Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Cost vs utility -- a survey

Posts

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#26

Gageteers

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Woodworkers, while being susceptible to the latest gotta-have hoochie at the wood show, are no different than other hobbyists. I know several photographers that have $60,000+ in glass [lenses] sitting on shelves, and can't wait for the next new camera model to come out.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#27

Depends on who's doing the thinking...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I think about the utility, my wife (aka the finance committee) thinks about the cost :-))

bruce

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#28

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Fred Davis

>"What I'd like to know is how do *you* buy tools? How good is good enough? How important is the price? How much extra are you willing to pay for marginal increases in utility or feel or bragging rights or investment value? What other factors enter your decision?"

Some very good questions Bill.

Know the difference between "cheap" and "cheaply made".

.

A Stanley plane for instance , made in the UK , bought second hand and well maintained is always better then recently made ,new knockoffs, cost wise and the utility of it is equal to what you would ever use it for.

Some tools become obsolete , at least in my shop, you will find many straight blade screw drivers, but I avoid slotted screws like the plague. So I now have a bunch of different screwdrivers , power drivers and the straight blades and slotted screws rest quietly.

Some tools are consumables, like sandpaper , you never have too much.

Some tools are better made in the shop then mass produced ones, like jigs, push sticks, zero clearance inserts for saws, hold downs,.etc.

Big box stores and hardware stores to a smaller degree will sell a quality router for instance and have only cheaply made bits for it, same for power saws and drill bits, great tool , cheap acces

What I'd like to know is how do *you* buy tools? How good is good enough? How important is the price? How much extra are you willing to pay for marginal increases in utility or feel or bragging rights or investment value? What other factors enter your decision?

Where do I find it after I have decided to buy it?

I try to make tool purchases from the same tool supplier over the years, this practice will pay dividends, plus the good manager will know where to steer you and what price range and brand to invest in.

Estate auctions, flea markets, markdowns in tool stores etc,are good places to look.

That is the last thing I would tell you , a good tool regardless of the initial cost is a investment and like sound investments will grow in value.

For instance the Stanley Mark 45 combination plane I put out on the WC auction , I never really needed , but it sold for several hundred dollars and I had paid 15 dollars for it in a Eureka, CA pawn shop in 1964.

FredD

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#29

Re: Depends on who's doing the thinking...

mike from american sycamore

>Years ago my wife scolded me for spending money for my shop. I pointed out all the extras I had built for her and our home. I also showed her how much money I had earned from my shop and woodworking and how much of that money went into the house hold budget.

I then told her that I would stop doing woodworking and not spend any more money in my shop. However my new hobby would be drinking beer with her brother down at the local tavern. I told her that I would spend the same amount of money that her brother spent drinking beer and smoking. She decided that it would be best for me to remain in my shop doing woodworking and I could spend money on my shop and my tools! She never complained again. Where do you want me? out in the shop? or down at the bar?

Mike

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#30

ROFL ! . . .

steve mackay

>Same argument worked for me long ago. Same result !

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#31

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Ron in Sterling, CT

>I started making sawdust 60+ years ago with a set of tools in a handmade wooden toolbox my folks gave me for Christmas. Over the years I have added a lot of tools, always trying to get the best quality I could afford at the time. Utility has always been very important to me. I also consider the frequency with which I will use the tool, and enter that into my cost consideration. I am now retired, and love to haunt the flea markets and Craiglist looking for tool upgrades at bargain prices. They must be tools that I don't have, and can use without a lot of tuning, not just a good $ bargain. I have the time to be patient and wait for the real bargain to come along such as my $10 Bedrock 606.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#32

It varies greatly by project...

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>I'm not one kind of woodworker, and I bet most of us aren't.

In the middle of making Windsor chairs and deacon's benches, primarily with hand tools, and methods respective of my great-great-grandfather's ways, the kitchen sink leak is discovered, and the previously ignored particle board cabinets need to be replaced. When I'm doing a 10 sheets of plywood kitchen, you know I really appreciate a Unisaw, a biscuit jointer, power sanders, impact drivers and Robertson screws from McFeeley's. Not so much with a Windsor.

What's been fun is making tools for the handwork parts of the craft lately. It's hard to buy a travisher, a profile scraper, a compass plane and the like. What I have cobbled together might just work for me for a while. And Grandpa Dutch's drawknife is pretty darned fast.

Having used a Stanley block plane, and a Lie Nielsen, though, I can tell you where the money will be spent if I were to need another one.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#33

Woodworking is a cheap pass time

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I live in the land of bass fishing. Every time I go somewhere I wind up following a 4 wheel drive 3/4 ton pick up pulling a trailer with a bass boat and 200 HP motor. Now that it is deer season these same trucks are pulling a trailer with a 4-wheeler. Compare the Lee Valley catalog with Bass Pro Shops. Spouses should be thrilled when someone commits to this pass time instead of most others.

There aren' t many pass times (hobby if you will) that provide the opportunity to produce stuff that greatly exceeds the pass time investment.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#34

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>1. Why do I need (not want) the tool?

2. What will it have to do?

3. Price?

4. Compare w/other tools in general range.

A table saw, as it did with me, must go on price and utility first. Contractor or cabinet? Within a type, all tools seem to be similar as to ease of use, etc.

I recently purchased a pair of Rigid 12 amp tools - drill and screw driver/hammer. Type of use was important here as I do not use them all day, every day. Thus less expensive and less powerful tools are fine with me.

I also recently purchased a Skil power hand plane. I cannot scrub plane a board any more and I have no large planer. Thus I checked on price, durability, ease of use (utility) and "heft" of design. Thus Skil vs the more expensive machines.

My reciprocating saw was purchased using the same criteria.

When purchasing a hand plane It must be well made, easy to use and require little initial setup time. Thus Veritas. Expense is second here.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#35

I don't recall anything

Dan Donaldson

>in the question about Festool. ;-) The question is around why people buy what they buy and the criteria that they use.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#36

And I almost got it ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>Got outbid at the las second. ;-)

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#37

You don't mind

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>if I borrow that argument, do you? :-)))

Bruce

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#38

How much does a fish or a deer really cost, anyway

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Thanks, Bill, I'll borrow this one, too.

Bruce

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#39

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Simple........

Jesper, Denmark

>I buy the best tool for the intended job, which I can afford.

Another few auxiliary rules:

I do not buy tools in sets, you end up paying for stuff you never need.

I buy reputable brands and from reputable dealers. The extra cost is well worth having access to service and repair.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#40

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Bricofleur

>I stick to the popular brands that I know and I also stick to respectable stores and tool retailers/dealers. I avoid mail orders when buying expensive/electric/electronic tools.

I buy only when on sale or when I can get a fair discount. Since I know what tools I want, I keep an eye on my local news papers and flyers and on the websites of my trusty dealers and retailers.

Ex. For a long time I was looking for a 23 gauge pin nailer. Finally I got it this morning at $100 instead of $125 (20%) and I got an additional 10% gift card for my purchase. This is a 1-1/2" Paslode.

Last week I bought the attached 11 amp Milwaukee router combo on sale at half price for $149. This one was not on my list, but you can't never have enough routers!!! By the way, I didn't have one featuring dust collection. Now I do.

Knowing what I want, I wait for the good deal and go for it.

Best,

Serge

http://www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com


img

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#41

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Terry Alexander

>Very rarely do I go out and just buy something. I am not an impulse buyer and I will not let a project "dictate" to me what I need to buy that very moment.

I am the consumate planner.

If I know I am going to need a new (or additional) tool for an upcoming project, then I keep my eyes out for the best deals. I may wait months...many months, but I will eventually get what I want.

I stay away from the Cadillac of tools. Example. There is a wet-vac out there by a "Cadillac" mfg that is over $400. I can buy a lot of other wet-vacs from the big stores for less. At the same time....I will not buy a piece of "junk" unless it is for sure a 1 time only use.

HTH

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#42

Reliability

mdclor

>I really want reliability from my tools. To me that means tools that will not break under normal, reasonable use. I am not mechanically inclined and do not enjoy "tinkering" so fixing to me means taking a tool someplace and then being without it until they (hopefully) fix it properly.

This means that I usually will not buy a used tool because I don't want to buy someone else's problems.

I usually don't buy the "top of the line" model or manufacturer since I am of the opinion that the latest bells and whistles are high profit items for the manufacturer that don't necessarily add a great deal to the utility of the item.

Finally, the highest reliability machine is usually not the highest priced, based in the KISS principle.

That's my story and I'm stickin' to it! :)

Merle

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#43

Re: Reliability

Fred Davis

>Merle,

by refusing to consider used or second hand tools because you think it might have a previous problem passed on to you, shuts you out of a huge market of reasonably priced tools that are every bit as good as new ones.

For example some of the better tool makers like Skil/Bosch sell refurbished tools that are like new , have a new garantee and in every way equal to their new counterparts except in one important catagory, they are much cheaper.

I know from experience , I have a Bosch ROS that is clearly stamped "refurbished" and the price was like half of the new one. ;-))

Fredd

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#44

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Brian in Brighton

>I buy what I need. If I plan on using it a lot than the price for a better tool is worth it. If I plan on using it infrequently, then a cheaper tool is worth it.

A good way to think about it is this. If I were to depend on making a living out of it, then I buy quality hand tools. If I need an oddball size for one project (like a 1-3/8 socket), then HF works just fine.

I've been down the path of cheap power tools, and will only buy good quality now.

Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice...well..you can't fool me again.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#45

Re: Reliability

mdclor

>I agree that factory refurbished would be okay and I have seen them offered a few times. Basically, I consider "buying new" as the price I pay for my own ineptitude. :)

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#46

Just imagine . . . . .

Pete in Holland, MI

>. . . .if we all were introduced to woodworking with all of the very best tools avaiable.

We would go home and buy tools within our greenhorn budgets and try to do the same work that we were trained to do, only to find out that we struggle with lesser quality tools. Most would realize the hobby was going to be very expensive, or just throw in the towel and give it up from the start as a rich man's hobby.

As mentioned earlier; I think the worse thing we can do is use a friend's higher quality/cost tool. This only points out the stuggles we have with our current tool and make us drool for more expensive tools. If you can figure out how to make lesser quality tools do the work needed, you become that much better in the long run.

Interesting thread thus far, but there appears common themes in all.

1) Buy for the long haul, or for that one time job.

2) Spend what you can afford & make it work. Everyone agrees quality (which has different meanings) is something worth having.

3) If you are savy re-habbing old tools, they can be fun to restore and a big money saver.

4) The tool needs to do the job it was intended for. More features can be a bonus, or if un-needed, a waste of dollars.

Pete