#5

Re: Will this thing kill me

John McGaw

>I suspect that it is wildly over-built. A properly done torsion box could probably get along with a third of the lumber and still be strong enough to hold up a car. There used to be a television advertisement showing a large truck crossing a bridge made of corrugated board while the announcer stood underneath. It isn't the material as much as it is the way it is put together.

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#6

More seriously

Henry Higginbotham

>I think the biggest concern would be one of the boxes folding up on you. As long as that doesn't happen, it'll hold up way more than you're asking of it. Lots of glue and screws on the side panels (which act as diagonal bracing) would make it quite adequate, I think.

Be careful in the back, though. I had a '63 Spyder, and the engine fell right out onto the road one day. Well, the back of the engine, anyway. There's only one bolt (or stud, maybe) holding the rear of the engine up, and somehow the nut worked its way off.

And I guess you can't turn them over--I certainly tried.

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#7

Re: Ralph Nader said it will

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>I know that, Chuck. A colleague of mine had one -we used it to go hunting. Ralph Nader is not one of my favorites.

I just enjoy using "tortured logic" as I did above.

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#8

There is no way

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>There is no way on earth I would get underneath that, assuming that's your question.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#9

Re: Will this thing kill me

Craig in Silverdale

>I'd not hesitate to put my Ford Ranger up on you rack. It should be a bit higher though. Then you could sit on a stool to work under it. I had a '64 Monsa years back. I loved that car. Have fun on your restoration.

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#10

Re: Will this thing kill me

Norman

>If this is designed for storing the car over a length of time, wouldn't you want to unspring the suspension?

Support the chassis instead?

Norman

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#11

Re: Will this thing kill me

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I'm a belt and suspenders type of guy when it comes to getting under something as heavy as a car. I would still get four metal jack stands under the frame......you only get one life.

Lee

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#12

Re: Ralph Nader said it will

Victor Parisian

>Me and friend used to race his dad's Monza up and down Tontogany Creek Road in Northwestern Ohio. The twistiest road we knew of. Great fun, surprised we ever made it to 20 years old. We referred to it as the ******* road oiler for all the 10w30 we put in it.

Oh ya, the boxes should do just fine. Wear protective glasses etc...

Victor in cool and sunny Houston.

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#13

Re: Will this thing kill me

steve mackay

>In the ARMY I learned (here he goes again) that if I questioned the wisdom of a plan of acction enough to start polling it probably wasn't wise.

The chances of the construction failing might be one in a million.

If the one-in-a-million happens while I was under it, who would my wife sue ?

Jack stands and cynder blocks are cheap.

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#14

Re:Will this thing kill me.Thanks for the feedback

davhamm

>Thanks everyone for the Replies.

Been hanging out on Corvair forums so long, forgot the replies I would get about the car, (Truely loved them, part of the fun of having a vair). For the record, I have yet to come out and find it sitting on the roof, but I have heard these things roll over all by themselves.....

The main reason for the platforms is easy access under the car, not really long time storage, just a place to park where I can easily get under and play whenever I want/need to.

I could throw some stands under there, just makes less space for moving around. Plus if the boxes are going to collapse in any direction I would suspect the force would be high enough to just knock the stands over also.

I surveyed here, just as a sense check, cause car guys are generally metal heads and had a few ? the strength.

As for toppling over domino style there are 5 3" screws through the top and bottom of each stud, plus the double OSB closeouts on the small boxes and one side on the big. But Next time at the hardware store I might pick up some 90 brackets to screw in as triple insurance. I was very happy when I drove up and their was zero visible deflection in the wood. Others who have built these (with less support) had always talked about a bit of wood deflection.

On the WW side my co-worker who is into woodworking also is dieing when I tell him this is what my PM66 and festool tools have been cutting lately. Oh well at least its wood.

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#15

Engine dropping out

davhamm

>One of the things I need to inspect now that its up.

The Earlies had one bolt with a extra tall castle nut holding up the back of the engine, sometimes Mech. would forget the cotter pin, or use a regular nut and eventually nut comes free engine drops...

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#16

Re: Will this thing kill me

Dale Stansbery

>I still think putting it up on four drive on car ramps would be safer.

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#17

Re: Will this thing kill me

Larry in NW Ohio

>The Monza had a turbine in it that ran off the exhaust, didn`t it? Larry

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#18

spyder

davhamm

>The Spyder was the turbo charged version

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#19

Re: Ralph Nader said it will

Bill White

>Anything will kill ya. Now let's see....Gin, Vodka, Sour Mash, Nail guns, Miter saws, hammers......

Oh Well!!!! That's all I can remember right this minute.

Bill

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#20

One thing

Dan Donaldson

>One thing that all people who die have in common is that they were born. It therefore stands to reason that being born causes you to die.

(ducking and running)

Re: Will this thing kill me *LINK*

#21

Its only about 92% fatal

davhamm

>Cant find or do the numbers right now, but if you look at it as a # alive today / # total born you have about 8% alive today... There for life only has a 92% fatality rate... well at least in this analysis.