Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Bandsaw Blade questions

Posts

Bandsaw Blade questions

#1

Bandsaw Blade questions

Barry Irby

>I have a Delta 14" band saw with riser block. I would like to get blades, but I agonize over cheap VS high dollars. I sometimes only get a few minutes use out of a blade. Been using blades I bought in bulk for about $12 each. I like to try a carbide tipped one, but I am pretty sure I would hit a nail or stone and ruin it. What blades do you recommend?

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#2

William Falberg

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

William Falberg

>Stay away from carbide if cost is an issue but otherwise get the widest selection of different blades your saw can tension. Get different widths, different sets, different pitch, and different thicknesses. Depending on your bandsaw's spring you might be able to run 3/4" W blades too; so try those. There is no good blade and there is no bad blade. They're only good or bad relative to the job at hand and your saw's ability to tension it properly. When you ask vague questions like that you invite a lot of vague answers, none of which will answer your specific question and you'll be back next week asking for the next best blade. The key to selecting the "right" blade is in knowing the blades' set angles; and they won't tell you that so you end up buying a lot of duplicates. Sad but true, blade disributors don't think you're smart enough to handle the details of blade geometry so you'll have to demand answers and buy elsewhere if they won't tell you. Would you buy a car not knowing its engine's displacement?

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#3

clarification.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>what do you mean by you only get a few minutes from the blade. What a happens?

I get Starret or Lenox blades from Misenheimer in Morrositown , TN. They cost less than $10. Most areas have a Lenox dealer and they weld up blades in their local shop from rolls of stock. It is a cheap source for good blades.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#4

Re: clarification.....

Barry Irby

>You are both right. I asked a vague question. I would like to have a universal blade that does it all. (Wouldn't we all?) I occasionally resaw, generally to make thin stock like veneer. The rest of the time I rough saw things like bowl blanks. I have the saw tracking so that the blades run nearly centered on the top wheel. Been running half inch blades. The last two blades ran forward and crashed into the protective guards. I don't know why. The saw was running, but I had walked across the shop.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#5

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

Rob Sandow

>Barry,

I have 2 Lenox carbide blades for my 16" saw and can assure you they will run right through a typical mild steel nail with no noticeable loss of performance DAMHIKT. I'm not sure about stones though.

For the price, I consider them to be one of the best investments in my shop. Because they are thicker than many blades, I find there is no drift. You can just set your fence at 90 degrees to the blade and resaw accurately with little sanding or planing/jointing required for cleanup.

Rob

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#6

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

Fred Davis

>There was a pretty detailed article eary this year in FWW on set angles and what they mean and how to figure them for your bandsaw.

FredD

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#7

William Falberg

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions *LINK*

William Falberg

>I know; I wrote it. Things like this are just too complicated to discuss in "bumper sticker" terminology and I cover it in much more detail in Chapter Three of my as yet unpublished book wherein I ask the reader to DEMAND complete specs, including set angle, from his blade supplier and REQUEST the reader to measure his spring's rate. With these two numbers the reader predicts exactly what will happen every time he takes blade to wood and lives happily ever after. The End.


img

http://i282.photobucket.com/albums/kk264/falbergsawco/YBSCover3.jpg

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#8

On that note...

John in NM

>I recently bought Highland Hardware's general purpose blade and was very surprised at the clean cut. I normally make my own but was out of acetylene for soldering. I too would like to know the set angle and other specifics for available blades, as these performed better than other commercial ones I've used (on other saws, so kind of a backhanded comparison). This was the first blade though that made me think we expect too little from our bandsaws.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#9

certainly not the blades fault

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I can not think of any blade property that would cause one to suddenly run off the saw, unless they stretched. A blade that stretched would indeed be a "cheap blade". . I would look for some sort of band saw problem.

That said, to paraphrase another responder, I think some demand too much from a band saw blade in terms of smoothness of cut. I resaw with an ordinary 3/4" Lenox 3 tpi blade on a well tuned 20" Delta saw. Miles of this stock is used in furniture factories. They cost about 12$ for this saw. The tooth marks I get can be planed out with two swipes with a hand plane or not much sanding with 100 grit. I don't need to spend more money to get a more smooth cut for the kind of resawing I do, and certainly not for bowl blanks. If I was sawing much thin veneer a smooth cut, one that could be glued without further treatment, would be important.

Carbide is another issue. They don't get dull very fast and they do make very smooth cuts. So if I was doing a lot of resawing, or sawing very thin veneers, I would buy a carbide blade. They are over $200 for my saw. I don't ever expect to get a pay back from carbide with the amount of resawing I do.

In resawing, blades get dull fairly quickly so an inexpensive blade seems to me to be a compelling advantage, especially so if I was sawing bowl blanks with their bark, grits, and other blade challenging features.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#10

Clint Searl

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

Clint Searl

>For a saw that gets used six hours a day, tooth geometry, blade tension, guide mechanisms, etc. may be worth paying attention to. But for the frequenters of this forum, 99.99% of what gets done can be handled by two blades: a Lenox 1/2" 3TPI carbide tipped, and a 1/4" 4TPI Timberwolf.

Clint

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#11

William Falberg

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

William Falberg

>Are you joking, Clint? Those are two of the worst blads ever made. I wouldn't recommend them for anything.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#12

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

Barry Irby

>That's what I am talking about. I have a few minutes here and there to pursue my woodworking hobby. What I need is two bandsaws, one with a rough 'circle' cutting blade to hack out bowl blanks and other rough work and another with a top notch blade to resaw with. I don't have the money or space for another band saw. I don't have the patience to keep changing the blade. What a PITA. Back off the guides, Release the tension, Remove the blade, Fold it up, unfold the other blade, put it on the saw, re-set the guides, etc. Never mind, times up, go to my real job.

I have a WWII Combo-blade on my TS. There are blades that will do certain things better, but it does an excellent job of most everything I ask of it. Used it for five years and had it sharpened. Just about the only time I remove it is when I think there might be metal in what I'm about to cut, and then it takes about three minutes.

So, what I did was bought ten 1/2" 3TPI blades form the company mentioned in an article in FWW a couple of years ago. They resaw well enough when new/sharp and I can cut bowl blanks with them even if I have to cut them as octagons or some other polygon. Does not take long to knock ten or twelve corners off on the lathe.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#13

Show me the magic!!!

Barry Irby

>You wrote the article. I'm willing to hunt it up and read it. Just not sure how I would manage to go to Lennox and tell them they have the one of the worst blades and if they would just reveal their stats to me I would understand it also and beable to tell them what to do to make them better, based on an article in FWW.

I don't want to do research on blades and come up with the perfect design and set up a company to make them for me. I want to buy a good blade at a fair price and use it.

I don't really care how it cuts, why it cuts, All I want to know is that it cuts.

I have a Delta 14" bandsaw. Been around a long time. Jet has a similar one. There must be a dozen more clones out there. Perhaps I should have bought a bigger saw or a better saw, but it seems to me that it is not unreasonable to expect to be able to buy an excellent blade for this class of saw without making it myself.

So, If you were restrained by being semi-employed with a relatively small income, had a 14" bandsaw, a small shop, and wanted to occasionally resaw stock or slice a piece of veneer and cut bowl blanks now and then, what blade or blades would you buy?

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#14

Re: clarification.....

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Barry, After two post, you still have not told what blades you have used, If you want to learn from your mistakes, please cough it up. Also, it might be good to know how much power and blade speed.

If you put the blocks in to get extra height, but are trying to drive too many teeth, with too little power at too high a speed, you could just be burning the blades up from cutting too slow.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#15

Re: clarification.....

Barry Irby

>Keith, I am running 1/2" 3 TPI blades.

The saw has the 3/4hp 1725 rpm motor that cam on it and the same pulleys that came on it. So the blade speed is what ever Delta set it at.

I did not mention the blades I was using because I wanted to know what to use, not what was wrong with what I was using.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#16

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Barry, The 1/2" 3 tpi ought to do the re-sawing and turning blanks for you, unless your saw is starved for power, causing you to cut so slowly that your teeth can't take a large enough chip to carry the heat away with it.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#17

Clint Searl

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

Clint Searl

>Bill, I defer to your considerable expertise in all things bandsaw. That said, whether it's resawing, trimming a blank, or cutting the occassional curve, the cut requires further treatment. If the work has to be planed or sanded anyway, the nuances of blade design and saw setup become irrelevant as long as it gets one from point A to point B.

Clint

P.S. I spend more time on the bandsaw chunking up cherry and hickory limbs for my smoker than on furniture projects.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#18

William Falberg

Re: Show me the magic!!!

William Falberg

>Just kidding about Lennox; they make excellent blades. If you want simple; a one-blade-fits-all solutions; I'd have to say TW 1/2" - 2TPI. They're the closest thing to a chain saw and will cut whatever you put in front of it.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#19

agreed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I used a 1/2" x 3 tpi on my 14" Powermatic for years and it did everything but cut tight curves. I would think it ideal for your bowl and resaw tasks and can't think of anything better. I would caution that if the blade is dull from cutting dirty bowl blanks then you will have all sorts of problems resawing. I ran a 1 HP motor on my saw and it was not overpowered for resawing, especially if the blade was dull.

If changing blades is a pain there is some flaw in the technique. If you stick with the same thickness blade then there is no guide adjusting for the same width blade and only one easy in/out adjustment of a different width blade. The rest seems trivial.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#20

Re: agreed

Barry Irby

>That's exactly why I bought a dozen of the 1/2" blades. changing it went from a lot of fiddling to just take the old one off, put the new one on, check the tracking, go back to work.

I would like to increase the power. I have a two hp motor, but it runs at 3450 rpm. And It has the wrong type of mount. So, I would have to adapt the mount, its one of the face mount type. Probably change the switch and wiring, and change the pulleys. To much to do to use a free motor.

Re: Bandsaw Blade questions

#21

Re: Show me the magic!!!

Larry in NW Ohio

>Bill You said the TW 1/2 2 TPI is one of the best blades, where can a person buy one. Thank You Larry