Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

What finish for Walnut coffee table?

Posts

What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#1

What finish for Walnut coffee table?

Dan Mitchell

>I've just competed a coffee table, about 54" x 20", out of Walnut, and I'm wondering what finish to use. It's a contemporary piece, based on a design by Tage Frid. A pic is below. I've read about staining the sap wood so it matches the heart wood, but the top doesn't really have that much sap wood, and frankly, I think I like the natural grain better. I've read that orange shellac can "warm up" the coolness of today's steamed & kiln dried walnut, and also of using Danish oil on the species, but I wonder if either would be durable enough for a relatively high-traffic piece like a coffee table. On the other hand, I haven't had great luck in terms of runs, etc., with brushed on and sprayed on finishes, so I think I would prefer a wipe on approach. Suggestions?

TIA

Dan


img

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#2

JL

Got scraps?

JL

>That's what I use to test. I've use the BLO/Poly/Mineral spirits on a variety of tables with reasonable success. I've also used Waterlox.

The table below used BLO/Poly/Mineral Spirits.


img

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#3

Polyurethane

Pete in Holland, MI

>Coffee tables will get used and spilled upon over the years (at least in my house). Not everyone will remember to use a coaster. Some folks down-play polyurethane, but after all your hard work, when another finish is compromised and a permanent stain sets in to be looked at for the rest of the life of the table. I do all my furniture with a satin sheen and after 10+ years & kids, still looks great.

Pete

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#4

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table? *LINK*

pecker

>I really like this stuff. Both for it's appearance, and the fact that it smells great while using it.

You can't get any runs with it.


img

http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?page=11243

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#5

Clint Searl

Water white lacquer

Clint Searl

>

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#6

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Don't worry about staining the sap wood. Leave it be...it looks fine. To warm the walnut use an alcohol based anyline dye like Transtint. I mix some amber with some reddish brown and find that it gives walnut a nice warm tone.

Tom

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#7

Is it an optical illusion . . .

Yonak

>. . . or are the corners of the top thicker than the middles ?

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#8

Poly +

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Attached pic is of a walnut sideboy in my front hall. The finish is composed of a light wash of Mission Brown Transtint to blend the sapwood, then several coats of Minwax Gloss oil poly cut 30% with naptha and hand-applied. When cured, the poly was cut back and then the pores were filled with Crystal-lac pore filler. Lastly 5 more coats of the poly mix and finally rubbed out with Meguires Nos. 3 and 9.

Been there for 10 years and looking great, especially for a hallway piece that gets keys, wet umbrellas, and what-have-you dropped on it.


img

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#9

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>Lately I have been using a really odd sounding combination on walnut with fantastic results. I apply one coat of Jasco brand tung oil finish which has a nice amber/orange color that highlights the natural color of the walnut nicely while poping any figure. I lay out my rags and remove my gloves and imidiately follow with a brushed on coat of General's HP poly which is a water based poly acrylic blend with a UV inhibiter. The tung oil seals the wood so that the water based poly dosen't raise the grain. I usually apply 3-4 coats of the general HP poly and often lightly sand with 220 between the 3rd and 4th coat then rub out with 0000 steel wool. A high quality artist brush for water based media is a worth investment but a foam brush will do id you use a fresh one for the last coat. The General HP poly sands and rubs out so much like nitro celulose you will think they made a mistake in lableing the can.

I have done testing of the cured finish and I get no delamination and I have had a bench with this finish schedule in a high traffic area for 18 months with great results. The poly is rather tender for the first 10 days but after about 30 it will out perform lacquer or wiping oil.

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#10

No, it's not an illusion

Dan Mitchell

>The top started out as a rectangle. I then tapered all 4 edges by running the top through the TS vertically on all 4 sides (the short edges were especially fun, with the top sticking 4.5' in the air!). Then I made a template out of 1/4" MDF, with an arc laid out on each of the 4 edges using a batten. I traced this onto the walnut, rough cut it with a jig saw, than clamped on the template & trimmed the top with the router. Due to the darkness of the wood (and my limited photographic abilities ;-) it's a bit hard to make out the shape in a photo. I have to say, I'm really pleased with how it looks "in person".

The pic below shows the bottom side of the top, which gives a better idea of the actual shape.


img

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#11

Re: Got scraps?

Dan Mitchell

>Nice piece! Do you mean you MIXED BLO/Polyurethane/mineral spirits? How did you apply? What brands did you use?

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#12

Boy! I was REALLY hoping there'd be ONE BEST! *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the input. I'm afraid some of those approaches are a bit too sophisticated for my very limited finishing experience! Has anyone else used the finish Pecker suggested (see link below)? I'd really like to avoid brushes!


http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?page=11243

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#13

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

Fred Dabis

>no less a woodworker then Sam Maloof would let the sapwood in Walnut show as a contrast in many of his Tables.

FredD

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#14

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco------WebKitFormBo

>And Sam would finish in oil, mixed with some varnish, and wax, and hand buffed.

Your table, finished thusly, would not be as durable as with poly, but it would be reparable easily, and gorgeous.

Dead simple, too. Rockler used to sell the stuff in cans, premixed.

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#15

Better than Bartley's Gel Varnish?

Bart Goldfberg

>How does the General Finishes Gel Poly compare to the Bartley's Gel Varnish?

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#16

Mark that finish is Awesome!

Bart Goldfberg

>

Re: What finish for Walnut coffee table?

#17

Even Better Now

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I didn't perfectly fill the pores with Crystal-lac so, as the top film poly cured and pulled down, a very slight grain reappeared, relieving the "plastic" look that oil poly can have when put on too heavy.

[Thanks for the comment]